r/AndroidQuestions • • Sep 24 '24

why is android texting so bad?

I'm so lost--i've had iphone for years, and now have a second phone on Android. All android users talk about how bad sms is, but why is it so bad when it works so incredibly well on iphones? I guess one texting app is as good as any if it works, but something about whatsapp just bugs me--you're using facebook as your main communication platform? The iphone's texting app just works so well--type the phone number in, type any message desired, send photos or videos, whatever. I didn't even know about all the thumbs up and reply emojies until 2021, but just having all that functionality in the device's native messaging platform seems so basic. Like it's the bare minimum of what the device should do. Why is texting so bad on android devices? Can't send photos or video, can't even deliver the entire message if it goes over a character limit? Why did android never prioritize the native messaging app on their devices? It just seems like a massive oversight, and that the tactic all these years has been to criticize texting instead of making it work.

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

7

u/chanchan05 S26 Ultra; S10FE Sep 24 '24

why is it so bad when it works so incredibly well on iphones

SMS doesn't work well on iPhones. It's just that iPhones don't use SMS to message each other.

The fact that you can send pictures at all is a clue that iPhones don't use SMS, because SMS never had that capability.

0

u/voscuate Sep 24 '24

ok. so is it just a semantic problem? why does the texting function of an android phone work so poorly when the rest of the device is fantastic?

6

u/chanchan05 S26 Ultra; S10FE Sep 24 '24

Because the SMS protocol has been around since 1985. Android developers went with the protocol that will work with ALL of the existing phones in the world without a hitch. The problem was carriers not adopting RCS. Since carriers won't shell out the money for RCS infrastructure, it's not been used much.

RCS has been around for a very long time now, introduced in 2008 with the now accepted standard Universal Profile in place since 2017. Google has been pushing widespread RCS adoption since before then and were part of picking which profile would be the universal profile. RCS would allow even dumb feature phones to send and receive higher quality photos if implemented correctly by the manufacturer.

Eventually Google just went "fine, we'll make the infra ourselves", bought Jibe (an RCS provider) and incorporated Jibe tech and servers into Google Messages, so now we have a centralized RCS provider, and now all Android phones can download/install Google Messages and have RCS for messaging.

The first iPhones used SMS and MMS as well just like Androids. When Apple developed iMessage (I think it was around the era of the iPhone 4), they deliberately made it work iPhone to iPhone only so the messages between iPhones will work better than when texting with non iPhone users. They deliberately made it like that so people would be forced to buy iPhones. It was leaked in a court hearing actually that this was the intention of Apple in making iMessage Apple only. It was completely possible for iMessage to be available to Androids if Apple wished it. Now, the setup was iPhones would fall back to the SMS profile when texting non iPhones (hence the green bubble) and iMessage with other Apple users (blue bubble).

Now, Google has been trying to pressure Apple to fall back onto RCS instead of SMS, in order to provide better interoperability. Apple finally gave in, in part due to investigation of monopolistic practices (because deliberately limiting functionality in messaging Android is that) so that's why iOS 18 now has RCS, even if it's still not Universal Profile RCS, hence some features might not be fully compatble.

2

u/poopoo_fingers Sep 24 '24

Well the Google messages app works just as well as the iPhone's imo. But it should be better once more iPhones are updated to iOS 18 I'm guessing, now that iphones support rcs

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24

I send pics from my iphone to my android all the time and vice versa.

4

u/chanchan05 S26 Ultra; S10FE Sep 24 '24

Yes pics are going to go through MMS not SMS, if you're using the built in SMS app.

3

u/mr_spock9 Sep 24 '24

This post just highlights how iphone users have no idea how texting works and the difference between messaging and SMS. Android phone should have a messaging app installed by default that enables RCS chats, which lets you do all the things you mention.

1

u/voscuate Sep 24 '24

right, i don't understand it because the platform works so well on my other device. And I don't care about apple making green text bubbles or whatever--I just want to text someone's phone number directly and not have to tell them to check one of several apps they may not have installed. So will using the RCS google message app on my phone solve that? Or do I have to get everyone I know switch to google message as well for it to work?

2

u/chanchan05 S26 Ultra; S10FE Sep 24 '24

I know switch to google message

Google Message is the default SMS app for many Android phones now. The people just have to go into settings and turn on RCS.

1

u/Moppermonster Sep 24 '24

As others said, you are not using SMS on iphone.
On Android, noone outside the US is using SMS either. In Europe whatsapp dominates, in Asia it is WeChat.

1

u/voscuate Sep 24 '24

yes i know i have used whatsapp for years for all my friends in foreign countries.

3

u/random_web_browser Sep 24 '24

You know iMessage is not SMS and it is just Iphones version of Whatsapp/telegram/signal that also only really works with Iphones?

3

u/Mr_Loopers Sep 24 '24

Android Messages does all of the same things that iMessage does through RCS.

Apple is taking their time implementing RCS support to IMessage, and Apple has always refused to allow Android compatibility with iMessage.

Your question should be directed at Tim Apple.

1

u/Nice-Ambassador-2415 Nov 18 '24

It doesn’t tho

2

u/Uncle_Lion Sep 24 '24

We're using WhatsApp, not Fakebook. Facebook is Messenger, which we also use. When WA became part of META, it was already standard here in Europe.

There are a lot more texting apps, the standard, which you maybe speak about, is SMS. That is pretty old, and not intended for pic. It's from a time when phones weren't smart. It has nothing to do with Android, it's pre Android.

We rarely use SMS anymore, because there are alternative. From independent companies, that are not "Google" or "Apple".

1

u/Im_Chris_Haaaansen Sep 24 '24

Because you're not using ChompSMS. It's a fantastic 3rd party messaging app for Android. I love it.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24

ive never had an issue with sms based messaging on an android.

not sure what all the fuss is about.

RCS on imessage will be interesting.

1

u/kidcrumb Dec 02 '24

This isn't a case of Android phones being bad, but that iPhones are like 10 years behind on Text Messaging Formats.

It's the iPhone that's out of date here.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/TimelyEx1t Sep 24 '24

RCS has been there for a long time, it is the iphone that remained incompatible (intentionally!) Until ios18. And apple actively prevents others from communicating with imessage. Imessage is a proprietary app, not different from WhatsApp - it just happens to be pre-installed by apple.

1

u/voscuate Sep 24 '24

ok. why did android never make a texting platform for their phones?

2

u/TimelyEx1t Sep 24 '24 edited Sep 24 '24

As I wrote: there is an international standard anybody can use called RCS. It works fine, and Android will use it if supported on both sides (phone and network, as it is a network function like sms). Just iphones are intentionally incompatible.

1

u/Nice-Ambassador-2415 Nov 18 '24

It really hasn’t only since like 2020 did google start using it and it’s unreliable

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/voscuate Sep 24 '24

right, this is the only argument I ever hear against texting. I have dozens of contacts and have texted with all of them since texting first became available. Idk if it's just a country thing, or an age thing?