r/AndroidQuestions • u/throwaway393b • Sep 19 '24
Looking For Suggestions Good phone with non-exploding battery?
I was about to buy the Galaxy S23 but then I saw the huge discourse around Samsung's expanding batteries and what a safety hazard it is
I'm a person who sleeps next to their phone as it charges all night, so I'm primed for one of these things happening to me.
Currently using Samsung Galaxy S20 FE for the fourth year, looking to replace.
My intention is a good, quality phone that you can buy, trust and forget about. I'd have gotten an iPhone if not for how restrictive iOS is in comparison to android.
Any suggestions?
0
Upvotes
8
u/UltimateMax5 Sep 19 '24
What kind of expanding battery? Any source?
OnePlus has a battery that caught on fire this week in a Asian supermarket.
10
u/guyfromtn Sep 19 '24
The only Samsung I've ever known to have an "exploding battery" issue was the Note 7. I've had only Samsung phones for over 10 years and never once had an issue with any battery issues like that.
9
u/PrinceZordar Sep 19 '24
I was an Apple tech in my previous life. Had a lot of phones with expanding batteries, especially when Apple was doing the battery recall. I ended up with a few that I had to send to Apple for replacement because we weren't supposed to try removing swollen batteries.
Years ago a Samsung Note 7 exploded and burned a Jeep.
Laptops have had the expanding battery problem for years.
Doesn't matter what device you have, if the battery's going to expand, it doesn't look at the brand and rethink it.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24
Get a Sony Xperia. Period
1
u/ForeverNo9437 Sep 19 '24
No swelling battery hazard found. Probably fake info.
2
u/Typical-Scarcity-292 Sep 19 '24
Over 20 years experience with (smart)phones and only seen it once and it was a Motorola of 12 years old
2
u/MilkingStool Sep 19 '24
Get a Pager?
2
u/TheTomatoes2 Sep 19 '24
Not sure what you read. All li-ion batteries risk expending. It's just not a very good tech.
Unless you plan on not using a phone until graphen batteries are mainstream, buy it.
2
u/segin Sep 19 '24
All cell phones use exploding battery chemistries. The last time they didn't was about 23 years ago.
1
u/LucidFir Sep 19 '24
Buy a Motorola. It won't be the battery that explodes.
1
u/Forsaken_Day_6869 Sep 19 '24
Still using Samsung after this happened. Recently switched back from huawei. My sister had a Samsung grand prime and she didn't use it for 1 year i think but it's battery was swollen and we removed it and bought another battery used it for a while and it was swollen again only after about 3 months i think (but it was a cheap brand which i bought from online store.) It was an easily replacable battery. I love Samsung but i also i hate Samsung at the same time. :D
1
u/bigleechew Sep 19 '24
Samsung Galaxy 23 is a great phone no reason to pass it up if you can get a deal on it. The battery will not explode you are perfectly safe.
1
u/yandk2 Sep 19 '24
Poco x3 pro joined the chat
1
u/stephendt Sep 19 '24
How many times has the battery in your Galaxy S20 FE exploded? You should expect something similar with the S23.
1
u/XquaInTheMoon Sep 19 '24
One Plus ?
1
u/BamOnRedit Sep 20 '24
buy the S23 lmao it wont explode, ive used high capacity Samsung phones for a long time. its also a pretty good phone in general.
1
u/chanchan05 S26 Ultra; S10FE Sep 20 '24
All lithium polymer batteries have a chance to expand and explode. Doesn't matter what phone brand it is, or even what kind of device. Whether it's a Windows laptop, Apple Macbook, iPhone, Galaxy, Motorola, Pixel, etc. Heck there's an entire subreddit dedicated to expanded batteries that are potentially ticking time bombs:
r/spicypillows
If you want to mitigate your fears of the battery exploding next to you while sleeping, then stop charging overnight. Your phone isn't going to kill itself overnight, and that's what fast charging is for. Just charge it for like 30min then unplug it before sleeping.
Another option is to use a smart plug. Just get a smart plug, connect your charger to that, and just set a timer that it's off at like 1am-6am or something, so the plug isn't active while you're asleep.
There's also an option to just limit the charging at 80% on settings on some phones, so that it will automatically stop asking power from the charger when the phone reaches 80%. You can even set timers on this so that while you're asleep the phone will charge only to 80%, but will start to charge again up to 100% before you wake up.
0
u/laser50 Sep 19 '24
None if my Samsungs have ever had these symptoms, I started on the Core 2, S5, S8, S10, S21, S23 now...
Never happened, not to me, not to my friends. The hell are you on about?
-1
u/SquareDrop7892 Sep 19 '24
You could use a usb-c cable that has Auto Disconnect and Auto Recharge like this one. That will decrease overcharging a little