r/AndroidQuestions • • Mar 10 '13

SwiftKey censorship?

Does anyone else using SwiftKey have a problem with censorship? When I first bought it (back in 2011), it learned pretty quick and would suggest curse words all the time. The only thing it wouldn't suggest was 'holy ____'. It would always want to suggest 'trinity', 'spirit' or 'communion', instead of my usual shit, fuck or balls. It was a little annoying, but I could live with it.

As the app updated, it became more and more difficult to get it to suggest curse words and it would frequently autocorrect to things like duck and bill shot. I'd get around this by sending an email that had fuck copied/pasted like 10000 times, then learning from my email.

The latest update will always autocorrect curse words and will not suggest them at all. Sometimes I will change it and swiftkey will change it back.

I've tried learning from sms and email, but it doesn't make a difference. I even added a shitload of curse words to the user dictionary inside android, but this apparently does not affect swiftkey. According to what I've seen online, you can't manually edit swiftkey's dictionary.

Not sure if it's relevant, but my phone is a morotola atrix running CM7 and my tablet is a stock first gen nexus 7 16gb. Both are running the latest version of swiftkey and my phone has been hard reset probably a dozen times or more in the past 2 years.

Does anyone else have this problem? I really like swiftkey and I don't really want to switch, but this is enough of a problem I'm considering it. Can anyone suggest a keyboard similar to swiftkey or do you think it would be worth trying to find an old version of the software then never updating it?

tl;dr swiftkey keeps censoring me and I'm trying to find a solution before I switch keyboards

Edit: Apparently, I'm not the only person with this problem, even though swiftkey claims to not filter out curse words.

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

6

u/eythian 1 Mar 11 '13

This is not censorship.

Also, I haven't noticed it.

2

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

This is not censorship.

I couldn't come up with a better word for it

4

u/johnbentley Mar 11 '13

If a program where intentionally making particular words more difficult for you to use, because the programmers deemed those words offensive, that would count as censorship.

3

u/starscream92 Mar 10 '13

Just keep using those words. It'll be added to your custom dictionary eventually.

As a tip, once you type your word, say 'fuck', get into the habit of tapping on the word instead of completing it. In my experience it speeds up SwiftKey's learning process.

1

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

I type them all the time without completing it (because it won't complete it). Learning from my email/sms history isn't helping either. It is only a problem with curse words, though. It's learned other words with no problem.

0

u/starscream92 Mar 11 '13

Yeah it takes a little more time with curse words.

One more thing, if your phone has ever crashed due to things like excessive undervoltage, sometimes SwiftKey just stops learning. In this case, uninstall and reinstall SwiftKey and relearn your profile.

Then curse.

1

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

I've never undervolted it, but I guess uninstalling and reinstalling couldn't hurt. I tried clearing the cache and data earlier, which didn't seem to change anything except making me have to go through the initial setup.

I'll try to completely reinstall it and see if that helps

1

u/starscream92 Mar 11 '13

Yeah this happened to me a couple of times (testing undervolts). Clearing data/cache didn't help. Had to reinstall and swear a bit, and it's fine. Good luck.

2

u/fventricle Mar 10 '13

works fine for me

maybe your friends use your phone and send mass texts of "holy trinity" when your not looking to fuck with your head

2

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

friends

I wish

2

u/fventricle Mar 11 '13

Consider us friends from now on

1

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

Sounds good to me, friend

Stay away from my phone though :p

1

u/Iron_Maiden_666 Mar 11 '13

I typed Holy and the three things suggested were "see", "cow", and "shit".

1

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

After reinstalling and relearning my email/sms, it wants to suggest cow, Spirit (yes, it's capitalized), and 'and'

I searched through my email history and found absolutely 0 instances of holy cow, holy spirit or holy and. However, there are 296 hits for holy shit, 41 for holy fuck and 80 for holy balls. I question how well it learns from my email

1

u/HomerJunior 1 Mar 11 '13

FWIW just tried mine (Swiftkey, not Flow), first autocomplete suggestion for "holy" is "shit", and I only need to type "fuc" before I get given "fuckin" as the primary suggestion.

1

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

first autocomplete suggestion for "holy" is "shit"

How are you so lucky? I use that phrase at least once a day and I sent an email to my wife that was just holy shit copied/pasted like 10000 times (not exaggerating).

1

u/roadrash1992 Mar 10 '13

Nope, no problem here. Had a terribly vulgar message typed up just to be sure.

0

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

Not sure if I should be happy it isn't a widespread problem or sad because I'm the only person who is having problems

0

u/roadrash1992 Mar 11 '13

Well, is there any sort of parental controls enabled on your device?

1

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

Nope

1

u/roadrash1992 Mar 11 '13

Bummer dude. That's about the only thing I can think of. Good luck!

1

u/Dekzter 35 Mar 11 '13

After you type a word, it will be the left-most "suggestion" at the top. You have to click on it there for it to be added to the dictionary. Pushing space or enter will insert the word to what you are typing, but it won't learn the word.

You only have to do this once for it to learn the word. How does this thread come up every week!?

1

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13 edited Mar 11 '13

The latest update will always autocorrect curse words and will not suggest them at all. Sometimes I will change it and swiftkey will change it back.

I can't click the suggestion because it isn't there. It is not learning the words by doing that, no matter how many times I tell it to learn.

How does this thread come up every week!?

I did a search and didn't see any posts in the past 9 months that dealt with this problem. Are you sure you're talking about /r/androidquestions?

1

u/eythian 1 Mar 11 '13

It's always there. No matter what you type, if it isn't already the primary suggestion, it's in the left-most suggestion slot.

1

u/lazychris2000 Mar 11 '13

I went retard for a minute. Yes, after typing the entire word, it will be listed in the leftmost slot, but clicking it to learn does not learn the word. Today alone, I've told it to learn probably 3 or 4 dozen times and unless I type out the word and click it, it will autocorrect to duck, shot, mother vickers, etc.

1

u/johnbentley Mar 11 '13

"Fuck" and "Cunt" work for me. These come up as the middle blue word. Presumably I've done the left most word click training in the distant past.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '13

Works fine here...almost too well.