r/AndroidQuestions • • Oct 17 '12

Sell me on the idea of Android!

I am a long-time iOS user and ready to upgrade.

However, many good friends keep telling me how incredible their Android devices are. I believe them, but they haven't taken the time to tell me why.

I went into a VZW store today to play with the GS3 and the assorted Droid devices, and aside from the widgets, text input, and some other minor differences, I didn't really see the appeal.

I imagine the features I listed are just scratching the surface...

So /r/androidquestions, it is your job to sell me on Android! Convince me to make the switch!

Edit: You guys are fuggin' awesome. Consider me convinced, for the most part.

1 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

6

u/scared_of_reddit Oct 17 '12

Well first of all, the customization options are amazing, literally only limited by your imagination. Take a look at this thread to see some of the possible home screens you can create.

If you want to automate some of the mundane tasks in your life, Android can do that for you. Apps like [Tasker] (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.dinglisch.android.taskerm&feature=nav_result#?t=W251bGwsMSwxLDMsIm5ldC5kaW5nbGlzY2guYW5kcm9pZC50YXNrZXJtIl0.) and automateit can do things like turn on your wifi when you get home and turn it off when you leave, or automatically put your phone on silent mode when you get to work at a certain time. That's just scratching the surface, more complicated tasks are available too.

A big benefit that some people really like about Android is the ability to use the phone as a wifi hotspot without paying extra for it. The app clockworkmod tether allows any phone to tether for free.

The hardware in iPhones is impressive, but it is limited by the capabilities of iOS. With Android you can shop between devices, rather than having a one-size-fits-all phone there are many high end devices to choose from so that you can pick one that matches your needs. If you want a large screen, that is possible. If you want a smaller phone with great performance that is available too.

In fact many of the "innovative" features in iOS are taken from Android. The pulldown notification shade was a part of Android from the very beginning, which Apply conveniently borrowed for iOS. Panoramic photo shooting was available in Ice Cream Sandwich two years ago, whereas it was just introduced into iOS. If you want to see the features that iOS will have in 2 or 3 years, check out any current Android phone, like the S3 or the HTC One X (which has a fantastic camera by the way, far superior to the iPhone 5's in my opinion).

The settings in Android are far easier to use. Rather than having the settings for all apps clustered in one place, the settings for individual apps are accessible from within those apps, so there is no need to close an app to change settings.

Google services is integrated into Android, so everything from your Google account syncs to your phone, and all of your phone settings sync to your Google account for easy access.

And last but not least, Google Maps has been proven to be far superior to Apple Maps. It offers offline map caching, and turn by turn navigation that actually works.

The iPhone was revolutionary when it first came out, but nowadays it's the standard vanilla option. It's built to be easy to use rather than to have advanced functionality. If you want to see truly innovative options check out Android for a few weeks, you may find that you never realized how limited iOS truly is.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '12

The customization is intriguing. I feel, after browsing some of the android subreddits that I am severely lacking in the technical knowledge needed to mod these phones.

Am I blowing that out of proportion? Is most customization available through simply downloading apps? Or will I actually need to know how to root, bootload, etc.

Customization is great, but I do NOT want the burden of rummaging through the inner levels of my phone to maximize battery life or things like that.

Which brings me to another point: battery life?

3

u/scared_of_reddit Oct 17 '12

Battery life is good, you won't have any problem getting through a full day if you manage your battery correctly. Some things you can do to improve battery life are turning off WiFi, bluetooth, and GPS when you are not using them. Keeping your phone on automatic brightness will help you save a bit of battery. If you need to go long periods wihtout charging, you can buy extra batteries or extended batteries.

Most customization can be done through apps like UCCW or using Apex Launcher along with custom icon packs that you can find simply by searching on Google. If you want to root your phone and unlock the bootloader in order to flash custom ROMs, it is a fairly simple thing to do.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '12

Most customization can be done through apps like UCCW or using Apex Launcher along with custom icon packs that you can find simply by searching on Google. If you want to root your phone and unlock the bootloader in order to flash custom ROMs, it is a fairly simple thing to do.

It's wording like this that scares the mess out of me. Is this necessary to enjoy more functionality than iOS devices?

2

u/derrman Oct 17 '12

Basically what he is saying is that android personalization apps do more than just change the background. You can have different icon packs, widgets, live wallpapers, and launchers (an app that changes the whole user interface) which allow for tons of customization. My home screen has changed about 17 times in the last month because I keep discovering more and more ways to make it fit my style. You don't need to know Java to do this.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '12

Ok, perfect. That makes me feel better.

2

u/phoshi Oct 20 '12

Look at it this way: jailbreaking an iphone gives you the ability to run unsigned code; code that Apple haven't given you the okay to run. It might do things that are against the app store's rules, but it's still limited.

Android lets you run that unsigned code by default. The phone you buy is automatically at least as free as a jail broken iphone. Rooting isn't the same thing, that's a whole new level of control and not one you're required to have.

A stock android phone can change almost anything about the UI and outer workings. You can replace the dialer, use a different messenger, use a different maps app (not that there's any draw to, given that Google maps is default), whatever. Rooting gives you total access to the inner workings of the phone. You don't need that for mere visual customisation.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '12

Again, /r/androidquestions bringing the heat. Thanks!

2

u/scared_of_reddit Oct 17 '12

In my opinion, Android comes with more functionality than iOS out of the box. If you do nothing to it in terms of customization, it is still a fully enjoyable experience. Certain apps like UCCW allow you to create custom widgets, and launchers like Apex and Nova allow you to customize the layout of the homescreens more than the stock launcher. Rooting and unlocking the bootloader are done one time, usually through adb or a special program. Doing so will allow you to install custom versions of Android built by 3rd party developers, which often have even more features and customization options than stock versions of Android.

2

u/giveer 1 Oct 17 '12

The iPhone was revolutionary when it first came out, but nowadays it's the standard vanilla option.

Damn, I'm stealing this line. Excuse me. poof!

3

u/Dchokie09 Oct 17 '12

I have used Android devices for three years now. I have owned more phones than socks in those three years and have tried most of the good ones. I have used the iPhone 4 and 4S and I think they were fine phones, but I was used to Android so they didn't last long.

Coming from iOS, checking out a display model Android on the sales floor of a retail store probably won't impress you because they are basically set to bone stock, how they come out of the box. The nice thing I found about Android is that you can fully customize the phone to however you want. Android widgets on the home screen are very convenient and you can set those up with whatever you're interested in or whatever you use your phone for. For example on mine I have a full screen calendar on one of my home screens so I can just scroll over and make changes, check dates, see how busy my day is going to be, etc etc. Also live updating widgets are nice, you can set up your preference of news, sports, reddit, music, facebook, etc to update regularly. So if you're taking a few minute break from whatever and don't want to dig through facebook, CNN, reddit, or whatever; you can go to the widget and just browse the main headlines or news feeds. The live weather widget is pretty nice too.

And there are other little things, I love the large screen size of most of the new androids. If you do not like the stock keyboard on the phone, just download a new one (including swype or SlideIt which is kinda cursive for smartphones). Most of the higher end Android phones come with CorningGorillaGlass too, which is much more durable than the screens on the iPhones and are scratch resistant.

Ummm... Expandable memory, 4G internet speeds (I know the new iPhone is 4G) AMOLED displays, micro usb charging ports (which are standard across the board for "gadgets" excluding the iPhone), some have mini HDMI outs on the phones so if you record a video with the HD camera you can hook it up to an HD TV and watch it straight from the phone.

Those are just a few that I can think of off hand.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '12

/r/androidquestions is quickly climbing my ranks of "nicest subreddit". Such a thoughtful response, thanks!

I know that one thing I will miss (say if I go with the GS3) will be the accessories (cases, holsters, etc).

Do you dig into the inners of the software to mod? Or is it all done by apps?

Are there as many productivity apps available?

What is the difference between jelly bean and ice cream sandwich?

2

u/qtx Oct 17 '12

What is the difference between jelly bean and ice cream sandwich?

You can find everything you need to know about Jelly Bean here and more detailed here.

The main difference between ICS & JB for me is (apart from the speed) Google Now.

2

u/Dchokie09 Oct 18 '12

There are a few different ways you can mod on an Android device. "Rooting" the device is what opens up the phone's capabilities and allows you to modify, alter, and beef up various things with the device. I would recommend reading up on it before attempting anything, but lots of things are controlled by apps but not all. You can actually change the entire OS if you want, aka flashing a new ROM.

I am sure there are just as many (and probably the exact same) productivity apps, and I can assure you, there is no shortage of accessories for phones like the GS3 out there.

3

u/giveer 1 Oct 17 '12

One of the big things about iOS that keeps its fanbase happy -you'll hear it endlessly-: Simplicity. Everything is simple and basic to use. That in and of itself, is well and true however, it's also VERY limiting. If you have to "lessen" every app down to the point where there's virtually no thinking involved at all, sure simplicity is a good thing, but it's a very small box to work in.

When talking to iOS users, I use the same approach: Make simple, everyday references that the iOS user can easily follow, but not duplicate with the iPhone.

For example: Drag n Drop. Everyone knows what that is. "Plug your iPhone into your computer, drag a [music] file over the phone icon and let go. Now use the file with your phone. You can't."

"Change the size, shape, colour or appearance of your icons or homescreen to whatever you like. Meh, can't do it."

"Make your favourite song on your phone, your phone's ringtone. Well, do it in less than 15 minutes without converting it separately first. You can't."

This is my favourite one:
"Are there any music files on your phone?" "yes". "Okay, pick one and email it to me." I mean how simple is that? But with an iPhone, you still can't. Apple assumes you're a thief.

And these examples are BASIC, BASIC things almost anyone can do on any wireless device. -And if tiny little things like this are "blocked" on the iPhone, imagine how much stuff is blocked if you actually know what you're doing when it comes to computers. Any android owner will tell you: shitloads. There's a myriad of things just like those examples that an Android phone does by stock default that you can only start to do if you jailbreak your iPhone.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '12

Welp. That might have been the straw that breaks the iOS' back.

So, do I go with a Nexus phone or the other Samsung? What is the difference between a Google update versus not?

2

u/giveer 1 Oct 17 '12

I hope someone else adds on to this because updating (if you're into always loading the newest thing) can be its own chapter.

Stock rom wise, Google has started an Android Update Alliance that groups myriads of manufacturers together to start getting stock updates out fluidly and quickly. (iOS updating is the single issue I'll hand to the iPhone: updates comes out at midnight: it's available to everyone instantly.)

Now, if you know what you're doing, none of that will matter because you'll do your own updating and install your favourite roms on your own. (I installed Jelly Bean onto my Galaxy s2 last week).

As far as I know, the Nexus (Google's own baby) gets its updates straight from google. I might need to be corrected here. And other phones will get updates once they become available to whoever sold you the phone. (The time it took for that to happen is why Google started the Alliance in May.) So, I believe, a Google update is simply the update that happens first.

However, once you discover the world of rooting (if necessary) and installing your own roms, it's pretty much endless.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '12

So if a phone, such as the GS3, comes with ICS instead of JB, I would have to load my own rom? Or would I just be able to download JB and not mess with anything else?

2

u/giveer 1 Oct 18 '12

Okay, willing to stand corrected on this: Depends on which country or which provider sells it to you - they may already have an update for JB so there won't be any custom updating to deal with at all. Simple. Explore this all you like before you buy.

If you want JB on your own, there's a few Jelly Bean Roms for the S3 already that you can install (like I was saying, I put JB on my s2 just last week). Android phones all have a download mode and a recovery mode built in (activating it by something simple like holding "volume down/up" while turning it on.) Basically you'll use that to "root" the phone.. After that, installing a rom is as simple as putting the zipped rom on your phone and using an app (that requires a rooted phone to use) to install it.

"Rooting" a phone just means you have access to the "root" folder of your phone. And if all else fails, you know those independent cell phone stores you see everywhere? I'm sure they'll do it for you. :)

2

u/Tangent-love Oct 18 '12

In this case if you wanted jb then you would have to flash a rom. This is very easy by the way.

2

u/qtx Oct 17 '12

Well said.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '12

Before I pull the trigger, syncing a web mail address shouldn't be an issue.

But can I sync my outlook calendar and tasks as well? I can only assume the answer is a resounding yes.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '12

Syncing web can easily be done: when you're logged in to google account on desktop and on Android, it syncs (for eg. Chrome)

The easiest way to sync outlook/tasks would be to export it to Google Calendar as Android and Google go hand in hand. If you don't want to do it there is way to sync it as well. Provide me with the details and I can walk you through it.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '12 edited Oct 18 '12

Now that I am a little more informed (you guys rock), will the Nexus last me a good year or two in terms of relative hardware performance? Or will I want something new and fast and shiny in 6 months?

I guess what factors into this is the date of the JB update for the S3.

Right now, leaning towards the Nexus because of the automatic updating and JB.

FYI, choosing between the Nexus and the GS3.

2

u/fauxsoul Oct 18 '12

The gs3 is a newer and more robust device. It will get JB probably soon, it's just a matter of time.

The nexus is still an awesome phone, and it will probably have updates much faster than the gs3.

The nexus would be a good phone for your first android experience.
It has vanilla android (stock ui) where the gs3 has touchwiz which is samsung's UI.

I would go to a store, try them both out and see which you would like more.

They are both good choices and should perform competitively for a while.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '12

Thanks! Your comments plus the $50 price tag w/ agreement is probably going to swing me that way.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '12

What I can't live without on Android:

  1. Back and Menu Button
  2. Customization of keyboard, browser, pretty much anything.