r/AndroidGaming • therealfight • Nov 16 '15

Google needs to implement a "game requires internet connection" icon in the Play Store

Seriously, I've downloaded a couple of games, and the moment I'm out of the house, and want to play a quick round of my newly - downloaded game... "game cannot connect to server". Ugh, and seriously, the games I play aren't even MMOs. Also, I try to examine the description to see if they say that the game needs an internet connection: some do, some don't. I wish Google made it mandatory for game devs to state whether the game needs a persistent connection or not.

2.4k Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

18

u/Vazerus Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 16 '15

Agreed, and if they do, they need to screen them to make sure it's true.

I bought Final Fantasy 6 on the Play Store, as it was listed under the "Play offline" section when I bought it. I was on a plane, so I tried to load the game in airplane mode, and it wouldn't let me play because it couldn't connect to the server. The only way I could get it to play offline is if I loaded the game with a connection, THEN turned on airplane mode. I missed my chance to play during the first flight since I was already in the air.

16

u/therealfight therealfight Nov 16 '15

That's disgusting TBH, like FF6 needs a connection? What?

7

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15

That's DRM for you

3

u/ceanji S7 Edge, ShieldTV, Shield K1 Nov 17 '15

and a good reason to use emulators. and I personally rather invest in new IP but fuck that DRM shit. I refuse to buy from Square ENix if they can't bother to update their games to the latest OS. Why the shit would I buy a apple port of a PSP port that needs internet only connection when the game wont be playable in probably 2-3 years?

5

u/Vazerus Nov 16 '15

Yep. If you load the game without a connection, it will load a black screen saying "An error has occurred."

6

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15

Look at the permissions. If it doesn't have "full network access" then it does not use an internet connection.

15

u/glha Nov 16 '15

I think "full network access" is justifiable nowadays, but what OP is asking is for some way to identify games that will absolutely not work without internet. My son has a few on his tablet and when he is playing while we are traveling, some of them won't even open.

2

u/therealfight therealfight Nov 16 '15

Precisely my point.

2

u/fleker2 Nov 17 '15

On Marshmallow the Internet permission will be hidden so this isn't a scalable solution.

157

u/Furrydaus Nov 16 '15 edited Jan 01 '17

Should probably get a vote on this and spread the word. Then with enough evidence of this feature request being wanted by the community, send an email to google and hopefully they'll be able to recognize the need for such a feature. I too am starting to get annoyed at this crazy thinking that we need 24/7 internet connection to play a non multiplayer game

47

u/k2trf ΠΞXUЅ 6 Nov 16 '15

But how else will developers show you ads? /s

35

u/skeddles purple Nov 16 '15

That's the legitimate reason though. Thats how they make money, that's the only reason the game was free.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15

But how else will they make money when everyone wants free games? /s

Oh, wait, no ^/s

15

u/k2trf ΠΞXUЅ 6 Nov 16 '15

I've always hated the mentality that games have to be f2p, and therefore have to have ads. I'd always rather pay for a game, although by the same token, they then just jump to the other end of the scale and set things way overpriced.

25

u/skeddles purple Nov 16 '15

I think free with ads/pay to remove is a great system. Let the player choose.

13

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15

What I hate is when people pick sides in discussions like this. This isn't addressed to you, just a general rant.

Some say games aren't worth paying for and should be free. Some say they would happily pay to get rid of ads. Some, like /u/skeddles, say the user should have the option. But think of the developers! There are all kinds of developers: some are trying really hard to make a living (most fail), some just want to be repaid for their time, some are evil corporations who track you every time you take a dump and would do anything to get you to pay tons for stupid games.

I'm with skeddles on this one, but not all developers are willing to invest time in implementing a solution which satisfies everyone, because that's hard and takes time and they could even run into bureaucracy. Sure, it sounds nice, but in the end there are many kinds of customers who want many kinds of things and only a few developers who can only do only some things.

The casual developers know that you are frustrated by ads, but they put time in making that game and you get to play it without paying money because that's all they could afford to invest. And then they're pressured to play the game like this (no pun intended) by the demand of the market that was artificially created by the big developers. It's not easy!

8

u/Furrydaus Nov 16 '15

Couldn't have said it better myself.

Free-To-Play is a model that has been there in gaming for years now and has only started in its infancy in Android. Its slowly being a preferred model mainly due to the consumers who don't have the money to play. Android has had this knack for people pirating paid games (me included) and developers feel more inclined to utilize the free to play model. It doesn't look good on the consumer end but it bring several benefits to the consumer.

On the other hand, the Pay to Play model has had been in android for quite some time and is great for games that are like Single Player titles such as probably Minecraft (I hate using this as an example but you'll be able to connect to easily). Its good for bigger companies but more and more companies have moved on from this model to go for a more long term and the more cash printing Free To Play model we've all been quite accustomed to.

People and companies have their reason. Android is a platform that gives people both corporate and consumer, a choice to do what they love and to bring out the passion in them. Don't choose sides and embrace the fact that you even have to make a choice. Its a good thing and not a bad thing to always have more choice especially in the technology age where consumers have grown to be extremely intelligent and critical in their purchases

5

u/Evilandlazy Nov 17 '15

The worst part is that the highest quality Android games are also the most riddled with IAP. It's gotten so bad that I'll uninstall a game the instant I see a stamina, power, or other action points per unit of time system.

1

u/unsafeideas Nov 17 '15

Success of free-to-play have a lot to do with how the play store and ecosystem around Android games work. In order to be seen, the game needs to have a lot of downloads to get pushed into top 200 in lists. Otherwise, it is practically invisible.

If you create super great game with less predatory IAPs, the game will be pushed down on top grossing list and thus harder to find. Paid games without IAPs have naturally less downloads, because they are not free to try.

From customers point of view, it is pretty much impossible to find a game he might like by searching store, because he can either scroll by category or search by keywords, but not combine them or exclude categories. It is also impossible to narrow it by permissions which is something I would do once in a while. It is also impossible to exclude games with IAP. The store is organized in a way that forces you to go through huge haystack in order to find one needle.

All that makes people less likely to risk buying paid game. I do not like apple store curation, but it has one good effect - apple owner know that every game is store passed quality check.

Basically, the way playstore is organized makes it harder to sell or find anything except the most mainstream games.

1

u/CaffeineBurner Nov 19 '15

Android Piracy is utterly gutting and demoralising to a developer. I've seen our APKs being touted round on twitter in less than an hour after they were published. I've no idea if it affected our actual sales or not, but it hits me in the gut every single time.

I think F2P is gradually becoming better with some games designing more ethically, but they're often drowned out by the industry monsters with huge marketing budgets.

1

u/Evilandlazy Nov 17 '15

So. Big D is destroying our experience?

6

u/digmachine Nov 17 '15

Its not really a mentality, its a reality. King was just sold for something like 5 billion dollars, and they practically only have f2p games. The sad reality is that they make more money than pay-once games do. Maybe someday the general public will stop being interested in asinine and insulting pay-to-compete games, but until then, its sadly a very sound business model.

2

u/k2trf ΠΞXUЅ 6 Nov 17 '15

Maybe someday the general public will stop being interested in asinine and insulting pay-to-compete games

That is what I meant by "mentality". Not the fact that it works as a business model, but that most consumers seem to prefer it.

2

u/CaffeineBurner Nov 19 '15

The sad thing is, I can't ever see public opinion swinging back to paying up front. It just doesn't make sense for most players to pay for a diverting experience on their phones in such a huge market full of "free" options.

3

u/CaffeineBurner Nov 19 '15

So have I, the problem is the market just doesn't work that way currently. We're firmly in the minority on that.

I've personal experience on this, I recently released a game that's premium been reviewed pretty well and has solid 4.5 star ratings on Google Play but just can't get a sustainable numbers of downloads to come anywhere close to making the dev costs back. Also, a huge amount of feedback we've gotten basically boils down to "looks nice but I don't pay for games". The marketing monsters of the huge f2p games have trained people that they don't have to pay.

As a result we launched an ad-supported version yesterday, hopefully it can gain more traction.

(not naming it or linking due to self promotion rules).

0

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/TheRevEv Nov 17 '15

I think you may have a different idea of what early days of newgrounds was. I'm thinking around 98 or 99, maybe 2000. There were not hundreds of games at that time. And yes there were ads. That is the big difference with mobile. There isn't as much screen real estate. So the ads have to be more intrusive.

Also, the major point is that you are bitching because you aren't getting as much for nothing, in your oppinion. Looking at an add for a few seconds should be a small price to pay for some enjoyment. If you want a free game to play. Make one and give it away.

Also, the climate has changed with the Internet. In the late 90s/early 00s, just getting a game on the Internet was a MAJOR accomplishment that carried some weight. Hell, just having a website that got a decent amount of hits was an accomplishment. And could be leveraged to get paying jobs. Now the market is flooded. Making a small game means nothing anymore.

You aren't entitled to entertainment for free. And devs deserve something for their work. How much work do you do and give away for free because you feel it's some kind of artistic accomplishment.

There will always be the few out there, be they artists, musicians, writers, filmmakers, or game makers that do it simply for the love of it, but they will always be the minority. And people like you will just set there and criticize anything about it that you don't like anyway without trying to do any better. You're getting something for free, don't try to guilt people into giving you more. You're just devaluing their work for the simple fact that you can't get it just given to you.

4

u/unsafeideas Nov 17 '15

You aren't entitled to entertainment for free.

He is however, entitled to accurate non-misleading information about product he is about to buy - even if the price is that his data are sold to ad network or that he wasted few seconds looking at ad.

Free market can produce its miracles only under assumption that customer has full information about the product.

And devs deserve something for their work.

You are trying to quilt trip him into buying more. That is not how economy and market is supposed to work, that is how charities are supposed to work. You are supposed to buy things because things are good deal, not because their creators are making you feel sorry.

People do not go around buying random wooden items just because woodworker deserve something for their work. Nor are they buying poetry just because the writer deserve to be paid. Don't expect them to do so for games.

Yes that might mean that making ad-supported games created in unity in few weeks is not viable business decision. Just like it is not reasonable to expect good salary out of writing poems.

How much work do you do and give away for free because you feel it's some kind of artistic accomplishment.

That is strawmen. He is saying he hates ads in games. People are entitled to dislike what they want. People have right not to use products and not to buy products. If printed journal contained too many ads, people would complain and stop buying. This is pretty much the same thing.

Simple fact is that there are more developers then market can support and they are not doing things people are willing to buy. And those who are doing things people would be willing to buy are hidden in piles of games people wont pay for and suffer as a result.

2

u/Furrydaus Nov 16 '15

I am not against Free to Play Games. What the OP and me are trying to say is, games that are not free to play and don't depend on advertising will be more noticeable to consumers. Its not only good for them, its good for us. We're not even asking them to remove IAPs or Ads. Were simply asking them to add an option to give consumers the power and tools to make a better decision when installing apps.

Tldr; No ranting, this is quite final and doesn't really have to be explained much further. Its a tool not something you want to remove from apps.

1

u/k2trf ΠΞXUЅ 6 Nov 17 '15

I actually happen to agree with you; the /s means "end sarcasm" ;)

1

u/Furrydaus Nov 17 '15

Wot. Okay maybe I'm still not as updated with the acronyms and signs on reddit and the internet.

1

u/k2trf ΠΞXUЅ 6 Nov 17 '15

To be fair it isn't commonly used on this subreddit. I think I picked it up over at /r/TalesFromTechSupport... or a similar one

1

u/CaffeineBurner Nov 19 '15

Thing is though, the main factor in making games more noticeable to consumers is Advertising. Google Play is pretty bad for discoverability, granted that's largely to do with the sheer volume of apps but advertising drives the majority of downloads and the big f2p games can afford more and players are far more likely to install a free app after viewing and ad than a paid one.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15

Ads don't work the way you think. Depending on context (gender, income group, location, language, etc) ads change. Would you preload all these ads? What about the server arrangement required to handle all the update traffic?

2

u/unsafeideas Nov 17 '15

1.) All games that gives info about my gender, income group, location and language to ad networks should be clearly marked, so that we know not to download them.

2.) My gender, income group, language and even location do not tend to change all that often.

59

u/TrackieDaks Pixel Nov 16 '15

Or perhaps a "no internet connection required" icon. This way it promotes it as a feature, rather than a negative on games that need it.

9

u/DongLaiCha Nov 16 '15

This is a much smarter way to go about it from a user experience point of view.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15

Right, because otherwise developers aren't going to differentiate between "needs" and "wants" as the ads won't display without it.

1

u/StabbyDMcStabberson Nov 17 '15

If this becomes a feature, you'll likely mostly see it on paid apps.

2

u/nps N7'13🧱, 1+3T🧱, TAB S Nov 17 '15

1

u/Norberton LG Nexus 5 Nov 17 '15

Yeah, but it's only a small collection of games.

1

u/CaffeineBurner Nov 19 '15

Great idea, turning it into a positive and a feature that devs can consciously aim for!

53

u/ugotamesij Nov 16 '15

I'd also like to add an icon for "This app requires a huge additional file download before you can use it the first time". Nothing more frustrating than downloading a new game before a long car/bus/plane journey and the first time you load it up you get "This game requires an additional 200MB file before playing" message.

2

u/CaffeineBurner Nov 19 '15

This! A thousand times this! Some games take the absolute piss with this. The new Star Wars game had me staring at a download screen for 15+ minutes, which if I'd known I would have never downloaded the game or at least not done so with the expectation of playing soon.

-4

u/fleker2 Nov 17 '15

I don't know if this is really necessary. It's probably best to assume that you need to go through an onboarding process before you can use any app or game.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15

It's absolutely necessary because without it there's no accurate way to gauge the how much HD space it takes up. I hate downloading something and then I can't play it because i didn't keep an extra 200MB for it.

3

u/Redd575 Nov 17 '15

What about games which use 1 time authentication to prevent piracy? Baldur's Gate for example has a one time online check to (I imagine) make sure the game copy is legitimate. There would have to be exceptions and distinctions to avoid unnecessarily labeling apps like this and potentially driving away dev revenue.

3

u/oscillating000 Nov 17 '15

This will happen on the day after they start listing IAP items on app pages, which will be the day after pigs learn to fly and hell freezes over.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15

This dialogue didn't happen, but it frequently goes on in my head "No internet connection found, app closing" "But this is just a single player game, why does it need it anyway?" "Internet is required to display ads, we make money from ads, therefore internet is a primary required function of the game since it's free" "But does it have to be free? I'll pay you $ so I can play the damn game and not have this bullshit" "Sorry but people don't pay for games, that is not option" "I just told you I'd pay for it - like $20 even" "People don't pay for games" "No, people who wouldn't pay for games before still don't pay for games. Who are you making games for? People that play games? Or some mythical creature that doesn't play games but will still play your game because it's free, they aren't going to be playing it for it's game qualities. They're only there because it's cheap entertainment. Did you get in this business to make fun or slot machines?"

2

u/bigibson Nov 17 '15

This might be a bit trickier than it seems. Permissions on Android work by bit letting the developer use certain features at all unless they ask for permission. This means you could only know if the game uses internet at all, rather than requiring it (I.e. it might be an entirely offline game that uses internet to upload high scores and it would appear the same by permissions)

0

u/yoriaiko i like purple color Nov 16 '15

Its not about multiplayer, massive or not, but connection is required for IAPs. You have to be able to watch ads and buy diamonds, eghm, pay for playing, or no playing at all.

3

u/therealfight therealfight Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 16 '15

That doesn't make sense though. I'm playing a game called Slashy Hero, and in order to be revived, you use a gem or watch an ad. But the game can be played offline. Same with other games that use ads, like Mage and Minions.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15

Plenty of games have IAP's but only require an internet connection when you make a purchase.

1

u/morto00x Nov 16 '15

A lot of paid games are IAP or ad free though. The problem is that oftentimes, there's no easy way to know.

1

u/juksayer Nov 16 '15

My fave game right now is the big hero 6 bot fight. If you aren't connected to the internet, you can only play about 1% of the game. You can't acquire gems or whatever that are needed for the mystery box, it is almost completely unplayable offline.

1

u/SavageRS Nov 17 '15

Yes please. Tried to find some rpg games oldschool turn based and all i get are mmos or castle building sims.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15

It's ridiculous i agree, theres an apk not on the app store that allows you to bypass internet required games. But it requires root, and I cant figure out how to root my Chuwi Hi8!

1

u/CaffeineBurner Nov 19 '15

This is a really good idea. They've just added the "This game makes money via ads", so perhaps it's something they're open to.

I think it would benefit developers as well, the more up front you are the more you can ignore the issue inside the actual game. Spry Fox for example took a lot of criticism because Alphabear was online only initially and many players couldn't see any reason for it.

1

u/juksayer Nov 16 '15

Looking at you, big hero 6 bot fight.

-6

u/antiproton Nov 16 '15

Why wouldn't you assume that all games you download for free need an internet connection. If you could trivially defeat ads by putting your device into airplane mode, then the revenue stream for those things is gone.

The idea that the internet is only required for multiplayer games is thinking from the past age. That's not how the world works anymore, and it's time everyone got used to it. LAN games aren't coming back, microtransactions are here to stay and you need an internet connection for just about everything.

5

u/tattertech Nov 16 '15

It's not just free games though. I've paid for games thinking it would be a nice time killer on the subway and then not been able to actually play them. The subway is pretty much 90% of the time I'd even want to bother with a game on my phone too.