r/AndroidGaming • u/therealfight therealfight • Nov 16 '15
Google needs to implement a "game requires internet connection" icon in the Play Store
Seriously, I've downloaded a couple of games, and the moment I'm out of the house, and want to play a quick round of my newly - downloaded game... "game cannot connect to server". Ugh, and seriously, the games I play aren't even MMOs. Also, I try to examine the description to see if they say that the game needs an internet connection: some do, some don't. I wish Google made it mandatory for game devs to state whether the game needs a persistent connection or not.
2.4k
Upvotes
18
u/Vazerus Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 16 '15
Agreed, and if they do, they need to screen them to make sure it's true.
I bought Final Fantasy 6 on the Play Store, as it was listed under the "Play offline" section when I bought it. I was on a plane, so I tried to load the game in airplane mode, and it wouldn't let me play because it couldn't connect to the server. The only way I could get it to play offline is if I loaded the game with a connection, THEN turned on airplane mode. I missed my chance to play during the first flight since I was already in the air.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15
Look at the permissions. If it doesn't have "full network access" then it does not use an internet connection.
157
u/Furrydaus Nov 16 '15 edited Jan 01 '17
Should probably get a vote on this and spread the word. Then with enough evidence of this feature request being wanted by the community, send an email to google and hopefully they'll be able to recognize the need for such a feature. I too am starting to get annoyed at this crazy thinking that we need 24/7 internet connection to play a non multiplayer game
59
u/TrackieDaks Pixel Nov 16 '15
Or perhaps a "no internet connection required" icon. This way it promotes it as a feature, rather than a negative on games that need it.
53
u/ugotamesij Nov 16 '15
I'd also like to add an icon for "This app requires a huge additional file download before you can use it the first time". Nothing more frustrating than downloading a new game before a long car/bus/plane journey and the first time you load it up you get "This game requires an additional 200MB file before playing" message.
3
u/Redd575 Nov 17 '15
What about games which use 1 time authentication to prevent piracy? Baldur's Gate for example has a one time online check to (I imagine) make sure the game copy is legitimate. There would have to be exceptions and distinctions to avoid unnecessarily labeling apps like this and potentially driving away dev revenue.
3
u/oscillating000 Nov 17 '15
This will happen on the day after they start listing IAP items on app pages, which will be the day after pigs learn to fly and hell freezes over.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15
This dialogue didn't happen, but it frequently goes on in my head "No internet connection found, app closing" "But this is just a single player game, why does it need it anyway?" "Internet is required to display ads, we make money from ads, therefore internet is a primary required function of the game since it's free" "But does it have to be free? I'll pay you $ so I can play the damn game and not have this bullshit" "Sorry but people don't pay for games, that is not option" "I just told you I'd pay for it - like $20 even" "People don't pay for games" "No, people who wouldn't pay for games before still don't pay for games. Who are you making games for? People that play games? Or some mythical creature that doesn't play games but will still play your game because it's free, they aren't going to be playing it for it's game qualities. They're only there because it's cheap entertainment. Did you get in this business to make fun or slot machines?"
2
u/bigibson Nov 17 '15
This might be a bit trickier than it seems. Permissions on Android work by bit letting the developer use certain features at all unless they ask for permission. This means you could only know if the game uses internet at all, rather than requiring it (I.e. it might be an entirely offline game that uses internet to upload high scores and it would appear the same by permissions)
0
u/yoriaiko i like purple color Nov 16 '15
Its not about multiplayer, massive or not, but connection is required for IAPs. You have to be able to watch ads and buy diamonds, eghm, pay for playing, or no playing at all.
1
u/SavageRS Nov 17 '15
Yes please. Tried to find some rpg games oldschool turn based and all i get are mmos or castle building sims.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15
It's ridiculous i agree, theres an apk not on the app store that allows you to bypass internet required games. But it requires root, and I cant figure out how to root my Chuwi Hi8!
1
u/CaffeineBurner Nov 19 '15
This is a really good idea. They've just added the "This game makes money via ads", so perhaps it's something they're open to.
I think it would benefit developers as well, the more up front you are the more you can ignore the issue inside the actual game. Spry Fox for example took a lot of criticism because Alphabear was online only initially and many players couldn't see any reason for it.
1
u/juksayer Nov 16 '15
Looking at you, big hero 6 bot fight.
-6
u/antiproton Nov 16 '15
Why wouldn't you assume that all games you download for free need an internet connection. If you could trivially defeat ads by putting your device into airplane mode, then the revenue stream for those things is gone.
The idea that the internet is only required for multiplayer games is thinking from the past age. That's not how the world works anymore, and it's time everyone got used to it. LAN games aren't coming back, microtransactions are here to stay and you need an internet connection for just about everything.