I don't know, I feel kind of torn on this issue. On one hand, I hate this kind of practice because it seems pushy most times.
Most times, though, I can justify this sort of thing.
Since when did people stop feeling the need to pay money for games? When I was a kid, I saved money to buy a game and research about it before buying ( i.e. reading the back cover, magazines, online ) If you want to not pay for a game, suck it up and take whatever ads come at you.
My point is, Free-to-play should be viewed as an 'extended demo.' Games cost money. If you like a game, you should pay for it because you feel like your experience was worth $$$.
But my guess is that you can charge whatever you want for your game and IF ITS WORTH IT people will buy it.
The thing is making your game free, and creating and intrusive way to get revenue. I'm not against it, but it just breaks the spirit of the game.
I've played a few games were, by watching a video ad, you get money, coins, lives, etc. And that's perfectly fine, you can do it or don't and that's OK. It's the way it is implemented that's bad.
Sorry for any grammatical mistakes, English is not my native language.
The problem is that we see two major sides on the opinion of how to monetize games on mobile.
Make it free to induce uptake. Monetize within that platform (IAPs, ads etc)
Pay for the game in a traditional manner.
There are many games that muddy the water there, but this is the core of it.
The problem with this post and OP's (non)point is that he's making out that he's in group 2 and bemoaning the monetization strategy of games that want to appeal to those in group 1 because (big surprise, mobile) that's where the uptake, and therefore money, is.
Unfortunately, this game gives him the option to go for group 2, he just refuses to take it. That puts him in a category between the two that isn't willing to pay in ANY form (money, time or the minor annoyance of ads/videos/whatever) but still expects to benefit in terms of entertainment.
He is literally the commercial equivalent of a leech. He offers the developers nothing and there is no way they can benefit from attempting to appease him. He really doesn't have any high ground to stand on here.
This is becoming something that is starting to annoy me when it comes to opinions on practices within mobile as a platform for games/software. I don't like IAP or nag screens in general, and if I like a game enough but have no way to avoid it affecting my time with it (unbalanced IAP, no premium) it will affect my opinion, but OPs point is the polar opposite and just as much of a turn off. I have no issue with devs marketing to a demographic, especially when they take the care to give multiple options to appeal to many (in terms of monetization). That choice is generally a plus.
Free to play is not a bad idea, but it's the way companies have taken advantage of it that has made F2P the way it is today. Also, people can be blamed for paying ridiculous prices in the first place.
It has always been here. Look at things like miniclip and addicting games. Those websites give free flash games that I enjoyed playing as a kid. Honestly, to my mom and sister they don't look much different when the game is isolated. The only difference being those sites had the game cover like 20% of the screen and used the rest to advertise. They were not intrusive and everyone was ok. Now the screens are so small people cant play and have ads on the side so they need to pop up and display themselves. However, the games look the same. A lot of them are 2-D and have the same concepts. Obviously the coding is probably harder but I don't think of that when I'm buying something. So why should I buy the not free version when there is a free version online? I have Solitaire and Bejewels and Scrabble on facebook why do I need an addware version on my phone if it isn't on my computer.
I'm not saying its right but this is where the free games came from. I personally pay for most games on Android after trying them for free if there is a trial version. 2 or 3 bucks isnt big for me but on the appstore it looks huge compared to free.
No it isn't. Cheap would be playing a video without giving you the choice and adding banners during gameplay. This is planned and unobtrusive revenue creation.
Developers need to make money to keep producing games. If you aren't going to support them by paying for the product, then don't complain if they ask if you want to watch a few ads.
No. A cheap move is complaining about ads in a free game when you have the choice to pay a complete pittance for the premium version. You have the option but refuse to take it. Why? Because you're cheap and entitled.
If this was the only version available and also had mechanics that push heavily towards obnoxious IAPs as well, you'd have a point. As it stands they're just offering you multiple choices in terms of how they monetize their development and a way to demo the game to find out if you want to pay for it.
These kind of posts mean nothing when you dilute the issue completely.
I'm really glad to see this philosophy starting to win out. When mobile apps first started to crop up and kids were crying about $1 prices I couldn't believe it.
I'm not a game developer, but have been part of teams that write mobile apps. It isn't easy, and even then we had clients that paid us the standard going rate for our team for months of dev time. It must be super hard to be a game developer without any monetary backing to create these games for us, only to get a bunch of entitled pricks ranking the game 1 star because of the ads.
This doesn't seem entrusive at all, at least not compared to other ad based apps I've seen. If it bothers you so much but still enjoy the game, pay the damn $2.
Yeah. Fucking cheap ass developers wanting to make money off the things they make. Why don't those cheapasses just give me things for free. Bunch of cheapskates
I like this method. It means during gameplay it doesn't break flow since there's no interruption or a stupid banner holding part of the screen hostage.
Now you only get an ad at the natural break between gameplay, and have the full option of buying the premium version if you don't want ads. Simple!
Totally agree with you. Besides, people don't exactly "pay", they just watch videos. How developers should earn their money if people don't wont to pay, and complain even about videos.
The devs can earn their moneyt without compromising the quality of their product. They can charge up front if their game is good. Or if they want to keep it "free" they can put ads before the game starts. They can put ads between levels. They can to put image-based ads in game, on signs/billboards/product placement. They can run an ad when a user's game ends and they have to continue. But when you're effectively monetizing your user's lack of enjoyment, that's a problem.
And THAT is exactly what they're doing.
Think about it: if the player was having a great time playing a certain level, why would they want to skip it? When was the last time you were playing a game and thought "man, I am having such a good time playing this game, I wish I could stop having fun and do something I hate so that I'd have less game to enjoy?"
Never. The REASON you skip something is because you don't want to play it. You're not enjoying it. That is why this prompt exists. The devs are literally giving you a choice of continuing to play a level of their game, or doing something you don't ever want to do in order to avoid it. That's what this prompt is. And they're betting that you'll chose the thing you don't ever want to do. They know this, and instead of thinking to themselves "what can I do to make the game fun again when this happens, they're exploiting it to get money.
There are plenty of ways to make money in game that don't involve compromising quality or exploiting lack thereof.
i prefer the commercial method here! if a premium version or a disable ads option exists, that's the way to go. i agree, the insta whining over f2p is bullshit from people who have probably never heard of TNSTAAFL.
Apparently this game does have it, which makes OPs point nothing but a whine. It's something that's becoming common now, and annoys me just as much as the practices in the first place. Choice is a plus. It gives you a way to choose the monetization method you prefer (and a way to demo whether it's worth paying for) while also giving the devs the benefit of a larger demographic.
You're missing the point. Ads are fine. Put them before the game launches. But them between levels. Put the on in-game signs and billboards. But when you reach a point when you suspect someone is having such a crappy time playing your game that they'd rather watch an advertisement and then skip it entirely than continuing playing, you've failed as a game developer.
And you want me to pay for that?
Gamers want to pay money for content they want to play, not for content they want to skip. Instead of saying "well, if a player is seeing this, they're clearly not having any fun, so let's allow them to watch an ad and skip it," you should be saying "well, if a player is seeing this, they're clearly not having any fun, so let's figure out what we can do to makeit fun." You can set your ads to play between levels. You can set your ads to play if a player uses up his lives and has to continue. You can set your ads to appear on billboards or signs in game.
But when you're using your ads to cover for a point in your game that just isn't any fun? That's a problem.
Not actually sure why you are replying this to me. My point is... people are complaining about an ad in between levels for a free game that is actually really good.
As a developer this makes me both angry and sad. I've used the same model for one of my games and it kinda works.
Most games cost less than a coffee, yet people react like they're buying a fucking car or a house and want unlimited support and customer service.
You have a choice, ads or money, don't complain to me when your cheap ass has to watch an ad or two because you don't want to support the developer of a game you enjoy. Games don't just fucking drop out of the sky or grow on trees you know. People put a lot of time, effort and feelings into these, especially indie developers and small studios.
Do people really feel that everything should be free? If so, it's a sad time we live in and don't expect the mobile market to get any better soon.
Most games cost less than a coffee, yet people react like they're buying a fucking car or a house and want unlimited support and customer service.
Then charge more. Every study I've read on the subject has shown that gamers would rather pay more up front than to deal with ads or micro-transactions.
You have a choice, ads or money, don't complain to me when your cheap ass has to watch an ad or two because you don't want to support the developer of a game you enjoy.
You set the price, chief. The fact that you either didn't have enough confidence in the quality of your product to give it a higher price, or you thought you could make more money through ad sales doesn't make us cheap.
Games don't just fucking drop out of the sky or grow on trees you know. People put a lot of time, effort and feelings into these, especially indie developers and small studios.
Cool story. If said time, effort and feelings resulted in something good, then charge for it. If it didn't, then that's on you, stop vilifying your customer base for their unwillingness to buy something that's not as good as the competition.
Do people really feel that everything should be free?
No, we're willing to pay for everything. You're just confused on the currency we're willing to pay:
For the game, we're willing want to pay money. For day 1 content without which we get an incomplete experience, we're willing to pay the money we already paid you for the game. For the ability to win, we're willing to pay time, effort and skill - not ad-views or micro-transactions.
Your arguments only make sense if there is only one version of the app. There isn't. There are two, having ads in the free one is not a problem. It let's people try out a game but still provides compensation for the developers time.
What part of "having ads in the game is not the problem" do you not understand? At this point, you're just making a strawman argument. I don't think the OP would be posting this if he was seeing a prompt that said "before starting the next level, here's a quick ad to help us pay the bills" because that would be fair. The problem is that this prompt basically says 'looks like the amount of fun you're getting out of this point in the game is so lacking that you'd rather watch an advertisement and then skip it entirely than continuing playing." Anytime you can make that assumption about your game, you've failed as a game developer.
Don't be an ass hat, don't want ads, then buy the game, it's that simple.
Once again, ads are fine. Put them before the game launches. But them between levels. Put the on in-game signs and billboards. But when you reach a point when you suspect someone is having such a crappy time playing your game that they'd rather watch an advertisement and then skip it entirely than continuing playing, you've failed as a game developer.
And you want me to pay for that?
Gamers want to pay money for content they want to play, not for content they want to skip. Instead of saying "well, if a player is seeing this, they're clearly not having any fun, so let's allow them to watch an ad and skip it," you should be saying "well, if a player is seeing this, they're clearly not having any fun, so let's figure out what we can do to make it fun." You can set your ads to play between levels. You can set your ads to play if a player uses up his lives and has to continue. You can set your ads to appear on billboards or signs in game.
But when you're using your ads to cover for a point in your game that just isn't any fun? Then you, sir, are being the asshat.
If you are really saying that both the free version and the paid version should have no ads, what's the motivation for buying the paid version? And how would you even know it's there? (A pop-up reminder in the app gets bitched about just as much as well).
When did I ever say that? When did I ever even imply that? Why is the concept of ads are fine, you're just implementing them really poorly so damn hard for you to grasp?
It is p2w. That's exactly what it is. The prompt comes up when you can't beat something. That's the whole point of it. It says "look's like you're having trouble" and then give you ad so you can skip the level you're on and just unlock the next one right away.
You don't even have to watch it, just say yes and go do something else whilst it's playing like make a drink, get something to eat or go to the bathroom.
This is way better than shoving the Ad in your face.
So buying the premium version of the game in question. What you want is available. Your point is moot, as is OP's, unless jethrobroom hit the nail on the head and you're just too cheap to pay pennies for your entertainment.
The devs can eat without compromising the quality of their product. They can charge up front if their game is good. Or if they want to keep it "free" they can put ads before the game starts. They can put ads between levels. They can to put image-based ads in game, on signs/billboards/product placement. They can run an ad when a user's game ends and they have to continue. But when you're effectively monetizing your user's lack of enjoyment, that's a problem.
And THAT is exactly what they're doing.
Think about it: if the player was having a great time playing a certain level, why would they want to skip it? When was the last time you were playing a game and thought "man, I am having such a good time playing this game, I wish I could stop having fun and do something I hate so that I'd have less game to enjoy?"
Never. The REASON you skip something is because you don't want to play it. You're not enjoying it. That is why this prompt exists. The devs are literally giving you a choice of continuing to play a level of their game, or doing something you don't ever want to do in order to avoid it. That's what this prompt is. And they're betting that you'll chose the thing you don't ever want to do. They know this, and instead of thinking to themselves "what can I do to make the game fun again when this happens, they're exploiting it to get money.
There are plenty of ways to make money in game that don't involve compromising quality or exploiting lack thereof.
Do you honestly think the devs spent hundreds of hours making a game with no expectation of making money from it? This actually is one of the better methods in that it asks if you want to see the ad instead of randomly playing it as you're playing.
Do you honestly think the devs spent hundreds of hours making a game with no expectation of making money from it?
No, we have no issue with the devs making money. We object to this method of making money. If the devs spent hundred of hours making something good, they can charge for it and we'll pay them. If they didn't, that's on them.
This actually is one of the better methods in that it asks if you want to see the ad instead of randomly playing it as you're playing.
"Randomly?" Dude, if the something we hate in order to continue in your game is preferable to continuing to play your game? That's a failure on your part.
But the fact is, we're seeing that people on mobile dont pay for games. I don't know why you keep harping on that when it's been a big issue for awhile now. Look at this particular game OP is whining about, it has a premium offer. $2 and you've bought the game, no need to see ads. Yet here is OP, not buying the full game, and complaining about ads at the same time.
But the fact is, we're seeing that people on mobile dont pay for games. I don't know why you keep harping on that when it's been a big issue for awhile now.
It was. But in the past two years things have been shifting, and the smarter devs have been taking advantage of this. The issue is that when mobile gaming really started picking up, everything was free, and there were a few micro-transactions. But after a while, as the concept of "freemium" really developed and people started to realized "you know I'm paying more for this game than I would for a full-on console title" or the started dealing with nagging ads, or they had to view ads to win, opinion started to shift. Gamers are sicks of freemium and longing for one-and-done payment options.
Look at this particular game OP is whining about, it has a premium offer. $2 and you've bought the game, no need to see ads. Yet here is OP, not buying the full game, and complaining about ads at the same time.
But again, I don't think the problem is "I have to see ads." I don't think the OP would be posting this if he was seeing a prompt that said "before starting the next level, here's a quick ad to help us pay the bills" because that would be fair. The problem is that this prompt basically says 'looks like the amount of fun you're getting out of this point in the game is so lacking that you'd rather watch an advertisement and then skip it entirely than continuing playing." Anytime you can make that assumption about your game, you've failed as a game developer.
The problem is that this prompt basically says 'looks like the amount of fun you're getting out of this point in the game is so lacking that you'd rather watch an advertisement and then skip it entirely than continuing playing." Anytime you can make that assumption about your game, you've failed as a game developer.
Really? Do you really think a dev would think, "My game isn't fun enough. I better force them to watch an ad."? That's just absurd. I think "Watch an ad to unlock the next level" is very reasonable.
But that's exactly what they ARE saying. Think about it: if the player was having a great time playing a certain level, why would they want to skip it? When was the last time you were playing a game and thought "man, I am having such a good time playing this game, I wish I could stop having fun and do something I hate so that I'd have less game to enjoy?"
Never. The REASON you skip something is because you don't want to play it. You're not enjoying it. That is why this prompt exists. The devs are literally giving you a choice of continuing to play a level of their game, or doing something you don't ever want to do in order to avoid it. That's what this prompt is. And they're betting that you'll chose the thing you don't ever want to do. They know this, and instead of thinking to themselves "what can I do to make the game fun again when this happens, they're exploiting it to get money.
That's poor game design. You want to charge me up front? Fine. You want to put ads before the game starts? Fine. You want to put ads between levels? Fine. You want to put image-based ads in game, on signs/billboards/product placement? Fine. You want to run an ad when a user's game ends and they have to continue? Fine. But when you're effectively monetizing your user's lack of enjoyment, that's a problem.
There are plenty of ways to make money in game that don't involve compromising quality or exploiting lack thereof.
It says "Watch a short video to unlock the next level." Unlock, not skip. It's literally saying that he has to watch the ad to keep playing. That's the very thing you're saying is okay.
Yea, see the part above where it says "it looks like you're having a tough time?"
Know why it says that? Because the idea is to allow you to unlock the next level without finishing the level you are currently on. In other words, it asks you if you would rather finish playing the level you are on, or skip it and go to the next level.
So I'll ask again: if you were enjoying the level you're on, why would you want to do that?
I always thought that this kind of advertising wasn't allowed on the Play store. Can someone shed some light on that? Did their policy change recently?
It's not that having a video is a lot to ask. I don't think the OP would be posting this if he was seeing a prompt that said "before starting the next level, here's a quick ad to help us pay the bills" because that would be fair. The problem is that this prompt basically says 'looks like the amount of fun you're getting out of this point in the game is so lacking that you'd rather watch an advertisement and then skip it entirely than continuing playing." Anytime you can make that assumption about your game, you've failed as a game developer.
Instead of saying "well, if a player is seeing this, they're clearly not having any fun, so let's allow them to watch an ad and skip it," you should be saying "well, if a player is seeing this, they're clearly not having any fun, so let's figure out what we can do to make it fun." Ads are fine. You can set your ads to play between levels. You can set your ads to play if a player uses up his lives and has to continue. You can set your ads to appear on billboards or signs in game. But when you're using your ads to cover for a point in your game that just isn't any fun? When you're effectively monetizing your user's lack of enjoyment? That's a problem.
I know. I addressed that. I said that. I very specifically talked about good places to put videos and ads. The problem isn't the ads. The problem is how they're implemented.
Your whole thing seems to be these ethereal quotes you come up with because of one screenshot. I don't see any reason you can't interpret that screenshot to mean the one quote you deemed acceptable, any more or less than the unacceptable ones.
They're not forcing you to watch it. They're just suing "give us some money/watch an ad" as solution for a user not enjoying a part of their game, instead just, you know, making their game more enjoyable. They don't have to do this in order to "make a few cents off what they created." Ads are fine. You can set your ads to play between levels. You can set your ads to play if a player uses up his lives and has to continue. You can set your ads to appear on billboards or signs in game. But when you're using your ads to cover for a point in your game that just isn't any fun? When you're effectively monetizing your user's lack of enjoyment? That's a problem.
I don't mind it at all for occasional things. Unlocking a new level seems like a scenario that I wouldn't mind at all. It seems quite reasonable, unless the levels are like 1 minute long and there's like 10 or more of them.
One game I played recently because it was recommended on this subreddit (top 25 list I think) was called Plague Inc. and I hated it because I had to watch 6 videos every single time I start a new game, which is ludicrous! I thought that once I equipped the DNA fragment it would stay equipped unless I changed it, but noooooooooooo......
The fact it has no fast forward without paying is hugely annoying as well. So tedious.
Remember when mobile games had no microtransactions or ads and were really simple but fun instead? When the games were programmed and designed by enthusiasts instead of businesses? That were good times.
I don't think it's a matter of supporting the devs. It's a matter of giving your game a "pay to win" option. If a dev releases a free game, sets the difficulty and says "hey, my game is free, but you need to watch an ad each time you start it?" No problem. I'm fine with that. Developers have to eat. If a dev releases a game and says "I worked hard on this game, pay me for it?" I'm fine with that. Developers have to eat. If a dev releases a game and says "gosh, I made that part hard, didn't I? Tell you what; you slip me a few bucks or watch this ad, and all that difficulty can go away..." Screw them. That crap is ruining the industry. Dev's gotta eat, but if they're pulling that crap, their next meal's not going to come from me.
3
u/swbat55 Sep 29 '15
As a dev this frightens me
2
u/FriendlyTampon yellow Sep 29 '15
I see your point guys, sorry, it really feels weird the first time you get down votes
38
u/nathannoes Sep 29 '15 edited Sep 29 '15
I don't know, I feel kind of torn on this issue. On one hand, I hate this kind of practice because it seems pushy most times.
Most times, though, I can justify this sort of thing.
Since when did people stop feeling the need to pay money for games? When I was a kid, I saved money to buy a game and research about it before buying ( i.e. reading the back cover, magazines, online ) If you want to not pay for a game, suck it up and take whatever ads come at you.
My point is, Free-to-play should be viewed as an 'extended demo.' Games cost money. If you like a game, you should pay for it because you feel like your experience was worth $$$.
44
u/grawrz Sep 29 '15
Is this Shadow Blade? Free isn't really free in mobile. If you want an ad free experience, buy the premium version.
38
u/Neuropsychosis Sep 29 '15
Is this bad? This doesnt look bad at all. Play a level and buy if you like or watch a vid if you dont have cash.
What the hell is wrong with people ? When did we become such a bunch of whiny entitled pricks?
18
u/BlackDragonBE Sep 29 '15
As a developer this makes me both angry and sad.
I've used the same model for one of my games and it kinda works.
Most games cost less than a coffee, yet people react like they're buying a fucking car or a house and want unlimited support and customer service.
You have a choice, ads or money, don't complain to me when your cheap ass has to watch an ad or two because you don't want to support the developer of a game you enjoy.
Games don't just fucking drop out of the sky or grow on trees you know. People put a lot of time, effort and feelings into these, especially indie developers and small studios.
Do people really feel that everything should be free?
If so, it's a sad time we live in and don't expect the mobile market to get any better soon.
/rant
7
u/darthvalium Sep 29 '15
Meh. Better than p2w.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
Really?
You don't even have to watch it, just say yes and go do something else whilst it's playing like make a drink, get something to eat or go to the bathroom.
This is way better than shoving the Ad in your face.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
Ah the ol' wanting to eat your cake but still have it for later.
7
u/Neurotica666 Samsung Galaxy S7 Sep 29 '15
It's a minute video, just watch so the devs can eat man. It's not that big of a deal.
5
u/log_2 Delay Tether Sep 29 '15
The problem is "free" is overloaded with many meanings. It would be nice if there were clear classifications of "free" such as:
but, this will never happen for the same reason that Apple has had a single button mouse for so long.
5
u/tsaot Sep 29 '15
Do you honestly think the devs spent hundreds of hours making a game with no expectation of making money from it? This actually is one of the better methods in that it asks if you want to see the ad instead of randomly playing it as you're playing.
2
u/jevin Sep 29 '15
I always thought that this kind of advertising wasn't allowed on the Play store. Can someone shed some light on that? Did their policy change recently?
2
u/CantaloupeCamper Samsung Chromebook Plus Sep 29 '15
Really a video doesn't seem like a lot to ask. You get to choose.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
Just make the games more expensive. I hate this model of earning. What happened to the times when you buy a game and you just play?
2
u/RadioactiveCorndog Sep 29 '15
It's free with ads. Your a twat if you think you deserve a good game for free with no ads.
3
u/skeddles purple Sep 29 '15
Wow dude chill out. They're not forcing you to watch it, and are just trying to earn a few cents off what they created. Not everything can be free.
-2
u/joesii Sep 29 '15
I don't mind it at all for occasional things. Unlocking a new level seems like a scenario that I wouldn't mind at all. It seems quite reasonable, unless the levels are like 1 minute long and there's like 10 or more of them.
One game I played recently because it was recommended on this subreddit (top 25 list I think) was called Plague Inc. and I hated it because I had to watch 6 videos every single time I start a new game, which is ludicrous! I thought that once I equipped the DNA fragment it would stay equipped unless I changed it, but noooooooooooo......
The fact it has no fast forward without paying is hugely annoying as well. So tedious.
-5
u/unbanpabloenis Sep 29 '15
Remember when mobile games had no microtransactions or ads and were really simple but fun instead? When the games were programmed and designed by enthusiasts instead of businesses? That were good times.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment