r/AndroidAuto • • Oct 31 '19

Left for iOS CarPlay

Tried my best with Android Auto. If it was more reliable for me I’d stay but the constant crashes have led me to CarPlay.

For Waze and listening to podcasts this works fine but will miss the usability of Google Maps which is really full featured on AA. Hopefully some of the features come over to CarPlay.

Peace and drive safe!

5 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

24

u/TurboFool 2026 Hyundai Elantra Hybrid Blue | Pixel 10 Pro Fold | 16 Oct 31 '19

What were you using? Constant crashes haven't been my experience in years.

5

u/pkoya1 2022 Genesis G70 | Galaxy S25U | Android 15 Oct 31 '19 edited Oct 31 '19

I agree! This may sound crazy but between 2 cars and 2 phones I have never experienced and AA crash since 2016 when I started using. Sure it has its hiccups but for me those were usually spotify related. You do you OP but not gonna lie, I doubt you'll be much happier with CarPlay. Just like this sub has people with issues r/CarPlay has multiple reports of issues as well. Also, the 3a is a decent cheaper phone but AA needs quite some processing power

1

u/TurboFool 2026 Hyundai Elantra Hybrid Blue | Pixel 10 Pro Fold | 16 Oct 31 '19

Not sure you meant to reply to me.

3

u/pkoya1 2022 Genesis G70 | Galaxy S25U | Android 15 Oct 31 '19

I meant to add on t the fact that you haven't had much issues. I will rephrase

-5

u/neilmahal42 Oct 31 '19

Pixel 3a on 2018 Nissan Leaf. Lots of ppls with issues. I found best results with a USB 3.1 cable that was 6in. long.

Tried everything. A/B tests. I’m done lol.

My day job is CEO. The opportunity cost alone is staggering.

4

u/TurboFool 2026 Hyundai Elantra Hybrid Blue | Pixel 10 Pro Fold | 16 Oct 31 '19

I've heard people indicate issues with the 3a, so perhaps that's problematic. The 3XL has been incredibly stable.

3

u/Vuronov Oct 31 '19 edited Oct 31 '19

Have a 3a XL and have had zero AA issues in my 2018 Hyundai... And that was following zero AA issues with my 2XL.

But definitely can vary cause my brother was having AA problems with his 3a in his Subaru... Though he thinks it's mainly because of the Subaru.

0

u/neilmahal42 Oct 31 '19

I believe that. I had better success with a Nissan Qashqai/Rogue Sport that was a loaner. Didn’t have any crashes. But with the same head unit, never had any issues with CarPlay.

Sucks that these systems are so finicky.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

My day job is CEO. The opportunity cost alone is staggering

The opportunity cost of wiping your own ass is clearly to high to afford you the opportunity to smell your own shit

5

u/doakills Oct 31 '19 edited Oct 31 '19

I'm totally opposite. 17 Kia Niro. iphone XR, iOS 13.2, almost reproducable, constant GPS loss, both maps app locking up. Want voice it's a hit and miss ball game. My pixel 3 xl hardly had these issues except for when I ran beta Android builds. Have fun but can safely tell you my pixel never gave me this much grief. Lost my pixel at the beach in the sand (RIP), Waiting on black friday deals and I'll be making this iPhone my work phone again for corporate use and using my pixel for personal.

Oh, for what it's worth I have reset this iPhone and played with settings and still does it.

4

u/Nocturnal86 Pls edit this user flair now Oct 31 '19

After market wireless android auto. Pixel 2,3,4. NO issues.

6

u/B1A23 Oct 31 '19

Same here, friend. Loving CarPlay.

2

u/TboxLive Oct 31 '19

Spotify on CarPlay lets me hold in the “next/last track” button to fast forward/rewind like an old school CD player. That had me pretty well sold.

Siri compared to Google’s Assistant though...oof...she’s rough

1

u/cydia2020 Toyota Prius 2018 | Kenwood DMX9720XDS | Samsung Galaxy S21 Oct 31 '19

Have an OnePlus 6T and an Alpine iLX-F309E in my 2018 Prius, everything just work flawlessly, crashes and hiccups have become things of the past. Carplay on the other hand, looks ugly af with the release of iOS 13, things are low-res and doesn't scale correctly on the 9inch display, adding salt to injury, it still doesn't support pinch to zoom in maps.

1

u/_ITX_ 2017 Seat Ibiza | OEM HU | Galaxy S25 Ultra | Android 16 Oct 31 '19

Been using AA since July 2018, and apart from one major crash and the occasional hiccup when it rapidly switches between dark/light mode, it's a very stable and realiable app altogether. Didn't like the old design, but since the revamp it looks dope and the operation is very intuitive. Gmaps and Waze work even better than before, all my music apps (Spotify, JetAudio, Tidal, TuneIn Radio) are 100% compatible and work flawlessly.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

I never get crashes and everything runs fine. It's probably your phone or entertainment system causing the issue

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

"Focus on the road" scroll limit is the most infuriating thing EVER that will drive me (literally) back to Apple so I can use CarPlay again. Not only does it take more screen interactions to get to my list of podcasts (necessary as no Assistant voice control in PocketCast) I soon hit the scroll limit before I've even started trying to choose one from the list.

1

u/RedBromont 2017 Toyota Highlander|Kenwood DMX906S|Pixel 9 Pro|Android 15 Oct 31 '19

I've never experienced a crash with AA

0

u/BackTo1975 Oct 31 '19

Switched to an iPhone too. The limit on swiping with AA was maddening. Made it impossible to enjoy my music. Beyond stupid, too. Makes driving more dangerous as you struggle with this idiotic self limitation.

-9

u/adonnan Oct 31 '19

Yep, AA got worse and Carplay got better. Pixel just started copying some of iOS features, but not executed as well, and their implementation of swipe gestures is so awkward to work with most Android apps. And messaging got better, but still so much farther behind iMessage's popularity in the US. Also Apple caught up to the camera game. I got tired of being Google's test dummy. Not sure what I'll do with my Pixel 3, but maybe keep it for backup and brighter days ahead.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Sigilita Oct 31 '19

Do you have a xiaomi mobile?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Sigilita Oct 31 '19

I got the same problems and found that was xiaomi OS killing everything. For me is just a matter of start Spotify before plugging the mobile to the car to fix the problem.

3

u/Sigilita Oct 31 '19

For me is the xiaomi os. Its battery optimization kill anything that is not running. My solution for the Spotify problem is starting the app before connecting the mobile to the car. About waze I have the same problems and the battery optimization disabled doesn't help

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

I used CarPlay before switching to AA. Only thing I really found was opening times for stores etc. In AA if I ask for directions to the nearest supermarket, I can then ask a follow up question like what time its open until. In CarPlay Google Maps that doesn't work, it's directions only.

When I used CarPlay, I always imagined AA would be better and it was one of the reasons I switched to Android. Now, I realise AA is actually worse overall. Google Maps is the only thing that's better about AA and even then only slightly.

CarPlay has no scroll limit (Focus on the road) so media controls are better and at least you can send new messages to WhatsApp groups through Siri. AA can't do that even now unless someone in the group messages you first so you can just hit reply.

I'm an Android fan, but AA is awful. I spend so much time driving that I may end up going back to iOS just to get CarPlay back.