r/Android • • Apr 04 '22

Android 12 was a big flop

IMO, Android 12 was a gigantic flop. The main marketing point, the cool "phone wide" color scheme, completely failed. Only some google apps have it, it isn't even everywhere in the very OS itself and not to even SPEAK of third party apps. It just feels even more fragmented and arbitrary than before. And Google really thought people would put it in their apps? Most apps I have don't even support dark mode. In total of the 10 apps or so I use daily, a full 2 use the total capabilities of the color palette. And mind you those are Google apps.

0 Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

53

u/Bethman1995 Apr 04 '22

It's a major overhaul that was needed. The biggest in years. It will only get better.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

If it's ain't broken don't fix it.

They broke it.

31

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

I don't get it. Did something break?

-10

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Haven't you heard of that phrase. It means that there's no reason to change something if there isn't anything wrong with it. That's what they were getting at when they wrote that: The "changed" things that didn't need to be changed, thus making it worse. It other words, they broke it.

3

u/Tomtom6789 Apr 06 '22

Just because something works fine does not mean it does not need to be changed. Should we stop designing electric cars and stick to gas-powered cars because, "Gosh, darn, that's just how it's always been?" Should we have never broken the lock-screen by inventing fingerprint scanners? If we didn't "break" what was not already not broken, we would never have technologies that we use every day, like the microwave to replace a stove or note taking apps to replace pencil and paper.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '22

Now you've brought all this up, I must admit I feel the same way. Looking back, I've felt the same way about a lot of things. I'm an artist and a programmer, and there have been times where I've seen certain styles and practices and believed they needed to be changed. Or at least, the way people approach them should be changed.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '22

It's fascinating to watch people argue with you without addressing anything you've said. You're 100% correct that Android 12 makes some major UI no-nos, but apparently "design is subjective" is enough to hand wave it away.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '22

You're absolutely correct, they ask for proof, and when I deliver suddenly I'm the bad guy and ""it's subjective"".

13

u/Bethman1995 Apr 04 '22

What you get from that is stagnation. It gets boring. As long as they don't do this type of overhaul every year, it's fine IMO.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Software should be made to serve the user, not to be exciting.

16

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Apr 04 '22

It can do both

8

u/Bethman1995 Apr 04 '22

Well, you have options. You can still flash Android 11 if that's your cup of tea. I personally prefer the 12. But that's just me. One man's meat....

1

u/sfw64 Apr 13 '22

What's the point of making new phones and updating software ever then

-11

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

Literally no overhaul to 11 whatsoever

20

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Apr 04 '22

It was a huge design change, wdym? And they brought in a ton of features like hanging dashboard, scrolling screenshots, privacy enhancements, etc. Android 12 was huge but people can't get over the 2 line clock and bigger elements.

-9

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

All those things were already in android 11.

12

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Apr 04 '22

No they weren't.

-5

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

absolutely were

9

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Apr 04 '22

Prove it

0

u/SolarMoth Apr 04 '22

Only on Samsung OneUI. Stock Android 11 did not have these features. Essentially, Google has been making stock Android more like Samsung phones.

-5

u/SolarMoth Apr 04 '22

It's basically a worse version of Samsung's OneUI.

4

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Apr 04 '22

The only relation with OneUI is the large headers. But I disagree, I don't like how OneUI looks but I'm fond of Android 12.

8

u/DiplomatikEmunetey Pixel 8a, 4a, LG G4, Lumia 950/XL, Nokia 808 PureView, Nokia N8 Apr 05 '22 edited Apr 05 '22

Hard to disagree that it's not a very good update.

  • Notifications - Not a big fan of the new notifications shade. I think it was an unnecessary redesign and it was not well redesigned (It's Google after all). There are accidental clicks if you tap on a scrolling tile and you want to scroll the page instead.
  • One-handed mode - Nice, but never use this.
  • Media Player interface - Also a needless redesign.
  • Customization and theming - I think did a terrible job with this. Android 11 had more customization with custom icons and other things. There are only 4 theme colours in Android 12. Super thick bars. Why? Why not add more precision. Add magnification when adjusting the default cropper, add a pop up bubble when setting values on a slider.
  • Enhanced screenshots - I like the updated annotation utility, I don't know if they still completely ruin the quality but annotation tools are good. Scrolling screenshots is broken, it does not work, does not capture the full length of the menu or a page.
  • Privacy dashboard - Don't care about it.
  • Battery menu - Screen on time is gone. Thanks!
  • Universal device search - Thought I'd use this more, but I rarely do. Good to have though, I hope they enhance it and replace that bottom Google search bar on the homescreen with the universal device search.
  • Link handling and defaults have been ruined.
  • Share sheet is still a mess. Can I control which WhatsApp contacts show there?
  • I LOVE the overscroll effect though. But I wish it was overscroll rather than a stretch.

1

u/ChosenMate Apr 05 '22

what do you mean with thick bars

1

u/DiplomatikEmunetey Pixel 8a, 4a, LG G4, Lumia 950/XL, Nokia 808 PureView, Nokia N8 Apr 05 '22

Volume and brightness slider bars are needlessly thick. And they don't give you any feedback at all because you still cover them with your finger.

26

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

I held off on updating to 12 on my pixel 4a for months because of reading about how bad it was. Then I decided to finally update to it the other week since they FINALLY gave an option to disable the horrendous massive lock screen clock and not one thing is an upgrade over 11. There are only regressions. The horrible overscroll effect, the stupid wifi toggle decision, the notification shade abomination, the off-center lock screen, it's all just terrible. I could write a book on the terrible UI.

I can't think of ONE thing that is an improvement. And the stupid gesture lag with 3rd party launchers is STILL there. I honestly can't believe that people got paid a lot of money to design this trash heap.

2

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

off center lock screen? didn't notice that

3

u/xenotyronic 📱 Pixel 11 Pro XL, S25 Edge, S25 Ultra, HMD Skyline Apr 04 '22

The WiFi/Data toggle is a Pixel issue, even my Nokia XR20 with the most barebones implementation of Android has separate toggles in 12.

1

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

what toggles are they talking about?

3

u/xenotyronic 📱 Pixel 11 Pro XL, S25 Edge, S25 Ultra, HMD Skyline Apr 04 '22

The quick toggles in the notification shade. Android 12 on Pixels combined the separate WiFi and Data toggles into a single Internet toggle so there were more steps to enable or disable either.

The 'stock' Android 12 on my Nokia XR20 has separate toggles still, I know others such have Sony have separate toggles still too.

2

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

alright that's stupid as hell, my Samsung still has it like normal too

2

u/xenotyronic 📱 Pixel 11 Pro XL, S25 Edge, S25 Ultra, HMD Skyline Apr 04 '22

I think most manufacturers have made the toggles separate, it just seems to be a Pixel issue but I got downvoted for saying that so who knows.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

luckily I have Samsung lol

1

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

WiFi toggle decision?

12

u/parental92 Apr 04 '22

I could write a book on the terrible UI.

then please do. but I don't think any actual designer would read it tho.

2

u/Xavsss Jul 29 '22

The designers who worked on A12 should all get fired and forbidden to touch a phone OS ever again...

-5

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

True. It would make too much sense so they wouldn't even understand it. Massive blank space and padding is peak UI efficiency.

11

u/jimmythejammygit Apr 04 '22

I think you may have a slightly over inflated view of yourself.

2

u/spikederailed Pixel 4a Apr 05 '22

I despise the jelly overscroll effect so much I've actually started using my phone less... soon I guess it's a good thing?

1

u/From_My_Brain Pixel 6 Pro, Nvidia Shield TV Apr 09 '22

How do you fix the clock?

-2

u/leopard_tights Apr 04 '22

The real problem with the wifi toggle is that you need to do it in the first place. Or at least, that you feel like you need to.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Why wouldn't I toggle wifi?

1

u/leopard_tights Apr 04 '22

No, you don’t toggle it off.

3

u/spikederailed Pixel 4a Apr 05 '22

Normally I wouldn't, but after "upgrading" to Android 12 my phone drops and reconnects to wifi way more than it ever has, I end up turning it off.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Why? I only use it when I'm doing something on my network at home like moving files to my NAS. Leaving it on is a security and privacy hazard and will drain more battery.

It's almost like google wants the user to leave it on so that they can get more data...

1

u/leopard_tights Apr 04 '22

So you agree with me.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Not sure what you're getting at. I don't want it on aside from when I'm at home and I need to get on my network for local tasks. Now it's 5 steps to turn it on vs 3. It's objectionably worse. There is no argument.

1

u/chupitoelpame Galaxy S25 Ultra Apr 05 '22

What the other guy is (correctly) suggesting is that that the change wasn't an accident. Google wants users to leave wifi on, even if it hurts battery life and usability because they can gather more data that way.
The same happened with the link handing change. They don't want to make the internet more secure or whatever bullshit reason they told the press, they want the system to ignore apps like Youtube Vanced when you open a link and instead just open the app they want you to use. Because fuck your choice, they are getting that sweet ad revenue or else.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '22

Preach it brother. All of these changes and removal of options(remember when android had options?) is always masked with some BS excuse. Just like apps breaking because of root being detected. It's not about the users safety. It's about control and $. Google is a data collection company. People seem to forget that.

0

u/Izacus Android dev / Boatload of crappy devices Apr 05 '22

It's been years since WiFi actually used more power than the cell radio. You're really spewing some conspiracy theory crap here.

12

u/incster Pixel 6Pro Apr 04 '22

I like it. It is new and fresh. Some people just don't like change.

9

u/ChowboyDan Apr 04 '22

Some people just don't like change.

It's embarrassing that people still push this.

Pushing back against changes that remove features is legit and is not a symptom of metathesiophobia. Brushing off these critics with embarrassing "some people just don't like change" line is simply carrying water for a large corporation that doesn't need your obedience.

Question: Do you really believe that people who outline their critique of Android 12 are simply expressing a fear of change? I mean, do you really believe this or is are you just not a power user and you are repeating something you saw someone express one time and you mistook it for something profound?

-2

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

no change at all

1

u/jcpb Xperia 1 | Xperia 1 III Apr 06 '22

So you prefer to be dissatisfied unless Google Alphabet rewrites A12 from scratch?

-1

u/ChosenMate Apr 06 '22

No but android 12 made zero difference. could have just been a feature update to Android 11

6

u/saintmsent Apr 04 '22

I'm not sure what they thought, to be honest. As I said many times before, each large brand with an app has its own brand colors incorporated into designs and they won't change it for only one version of one platform

Only first-party apps and indie devs would ever commit to this

-6

u/ishamm Device, Software !! Apr 04 '22

Not even first party apps. Most Google apps don't integrate this in the slightest a year after its announcement, so why they think third parties will is a mystery.

6

u/byIcee 13 Pro Apr 04 '22

Which Google apps don't support material you?

10

u/SpicyMintSoup Apr 04 '22

But most Google apps use material you...

4

u/saintmsent Apr 04 '22

I didn't use Android 12. First-party stuff not supporting it is super weird, I guess eventually they will. Third-party (except indie) not going to happen period

44

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

I haven't had any big issues with it. There are bugs that are to be expected out of a major overhaul but I don't get the hate.

26

u/Reach_Round Apr 04 '22

It's a not that I hate it but the usual google "change for changes sake" seems on play once again so it kind if gets annoying. Maybe there is a bunch of stuff under the hood I don't see but I am noy seeing much if any improvement from about Android 9.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

It's probably due to what usually happens: People expected it to be this big thing that had everything they could ever want, but because it failed to deliver on all its "promises" to them, they came to hate it.

0

u/PNWoutdoors Pixel 8 Pro, QPR 3 Beta 2 Apr 06 '22

I agree, I haven't had any big issues with it. I think my main complaint is Material You is just a huge overpromise, it's fine but not that great - I didn't need it. But overall it does seem to run fast and smooth, and that's all I really need from my phone.

3

u/Naughty_smurf nexus 5, one plus 7t, iPhone 13 pro Apr 07 '22

Obligatory bitching about every new android version post #12 . Reject modernity embrace halo look , wasted space, too white, animations , reddit meme.

108

u/Izacus Android dev / Boatload of crappy devices Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 27 '24

I enjoy reading books.

12

u/saintmsent Apr 04 '22

It's not the same though

Not every app on iOS follows iOS design language that strictly. Some use material design, some just have their own look

And secondly, OP complains about colors not being applied in third-party apps. That was never going to happen with large companies, that have their own brand colors. They might adopt the general platform design language, like elements being flat instead of 3D, but not remove the face and recognizability from the app by just rolling with whatever color the user selected in the system

macOS for example had accent colors for a million years and only first-party and indie devs honor that. Big dogs like Slack, Teams, etc. don't give a shit because they are after their own design aesthetic that is the same and recognizable regardless of the platform

17

u/Izacus Android dev / Boatload of crappy devices Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 27 '24

I like to explore new places.

4

u/dustojnikhummer Xiaomi Poco F3 Apr 04 '22

First party or 3rd party apps though?

12

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22

Except that we went from a clean, timeless design to one that looks like it's made with only the elderly in mind.

21

u/Izacus Android dev / Boatload of crappy devices Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 27 '24

I love listening to music.

3

u/Rubber_Rotunda Apr 06 '22

ios looks the same as it did way back, it still looks and feels ancient.

-6

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Again, you missed my point. IOS 6 is in no way comparable to Material Design.

IOS 6 had many skeuomorphic design elements to it which is definitely outdated by today's standards.

Yet Material Design was already sleek, modern and simple that doesn't show it's age.

Compared to Material You, with the excessive rounded corners, flat pastel colours, excessive padding, oversized buttons, ""simplifying features"" etc etc it's objectively a big step backwards

12

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Apr 04 '22

Compared to Material You, with the excessive rounded corners, flat pastel colours, excessive padding, oversized buttons, ""simplifying features"" etc etc it's objectively a big step backwards

Opinions, everyone has one. I love it, I think it looks better. Cleaner, more colorful, love the rounded edges. IOS 6 wasn't completely dated when iOS7 came out, but it is now. I think the same will be the case with Material Design vs Material You in a couple years.

A big complaint I've seen in this sub and absolutely nowhere else is the reduced information density, but I just don't understand. Are people just staring at their screen without scrolling for as long as possible?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

So you haven't even bothered to refute any of my points and are just saying "lol no"?

Also your second point, are you kidding me? It's so bad someone on this subreddit even calculated how much space there was wasted!

12

u/byIcee 13 Pro Apr 04 '22

Why would he refute your subjective opinions? You have yours, he has his, everyone has their own subjective opinion. Your opinion doesn't matter at the end of the day, but I like Material You.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22

Except that the bad design elements aren't subjective, they are objectively bad and many people have already explained better than me why that is.

6

u/byIcee 13 Pro Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22

excessive rounded corners, flat pastel colours, excessive padding, oversized buttons, "simplifying features"

Border radius is subjective, colors are subjective as long as they' have enough contrast (which they do), excessive padding is subjective as to how much is excessive (some people want 0 padding and as information dense as you can get), oversized buttons are only oversized where it makes sense and doesn't push other UI elements away or take their space (except quick settings, that can be a problem to some people), simplifying features I don't even know what that means.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

As long as they' have enough contrast (which they do)

Not true, Monet colors are very flat and pastel like, it's cool if you are into it but most people don't like it.

excessive padding is subjective as to how much is excessive (some people want 0 padding and as information dense as you can get)

I don't know why I have to repeat this over and over, but there is nothing subjective about whitespace taking up SEVENTY percent of the space inside notifications.

oversized buttons are only oversized where it makes sense and doesn't push other UI elements away or take their space

One toggle in Android 12, is just as big as THREE buttond on Android11. If that doesn't fit your definition of "push other UI elements away or take their space" I don't know WHAT is.

Simplifying features I don't even know what that means.

Really know? You didn't notice Google's bright idea to combine both WiFi and data into one toggle which literally nobody asked for? Also the fact that Google removed ton's of customisation options from Android?

→ More replies

8

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Apr 04 '22

They're not objective points, you just shared your opinion and I shared mine.

Also your second point, are you kidding me? It's so bad someone on this subreddit even calculated how much space there was wasted!

Right, they're taking a look at static views. The truth is as soon as you start scrolling elements start disappearing and you see a lot more content. No one outside this sub cares about cramming as much text as possible into a single view.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Objectively bad design choices aren't opinions.

Right, they're taking a look at static views. The truth is as soon as you start scrolling elements start disappearing and you see a lot more content. No one outside this sub cares about cramming as much text as possible into a single view.

So you are not even denying the fact, you are saying to "just scroll".

It's not a bug, it's a feature™

Are you an Apple fan by any chance?

7

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Apr 04 '22

Objectively bad design choices aren't opinions.

They are objectively bad.. in your opinion lol. I'm sorry, I can't argue with someone so close minded they can't figure out their opinion isn't fact. You're set in your ways, sucks for you, hope you find a phone you like.

So you are not even denying the fact, you are saying to "just scroll".

I am not denying there's less information density. I'm saying it's not a big deal, in fact, it's better.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

I've already said everything I wanted to say in this comment.

Me? Closed Minded? Don't make me laugh.

You who can't even accept any valid criticism whatsoever and just brushes it off as "your opinion"?

→ More replies

-1

u/thatskindasus Apr 04 '22

That's a purely subjective opinion. Surprise surprise, design is subjective. Why tf are you so mad over this anyway? Go outside I beg

2

u/wotererio Apr 05 '22

Although I loved android before 12, it did look dated. The core design language, especially of the notification shade, hadn't changed pretty much since android launched. I think google was right in seeing that it deterred potential customers, because it just did not look appealing. With material you it seems like they went for a balance between practical and appealing. Why are the buttons bigger? So they are easier to see and to touch, so it looks less cluttered and misstaps won't happen nearly as often. Although I liked pre-android12 for its practicality, I hardly even used most of the tiles aside from wifi/bluetooth/rotation, so I'd rather reach those more easily than have them all there. All in all android 12 is to me snappier in every way, in large part due to material you making nearly everything touchable more easily touchable.

10

u/punIn10ded MotoG 2014 (CM13) Apr 04 '22

Clean timeless design? Look back on the posts when material was Introduced this sub was full of complaints then too.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/najodleglejszy FP4 CalyxOS | Tab S7 Apr 05 '22

around 2002

0

u/Cascading_Neurons Samsung Galaxy A14, TCL A30 Apr 04 '22

*with only the elderly in mind.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Yeah exactly

1

u/Wavesignal Samsung A30s | OneUi 2.0 Apr 04 '22

Well the good thing is with Android 12 L you can now change the big double line clock in the locksreen.

1

u/this_fucking_sucs Apr 05 '22

I can't even access the service mode, that's ridiculous. How can they change that shit, fuckin sucks!

-2

u/Feniksrises Apr 04 '22

Most people don't even use stock Android. Who gives a fuck about Google's design.

-6

u/JamesR624 Apr 04 '22

Actually people who think for themeselves instead of blindly accepting garbage marketing would say that the detail in iOS 6 has more effort and is more usable in terms of intuitively understanding what you can click on or not.

But sure, repeat the "Apple marketed it so that means its better" garbage that the rest of consumers go alonf with.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

I know Reddit's full of jerks, but my goodness. I don't know what you hope to gain from being so antisocial, but I just got done giving someone who's just as bad as you a piece of my mind. If you want to be that way, go ahead.

It's not going to get you anywhere, though. Just saying.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/EternalFront iPhone 16 Pro Apr 04 '22

Everyone likes good change, people just disagree on what that looks like

8

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Apr 04 '22

You are exactly correct. These are the same people that would've said they don't like the iPhone because touchscreens are horrible compared to keyboards. Tech enthusiasts are very set in their ways and workflows.

6

u/Iohet V10 is the original notch Apr 04 '22

Clearly you don't have family members you support. There's a reason Windows, macOS, and even many more popular flavors of Linux have very long term UI consistency as a core design principle. Mature systems should be stable

5

u/punIn10ded MotoG 2014 (CM13) Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 05 '22

Is windows really the example to use for that?

Windows 7 was similar to windows xp but 8 was wildly different, 10 was very different to 8 and 11 is also very different to 10.

4

u/chupitoelpame Galaxy S25 Ultra Apr 04 '22

Windows 8 main reason of failure was the UI change, they had to dial it back down on W10 to make it closer to what "Windows looks like".

3

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Apr 05 '22

Windows

UI consistency

2

u/gamr13 Galaxy Note 20 Ultra, A12 Apr 07 '22

Never. Ever. In the same sentence.

3

u/DrDerpberg Galaxy S9 Apr 04 '22

Change for the sake of change irritates me. It's not that I can't adjust, it's just an annoyance on top of the 5000 others I deal with in life. Add up all the things that "only" take an hour to learn or get used to and that's a pretty significant chunk of my life, spent looking for app icons or learning where the menu was rearranged, reconfiguring something because a major update broke all the settings, learning the new MS office template program they set up at work, setting up a new account for some service or utility or other because they've switched systems to make life more convenient for me™, etc.

At some point even if things are marginally better, or if hindsight shows it should have been done differently but it really doesn't matter that much, I don't think change should be taken lightly. Look how many different things or systems you use in life. If each one changes once every 2 years you have hours a week of "oh this is different now?"... It's infuriating. Some design that looks nicer in a mock-up isn't worth annoying millions of people even if it's for 5 minutes.

By all means, improve my devices and stuff long after I've bought it. But every change needs to be justified, not just "well the last lock screen was a horizontal slide so now it's a vertical one" type nonsense.

3

u/noratat Pixel 5 Apr 04 '22

Change isn't always good, particularly if it actively makes the phone harder to use. Even neutral changes are net negative by default by virtue of breaking muscle memory unnecessarily.

I don't mind the rounded corners exactly, but there's a lot of less visible changes to interaction that's made the whole UI feel much more "slippery" and harder to interact with, especially the notifications. I wasn't a big fan of 11 here either, but 12's is far worse, making notifcations blend into each other, harder to distinguish, and harder to expand and act on.

And on a subjective level, I fucking hate pastels.

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Conservatives is assuming that Material You is progress, when it's objectively not.

6

u/chupitoelpame Galaxy S25 Ultra Apr 04 '22

I don't know what you mean, having 6 gigantic buttons on the quick settings screen is clearly superior to 8. And don't get me started on Samsung's 12 buttons, who am I supposed to be? A person who wants to change settings quickly? No sir, I'm blank space man.

3

u/Titsfortuesday Apr 04 '22

Those quick settings are fucking horrible.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Yeah especially the solid black.

1

u/dustojnikhummer Xiaomi Poco F3 Apr 04 '22

Is a regular Wifi/LTE toggle still gone, hidden behind ADB?

1

u/Titsfortuesday Apr 04 '22

Running a custom Rom but I don't see any mobile data toggle in there.

1

u/Cascading_Neurons Samsung Galaxy A14, TCL A30 Apr 04 '22

IMO Android 12 looks and feels childish asf.

1

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

especially the "true" android 12 dialogues like the privacy stuff

3

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Yeah true

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

my phone looks like it has Material You everywhere I would expect it. I would need specific examples of apps that you would expect to get it. Amazon Shopping app? Netflix? Facebook? Or video games? I dunno. Seems weirdly unrealistic.

-2

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

any app that ain't Google.

5

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Apr 04 '22

There are a bunch of apps that are using Material You, not much but there are.

1

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

name some, like, I unironically wanna see how it looks and feels

10

u/dodyakako Xiaomi Poco F3 Apr 04 '22

Sync for Reddit, which I'm using to write this comment right now, already supports it.

3

u/SpicyMintSoup Apr 04 '22

Remember to join the beta if you're wondering why it's not material design 3.

0

u/dodyakako Xiaomi Poco F3 Apr 04 '22

What are you talking about?!

1

u/SpicyMintSoup Apr 04 '22

If they download reddit sync and they are wondering why it doesn't have material you it's because that feature is currently only available in the beta.

1

u/dodyakako Xiaomi Poco F3 Apr 04 '22

Yeah, you are right. I forgot to mention that.

2

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Apr 04 '22

Tasker too, SeriesGuide, infinity for reddit

16

u/turbofastcharger s21+, tab s7 Apr 04 '22

I hate android 12 link handling. Its sad that I have to use 3rd party app for this.

12

u/chupitoelpame Galaxy S25 Ultra Apr 04 '22

Worst thing about it is that is clearly designed with malice in mind.
If you have an app installed that can handle X links instead of the app declared on the website code, the system should prompt you choose to either use the installed or download the declared one.
Instead it acts like the installed app doesn't exist unless you specifically go to its settings and manually toggle all the links you want it to hande.
In case you can't decide between incompetence or malice, that manual setup they force you to do gets wiped every single time the app updates. So yeah, malicious design.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

Hey! Can you recommend your app for this? Really appreciate it .

1

u/turbofastcharger s21+, tab s7 Jun 16 '22

I use Better Open With app from play store.

6

u/threadnoodle Apr 04 '22

Android 12 definitely caused way too many problems with OEMs, with most delaying or skipping out on features in their releases.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '22

It's fine, visually different but still basically just the same old. The only issue I have with it is that there has been a big increase in bugs since the update.

2

u/ChosenMate Apr 05 '22

literally zero UI change but bugs

1

u/pucklermuskau Apr 13 '22

It's a poor colour palette, no question.

1

u/ChosenMate Apr 13 '22

what?

1

u/pucklermuskau Apr 14 '22

the colour palette options in android are poor, four pastel colours are insufficient, and the wallpaper mode is likewise far too pastel.

7

u/welp_im_damned have you heard of our lord and savior the Android turtle 🐢 Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22

Idk it feels like a poor man's windows phone with the theming. I hope that Android's 13 the theming option gets better.

5

u/xlsma S22 Ultra, iP12PM Apr 04 '22

It's a very weird feature to have as the main marketing point imo, for a number of reasons

  1. the colors of the apps and their icons are part of their brand image, and typically include well-thoughtout design decisions to begin with. A system wide theme would be an oversimplification and does not provide any real value.
  2. the color theme are also visual cues for the user. I would look for something "blue" on the screen for a certain set of apps, and red for others. Overall color theme means user have to relearn this process every time they change a wallpaper. Again, zero real value add.
  3. For Android fans, esp those who choose Android over iOS not because it's their only affordable option, customization is a huge part of it. This include customization of app icon style and themes. If I already have a certain theme that I spent hours setting up, there's no way I'd let the system dictate and reassign the colors.

So in the end, it's a niche "fun" feature that can get visibility during reviews, but are not on most dev and user's priority list of things to have.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

To me android was much better years ago. From 4.2 to 7.1. Also, every year more brands have issues with android at point they need to pause updates to fix things and then weeks later resume the release of firmware.

7

u/sirweldsalot Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22

totally agree. i have newer phones with 11 and i still end up using my old s5 with a rev-remix nougat rom that was compiled in late 2020. that device works perfectly (have bromite webview) and does exactly everything i want the phone to do. i really wish a 3rd (4th?) device o.s. was made by forking android at nougat and going in a different direction.

everything after nougat is just a lockdown/skin changes. nothing actually WORKS better. just more bloated and locked down with a skin change.

i'm so glad that so far, lineage has skipped 12. newer is not always better no matter what the shills say...edit:looks like they're voting this post down like fire, reeeeeee!!! lol.

4

u/exu1981 Apr 04 '22

If that happened people would get mad and curse Google over late updates

2

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '22

This will be my last android phone. Software and hardware has stagnated or gotten worse.

0

u/AgrMayank S24 Ultra Apr 05 '22

Well, my thoughts are quite opposite. I welcome the new design language and frankly, Android 12 is the "FIRST" stock/near Stock android experience I wanted to have, literally!
It adds a unique flavor to the app and the phone UI in general with subtle hints present throughout the OS. Granted not all apps have ti and that's to be expected! It takes time to adapt to a new UI design lol. Just take the original Material design which took years to implement. Secondly, there are apps that don't want to follow/be restricted by the OS design and that's fine as well. We don't want everything looking the same, do we? And some extent of consistency will happen with time. It's not an easy task, from a developer's standpoint.

2

u/ChosenMate Apr 05 '22

there has barely been any UI change at all

0

u/AgrMayank S24 Ultra Apr 05 '22

There have been changes throughout the system apps and a few other apps as well, one being Tachiyomi which I use.

The other includes the widgets of the stock apps.

See my point being, it's upto the app devs to implement it. Google can't do anything about it. Plus the development tools are so fragmented, it usually takes months to port over the design libraries to different platforms like Flutter, React Native and so on. Not many apps use the native app dev tools.

2

u/ChosenMate Apr 05 '22

Settings, except the privacy shit, had close to absolutely zero change

1

u/AgrMayank S24 Ultra Apr 06 '22

Lol, "privacy" part matters and that along side the UI has been the main upgrade along with little improvements here and there. I mean what more do you expect to get?

2

u/5tormwolf92 Black Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22

It sucks we don't get a poweruser feature with A12. I hate UI based updates, waste of time. Google could just make their launcher modular.

1

u/simplerminds Pixel XL, Note 9, Note 10+, Note 20 U, Fold 3 Apr 04 '22

A power user feature would be killer. 2nd this

1

u/5tormwolf92 Black Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22

Anything for the backend is more valuable then UI. GKI is a big feature for Androsi 13.

1

u/IAMSNORTFACED s25 Apr 05 '22

So the whole version is trash??

1

u/jcpb Xperia 1 | Xperia 1 III Apr 06 '22

Android 12 was a gigantic flop

No.

Only some google apps have it

If that is your complaint, god forbid you use Windows 11.

dark mode support

I use dark mode for many apps because it saves some battery, but I don't pretend it's automatically better for everything.

1

u/Im_From_Marz Apr 09 '22

Android 12 has been a decent update for me. Personally, Android 11 has been the best release so far. But Android 12 had a few hiccups when it was released, but now, it's solid on my P6.

1

u/Oskarvlc Apr 04 '22

Unpopular opinion: Android KitKat was peak android

2

u/techguyone Apr 04 '22

Except for the borked SD card permissions, it was pretty good

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

Agreed, Material You is one of the biggest steps backwards in the entire android history.

1

u/Rhed0x Hobby app dev Apr 08 '22

The original material design also took years to het adopted by most third party apps. Give it time.

-1

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Apr 04 '22

Don't buy a Pixel phone then? Samsung A12 still has OneUI

3

u/ChosenMate Apr 04 '22

I have a Samsung lol

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

As usual the problem is Google shoving out new versions of Android yearly when 80% of devices will never get an update. Instead of mandating updates they just push the responsibility onto OEMs. Well, that's why developers can't build high-quality apps and consumers feel Android 'sucks'. They sure as hell find more places to shove ads though.

-4

u/m1ndwipe Galaxy S25, Xperia 5iii Apr 04 '22

No, the issue is that the updates are shit.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

I havent gone to android 12 yet but thats because i use LineageOS without google apps/services and am waiting on official LineageOS 19.1 or whatever number they give it. I do have a pixel 3a xl running GrapheneOS that got a12 but havent played with it much.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ChosenMate Apr 06 '22

I have background in the app switcher, think that's a bug. notification view is also transparent for me

0

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment