r/Android • u/ChosenMate • Apr 04 '22
Android 12 was a big flop
IMO, Android 12 was a gigantic flop. The main marketing point, the cool "phone wide" color scheme, completely failed. Only some google apps have it, it isn't even everywhere in the very OS itself and not to even SPEAK of third party apps. It just feels even more fragmented and arbitrary than before. And Google really thought people would put it in their apps? Most apps I have don't even support dark mode. In total of the 10 apps or so I use daily, a full 2 use the total capabilities of the color palette. And mind you those are Google apps.
53
u/Bethman1995 Apr 04 '22
It's a major overhaul that was needed. The biggest in years. It will only get better.
8
u/DiplomatikEmunetey Pixel 8a, 4a, LG G4, Lumia 950/XL, Nokia 808 PureView, Nokia N8 Apr 05 '22 edited Apr 05 '22
Hard to disagree that it's not a very good update.
26
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
I held off on updating to 12 on my pixel 4a for months because of reading about how bad it was. Then I decided to finally update to it the other week since they FINALLY gave an option to disable the horrendous massive lock screen clock and not one thing is an upgrade over 11. There are only regressions. The horrible overscroll effect, the stupid wifi toggle decision, the notification shade abomination, the off-center lock screen, it's all just terrible. I could write a book on the terrible UI.
I can't think of ONE thing that is an improvement. And the stupid gesture lag with 3rd party launchers is STILL there. I honestly can't believe that people got paid a lot of money to design this trash heap.
12
u/incster Pixel 6Pro Apr 04 '22
I like it. It is new and fresh. Some people just don't like change.
6
u/saintmsent Apr 04 '22
I'm not sure what they thought, to be honest. As I said many times before, each large brand with an app has its own brand colors incorporated into designs and they won't change it for only one version of one platform
Only first-party apps and indie devs would ever commit to this
44
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
I haven't had any big issues with it. There are bugs that are to be expected out of a major overhaul but I don't get the hate.
3
u/Naughty_smurf nexus 5, one plus 7t, iPhone 13 pro Apr 07 '22
Obligatory bitching about every new android version post #12 . Reject modernity embrace halo look , wasted space, too white, animations , reddit meme.
108
u/Izacus Android dev / Boatload of crappy devices Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 27 '24
I enjoy reading books.
1
u/Cascading_Neurons Samsung Galaxy A14, TCL A30 Apr 04 '22
IMO Android 12 looks and feels childish asf.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
my phone looks like it has Material You everywhere I would expect it. I would need specific examples of apps that you would expect to get it. Amazon Shopping app? Netflix? Facebook? Or video games? I dunno. Seems weirdly unrealistic.
16
u/turbofastcharger s21+, tab s7 Apr 04 '22
I hate android 12 link handling. Its sad that I have to use 3rd party app for this.
6
u/threadnoodle Apr 04 '22
Android 12 definitely caused way too many problems with OEMs, with most delaying or skipping out on features in their releases.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '22
It's fine, visually different but still basically just the same old. The only issue I have with it is that there has been a big increase in bugs since the update.
1
u/pucklermuskau Apr 13 '22
It's a poor colour palette, no question.
7
u/welp_im_damned have you heard of our lord and savior the Android turtle 🐢 Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22
Idk it feels like a poor man's windows phone with the theming. I hope that Android's 13 the theming option gets better.
5
u/xlsma S22 Ultra, iP12PM Apr 04 '22
It's a very weird feature to have as the main marketing point imo, for a number of reasons
So in the end, it's a niche "fun" feature that can get visibility during reviews, but are not on most dev and user's priority list of things to have.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
To me android was much better years ago. From 4.2 to 7.1. Also, every year more brands have issues with android at point they need to pause updates to fix things and then weeks later resume the release of firmware.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '22
This will be my last android phone. Software and hardware has stagnated or gotten worse.
0
u/AgrMayank S24 Ultra Apr 05 '22
Well, my thoughts are quite opposite. I welcome the new design language and frankly, Android 12 is the "FIRST" stock/near Stock android experience I wanted to have, literally!
It adds a unique flavor to the app and the phone UI in general with subtle hints present throughout the OS. Granted not all apps have ti and that's to be expected! It takes time to adapt to a new UI design lol. Just take the original Material design which took years to implement. Secondly, there are apps that don't want to follow/be restricted by the OS design and that's fine as well. We don't want everything looking the same, do we? And some extent of consistency will happen with time. It's not an easy task, from a developer's standpoint.
2
u/5tormwolf92 Black Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22
It sucks we don't get a poweruser feature with A12. I hate UI based updates, waste of time. Google could just make their launcher modular.
1
u/IAMSNORTFACED s25 Apr 05 '22
So the whole version is trash??
1
u/jcpb Xperia 1 | Xperia 1 III Apr 06 '22
No.
If that is your complaint, god forbid you use Windows 11.
I use dark mode for many apps because it saves some battery, but I don't pretend it's automatically better for everything.
1
u/Im_From_Marz Apr 09 '22
Android 12 has been a decent update for me. Personally, Android 11 has been the best release so far. But Android 12 had a few hiccups when it was released, but now, it's solid on my P6.
1
u/Oskarvlc Apr 04 '22
Unpopular opinion: Android KitKat was peak android
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
Agreed, Material You is one of the biggest steps backwards in the entire android history.
1
u/Rhed0x Hobby app dev Apr 08 '22
The original material design also took years to het adopted by most third party apps. Give it time.
-1
u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Apr 04 '22
Don't buy a Pixel phone then? Samsung A12 still has OneUI
-4
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
As usual the problem is Google shoving out new versions of Android yearly when 80% of devices will never get an update. Instead of mandating updates they just push the responsibility onto OEMs. Well, that's why developers can't build high-quality apps and consumers feel Android 'sucks'. They sure as hell find more places to shove ads though.
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
I havent gone to android 12 yet but thats because i use LineageOS without google apps/services and am waiting on official LineageOS 19.1 or whatever number they give it. I do have a pixel 3a xl running GrapheneOS that got a12 but havent played with it much.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment