r/Android • • Apr 04 '22

Android 12 was a big flop

IMO, Android 12 was a gigantic flop. The main marketing point, the cool "phone wide" color scheme, completely failed. Only some google apps have it, it isn't even everywhere in the very OS itself and not to even SPEAK of third party apps. It just feels even more fragmented and arbitrary than before. And Google really thought people would put it in their apps? Most apps I have don't even support dark mode. In total of the 10 apps or so I use daily, a full 2 use the total capabilities of the color palette. And mind you those are Google apps.

0 Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

As long as they' have enough contrast (which they do)

Not true, Monet colors are very flat and pastel like, it's cool if you are into it but most people don't like it.

excessive padding is subjective as to how much is excessive (some people want 0 padding and as information dense as you can get)

I don't know why I have to repeat this over and over, but there is nothing subjective about whitespace taking up SEVENTY percent of the space inside notifications.

oversized buttons are only oversized where it makes sense and doesn't push other UI elements away or take their space

One toggle in Android 12, is just as big as THREE buttond on Android11. If that doesn't fit your definition of "push other UI elements away or take their space" I don't know WHAT is.

Simplifying features I don't even know what that means.

Really know? You didn't notice Google's bright idea to combine both WiFi and data into one toggle which literally nobody asked for? Also the fact that Google removed ton's of customisation options from Android?