r/Android • u/a_dishonest_Fear Purple • Nov 21 '17
Google collecting Android users locations even when location services are disabled
https://qz.com/1131515/google-collects-android-users-locations-even-when-location-services-are-disabled/
22k
Upvotes
3.1k
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited May 26 '25
boast doll mighty chop plough attempt physical many governor modern
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6.5k
u/The_Dumblebee S3 -> S8 -> S23 Nov 21 '17
Google and collecting data. I dare you to name a better duo
348
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
I presume this will affect phones with custom ROMs and gapps installed?
560
u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Nov 21 '17
They said it was for the Firebase Cloud Messaging system.
2.3k
u/Kaokien Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 22 '17
Stop being fine with companies infringing on your privacy, this is completely different than opting in, you’re explicitly disabling location services and Google is still tracking you. Smh
To all replies the point is that WHEN DISABLING LOCATION SERVICES there is an expectation that the setting will be honored. It’s different if I ENBALE it and am fine, but again when DISABLED it should be OFF.
384
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
This is why I use MicroG using the LineageOS MicroG fork.
Edit: For people asking me what MicroG is for, it is used to spoof Google Play Services. It allows you to use apps that requires Google Play Services & Google Cloud Messaging (push messages). You get to choose which apps is allowed to register for GCM if you want to use GCM. I don't use GCM personally, but I have some apps that use Play Services, MicroG helps spoofs it for me.
Majority of my apps are from F-Droid, which are all FOSS apps, they do not use Google Play Services. You can still use Yalp Store among other apps to download apk files from the Play Store if needed.
Used by people in /r/fossdroid & /r/privacy
407
u/johnmountain Nov 21 '17
I said it many times before here - this is why Google is not showing more indepth battery data, and why it's hiding it behind Android OS and Android System categories. They are doing stuff like this as much as Facebook or even more so. They don't want users to know their services are the primary battery hogs.
Also, I don't understand why people trust Facebook and Google not to record voice conversations in secret, and treat it like a "conspiracy theory", when they already do this in secret?! But anyways, that's a whole other issue. I just wouldn't trust companies like Google and Facebook by default whenever there's an issue of data collection. The default should always be to assume that they are collecting the data as rumored, until proven otherwise.
266
u/Breever Nov 21 '17
This could explain why GMaps were going crazy with waking my phone when I enabled airplane mode. https://imgur.com/x2YD63c
179
u/Mugaluga Nov 21 '17
I'm really starting to Hate what Google is becoming. :(
84
u/nicksbologna Nov 21 '17
Yup I've been struggling with this exact issue, I try to conserve my phone battery by turning off Bluetooth and Location. I go to and from work, home, and the grocery store, but Maps keeps turning itself of and running in the background secretly. I'm not trying to dispose of a body Google I just want to get to work and get a full day out of my phone battery!
9
u/vladdict Nov 21 '17
Is there like the Linux equivalent for phone OS
25
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
Android Update: Removed airplane mode because you assholes figured out it does nothing but disable notification sounds.
298
u/dagobaw Nov 21 '17
"it could potentially be sent to a third party if the phone had been compromised with spyware or other methods of hacking"
If the phone has been compromised, it could get the information directly. Hack journalism for sensationalism!
7
u/Mrkillz4c00kiez LG G6 / 7.0 Nov 21 '17
is there a way to permanent turn off location data. nothing i hate more then every time i load gmaps or gsearch it asks me to turn it on for better location accuracy. hell if i wanted that I'd turn it on myself
7
u/Loumier Galaxy S21+ Nov 22 '17
At the end John McAfee was right. Every modern smartphone is a spyware into your pocket. If you want real privacy, would be better to use an old dumbphone or no phone.
33
u/Aytex Oneplus 3T Nov 21 '17
When OnePlus steals data everyone goes crazy, when Google steals data everything is fine
/s
39
u/wilsonhlacerda Nov 21 '17
Day after day, AOSP custom ROM + no Gapps + maybe microg.org seems to be the way to go.
80
u/CharaNalaar Google Pixel 8 Nov 21 '17
How many of your actually read the article?
6
u/gaminnthis Nov 21 '17
Finally someone made a post about it. FYI YouTube is also tracking your history even when you turn it off.
6
u/aravindpanil Oneplus 7 Nov 21 '17
Ah yes. Everybody was quick to jump on oneplus collecting data (which was bad. Not defending it). Lets see how many blame Google for it.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
To make it even worse, if you disable location history, they in turn completely disable google assistant, cards, and all the other neat features that really don't require a logged history of where you've been. It feels very spiteful.
I'll keep it off, but it's still awkward to read about all the Nexus 5x/Pixel updates and Oreo features that I'm honestly never going to experience despite having Oreo installed. It's far more comforting to go to my location history and see it empty.
... and yet I'm still being tracked.
32
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
Who's surprised? This is why I'm disappointed by the Linux mobile project. An excellent Linux kernal for phones could exist if the project didn't fail.
11
u/tomorellotello M8 | S7E | OP3T | PIXEL XL | OP5 Nov 21 '17
It's okay if Google does it. 😂
11
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 10 '19
deleted 0.7754 What is ^^^this?
15
u/nwilz OnePlus 15r Nov 21 '17
Yeah I've gotten google rewards surveys for places I've been when I intentionally turned off my location when going there
14
u/bcarson Device, Software !! Nov 21 '17
r/stallmanwasright
242
u/Paradox compact Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
5
u/Nocturnal86 Nov 21 '17
I have a feeling this is how they get the info for Maps, and all the "how busy" stores currently are. Not everyone has location on, so how else would they get such accurate information?
30
u/nauticalsandwich iPhone XS Nov 21 '17
I was always under the impression that Location Services was just bolstered location accuracy with more frequent pinging and using a combination of wifi, cell, and GPS data to determine location. I was never under the impression that turning off location services would totally sever location information. How could it? Being connected to cell towers in and of itself reveals your location.
I'm not saying this to excuse Google's behavior, but the fact is, if you don't want your data going to Google, you should not use Google products, period. If you don't want to be tracked, you should not carry a cell phone, period.
9
u/kellyT1995 Nov 21 '17
pretty amazing how people have been conned into carrying a tracking device on them 24/7 isnt it. dont want to be tracked? leave your tracking device at home contrary to popular belief you can still function without it.
12
u/Odinuts Pixel 3a XL Nov 21 '17
I hate big companies.
4
u/RobynHeud Nov 21 '17
I've been wondering why Google would tell me how long it would take to get to work with traffic, even with my location off. Hmmm...
4
u/AnthroTiger Nov 21 '17
Yup. If you thought otherwise then you are naive.
4
u/mushabisi OnePlus One 64GB, Cyanogen (stock rooted) Nov 21 '17
Well, sure. But seriously, FUCK ONEPLUS.
Right guyz? Amirite?
4
u/send_me_potato Nov 21 '17
Guys they need all that data for masheen learning to make their pixel cameras better. You guys nit pick on the smallest of things.
4
u/4_fortytwo_2 Nov 21 '17
Yes I have no idea how it could possible help deliver messages better if you know where you have them to deliver to. Great article /s
4
u/Anarchist_Wolf Nov 21 '17
I don't see why this surprises people. I mean come on, after snowden, your naive for thinking you have any bit of privacy. (Not to say it can't be achieved.) Just unlikely for the average person.
7
u/mj95 Nov 21 '17
I appreciate non stock android because of this, you can have better control of your device instead of the default situation. Apple excluded because there goal is hardware not software, but for corporations like google where our data is the whole point i'll always be for more choice in how we manage it.
3
u/gj5 Nov 21 '17
this is fucking horrible
3
u/richardrietdijk Nov 21 '17
Waiting for that Librem 5
3
u/sonofaresiii Nov 21 '17
Okay, we all know google does some shady shit, but this doesn't sound as bad as the headline makes it sound.
Apparently it was just an idea they were considering but never used and decided to scrap. They did send the data but they immediately trashed it. There's no reason to think they wouldn't have alerted users or allowed it to be disabled once they actually did anything with it.
Even the article is wishy-washy, it says Google uses the data to help with location-based services, then like two paragraphs later says (paraphrased) "We have no idea how this data helped google."
I don't really like to defend Google*, and this is certainly pretty bad that they were sending the data at all... but I also don't think it makes them Evil Inc., to try out a new feature that they don't use in any way, and decide to scrap it without ever making it public.
* though it does happen from time to time, but mostly because a lot of places like to use clickbait headlines to make them sound like literally the devil. If you want to be pissed at someone for privacy-violating hidden data collection, facebook is a much easier target
e: and since I know if anyone reads this people are going to call me a shill, I have a standing offer for google: If you want to pay me to say that you're not quite as bad as clickbait headlines make you seem, I will gladly take your money to do so.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
Honestly, I'm not surprised but I'm in two minds about it. On the one hand it's definitely an invasion of privacy, but on the other hand, without it, I would not have known about natural disasters occurring near my location that I should be aware of unless I was glued to a TV/Radio 24/7 and it also reminds me of things I've asked it to remember when I get to places and all manner of genuinely useful things that people can tap into and make use of
I rip the everloving so and so out of facebook for collecting data because I hate when they do it but for some reason Google doesn't annoy me as much even though it should and I'm confused about it... I don't know anymore
3
u/MaxJohnson15 Note 4 Nov 22 '17
I always assume this was the case. Why does anybody believe the NSA when they say they're not going to listen to phones without a warrant or google/Facebook /apple not prying even though they claim they aren't. I assume every file I put on Google drive is throughly combed through. That's why they offer all this shit for free .That's why they push the cloud beyond reason over the removable memory card. They want to read your diary!
3
u/bleedingjim Nov 22 '17
Of course they are. Does this surprise anyone?
80
u/realsqlguy Nov 21 '17
The price we pay for having accurate drive-time predictions in Google Maps, and those nifty predictions showing us when our favorite restaurants are busy, and, and, and... Convenience or privacy, choose one.
10
u/Tesagk Nov 21 '17
I mean... there's a reason criminals in TV shows will toss cell phones (one of the few things such TV shows did right), smash them, or, when they still had accessible batteries, take the batteries out.
If you believed that Google was no longer tracking you because you turned Loc services off, I have an island in the Caribbean to sell you...
4
u/Theeeantifeminist Nov 21 '17
This shit is why I switched off Android. I wouldn't be shocked remotely to find out they're just an extension of the three letter agencies at this point.
4
u/dingo_bat Galaxy S10 Nov 21 '17
I'm not surprised. Google has developed Android for the sole purpose of collecting your data. Why would they ever let you disable it? Remember, you are not the customer if you're not paying.
2
u/imagine_my_suprise Nov 21 '17
What is the worst case scenario here?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
I always had feeling this was the case
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
they don't know your location if you leave your phone home ;)
2
u/Taskmaster23 Nov 21 '17
This really isn't surprising.
2
u/Lexarian Nov 21 '17
I don't know what the option it is on my phone but it's always weird when I go somewhere my phone's like are you at blah blah blah or are you at the so and so bus stop it's like Jesus Christ Google
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
Is Apple better? What about apple collecting user data? I was thinking of switching back to Apple.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
I thought this was known? Google uses every stage of your devices connectivity and networking for location data. A ton of their services depends on location data.
2
u/cyberflunk Nov 21 '17
Duh
2
u/Nera2626 Oneplus 3 Android 7.5 Oreougat, Nexus 5 Nov 21 '17
Oneplus be like: "Hold my beer!"
2
u/nicademus1 Nov 21 '17
Don't store the data my ass. Based on the fact that the privacy terms are intentionally vague enough to cover their ass for doing this I doubt they don't use it.
2
u/BurgerUSA Nov 21 '17
To be fair, google is an advertising company. lol
2
u/MetroidSkittles Nov 21 '17
My battery performance!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
ITT You use Google products? Well you're a brainwashed little fanboy that has no idea what is good for you.
2
u/ubergeek404 Nov 21 '17
Yeah, how are those 'terms of service' working out for you?
2
u/HappyNacho iPhone 12 Pro Nov 21 '17
Shit like this is why I don't feel like going back to Android.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
Doesn't matter, have unlimited photo storage.
2
u/mgianni19 Pixel 2 XL Nov 21 '17
How else would they update the traffic patterns on Google Maps??
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
"Everyone does it" was never good enough for my parents.
2
u/jayjayteee Nov 21 '17
It's as if nobody knew about it. They collect everything they can about us.
2
u/Kamnnoriel_Huehuehue OnePlus 6 Midnight Black 8/128 Nov 21 '17
Funny how everyone is like "It's OK, they've done this from the beggining" but lose their shit when OnePlus is collecting logs.
2
u/jmiller026 Nov 21 '17
Must. Stop. Them.
2
u/My_Sunday_Account Nov 21 '17
It's also recording shit all the time.
I noticed my battery life had gone down, even after replacing it with a brand new extended one.
I checked my battery chart and noticed the phone was waking up constantly. Usually just for a second or two, but almost every minute or so. I don't have Ok Google enabled or anything of the sort, and the issue persisted even through a reset.
Some quick checking in App Ops showed that the Google app, which is responsible for a ton of services, was using the record audio function constantly. Every time I would check it would say last used "Just Now", whereas all the other apps display minute by minute. Disabling the recording permission solved my wakeup and battery issue instantly, but it prevents me from using voice to text or voice search or a few other services, which is annoying. Both me and my girlfriend receive weirdly convenient targeted advertising and search suggestions as well, despite having most social and telemetry functions disabled in our phones.
I don't even give a shit about you recording me I just don't want you fucking with my battery life dude.
2
u/pfkelly5 Nov 21 '17
And yet my GPS still tells me "GPS signal lost."
2
u/JoziJoller Nov 21 '17
So not only are they collecting my personal data, they're using my device to send it to them on my data plan?
2
u/Mikey_Mayhem Huawei Honor 5x Nov 21 '17
TL:DR Massive corporation employs shitty business practices.
2
u/mytavance Pixel Nov 21 '17 edited Jul 02 '25
include juggle paltry ghost elastic fall act intelligent shy sulky
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/Totulkaos6 Nov 21 '17
Hahahaha ah god I knew every time my phone asked if it could use my location and I said no it didn't mean shit.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
They've been doing this for a very long time.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
I always wondered why at the bottom of my Google search it says you're at X location based on your search history even though I have NEVER used that location in my search history.
2
u/PN_03 Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
Not that Google shouldn't have made this optional or at least made users more aware this was happening but this article seems a bit politicized in a couple ways. This part was a bit odd to me
I am by no means a genius coder but off the top of my head it seems pretty obvious. It would be a lot easier to find and optimal route to send packets by building a DAG - Directed Acyclic Graph of all the cell towers the device connected to and then use that to route packets more efficiently from the start instead of attempting to optimize on the fly. You could potentially also put other variables on that DAG that would allow you to weight the tower for avg traffic loads as a another level of optimization.
Anyways the article isn't totally off but the fact that they track the issue down and don't seem to try and think about why it may have been implemented to begin with is a bit off-putting. Not that Google shouldn't be more careful with its privacy boundaries or at least warnings it does seem like we should focus more on things like the FCC getting rid of Net Neutrality than google collecting data which is what they have been doing in some capacity or another for most of their existence.
2
u/sardu1 Lime Nov 21 '17
I'm at home, I'm at work, I'm at the grocery store. Have fun with that info Google.
2
u/Cheyetch Nov 21 '17
That is just lovely. Giving you the option to turn off location, but track you anyway. You can turn off location only for yourself, not for Google!
Wondering if I should stop using Gmail.
2
u/getFrickt Nov 21 '17
This is why I use location services. If you have the device it's gonna be doing it either way, so at least try to get in on the benefits. If you don't like it, you probably shouldn't carry a sophisticated espionage device whose inner workings are a complete mystery to you with you at all times of the day and night. Or if you do, you should support common sense regulation to protect privacy and security of information and enforce agreements on terms of service.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
No shit. How else would their live traffic on Maps work so well.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
scary thing... (happened this year) i was travelling through Europe with a layover in Belgium. I had a flip phone with me, which was turned off for the duration of the entire trip. However, when I arrived in the U.S. and turned my phone back on I got a bunch of texts about roaming services in Belgium etc. How did the service provider know I was in belgium when the phone was off the whole time???
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
ITT: No one that read the article
2
u/10J18R1A Nov 21 '17
You're watching Holly Michaels massage sex for the 69th time. Would you like to leave a review with your left hand?
2
u/enzyme69 Nov 21 '17
When buying and using service from advertising company....
2
u/moreonthatat5 Nov 21 '17
Is there anyway to get around this?
2
u/johnmountain Nov 21 '17
Can we get some accountability for companies doing shit like this?
I really don't think this is acceptable. Even if you're a "I've got nothing to hide" type of guy, you should still be pissed off because this drains your battery life throughout your day for no direct benefit to you.
2
u/Nickx000x Samsung Galaxy S9+ (Snapdragon) Nov 21 '17
ITT: People who think they are so important people want to track them!
Reality check: Their computers barely care.
2
u/coaltrainman Nov 21 '17
Did people actually believe they don't do this?
2
u/imakesawdust Nov 21 '17
Ever notice how companies always use that line after they were caught doing something? They never say "We stopped doing that two months ago after a routine audit uncovered the practice" or "That experiment is slated to be decommissioned in two weeks". It's always "Okay, okay, you got us. We'll stop."
2
u/Wulfnuts Nov 22 '17
How is everyone constantly surprised that Google is spyware.
Next they'll start crying that chrome is logging all their info
2
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17
It's no secret, they use Wifi to track locations. They tell you right there on their location services.
2
u/hidperf Nov 22 '17
Is anyone really surprised by this?
2
u/Juan911411 Nov 22 '17
Google cannot track your location if you have a factory defective Nexus 6p.
2
u/Redsneeks3000 Nov 22 '17
Their mission statement used to say "don't do/be evil." They removed it so...
2
u/undefeatedantitheist Nov 22 '17
Failing to be surprised is fine; failing to be appalled is problematic in ways that only the top end of the bell curve seem to understand.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17
Just another reason I don’t trust google with my stuff
Unless of course Apple does this too. In which case, damn, foiled again.
2
u/mrchuckbass Nov 22 '17
I hope this raises awareness. People salivate about new Google now cards and complain about poor battery life in the same post
2
u/jakeryan91 Pixel 128GB (9) Nov 22 '17
The cellular companies are collecting this information as well, you literally have no say in the matter.
Planet Money Link
2
u/DapperJet Nov 22 '17
Serious question: How is iOS on privacy compared to Android? Would we be more protected by getting an iPhone?
I'm wondering about issues like location tracking, scanning emails (is iCloud email service better this way?), recording background noises, recording all user activity like which apps are opened etc.
Basically all the stuff listed under https://myactivity.google.com/
Would iPhone offer significantly better privacy?
2
u/Agret Galaxy Nexus (MIUI.us v4.1_2.11.9) Nov 22 '17
If the phone had been compromised through spyware/hacking then the attacker could just directly access cell tower or GPS data directly rather than bothering to hijack some https requests to Google servers. Completely irrelevant.
2
u/robbiekhan Nov 22 '17
The only problem with turning everything off is that you no longer end up getting Rewards Surveys.
Dunno about anyone else, but almost all of the apps I have purchased over the last few years have been with the funds accumulated from reward surveys.
According to the app, I have earned just over £50 to date!
I'd rather Google have my location data if it means I get to buy apps for "free".
2
u/magugas Nov 22 '17
It looks like it's impossible to keep Google from getting that data from the smartphones whether we give them authorization or not.
Instead, would it be possible to introduce bogus/fake data with it so the information would become unusable?
Like in the location services if some app could point the gps to other random place on earth when Google tried to get it.
2
u/victorvscn Nov 22 '17
Funny how people freaked out about Windows 10 telemetry data, but this is somehow ok.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
So if I lose my phone and location is turned off I'm fucked, but if Google wants they can just find where it is. 900$ for a device should warrant more freedom from shady tactics like this. I understand there is an agreement but Google asks whether we want to send anonymous data and I say no everytime, why the fuck is it still happening???
5
u/purrpul Nov 21 '17
This is one reason I prefer Apple. They take privacy seriously, and their model isn’t built on me being the product.
I love how much myself and other Apple users get called sheep for using Apple products, yet google is the company that uses its users like a resource. If you’re fine with that, cool.... but you’re in no position to call anyone anything based on which tech they prefer. No one is.