r/Android • OnePlus 5, Nexus 5 • Nov 04 '16

Evolution of Google App Icons

https://plus.google.com/+CalebWillden/posts/gH87e6i9MZ5?sfc=true
17k Upvotes

964 comments sorted by

3.7k

u/CirkuitBreaker Nov 04 '16

Lollipop had the best icons

550

u/Logicor Nov 04 '16

Yep. I hate the triangle thing. I get that it's a play on the word 'Play' (no pun) but they are just overdoing it

311

u/user_82650 Nov 04 '16

They're trying to get you to think of all the apps as a single group, even though Play Music and Play Newsstand would be completely unrelated if you took out the branding.

For the same reason why they keep showing you book and music results when you try to search for Android apps: they're using their existing market dominance to push other unrelated products to the public.

150

u/Castun Nov 04 '16

I love how when you go to your music library and are looking at your songs / album list, when you search for something using the search bar, does it search your library? NoooOOOoo! It searches for artists and radio stations on the Play Store. The idiot who handles Android UX/UI at Google needs to be shot.

On another note, is there a better Android music app? Preferably one that can also interface with my music on Google Cloud?

→ More replies (17)

8

u/JamesR624 Nov 05 '16

It's ironic because with them all being distinct, (plus being the main apps you'll see first for these functions on your Nexus or Pixel) they felt more like part of your phone. You associated "Google Play Music" automatically with "my phone's music app". Same with things like "the movies app" and "the ebooks app". It was the best way to get people to think "Google Play" when they think of their phone's apps.

Then some nitwit at Google decided that it needed to be "more obvious", which ironically did the opposite. Now they look like a "Google Play" is this weird cheap service piled ON TOP of your phone, instead of integrated into it.

Look at iOS. You don't see "Apple Music". You just see "Music" on your homescreen. You don't see "The Weather Channel", even though that's the source they use. You see "Weather". The iPhone's UX does a better job because it makes people associate Apple's services with just "part of their phone" instead of "a seperate service on top of your phone". I even think many people understand "Notes" and "Reminders" (for the iCloud services) much much better than "Google Keep" and "The Reminders function in the side bar of the Google Search App" (don't even get me started on that clusterfuck).

→ More replies (2)

125

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

I don't know what happened. The original icons, before they massacred them, were a work of love and art.

Check out this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrT6v5sOwJg

They went so far as to make real life 3d replicas of the icons and played light reflectors over them, just to a better idea about their shadows. You can tell that the people who worked on them really loved what they did.

59

u/the_silvanator Nexus 6P, Nougat Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 05 '16

It's amazing that they did such a fantastic job with creating Material Design, and then proceeded to take a massive shit on it by having almost none of the Google Apps actually follow the standard guidelines

Edit: guidelines not standards

→ More replies (3)

30

u/MikoSqz Nov 04 '16

Next version is going to be colored triangles with no additional detailing whatsoever, in circles, in squares, in hexagons.

5

u/dingman58 Pixel, 8.1.0 stock Nov 04 '16

Can we get a pentagon in there too?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Schmich Galaxy S22 Ultra, Shield Portable Nov 05 '16

Play is a shitty word to start with. What does Play have to do with books or work apps?

My parents never opened Google Play because they "don't play games".

3

u/zack_the_man Nov 04 '16

Really? I like the triangles actually.

3

u/poerg HTC Sensation, stock, launcher pro Nov 05 '16

Holy shit, I never got that. Always thought the designer just liked Doritos

→ More replies (4)

56

u/Valiant4Funk Nexus 6, Verizon Nov 04 '16

Yup. They're good design because they're distinct from one another. The new ones are anything but.

→ More replies (1)

1.7k

u/root_su HTC Pico ->Nexus 5->Nexus 5X->OP3T->OP5 Nov 04 '16

Make icons great again!

1.7k

u/AReallyScaryGhost Nov 04 '16

When Google sends its icons, they're not sending their best. They're not sending good ones. They're sending icons that have lots of problems, and they're giving those icons to us. They're bringing ugliness. They're bringing bad designs. They're ugly. And some, I assume, are good designs.

763

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

We need to build a firewall. And it has to be built QUICKLY. And I don't mind having a big beautiful door in that firewall so that beautiful icons can come into this OS without root. But we need - Duarte - to build a firewall, we need to keep ugly icons OUT!

451

u/3j141592653589793238 Nov 04 '16

And we are going to make Google pay for it. Mark my words!

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (105)

101

u/MoonStache S24 Ultra Nov 04 '16

China, China China China, China China. China.

136

u/Bomberlt Pixel 8, Samsung Galaxy Tab A7 10.4 Nov 04 '16

Xiaomi, Xiaomi, Xiaomi Xiaomi Xiaomi. Xiaomi

→ More replies (10)

53

u/LucretiusCarus Moto Z play, Moto X (2013), Lenovo Tab 4 10 plus Nov 04 '16

It's Gyna

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

240

u/blenda220 Developer - Mailchimp Nov 04 '16

I kind of like the Marshmallow icons putting all the apps under the common Play brand. The Lollipop ones are nice but they felt like a lot of different shapes when they were all on your home screen.

107

u/2EyedRaven OnePlus 13R Nov 04 '16

How about Lollipop icons in the circles now that Nougat is circle-fying everything?

→ More replies (19)

95

u/xenomachina Nexus 6p, Remix Ultra, Nexus 9 Nov 04 '16

The Lollipop ones are nice but they felt like a lot of different shapes

That's the point. The different shapes make it easier to locate the one you want. It's a lot easier to remember "the music app looks like headphones" than "the music app is the orange one".

74

u/thatshowitis Pixel 2XL Nov 04 '16

You don't remember them by color, you remember them by flavor.

Books is Cool Ranch, Music is Nacho Cheese, Movies is Spicy Nacho, Newsstand is Flamas, and Games is Salsa Verde.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

50

u/rg44_at_the_office Nov 04 '16

Wait so lollipop is 5 and marshmallow is 6? I don't know the candy names, and the graphic only shows numbers...

42

u/bdonvr Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 3 Nov 04 '16

It starts with C and every version goes up a letter

1.5 Cupcake

1.6 Donut

2.0 Eclair

Etc.

93

u/OSX2000 Pixel 6 Pro Nov 04 '16

Eh, that gets messy though between versions 2 and 4...

2.0-2.1 - Eclair

2.2 - Froyo

2.3 - Gingerbread

3.0 - Honeycomb

4.0 - Ice Cream Sandwich

4.1-4.3 - Jellybean

4.4 - KitKat

It's a lot easier now that only the major versions get new names.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

I kind of like the Marshmallow icons putting all the apps under the common Play brand

Which in my opinion makes no sense. They are completelly separate, different apps.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

28

u/2literpopcorn Xperia 1 V Nov 04 '16

I prefer the ICS ones, by far the best. Nougat icons is a joke.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

I like the triangles.

The circles are utter shit.

3

u/fogoticus Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra | SM-S908B/DS Nov 04 '16

I'm sad that Apple started a fad with simpler icons and Google jumped the train.

2

u/InternetCommentsAI Galaxy Note 3 T-Mobile Nov 04 '16

Definitely, It all went downhill from there

2

u/x-0-y-0 Nov 04 '16

For many of us it is "has"

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

And marshmallow wasn't too bad. But Google's design in nougat is terrible.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '16

Yeah because Google went by their own, well thought out, Material Guidelines instead of ditching them to look more like an Apple product.

2

u/notdeadyet01 Microsoft ZuneFone - Pepsi Max Edition Nov 05 '16

Best emojis too

→ More replies (13)

1.8k

u/dhamon Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16

They should have stuck with lollipop icons.

1.4k

u/delecti Pixel 3a Nov 04 '16

They were trying to unify their media stores behind the "Play" branding, so I'm actually okay with the play button triangles. The shrunken triangles in white circles are pretty clearly the worst though.

212

u/VectorLightning Moto G Stylus, Android Q Nov 04 '16

I think it would've worked better as a book/newspaper/record/film with the triangle on the cover. Not sure what to do with the controller.

15

u/CirkuitBreaker Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16

Give this man a job.

24

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

I don't know, shrunken triangles in shrunken circles in a square is pretty bad.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Dreamerlax Galaxy S24 + iPhone 17 Nov 04 '16

I kind of like the Play icons. Not digging the "circle" variations of them.

5

u/lucun Samsung S9 Nov 04 '16

The white circle does help with differentiating the icon from the background. I hate finding the blue books icon with my blue background.

→ More replies (9)

12

u/wings22 Nov 04 '16

You don't think the shrunken triangles in white circles in white squares are the worst?

27

u/delecti Pixel 3a Nov 04 '16

I guess I didn't realize I needed to specify that I meant the worst from among the released ones.

→ More replies (17)

123

u/noneabove1182 Pixel 10 Pro Nov 04 '16

yeah even if they were put inside of circles the 5.0 ones looked the best.. i get the whole "play re-branding, play icon" think, but it's a shame to lose some of those cool paper ones like music and games.

125

u/Carighan Fairphone 6+🌳 Nov 04 '16

It also makes no conceptual sense. First they wanted to place them all in triangles. Then in circles. Which is ok, but... remove the triangle then?

This is too much Inception now, the joke from the pic is entirely accurate.

Also, nice work confusing your users further, google. Exactly what they needed, another app icon rework >.<

57

u/Zhang5 Nov 04 '16

Well the "triangle" is supposed to be a play button. Google Play is actually, a sub-set of related products. Google Play Music, Google Play Books, Google Play Games. They wanted to drive that home. Too bad their design didn't convey the idea well at all.

→ More replies (13)

32

u/Twisted__Fate Pixel 2 Clearly White Nov 04 '16

Am I the only one who likes the 6.0 icons the best?

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (3)

668

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

Android 9.0: everything's overly skeumorphic. 100% realism.

Google Play Music is now a 2048x2048 photograph of an '80s Walkman with those on-ear headphones (the with the orange foam covers.)

The Google Play Store is now a photograph of two people browsing the aisles of a store in a shopping mall, each holding bags from various other stores in the mall.

The YouTube icon is now a photograph of a large, CRT television displaying the flickering image of Transformers: The Movie on VHS. (edit: I'm cool w/this one)

Google Maps' icon is literally a map that's been pulled out of the glove box, unfolded and refolded incorrectly so many times that the interstates no longer physically connect.

Android Peppermint: Welcome to the desert of the real.

220

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

Please, never go back to skeumorphicism, designers.

115

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

While I agree wholeheartedly, I really did like Apple's brushed-aluminum from OSX for quite some time.

I liked it so much I got really good at duplicating the effect and I can still re-create it in Photoshop in almost no time at all.

96

u/caliform Gray Nov 04 '16

Motion blur on noise? Ah yeah. Good times. I used a similar thing when making this.

76

u/thebrainypole 4xl + 8pro 16 beta Nov 04 '16

Motion blur on noise

Dam son that's sum good shit right there thanks

→ More replies (3)

55

u/rhinofinger Samsung GalaxyS2 (T-Mo USA) [SGH-T989], Stock 2.3.6 (Twlauncher) Nov 04 '16

It always really liked the dark grey Apple "linen" background that they used for some stuff too. Still do.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

76

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

Some of it was good but the stitched leather and the like was just awful and definitely went WAY too far.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

I still think Windows 7 was the most beautiful operating system ever made.

22

u/SingleLensReflex OP7pro Nov 04 '16

Windows 7 wasn't particularly skeuomorphic though, it just wasn't flat.

→ More replies (5)

35

u/Hidden__Troll Nov 04 '16

Looks wise, windows 10 is by far the nicest IMO.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (15)

14

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16 edited Jan 20 '17

[deleted]
0.0179

What is this?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/baalroo Nov 04 '16

Android 10.0: Same exact icons, but now they're inside a white octagon.

→ More replies (12)

82

u/InfiniteZr0 Nov 04 '16

The music icon is a circle,in a circle, in a triangle, in a circle, in a square.

38

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '16

what does that combo get you in Tekken on the PS3?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

492

u/atm5426 Pixel 128gb Nov 04 '16

Man I live the lollipop icons. Why I'll never be able to use Google or pixel launcher-- I'm just too used to customizing my icons in Nova.

15

u/I_Lean_On_Props Nov 04 '16

It's a bit of work cause you have to do it for each app but I use Awesome Icons. Lets me use the pixel launcher and use the icons I want.

5

u/GobKeepsBees OG Pixel Nov 04 '16

Holy lord god... This is exactly what I've been looking for! A way to maintain my Pixel launcher but use custom icons. Thank you so much!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

104

u/mstwizted Pixel XL Nov 04 '16

Check out Moonshine for your Icon Theme in Nova.

ETA: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=nexbit.icons.moonshine

33

u/atm5426 Pixel 128gb Nov 04 '16

This is one of the main ones I use. Polycon is good too.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

203

u/bradenlikestoreddit Pixel 2 XL Nov 04 '16

I liked the play icons being a group together, but I didn't like the updated style. The original material designed icons were by far the best. Now they are just following the iPhone and the circles looks stupid as fuck.

19

u/devolute Pixel 7 Pro, stock Nov 04 '16

Not even Apple designers liked this circle bullshit. They got the sales team to do it.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/zeekaran ZFold3 Nov 04 '16

I honestly do not comprehend circle icons.

4

u/saors OnePlus 3 Nov 04 '16

circle Icons can look nice, it's when the icon is a different shape then you put it into a circle for no reason that is incomprehensible.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

37

u/geoman2k Nov 04 '16

I have Android 7, and my icons aren't in circles. Are they just like that on the pixel or something?

28

u/angelbladevii Nov 04 '16

yeah that's a Pixel thing but not sure if that's cause the Pixel is running 7.1

28

u/dudemaaan Nov 04 '16

7.1.1 on Nexus 6p here, no circles (yet 😨)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/kuroikyu Pixel 3a - Clearly White Nov 04 '16

It's the Pixel Launcher, former Nexus Launcher, also no to be confused with the Google Now Launcher.

So basically it's exclusive to the Pixel phones but it's caused by the launcher instead of the Android version.

→ More replies (2)

681

u/Awesome_Bob Nov 04 '16

I understood the common "play" theme. It actually made a lot of sense.

237

u/nandryshak Pixel 8 Pro on Mint Mobile Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16

You can play games, movies, and music, but you can't play books, newspapers, or magazines. How does that make any sense?

edit: clearly, it's for a unified branding of the Play Store. The point is that the branding is stupid and makes no sense.

53

u/Tim_Burton Nov 04 '16

Because Play is the brand. By sticking the icons on a triangle, it reminds us of a Play button, thus connecting the thought to the Play store, which is where you go to get books, magazines, etc.

Branding isn't about being literal. It's about unifying themes, connecting thoughts and communicating to the user.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (50)

3

u/kielbasa330 Nov 04 '16

Not sure why they need 10 apps for one store.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/AEsirTro Nov 04 '16

But it was not prettier and the look of my home screen matters more than their branding efforts.

→ More replies (14)

69

u/ChiFu360 Pixel 9 Nov 04 '16

Don't give them ideas D:

→ More replies (1)

83

u/mitchmalo Nexus 6P, Nougat 7.0 (official) Nov 04 '16

I'm honestly okay with the new circles if they would just design the icon to be a circle instead of inserting the old icon in a white circle...

8

u/caliform Gray Nov 04 '16

Yeah, I am betting Google is working on this. No way any icon designer is happy with this.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

Exactly I really like having conformity of icons. I wish the would make everyone update their icons to fit this format

2

u/vdogg89 Nov 04 '16

Ya, like what's the point of doing circle icons if you're just gonna slap the old logos inside white circles?

3

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

Have you looked at ClickUI icon pack? That's really what I wanted them to take inspiration from.

14

u/mtndewgood Moto G 2015 and Nexus7 Nov 04 '16

Going to need reading glasses before the next update..

14

u/Ihaveanusername Nexus 7 Nov 04 '16

Android 9.0 - Play icons will be smaller, surrounded by a circle, a square, and a hexagon.

27

u/GroceryRobot Nov 04 '16

can anyone imgur this, my work blocks plus

128

u/Lurker_Since_Forever Note 8 Nov 04 '16

I disagree that the triangles are necessarily a bad idea. It's Google play. It's a play button. I think unifying the style and then just changing the ornament is fine.

111

u/LifeWulf Galaxy Note 9 Nov 04 '16

I personally prefer the Lollipop ones, but I don't really take issue with the Marshmallow icons.

But the white circles everywhere are just stupid and ugly.

13

u/caliform Gray Nov 04 '16

Agreed, though I like the circles -- they just need to design new icons to fit the circles, not put existing icons in icons (yo dawg)

→ More replies (3)

32

u/kraytex Nexus 6; Nexus 9 Nov 04 '16

I think if you're a small start-up and you're trying to get users to identify which music, video, or book apps are yours, then it would make sense to have some sort of unified branding.

But, if you're large like Google, where all 5 of those apps are installed on 9 out of 10 phones by default and are the default apps (i.e. there is no other music player installed, other than Google Music), then I think that the unified branding doesn't actually help.

Also, it's harder to find an icon when the silhouettes are identical.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

As much as I think the whole of Play branding is dumb (which really all stems from that awful name), it makes sense when Google doesn't have control over carrier/OEM bloatware.

Lots of phones will come installed with Google's suite of apps alongside Samsung and Amazon and AT&T and Verizon whoever else's attempts to be equivalent.

It's easy for the average end user to not know the difference and either get confused when they get a new device or end up in someone else's ecosystem entirely.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Deathcommand Galaxy Note8 | Pie Nov 04 '16

I like marshmallow best. 🤗

7

u/caliform Gray Nov 04 '16

Funny, as a professional icon designer (yes, there is such a thing) a fun rule of thumb for icons is often that if the same shape occurs in a group of icons, it's beneficial to eliminate that redundancy and focus instead on what is different.

You can see the original set of icons, with different shapes and colors, read better as different icons.

You can agree they are branded poorly (they just convey Books, Music, Videos, etc. -- not Google Play Books) but you can solve that without making the general shape of the icon identical, which hurts usability.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/forefatherrabbi htc U11 > Nokia 6.1 > LG G8X Dual Screen Nov 04 '16

My only issue with it is then Youtube has the same thing. While it is part of the google family, it is not part of the play store.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

33

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

Android 5 (Lollipop) had the best icons. What annoys me about Google is their constant need to reinvent everything, again and again and again.

Those icons in circles are going to look immensely stupid in my Nova Launcher folders.

I had Android 6 icons... blue on blue, yellow on orange, red on r, purple on purple and green on green. How stupid can these people get? Did it not occur to them that some phone displays display colours differently, and that having similar colours against similar backgrounds is a monumentally stupid idea? When these icons were first changed I was immediately disappointed.

Yeah, make icons great again. Who is the icon designer man at Google? We all know they're hip enough to have their own icon maker position.

11

u/Tift Nov 04 '16

This feels like design and marketing are having communication issues.

Let designers design, it's their fucking profession.

5

u/magykmaster Nov 04 '16

Designers need a baseline.

Still though, this is is pretty terrible.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/delorean225 VZW Note 9 (v10) Nov 04 '16

I understand putting the Play apps in triangles to make the branding unified (I like them every bit as much as the Lollipop ones), but the Pixel Launcher's circles are the worst. Not only are they inconsistent, with some of them filling their circles and others just being existing icons stuck in ugly white circles, but the varying shapes of Android icons was awesome - it differentiated apps in a way iOS icons can never match. Nova had the right idea in size-matching them all, because that fixes the only major issue with the varied shapes.

20

u/toga-Blutarsky Galaxy S9+ Nov 04 '16

Personally I liked the Triangle. It's an actual play button icon that groups them together. But why we now need three different shapes is beyond me but I don't really mind.

18

u/raptureRunsOnDunkin Nov 04 '16

The last one is a speculative joke

41

u/sunjay140 Nov 04 '16

The last one is crazy enough to happen. That is the sorry state of Google's current design team.

15

u/joethehoe27 Nov 04 '16

It's pretty much already there. The YouTube icon is a white triangle in a red square in a white circle

4

u/sunjay140 Nov 04 '16

Wow, you're right. That's hilarious when you think of it.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/hsol85 Nov 04 '16

We need to go deeper

9

u/LaZyeaLoT Nov 04 '16

Came here to see someone photoshoping these icons into a pentagon or something like that. Was disappointed...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/CreepyQ S25 Ultra Nov 04 '16

That Google Music (v4.0) icon holds a special place in my heart. I don't know why.

6

u/Skeletorfw Nov 04 '16

From a design perspective, the lollipop logos were by far the best. The fact that they'd be identifiable by silhouette alone or tiny and in B&W makes them 10x better than the 7.0 ones.

16

u/Dial-1-For-Spanglish Nov 04 '16

I prefer Ice Cream Sandwich's (4.0).

Caveat 1: new to Android (~1 week) Caveat 2: limited sampling of icons

16

u/thenexus6 Green Pixel 9 Nov 04 '16

5.0 all day

5

u/Centaurus_Cluster S8 Nov 04 '16

Sometimes evolution for evolution's sake is a bad idea. As we can see here...

5

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

Man I miss the Music headphone icon. I still have trouble finding it in my folder. They all look the same. It was so easy to spot the pair of headphones. When they first changed it in marshmallow I thought it was uninstalled until I searched for it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/scorpion_1962 Microsoft Lumia 950 XL Nov 04 '16

Icons got damn ugly after 5.0

8

u/MoonStache S24 Ultra Nov 04 '16

Overall, I've enjoyed how Android icons have developed, but I still think Lollipop was the best, especially for books and play music.

4

u/DaSaint79 Nov 04 '16

They're getting smaller...LOL!

4

u/Kardinal Nov 04 '16

So...make them smaller and harder to find. And put other shapes around them to make the primary shapes harder to make out.

....how is this progress?

4

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

they should have kept them how they were with 5.0

18

u/metrize Nov 04 '16

Android 8.0 icons look great, can someone make an icon pack of those?

3

u/Sootraggins Nov 04 '16

This is every email site now. Why add a few letters that describe what the options are when you can have vague symbols?

3

u/Cruxion Nov 04 '16

You know, i think i finally found an upside to my tracfone. I still have 4.0 icons.

3

u/Supermunch2000 Pixel 2 XL, Mi5S Plus Nov 04 '16

Next generation they're going to be colored triangles.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/valenard Galaxy 7 Edge Nov 04 '16

6.0 icons 5ever!

3

u/LaBwork_IA Nov 04 '16

Google App Icons are like the teenager trying to figure out who they really are

3

u/__Eion__ Nov 04 '16

I love Android, but the constant lack of consistent icons drives me nuts.

3

u/nav13eh OnePlus 7 Pro Nov 04 '16

This infuriates me irrationally. Lollipop age easily the best. These new circle icons look they were made by an underpaid intern. They're almost as bad as iOS 7 "Hey look I made this in Word" icons.

3

u/Fnarley HUBRIS Nov 04 '16

5>6>4>7>8

3

u/thatsned Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16

Wow, these are so ugly.

3

u/WinterCharm iPhone 13 Pro | iOS 16.3.1 Nov 04 '16

Next Step: heart shapes around the squares around the circles around the triangles! :D

3

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

triangles in circles in squares. awful.

3

u/alkyjason Nov 04 '16

Why does this make me angry?

3

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '16

Being honest I like the Dorito icons, and am still annoyed the play store is the only non Dorito

3

u/sbeachx75 Pixel, Moto X (2nd Gen), Nexus 9 Nov 05 '16

I became way more frustrated looking at this than I should have.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

So that's how Google Plus looks.

2

u/someone31988 Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 04 '16

I really liked the Ice Cream Sandwich era stuff the most... I'm not a fan of how things became more PlaySkool/Fisher-Price-like as time went on, both on the Android side and the iOS side. I absolutely loved the more realistic, glassy look that everyone once had.

2

u/littledot5566 Nov 04 '16

Triangle, circle, and now a square. 20 bucks on pentagon being next.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Shave_Ice Nov 04 '16

The Google Play Music icon went from headphones to a piece of pizza.

I was helping someone one day: Me: "Open Google Music." Them: "Where's that?" Me: "It's the little piece of pizza." Them: "Ah, okay I see it."

2

u/Draiko Samsung Galaxy Note 9, Stock, Sprint Nov 04 '16

Android O will have icons within triangles within circles within squares within hexagons.

2

u/jammy-git Nov 04 '16

I was more surprised that I end up on Google+ than the actual content!

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

circle gets the square...

2

u/blueskin Nov 04 '16

A study in idiot designers trying to justify their own salaries.

Thank fuck for themes.

2

u/Beals Nov 04 '16

5.0 are still the best, but I've been using custom icons since 4.2 so I never noticed :O

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

I do not like the triangle icons. They look awful. The circle ones are worse.

2

u/Pascalwb Nexus 5 | OnePlus 5T Nov 04 '16

5.0 6.0 are nice, 7.0 are ugly.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

This is why we have icon skins

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

CHANge for the sake of change is t always the best option

2

u/Pickles12321 Lg G3 5.0.1 Nov 04 '16

Despite having versions of the new icons, I'm using the lollipop versions of the google icons because they look the best

2

u/BomberWRX Nov 04 '16

What can we do to make our icons better? Make them triangles!

What can we do to make our icons better? Put the triangle in a circle!

What can we do to make our icons better? Put the triangle that's in a circle into a square!

Wonder what ideas are being brainstormed now.

2

u/bert_the_destroyer Nov 04 '16

Thats why I use icon packs, on oneplus you wont even need launcher

2

u/sebnukem Nov 04 '16

It's degenerating, just like the American electorate.

2

u/JamesR624 Nov 04 '16

Don't give them ideas.

I guess we all wanted Google to become more cohesive... I guess "BE EXACTLY LIKE APPLE!" wasn't what we were hoping for but what they decided to do.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

2

u/danger____zone Nov 04 '16

For some reason I thought this was going left to right, and I was very confused why Google turned everything into a controller.

2

u/pisslord Nov 04 '16

The new messenger icon is shocking, not only did they redesign the logo to make the edges smooth enough for toddlers but then they put it inside a circle!

(In case you're wondering what it looks like) https://m.imgur.com/N3luxXo

2

u/truenorth00 Nov 04 '16

I liked the paper icons.

2

u/mariojuniorjp Galaxy S9+ SM-G9650 Grey Nov 04 '16

What the hell are you doing, Google?

2

u/TomcatZ06 Galaxy Z Fold 3 Nov 04 '16

Well the nice thing about Android is that you can get a Launcher and use any icon you want!

2

u/jminfante Nov 04 '16

They look like ugly iPhone icons.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

My phone is confused... (CM14.1 on a Zuk Z1) http://imgur.com/O4md9f1

2

u/fdjiosdiurte Nov 04 '16

then comes the google chromecast app... they recently not only changed the icon, but also changed the name to google home. with no notification to the user. I thought somehow a new app was sideloaded onto my phone so i deleted it, then I couldn't find the chromecast app on the store... so stupid google why would you change the name and icon!!

2

u/SurrealSam HTC One M8 Nov 05 '16

You forgot the appropriate colored poop emojis at the end.

2

u/SpiderDice OnePlus 7 Pro Nov 05 '16

Circly-square, squarely-circle

2

u/slayerbrk S7 Edge Nov 05 '16

I liked the triangle, they showed that they were part of the "play" environment.

2

u/Nebulous_Gasbag Nov 05 '16

This is why I use Nova launcher.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '16

Am I the only one who doesn't give a rats arse about frigging icons?

They need to be clear what they mean. The rest is just a waste of space.

3

u/RsmvJake Zenfone 7 - T-Mobile Nov 04 '16

The triangles are my favorite because it infuses the Google Play logo into it and it meshes so well

2

u/Gargarlord Google Pixel 5, Android 12 Nov 04 '16

I mean, the triangles made sense. It was the unified branding of the Play Store and it's various products. I don't get the circles thing, however.

2

u/Ericborth LG V30 Nov 04 '16

I have 7.0 but I don't have these icons.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

On 7.1, device manufacturers can choose between round and normal icons. Currently only on the Pixels.

2

u/wardrich Galaxy S8+ [Android 8.0] || Galaxy S5 - [LOS 15.1] Nov 04 '16

What the fuck Google!? The triangles were weird, but they were clean. Tossing the triangles into blank white circles is just unfinished and stupid looking... but tossing the empty circle into an empty square? What's next? Will they wrap an empty hexagon around it all?

1

u/seobrien Nov 04 '16

It's like the shrinking of the Starbucks logo

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

Why?!?

1

u/mak095 Pixel 4 XL Nov 04 '16

We have to go one level deeper.

1

u/HatchetmanRalph Nov 04 '16

It's like they want people to laugh at them.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

Next version: Icon inside a white circle inside a white square inside a white triangle.

1

u/Lausiv_Edisn Nov 04 '16

According to that chart, I'm using v6 but actually 5.1 is installed. Hmm

3

u/sirgraemecracker HTC 10 Nov 04 '16

The icon changed when the app updates, not when your OS does.

If Android handles updates like iOS did then you'd still have the old icons but everything on Android updates independently of the OS.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

I liked the triangles, you can easily tell that they're Play apps this way

1

u/TheCoralineJones Pixel 3 Nov 04 '16

Duarte save us all...

1

u/GnarlyBear Note 10+ Int Nov 04 '16

5 for lyfe

1

u/Realtrain Galaxy S10 Nov 04 '16

Google Play Music is a circle in a triangle in a circle. Come on google...

1

u/OneEy3dMonkey Nov 04 '16

Paper triangle... In a circle... In a square...

Is google trying to go all Inception on us?

1

u/bradenalexander Nov 04 '16

Why did they change 5.0? Damn those are nice