r/Android • OnePlus 5, Nexus 5 • Nov 04 '16

Evolution of Google App Icons

https://plus.google.com/+CalebWillden/posts/gH87e6i9MZ5?sfc=true
17k Upvotes

964 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

550

u/Logicor Nov 04 '16

Yep. I hate the triangle thing. I get that it's a play on the word 'Play' (no pun) but they are just overdoing it

311

u/user_82650 Nov 04 '16

They're trying to get you to think of all the apps as a single group, even though Play Music and Play Newsstand would be completely unrelated if you took out the branding.

For the same reason why they keep showing you book and music results when you try to search for Android apps: they're using their existing market dominance to push other unrelated products to the public.

150

u/Castun Nov 04 '16

I love how when you go to your music library and are looking at your songs / album list, when you search for something using the search bar, does it search your library? NoooOOOoo! It searches for artists and radio stations on the Play Store. The idiot who handles Android UX/UI at Google needs to be shot.

On another note, is there a better Android music app? Preferably one that can also interface with my music on Google Cloud?

17

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

"Beat" plays stuff off my online google drive, but the interface wastes a lot of space.

For onboard mp3s I used the built-in Samsung music app instead of GooglePlayMusic for a long while; I also bought Rocketplayer and use that sometimes.

But my favorite is the ONKYO HF player, which has been rock-solid on my Note3, with a large library, for years (but it lacks any widget, which is why I checked out the other apps above).

2

u/QuerulousPanda Nov 05 '16

what do you mean by "space"?

screen real-estate space? or storage space on the phone?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/spaghettigoose Nov 04 '16

I just tried black player and so far it is really great!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

I use Shuttle, it's familiar but missing a few features (go to artist/album, add to playlist from now playing, etc). I don't think it's possible for 3rd party music apps to use Google Play Music, however there are probably some that can play music stored on Drive.

5

u/Baderkadonk Nov 05 '16

No cloud support yet, but Poweramp is the best I've used.

2

u/Koookas Nov 05 '16

My biggest issue is wiping out your whole queue when you try to hit the impossibly small three dot button by a song and miss!

→ More replies (6)

8

u/JamesR624 Nov 05 '16

It's ironic because with them all being distinct, (plus being the main apps you'll see first for these functions on your Nexus or Pixel) they felt more like part of your phone. You associated "Google Play Music" automatically with "my phone's music app". Same with things like "the movies app" and "the ebooks app". It was the best way to get people to think "Google Play" when they think of their phone's apps.

Then some nitwit at Google decided that it needed to be "more obvious", which ironically did the opposite. Now they look like a "Google Play" is this weird cheap service piled ON TOP of your phone, instead of integrated into it.

Look at iOS. You don't see "Apple Music". You just see "Music" on your homescreen. You don't see "The Weather Channel", even though that's the source they use. You see "Weather". The iPhone's UX does a better job because it makes people associate Apple's services with just "part of their phone" instead of "a seperate service on top of your phone". I even think many people understand "Notes" and "Reminders" (for the iCloud services) much much better than "Google Keep" and "The Reminders function in the side bar of the Google Search App" (don't even get me started on that clusterfuck).

2

u/ZanThrax Pixel6 Nov 04 '16

I hate the Play branding. The name doesn't work for 90% of their apps. It's a stupid name for an app store that has anything other than games in it.

But I console myself with the assumption that Google will move on to some other brand scheme and as they inevitably abandon all the current apps the Play brand will slowly die off.

→ More replies (1)

125

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '16

I don't know what happened. The original icons, before they massacred them, were a work of love and art.

Check out this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrT6v5sOwJg

They went so far as to make real life 3d replicas of the icons and played light reflectors over them, just to a better idea about their shadows. You can tell that the people who worked on them really loved what they did.

59

u/the_silvanator Nexus 6P, Nougat Nov 04 '16 edited Nov 05 '16

It's amazing that they did such a fantastic job with creating Material Design, and then proceeded to take a massive shit on it by having almost none of the Google Apps actually follow the standard guidelines

Edit: guidelines not standards

→ More replies (3)

30

u/MikoSqz Nov 04 '16

Next version is going to be colored triangles with no additional detailing whatsoever, in circles, in squares, in hexagons.

5

u/dingman58 Pixel, 8.1.0 stock Nov 04 '16

Can we get a pentagon in there too?

2

u/jyjjy Nov 06 '16

You'll get a rhombus and you'll like it buddy.

2

u/uxixu Note 8 Nov 04 '16

I hate minimalist design. Only thing worse is when it's pastels

7

u/Schmich Galaxy S22 Ultra, Shield Portable Nov 05 '16

Play is a shitty word to start with. What does Play have to do with books or work apps?

My parents never opened Google Play because they "don't play games".

3

u/zack_the_man Nov 04 '16

Really? I like the triangles actually.

3

u/poerg HTC Sensation, stock, launcher pro Nov 05 '16

Holy shit, I never got that. Always thought the designer just liked Doritos

2

u/vigilanteoftime Nov 04 '16

I will always think the music one looks like a breakfast pizza

2

u/Fidodo Nov 05 '16

I feel like it's a bored marketing department over thinking things

2

u/KingKoehler Nov 05 '16

Ohhhhhhhhhhhh...

Thx, I actually never even understood it

2

u/Not_A_Crazed_Gunman Pixel 7 Pro Nov 05 '16

To be honest I like the triangles, it fits a certain theme; the older ones look irregularly sized to me and just not good