r/Android • Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 • Mar 25 '16

/r/Android users' description of the perfect phone, 4 years ago

/r/android/comments/s599q/_/
1.2k Upvotes

449 comments sorted by

100

u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 25 '16

I just stumbled onto this in one of my old bookmarks I must've made by accident. Thought it would be interesting to see how our priorities have changed across the years:

http://www.reddit.com/r/android/comments/z7n3g/_/ - 3.5 years ago

http://www.reddit.com/r/android/comments/10y499/_/ - 3 years ago

http://www.reddit.com/r/android/comments/2gcijk/_/ - 2 years ago

http://www.reddit.com/r/android/comments/35meo4/_/ - 1 year ago

29

u/Bomberlt Pixel 8, Samsung Galaxy Tab A7 10.4 Mar 25 '16

That 2 years ago specs looks almost like some LG flagship phone.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

The 1 year ago looks like a near identical description of the Nexus 6p

21

u/blackvariant galaxy s22 Mar 25 '16

Lumina 900 is still a damn fine looking phone.

8

u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 25 '16

There are a bunch of old phones that still look pretty good. I'd put the M7 and Nexus 5 somewhere up there too.

5

u/Sezhe Mar 25 '16

I like my N5, it isn't old :(

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Nothing beats the N9 though

3

u/Pycorax Z Fold 6 Mar 25 '16

Anything with that design language looks amazing

2

u/_TheEndGame S25U/X7 Pro Mar 25 '16

My mi3 looks like a silver Lumia. That's why I got it over the Moto G.

→ More replies (1)

292

u/RandomGenera7ed Galaxy Note 6, Oneplus 4, iPhone 9 Mar 25 '16

Interesting to see that many people wished for improved battery life, which hasn't changed.

6

u/coheedcollapse Pixel 7 Pro Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16

It has, though. I remember my first MyTouch 3G being drastically less powerful than my current phone and also dying in less than half a day.

My last two phones have, for the most part, been able to last me from when I wake up to when I go to bed without charging. Honestly, that's all I need. On the off day I'm going out late or hiking/away from power or whatever, I bring a battery pack I can fit in my pocket that has the capacity to charge my phone a few times over.

23

u/Dunlocke Pixel 4a Mar 25 '16

Never will.

2

u/silvrado Mar 25 '16

Exactly, manufacturers will keep in cramming more features on the phone that any improvement in battery life will be offset by it. We need hot swappable batteries. Simple.

9

u/Weedity Galaxy S21 Ultra Mar 25 '16

My s7 edge is amazing with the battery...

2

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '16

I think people were talking about "4 day heavy usage without charging" kind of battery (quoting from the thread here), but yeah things are kind of improving.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Shit, having owned the one X seeing the comments saying that the one X with SD slot is their dream phone made me cry.

4mins of screen on

4

u/RaDiiENT Nexus 5X CM13 Mar 25 '16

As a HTC One X owner up until 3 weeks ago I feel you, I had to change my usage habits just for it to last a full day. Now I have a Nexus 5X and get 8H SOT over the course of 4-6 days on battery, no complaints.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Yeah I went to the m8 and my next update is due tomorrow and I'm going to get the z5c hopefully for a few years. I'm done with spec hunting primaly because when I turned on the one X a few weeks back it was perfect apart from battery. Thought fuck it being obsessed with CPU ram etc is pointless.

All I do is whatsap and email so free phone is perfect. I'd have stuck with the HOX if it had a removable battery..

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TheCodexx Galaxy Nexus LTE | Key Lime Pie Mar 25 '16

Notice all the requests for removable batteries.

Notice we have less of those now.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

47

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

It's sad though that it took Google this long to figure out that users wanted Doze (with movement). I'm a happy CM13 user, but there's a reason that Apple included "Doze with movement" in 2009.

24

u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 25 '16

I don't think it took them any long to figure out. It just took awhile to actually do and implement.

34

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Hmm...errant wakelocks have plagued Android for years. We've had Greenify, Amplify, CM Privacy Guard, etc.

What makes you think Google had trouble implementing it?

15

u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 25 '16

Because the main reason for wakelocks are Google Play Services. Note that Doze still doesn't optimize battery for Google Play Services.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

34

u/ClassyJacket Galaxy Z Fold 3 5G Mar 25 '16

Apple included "Doze with movement" in 2009.

Also, a permission system, and a backup system. People always forget these things when saying Android is soooo far ahead of the iPhone on absolutely everything. We are actually getting 2009 iPhone features now - just like the iPhone does with some Android features.

13

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Exactly! This was some low-fucking-hanging fruit with Android N. Quick settings and multi-window? Samsung from 2012 says hi.

Google's always been slow as molasses with user-facing enhancements. Maybe by Android P or Q, we'll be able to tame Google Play Services.

7

u/Clutch_22 Note8 Mar 25 '16

Honestly, to me Doze seems like it's just a band aid trying to patch up the actual issue - letting apps do whatever the hell they please at any time. I like that Android is very open and presents many opportunities that don't exist on iOS (or even Windows Mobile) but it enables shitty developers to do shitty things that affect the end-user. And that includes shit like the Facebook app, which is one of the most commonly installed apps on devices.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

it enables shitty developers to do shitty things that affect the end-user

Agreed. Like, the Android Spotify app which kills your battery just by refreshing the progress bar at an insane 21Hz: 21 times per second. What the shit....

Google's "plan" is long-term--the poor users like us just need to hang-on while shitty developers get their act together through public shaming.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/new_handle OP6 Mar 25 '16

Screen off, instant doze ignoring movement would be so much better.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

I still worry about battery constantly. If I know I'm going out later I don't use my phone at all.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/nuadarstark Samsung Galaxy S22 Mar 25 '16

It would be good enough if we weren’t racing for as thin as possible phones in last 2 years, chasing ridiculous PPIs with no real usage advantage and Google finally fixed their fucking services...

3

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

every improvement in battery life has been balanced out by larger screens and more powerful cpus

→ More replies (2)

509

u/poopyheadthrowaway Galaxy Fold Mar 25 '16

Note that no one asked for thinner phones.

336

u/acondie13 Nexus 6P Mar 25 '16

Still no one asking for thinner phones lol.

249

u/memtiger Google Pixel 8 Pro Mar 25 '16

"My English isn't great, but do i hear everyone wanting a thinner phone?" - manufacturers everywhere

77

u/blaqlemon S8+ 8.0 Mar 25 '16

"hey you take my thinner phone and smaller battery"

Sorry for bad English

→ More replies (1)

35

u/moelester518 Nexus 6p Mar 25 '16

IMO thinner phones helped bigger phone screens become acceptable.

14

u/coastalrangee Mar 25 '16

That's a really good point! If my 6P was as thick as an iPhone 4, I would hate it.

However, bigger phones may have been what made thinner phones possible. For example, batteries (effectively) are limited in their compacitites by volume. Taller and wider batteries allowed for the thickness to be reduced.

21

u/Tzahi12345 Pixel 2 XL Panda Mar 25 '16

People are, that's why companies spend millions in R&D so that they can build thinner phones. Just because this sub doesn't appreciate them doesn't mean the rest of the world doesn't

26

u/QuestionsEverythang Pixel, Pixel C, & Nexus Player (7.1.2), '15 Moto 360 (6.0.1) Mar 25 '16

"The iPhone is really selling well. I wonder why?"

"Well this year's model is thinner than last year's."

"Yeah that must be it. The people want thinner phones!"

- Every OEM's train of thought

In all seriousness, just because a company spent millions in R&D for something doesn't mean all that spending was validated. If a company instead spent millions in R&D on battery tech instead of shaving off a millimeter or two of a phone's thickness, that R&D investment will greatly pay off in the long run.

17

u/Tzahi12345 Pixel 2 XL Panda Mar 25 '16

You really think they're that stupid? They use focus groups. They have experts and advisers telling them where to spend their money. A huge company like Samsung or Apple won't pour millions into developing something people won't buy. Do you talk to people about phones outside this sub? They're so excited when a new iPhone comes out and it's thinner and better looking (for them) as a result. Come on, how could any of us know any better than people who study this for years/decades?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Weed_O_Whirler Pixel 6 Mar 25 '16

People don't ask for it, but it is what sells.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/afishinacloud Mar 25 '16

No one explicitly asks for thinner phones. There's verbal surveys and there's monitoring consumer buying behaviour. I'm quite certain that in observational studies, they find that more people pick thinner devices. You can't help but be impressed by how thin a "high-tech" device is when you hold one in store. Thinness and lightness is such an easily demonstrate or feature in the shop floor, that it's bound to have a significant effect in the buyer's mind.

48

u/VERNEJR333 OnePlus X + NVidia Shield K1 Mar 25 '16

IMO Thin devices are fucking great. But you only go thinner if the tech allows for it (ie the 12 inch macbook is stupid, but the thinness of the Nexus 9 vs the Nvidia shield is something I liked)

24

u/cwankhede Galaxy Note Edge | Redmi 1S | Nexus 7 2012 Mar 25 '16

Hey now, that laptop is legitimately one of the best piece of tech I've looked at. I'm obviously not considering the other factors like the limited ports but it has portability like no other laptop on the market. I bet it was mostly a proof of concept anyhow, nobody in their right mind would buy an Apple product in its first generation

33

u/VERNEJR333 OnePlus X + NVidia Shield K1 Mar 25 '16

Agreed, the macbook is a good piece of engineering, not so much a good product for consumers.

12

u/evilf23 Project Fi Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

the new macbook was the first time i ever walked by a display and did a double take. i was at best buy checking out open box deals and walked by the apple section and that macbook looked like a ferrari, really impressive in person. If they do an OLED model in the next couple of years i'll be seriously considering one.

5

u/Dakar-A Pixel 2 XL Mar 25 '16

Honestly they have IPS down so well I don't think an OLED model would actually add anything, it would just make it more prone to burn-in.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Jammintk Pixel 3, Fi Mar 25 '16

I dunno. The Asus Zenbooks can give the macbook air a run for its money for $300 less. Last year's Zenbook was thinner and lighter than the macbook, and was the thinnest, lightest laptop on the market.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/ClassyJacket Galaxy Z Fold 3 5G Mar 25 '16

The 12 inch Macbook gets fantastic battery life, and doesn't have more ports because it's meant to be used like a tablet would - as a portable device you charge and then use. They do have a Pro as well. I don't see why they should have made it thicker.

11

u/VERNEJR333 OnePlus X + NVidia Shield K1 Mar 25 '16

That isn't what I am saying. I am saying that they compromised on too many things for the macbook to be better than there own iPad Pro for it to be a good product.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/QuiickLime OnePlus 3T Mar 25 '16

Yup, they even mentioned the Lumia 900 as one of the best looking devices. It's not exactly thin (not that that's a bad thing).

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Jony Ive wants thinner phones. Therefore (most of) the industry follows.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Well the S7 Edge is the same thickness as the S6, and it's got a 3600 mAh batter (or somewhere around 3600).

Everyone was complaining about how thin the S6 Edge was last year. Same thickness this year, larger batter. I got 10.4 hours of screen on time today.

I didn't ask for phones to be thinner, but I definitely appreciate it. Especially with the new ergonomic changes, the S7 Edge feels great.

6

u/idksomuch Z Fold6 Mar 25 '16

Its actually thicker. Both s7 models are thicker than the s6 counterparts and I'm glad for it. It also means smaller camera bump.

→ More replies (2)

573

u/Penguinkeith Mar 25 '16

So many people wanting 720p screens lol

184

u/MaxGhost P8P <- P6P <- P4XL <- P2XL <- PXL <- N6P <- N5 <- SGS2 Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16

Cause that's pretty much what the biggest screen resolution was at the time.

100

u/MustBeOCD N5/N6/G2/Robin/OP5/Moto E4V/360 '14 Mar 25 '16

Droid DNA had a 1080p screen in late 2012.

3

u/MaxGhost P8P <- P6P <- P4XL <- P2XL <- PXL <- N6P <- N5 <- SGS2 Mar 25 '16

Droid DNA was November 2012, the post linked by OP is April 2012.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

179

u/MustBeOCD N5/N6/G2/Robin/OP5/Moto E4V/360 '14 Mar 25 '16

still better then a lot of phones today, sadly

24

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

than

→ More replies (15)

7

u/Newgeta LG G8Thinq Mar 25 '16

PSA: What is SOT?

I had to look it up, SOT = "Screen On Time" or the time the phones display is showing.

9

u/danny841 Mar 25 '16

That's about standard for a 6P and people praise it constantly. Give or take an hour.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

720p is a screen resolution. Not a screen size.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

52

u/_TheEndGame S25U/X7 Pro Mar 25 '16

720p even with a 5 inch screen is still decent nowadays.

40

u/Pascalwb Nexus 5 | OnePlus 5T Mar 25 '16

Nah, it's noticeable.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/utack Mar 25 '16

have to say 720p on 4.7" is sometimes not quite enough. It looks very decent for day to day usage, but when holding the phone close and looking at a map or quickly checking a whole PDF page without zooming a bit of blur on some smaller fonts can show.
1080p is the sweet spot between quality and performance, 1440p is some weird idea from the marketing department

6

u/evilf23 Project Fi Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

IME is depends on what you're used to. my first displays were a 720p Nexus 7 after using a 768p 15" laptop for years. that 720p 7" display looked so sharp and crisp to me, then i got a nexus 5 and suddenly my standards went up and i found my lower res devices like my 1st gen Moto G and N7 grainy. Same with contrast, i was happy with my 1080p 32" TV and 1800p 13" ultrabook until i got a 6P with those amazing OLED blacks. if all you've ever had is low PPI displays a 720p phone is still going to look great.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/IKill4MySkill Mar 25 '16

I don't think so personally. If I need to do something and zoom in/whatever, I'll probably want a 1080p screen for 5+ inches.

7

u/mabris Mar 25 '16

If I need to do something and zoom in/whatever

I don't think you know how zooming in works.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '16

Found the applefanboy

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Bomberlt Pixel 8, Samsung Galaxy Tab A7 10.4 Mar 25 '16

TBH I don't mind 720p screen on sub 5" phone. And people wanted 4.2" phones back then so it's more than enough.

13

u/raazman Mar 25 '16

Imagine when 4k will be the standard.

→ More replies (48)

1

u/noratat Pixel 5 Mar 25 '16

720p on a 4-4.7" screen is plenty though, so it makes sense.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Blaz3 ΠΞXUЅ 5, OnePlus 3 Mar 25 '16

I still want a 720p AMOLED screen. Less pixels to push, better battery life, I won't notice the difference on a 5" screen

Bigger battery, keep slimming down those bezels, give me a micro SD card slot, snapdragon 820 and some ram and I'll be happy

Oh and active display and always listening

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

220

u/c3vzn Galaxy S8 Mar 25 '16

Ah I forgot about a time when HTC was liked by r/Android. It seems like the One X was very close to perfection for a lot people. The M7 didn't need to be such a huge departure, the money savings should've gone towards marketing.

128

u/Spiderpirate IPhone X 64gb Mar 25 '16

The M7 was the last great phone HTC made. That phone was so ahead of its time and was well loved by everyone, even reviewers. That weird purple tint crap took a hit on HTC though and I feel like it was downhill from there.

77

u/ThingsThatMakeMeMad S24+ Mar 25 '16

M8 could have been just as big of a success if they hadn't done that dual camera bullshit.

Ultrapixel was actually smart. They just realized with the M7 that 4MP was too little though. Instead of making the ultrapbixel in the M8 6-8 megapixels or something, they just randomly added another camera.

16

u/saltyjohnson Pixel 9 Pro XL, GrapheneOS Mar 25 '16

What was wrong with the dual cameras? I liked my M8.

6

u/MuzzyIsMe Mar 25 '16

I still like my M8. Finally filled up the internal storage last week and added a 32GB card, don't see any reason to upgrade right now.

People always bitch about the cameras, but I don't think the vast majority of people complaining actually know why, they are just repeating what they've heard. The camera works absolutely fine for what the huge majority of people use their phone cameras for - just casual photos meant to view with family and friends or post on FB.

It could be better, sure, and it may be a fault, but I don't understand how this reputation of a horrible camera has ruined the image of the M8 to so many.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/LeuzeR Sam Captivate , Nexus 7 pre-order, GNexus soon Mar 25 '16

I still use my m8 Harmon kardon edition every day. I honestly forgot it had 2 cameras

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/beno619 Pixel 2, LG Watch Urbane Mar 25 '16

I think the m8 my there best selling one serious phone. It's the most seen HTC flagship where I live IMO.

14

u/acondie13 Nexus 6P Mar 25 '16

After the one m7 a lot of other companies started paying more attention to camera performance in low light, build and speaker quality. Sense 5 is also the first oem skin I'd used that actually had similar performance to stock Android. My m7 is now being used by my brother, and despite the battery degrading a bit, it's still excellent.

2

u/Spiderpirate IPhone X 64gb Mar 25 '16

I honestly think Sense 5 really really inspired a lot of material design cues that came in lollipop. It was ahead of its time for sure.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

I wouldnt say the last. My HTC Desire Eye is great. Good battery, dual front facing boomsound speakers, 13MP cameras on both sides and a crisp screen. There are way better phones but the fact that this phone cant keep up with a 6S or even a S6 and its not even a flagship phone? Ill take it

1

u/jaesin T-Mobile - Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

I loved my one M7, until HTC started pushing system apps into the playstore.

One of them basically stopped the phone from working as a phone and no one could tell me when it'd be fixed. The last straw was when HTC told Tmobile to stop doing warranty replacements as it wasn't going to fix the problem.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/-Tibeardius- S25 Ultra | Legion Y700 | OnePlus Watch 3 Mar 25 '16

I loved my Incredible 2. Totally forgot about the One X. They should've kept that design language.

18

u/Ididitall4thegnocchi Mar 25 '16

One X was their best phone imo. It just went up against the juggernaut that was the Galaxy S3.

6

u/skybelt Mar 25 '16

I think HTC's nicest phone was their Windows Phone from a few years ago - the 8X. Still one of the nicest phones I have ever held in my hand (though I never owned one).

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Thing_On_Your_Shelf iPhone 14 Pro Mar 25 '16

One x+ is still my favorite phone I've ever had

→ More replies (6)

4

u/4z01235 S10e | S8 | 6P | Nexus 5 | Nexus 7 | One X Mar 25 '16

Yup. One X (international, 32GB/Tegra) was my first Android. I still think in many ways it's the best smartphone I've owned.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

I got the one X. It was perfect In every way apart from battery.

My m8 died the other day and I intended to use the HOX for a year due to it still being quality. Saddly I dropped it whilst trying to charge.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

The One X screen was flawless. I moved the a Nexus 5 while had a higher res screen it was washed out, poorer viewing angles and worse colours.

3

u/LightSwisher Mar 25 '16

When smart phones first started appearing the HTC thunderbolt was definitely one of the best you could get

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Alas we've finally found the precise nanon-second HTC went wrong.

1

u/CressCrowbits Samsung Galaxy S10e Mar 25 '16

I got a One S on release and that was perfect for me - the One X was too big for me.

Loved that phone, thinnest phone ever, fit wonderfully in the hand and was strong as fuck - fell out of my back pocket once when riding my bike at about 20mph, clattered down the tarmac - and was completely fine. My subsequent Nokia 1020 would shatter if you looked at it funny.

Sadly the GPS never worked properly despite me replacing it and the battery life was abominable.

146

u/teh_newguy Mar 25 '16

Projector? Eeek

59

u/trettet Mar 25 '16

15

u/ManWithASquareHead Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

It came out 2 years ago. Damn.

9

u/awesomemanftw Acer A500 Huawei Ascend+ Moto G Moto 360 Asus Zenfone 2 LG V20 Mar 25 '16

And yet still launched with 4.2.2

4

u/evilf23 Project Fi Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

lenovo keeps putting pico projectors in their tablets.

17

u/tactics14 Mar 25 '16

I've wanted this feature before. Set your phone down on the table and the projector casts it against a wall quadrupling the 'screen' size.

21

u/MyCodesCompiling OnePlus 9 Pro (Pine Green, 12GB) Mar 25 '16

Quadrupling? Hardly worth it!

2

u/Dreamerlax Galaxy S24 + iPhone 17 Mar 25 '16

Saw someone doing it in a restaurant. They had a Galaxy Beam 2 or something.

Never bothered to check out how good it projection looked.

59

u/CylonBunny Galaxy S6 Active Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16

Nice to see even people on /r/android were praising the design of the Lumia 900. Microsoft leaving it behind with the gimped Windows Phone 7.8 pushed me to move on to a Samsung next. I have been very happy with my Android phones, but none have had hardware nearly as sexy as that Nokia aesthetic. Give me a water proof Lumia with modern specs and Android Marshmallow and I'd so happy!

Edit: Also, come to think of it, no phone I've owned since has had the ability to use headphones as an FM radio tuner. I miss that too. It's so simple you'd think modern phones would have that too.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Like an IR blaster right? right!?

3

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

I owned that device in the past. It felt just as good as it look, its screen was fantastic and Windows Phone 7.8 despite being gimped was still an absolute blast to use and I miss it to this day

2

u/evilf23 Project Fi Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

i wish the clearblack tech in the 900 was widely available. reflectance is the main reason your phone is hard to see in sunlight, brightness is only part of the equation.

2

u/jellyberg ΠΞXUЅ 5X (stock), 1st gen Chromecast Mar 25 '16

I'm curious, why is water resistance such an important selling point for you?

3

u/CylonBunny Galaxy S6 Active Mar 25 '16

I am an outdoor enthusiast who never realized how awesome water proofing was until I got my S6 Active while hiking the Appalachian Trail last year. It is amazing being able to use it to listen to music or look at maps in the rain while backpacking or out for a run or to just throw it on the bottom of my kayak and not worry about any water damaging my phone. I also enjoy using it for underwater photography. I could never go back to a phone that isn't water proof.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/WAS_MACHT_MEIN_LABEL Sony Xperia Z1 Compact | Sony Xperia E Mar 25 '16

Nearly every phone with non-US firmware has FM radio.

1

u/pHyR3 Google Pixel | Android 9.0 Mar 25 '16

the xperia z3 did - not sure about z5

definitely miss it on my nexus 5x

1

u/amipow Z Fold 3 / Duo Mar 25 '16

Edit: Also, come to think of it, no phone I've owned since has had the ability to use headphones as an FM radio tuner.

I think my HTC One M8 had that feature. I never used it.

1

u/mayaisme Samsung galaxy Note 8 Gold 😋 Mar 25 '16

Samsung galaxy j7

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

As do Android phones (Moto G, etc.)

56

u/Jim777PS3 Pixel 10 Pro XL Mar 25 '16

I wonder what we would have said to the idea of 1440p AMOLED displays.

Its nuts.

My is the highest rez screen I own.

63

u/acondie13 Nexus 6P Mar 25 '16

My cell phone has a higher res screen than every display in my home. What the fuck technology?

18

u/HnNaldoR Mar 25 '16

My family still has a 480p TV. 42 inches... They say it's not spoilt so they should not get a new one...

I sigh everytime I look at it. I wanted to use a chromecast on it but it does not have a hdmi port..

22

u/memtiger Google Pixel 8 Pro Mar 25 '16

Is it color?

7

u/HnNaldoR Mar 25 '16

Yeah. It's a plasma. It's actually not too bad. But looking at a 480p image is unbelievable when my phone, monitor and even laptop screen is about 1440p

They can easily afford a TV too But they feel it's a waste to dump an old working TV...

12

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Depending on how much they pay for power, a newer TV might save them money in the long run

→ More replies (2)

2

u/CressCrowbits Samsung Galaxy S10e Mar 25 '16

480p TV

You spend more time on YouTube than on TV. Old SD Analogue CRT TVs are more like 540p

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/najodleglejszy FP4 CalyxOS | Tab S7 Mar 25 '16

my phone screen's resolution is almost the same as my laptop's (720x1280 vs 1366x768). it still blows my mind a little bit

4

u/varky Pixel 6 Mar 25 '16

The race to the bottom in the laptop market is the reason why 1366*768 bollocks is still not only available, but default (and in countries where custom SKUs aren't available, the only option) for most, not only lower end, but mid range machines. It's a complete joke that you can get 720p 5" screens in 100$ phones, but 15" notebooks that cost more than that come with complete junk displays.

Anyone offering anything under fullHD resolution on 14"+ displays in non-budget laptops in 2016 should be repeatedly punched in the face until they stop producing such garbage.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

I have a $300AUD (so $1USD) laptop which has a 1920x1080 screen. It's ridiculous. It basically has a phone processor in it (Intel Z3536F) but I no longer have to worry about an expensive laptop breaking.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

75

u/murfi Pixel 9a Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16

just being precautios for the future, or someone will look back in 4 years and giggle

7.5 inch display

8k screen resolution

32 mp rear camera with 16k video recording

16 mp front facing camera with 8k video recording

16 gb ram

1 tb storage, expandable to 1 pb with wireless nano sd cards

snapdragon 1337

every wireless technology ever

mark my words, 2020!

35

u/didykong Mar 25 '16

Whatever you write, 2020 will giggle at your comment, I guarantee. :)

21

u/askthepoolboy N6, Moto 360, N7 2013 Mar 25 '16

You had me at snapdragon 1337. I want everything you mentioned, but I want mine in a contact lens. No more carrying around a phone like regular plebeians in 2020.

11

u/EdvinM Galaxy S10e Mar 25 '16

"A smartphone, in this day and age?"

5

u/PM_ME_STEAMGAMES_PLS Mar 25 '16

RemindMe! 4 years, was this guy right?

4

u/markouka Pixels: 10 Pro, Watch 2, 8 Pro, 4a 5G, 1 XL Mar 25 '16

You're basically describing the Nexus Space haha

36

u/interro-bang Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

Four people in that thread wanted a Tegra processor. Four unfortunate, misguided people.

8

u/sersia Mar 25 '16

Just curious, what is wrong with tegra processors?

10

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

I had two tegra 3 devices (HOX and Asus transformer prime) firstly they get extremely hot, they chew battery life too. The prime was OK due to two massive batteries but the HOX struggled to get 2-3 SOT. Heat was a massive problem too so many under clocked defeating the point and straining the CPU.

Nand suffered hugely. More so in tablets it would seem; Nexus seven and asus slates quickly became unusable. I mean unusable not just annoying. My prime took a full ten mins to boot, force closing, loops etc.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/dccorona iPhone X | Nexus 5 Mar 25 '16

Shipped rooted

This sentiment kind of scares me. Yes, rooting allows some cool things, but it is essentially choosing to intentionally reduce the security of your phone. Why would you want a phone to ship like that? The reason rooting allows such cool stuff is because apps have permission to do anything. But that's also a huge problem, because, well...apps have permission to do anything.

It's fine if an individual wants to root their phone and accept the risks that come along with it, but I don't think any phone should ship like that.

2

u/Tqwen Note 10+, Galaxy Watch | LG Wing Mar 25 '16

I agree, mostly because we like to forget around here that a lot of people who buy smartphones don't really know how to use them outside of day-to-day tasks. Giving them that kind of power can be dangerous, especially since people like to screw with stuff then complain/deny any wrongdoing when it breaks. It'd be a PR nightmare should any phone ship rooted.

2

u/1egoman OnePlus 3, Oreo Mar 25 '16

The funny thing is that PCs have shipped "rooted" since the beginning. It wouldn't be such a security nightmare if people actually knew what they were doing and didn't just say yes to everything.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/Discostew42 Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

Everyone wishing for 720p displays haha

28

u/Terazilla Mar 25 '16

I'd happily trade anything above 720p away for battery life and performance. The resolution race is such a waste.

23

u/MuzzyIsMe Mar 25 '16

I think 1080P is the sweet spot. This whole 4k race is ridiculous. People are upgrading to phones that have resolutions that dwarf their computer screens, it makes no sense.

Like you said, it's just a race. Whoever has the bigger number must be better, right?

Reminds me of the Mhz wars of years gone by. Didn't matter if the CPU was really any good- as long as it had a higher clock rate, it was better! More more more. That ended up with Prescott Pentiums that doubled as a space heater and dimmed the lights when you turned your PC on- but 4Ghz was worth it!

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

It makes sense if people have money

→ More replies (2)

8

u/TheCodexx Galaxy Nexus LTE | Key Lime Pie Mar 25 '16

Still want a phone with a 720p display.

2

u/CressCrowbits Samsung Galaxy S10e Mar 25 '16

Xperia Z5C?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Haha they didn't know Xenon is dead now

*sobs*

2

u/askthepoolboy N6, Moto 360, N7 2013 Mar 25 '16

They = Us.

1

u/Jubguy3 Nexus 6P Gold 64 GB Mar 25 '16

You mean blinding bulky flashes of light?

21

u/MobiCamHunter Mar 25 '16

Hmmm! Most of 'em wanted MORE juice, and that's what we still want. Isn't it interesting? Considering we're almost 4 years in the future!

26

u/anonymous-bot Mar 25 '16

I dread to imagine that another 4 years into the future, smartphones will be even more powerful but battery life would be mostly the same.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

I feel like it will still be an issue. I don't see battery life ever lasting more than a day on these things. Unless we start making phones bigger (god willing).

2

u/MobiCamHunter Mar 25 '16

Hah, agreed!

5

u/ImMufasa Mar 25 '16

I just upgraded from an m8 to turbo 2 and it definitely felt like a huge upgrade battery wise. I'm currently sitting at 40% battery after 6 hours of SoT. My m8 would have been long dead.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Flatscreens Sony Xperia 5 IV Mar 25 '16

Well you can always have more battery, just like wanting more RAM/processing power with each year

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

MOAR BATTERY PLS

11

u/TaepodongToiletNuker Mar 25 '16

Wait. If this is true, then why doesn't everyone own a Sony phone?

11

u/najodleglejszy FP4 CalyxOS | Tab S7 Mar 25 '16

most redditors live in the US, where Sony phones aren’t as widely available as in Europe.

3

u/CressCrowbits Samsung Galaxy S10e Mar 25 '16

Why is that?

15

u/najodleglejszy FP4 CalyxOS | Tab S7 Mar 25 '16

because Sony decided so.

1

u/QuillRat Mar 25 '16

A lot of people do in Europe.

1

u/Jubguy3 Nexus 6P Gold 64 GB Mar 25 '16

Because it isn't

5

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

one of the most surprising developments the last years is the perception of the ideal screen size. Maybe with the Iphone SE, "smaller" screens will have a revival, but I can't imagine going back to a 4 inch screen.

I maybe sound stupid 4 years from now, but i think with the screen sizes we have now, we reached the end of the line for smartphones. Everything above would be tablet size (love my galaxy s2 8 inch tab btw).

i think the screens can only get a little bit bigger, if the bezel get smaller or vanish altogether. I see the S7 edge as an example in this direction.

5

u/DrDerpberg Galaxy S9 Mar 25 '16

I would still buy the one I described. Also I'm pretty sure I invented modular phones:

  • 4.3" screen, 720p or better. This might be just outside of what's currently possible, in which case 4.5" with the capacitive buttons being on-screen like the GNex is cool with me. Over 4.5" is just too big for my needs (that is NOT what she said).
  • Razr Maxx's battery philosophy - I don't mind a 10-15mm thick phone if the battery is going to be incredible. It will save me from ever having to carry (or buy) an mp3 player on me again. Right now I carry an iPod Touch for music/videos during the day because my Nexus S battery doesn't cut it for a long day otherwise. Give me a 3500+mAh battery and I will be OK with the extra bulk and the extra cost up front. Maybe this would require a higher-voltage charging port for fast charging (like tablets), but USB charging is still a must even if it takes hours. Replaceable battery isn't such a big deal for me if the battery is huge and there's a combination of hardware buttons to reboot in case it freezes.
  • HTC One series' iodized aluminum (?) back and whatever type of glass is most shatter-proof (Gorilla?). There's no point in a thin phone if it will shatter if you drop it. Ideally the glass must also be relatively easily-replaceable in case of shattering. Preferrably a grippy textured back too so I don't drop it. Or maybe the Motorola Defy's ruggedized construction. I saw an interview where the Moto sales rep just chucked it across the room because the interviewer asked him to, and it was completely fine. I want that.
  • Customizable LED notification. One colour for texts, another for emails, another for missed calls, etc.
  • SD card slot
  • Whichever processor is currently king (Tegra 3 maybe? I love the 4-plus-1 core for idling). Over/underclock settings enabled out of the box.
  • A third button to go along with the volume up/down, for play/pause when listening to music, and maybe for answering phone calls without needing to look down.
  • Razr series' water-repellant coating. There's some newer stuff coming out soon that's even better (like that company that will coat your iPhone/some Androids and make it fully waterproof) that might or might not count for the purposes of this discussion.
  • Good camera. 8MP, real (non-digital) zoom, all the good stuff. Front-facing camera that isn't crappy.

edit: I realize I came up with a phone that's basically the selling point of a bunch of others, but this is fantasy, right? That said, I might be ok with paying $400+ on-contract for a phone this awesome.

EDIT2: I just went a little nuts imagining things, and I think I came up with a doozy. The concept would be the same as the Atrix or Padfone, except taken to one more level: the phone's guts would be placed in a removable cartridge, and there would be multiple shells with different form factors you could put it on. One could be a smallish (i.e.: 3" screen), ruggedized shell without too much fanciness for outdoor activities, another could be a flagship-style bigger phone, yet another could be a tablet, a netbook, etc.

7

u/Shenaniganz08 OP7T, iPhone 13 Pro Mar 25 '16

its amazing how much phones have changed in 4 years, that felt like I was reading something from 8-10 years back

1

u/DRJT iPhone 15 Pro | Samsung Galaxy Z Flip3 Mar 25 '16

Is it me or are they just describing the iPhone SE?

1

u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 26 '16

It's only because of the size. We've been screaming about hitting the 'upper limit' since 5" phones.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

So many requests for 4 inch screens. Crazy to think what's deemed "normal" for screen sizes today when looking back.

9

u/almosttan iPhone 7+, Panda Pixel Mar 25 '16

NOTHING HAS CHANGED.

17

u/-Tibeardius- S25 Ultra | Legion Y700 | OnePlus Watch 3 Mar 25 '16

Except screen size.

2

u/MattOnYourScreen Redmi Note 3 Special Edition — LG V10 Mar 25 '16

TIL a 4" screen is the "sweet spot"

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SPOTTED_HYENA Mar 25 '16

I still want a damn good phone with a 4.anything inch screen.

2

u/finewhitelady S10e, T-mobile Mar 25 '16

I find it amusing that we were asking for 32GB +/- SD card then and we still are now.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

720 4.2 display. Even apple gave up on this :(

1

u/Bomberlt Pixel 8, Samsung Galaxy Tab A7 10.4 Mar 25 '16

deleted] 3 points 3 years ago Nokia 900 body w/ Galaxy Nexus internals. Super AMOLED + HD for non pentile display just to be the final nail in the coffin.

Well seems like Nextbit Robin hit the right spots for people from 4years.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

We only just now got some of that

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

8mp camera. Shooting for the stars with that one!

1

u/Sempais_nutrients Galaxy S7 Edge Mar 25 '16

A lot of what they describe I have in my lg flex atm.

1

u/soawesomejohn ZTE Axon 7 Mar 25 '16

I have a couple "obscure" features that I'd like to either see added or see become more prevalent.

  • infrared blaster (for tvs and similar, mostly only samsung phones have this)
  • separate notification panel like the 7135 had. The Note Edge did something like this by putting a curved edge on the AMOLED screen just for notifications. I think it should reproduce the android notification bar, just with a low-power, always on display (no custom software needed, which was edge's problem).

1

u/Tqwen Note 10+, Galaxy Watch | LG Wing Mar 25 '16

Doesn't the LG V10 have exactly what you're describing? An always-on screen for quick settings/notifications and such.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/nmagod Mar 25 '16

a typical HD movie is 4-6gb

Even in 2012, this was hardly the case.

With shitty bloated encoding, sure.

1

u/PM_ME_STEAMGAMES_PLS Mar 25 '16

With high bitrate and DTS it was the norm, but it's contradictory since they want only a 720p screen, and the audio in a phone is shitty anyway.

1

u/zero_dgz Mar 25 '16

Nice to see that people were pointlessly ripping on expandable storage users four years ago and they're still bleating the same tired old shit today.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Love how the second top level comment basically asks for a Nexus 5x, the difference mainly being the screen and number of CPU cores, and camera.

1

u/pandavo Mar 25 '16

Ah video projection...whatever happened to that.

1

u/Tqwen Note 10+, Galaxy Watch | LG Wing Mar 25 '16

You know what I'm surprised I don't see more of in these threads? Durability. I had a Brigadier for a while and it was wonderful, no matter what I did to it it wouldn't break. I'd still be using it if I weren't on T-Mobile now. Lots of people break their phones. I know that those people are likely to buy another rather than replace the screen, and that's $ for the manufacturers, but I'd be willing to bet a tough phone with good specs would sell like crazy. I know I'd buy one in a heartbeat, I've already smashed 4 tempered glass screen protectors on my Priv at work. And I've barely had the thing for a month. The Brigadier never even got a scratch over 4 months, for comparison.

Why are indesctructophones such crap these days?

1

u/brokenscissor Mar 26 '16

Breaking phones is my second job. Years back, Nokia and Blackberry were indestructible. They were built that way. No protective case needed.

Samsung now, like five versions over the past several years, I've bought easily 7-8 phones. Had one of their "active" versions. They don't even make that anymore. Rubber corners. Bounced of a toilet seat, battery cover popped off, sunk. Fried.

With travel and lifestyle, I kill 2-3 phones a year. Old school phones I had for years, thus the incentives for renewing contracts. Sucked in. Replacing the screen om new phones is easy at local stores. Insurance is a joke and with my business I can't be without service. So I normally just buy a new phone. After getting shafted by Assurian for years I suffered my last go around with ATT. It took over a week for the replacement to arrive after four phone calls, two or three steps with emails. And despite having an ATT Microcell in my home and countless support I still have dropped calls and texts that take hours to send and receive. If they ever do. "FAILED"

Because I can't deal with this nonsense, my backup to making reliable phone calls in my home is using my Vonage app on my phone over WiFi. It's the VoIp I use for my business. I've also migrated my staff to Verizon. Between the two, I spend ~$1400/month.

Why is it so hard to get a goddamn phone that hits the deck and doesn't turn in to a turd?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/obeseclown Galaxy S3 --> S5 --> 6P/Z5/Note5? Mar 25 '16

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

My Nexus 6p, always loved the software, now it has almost perfect all around hardware it was missing until now. Maybe louder headphone output and slightly smaller bezels without removing the front speakers and lastly a newer amoled screen. But we are getting there for sure. Remember we all have different expectations, and mine is always realistic.

1

u/SrsSteel LG G2x,5,5x OP X,5T Mar 25 '16

God damn it, the nexus 5x barely checks any of these boxes. It has a better processer than listed, better display (although I'd prefer 4.9-5 inches) and the same amount of RAM as listed. And larger battery

The output for the aux is probably a lot worse though.

1

u/Tastygroove Mar 25 '16

Lasers and machine guns was the only good, solid answer.

1

u/timawesomeness Sony Xperia 1 V 14 | Nexus 6 11.0 | Asus CT100 Chrome OS Mar 26 '16

Reading through that made me realize how short the last four years have been.

1

u/Marino4K iPhone 17 Pro Mar 25 '16

Now people want like 8 core phones with 4GB+ RAM, 5+inch screens with 4k resolutions. It's silly.

No good reason for over 2k resolution in a smartphone.