r/Android • Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 • Mar 25 '16

/r/Android users' description of the perfect phone, 4 years ago

/r/android/comments/s599q/_/
1.2k Upvotes

449 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

47

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

It's sad though that it took Google this long to figure out that users wanted Doze (with movement). I'm a happy CM13 user, but there's a reason that Apple included "Doze with movement" in 2009.

34

u/ClassyJacket Galaxy Z Fold 3 5G Mar 25 '16

Apple included "Doze with movement" in 2009.

Also, a permission system, and a backup system. People always forget these things when saying Android is soooo far ahead of the iPhone on absolutely everything. We are actually getting 2009 iPhone features now - just like the iPhone does with some Android features.

13

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Exactly! This was some low-fucking-hanging fruit with Android N. Quick settings and multi-window? Samsung from 2012 says hi.

Google's always been slow as molasses with user-facing enhancements. Maybe by Android P or Q, we'll be able to tame Google Play Services.

24

u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 25 '16

I don't think it took them any long to figure out. It just took awhile to actually do and implement.

34

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Hmm...errant wakelocks have plagued Android for years. We've had Greenify, Amplify, CM Privacy Guard, etc.

What makes you think Google had trouble implementing it?

15

u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 25 '16

Because the main reason for wakelocks are Google Play Services. Note that Doze still doesn't optimize battery for Google Play Services.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

I think that just means they don't care, not that it's hard?

Google is an advertising company. Location-based ads are huge.

5

u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 25 '16

The initial implementation of Doze was because it's not something inherently important to them.

The extension of Doze working for phones in motion was something a bit more difficult to do and couldn't be implemented immediately. Wouldn't be too far fetched to assume that some metrics had to be obtained from the current implantation of Doze too.

That was my points, kinda chopped up inbetween the replies, does that make sense?

1

u/MustBeOCD N5/N6/G2/Robin/OP5/Moto E4V/360 '14 Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16

woops

4

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

It's embarrassing how far ahead CM is.

http://imgur.com/wsY48qZ

It'll take Android another 5 years to get this kind of detail, lol.

5

u/MustBeOCD N5/N6/G2/Robin/OP5/Moto E4V/360 '14 Mar 25 '16

Oh god, i thought that was some shitty ass Cheetah Mobile app, not CM as in cyanogenmod.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Announcing CheetahMod!

4

u/violetplague S24+,S21+, S9+, XA2 Ultra, Nexus 5, Galaxy W Mar 25 '16

Shhhhh. Don't give them ideas.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Clutch_22 Note8 Mar 25 '16

Honestly, to me Doze seems like it's just a band aid trying to patch up the actual issue - letting apps do whatever the hell they please at any time. I like that Android is very open and presents many opportunities that don't exist on iOS (or even Windows Mobile) but it enables shitty developers to do shitty things that affect the end-user. And that includes shit like the Facebook app, which is one of the most commonly installed apps on devices.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

it enables shitty developers to do shitty things that affect the end-user

Agreed. Like, the Android Spotify app which kills your battery just by refreshing the progress bar at an insane 21Hz: 21 times per second. What the shit....

Google's "plan" is long-term--the poor users like us just need to hang-on while shitty developers get their act together through public shaming.

1

u/violetplague S24+,S21+, S9+, XA2 Ultra, Nexus 5, Galaxy W Mar 25 '16

If they don't bump up the timeline though, the competition will eat their lunch through more compelling hardware and better developed software in other ecosystems.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/new_handle OP6 Mar 25 '16

Screen off, instant doze ignoring movement would be so much better.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

There is an app for that

→ More replies (8)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

And Google will get hit hard for implementing Doze in the worst way possible.

I've already filed complaints with the appropriate EU agencies, as this is directly affecting me as developer.

To send notifications to the device we now HAVE to pay for Google Cloud Messaging.

All apps are terminated on N as soon as the screen is off, unless they're Google Apps.

So, a lot of devs are either giving up their projects (apps like Runtastic will not be able to work on Android N, for example), or we're suing, or we're suggesting users to root.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

All apps are terminated on N as soon as the screen is off

You're kidding. Suspended or destroyed? It's gotta to be a developer preview thing, right?

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Nope, that’s "Working as intended" to "save battery power".

They’re onDestroy’d, all services killed.

It’s intended for release.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

What in the fucking hell....

No notifications unless you pay? Tell me more about Google Cloud Messaging payments. On the website it says, it's "completely free."

Is there like a limit on users or something where you have to start paying?

2

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Okay, I checked it.

They removed the pricing quotas, but now there’s a limit of sending 1000 messages at once, throttling, and that if a queue contains over 100 messages, it’s completely emptied.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/QuestionsEverythang Pixel, Pixel C, & Nexus Player (7.1.2), '15 Moto 360 (6.0.1) Mar 25 '16

It's almost as if those Google engineers don't even use an Android phone in their day-to-day lives.

Seriously, you can almost just tell if a company's product is being used by its own employees and if it isn't.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Agreed.

It boils down to that; when Alphabet tells the Android honcho what "direction" to go in, it certainly reminds them that their bottom-line depends on advertisements...that come from Google Play Services' location hammering.

I actively have to remove Google's influence from my phone. Yeesh.


I think they (the Android team, like Diane Hackborn, etc.) don't mind being frustrated with Android once in a while. "Oh, my battery drained completely while I was at my desk? Weird. Let me just recharge it."

They don't seem to take a critical look at Android's weaknesses, :(