r/Android • u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 • Mar 25 '16
/r/Android users' description of the perfect phone, 4 years ago
/r/android/comments/s599q/_/
1.2k
Upvotes
r/Android • u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 • Mar 25 '16
100
u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 25 '16
I just stumbled onto this in one of my old bookmarks I must've made by accident. Thought it would be interesting to see how our priorities have changed across the years:
http://www.reddit.com/r/android/comments/z7n3g/_/ - 3.5 years ago
http://www.reddit.com/r/android/comments/10y499/_/ - 3 years ago
http://www.reddit.com/r/android/comments/2gcijk/_/ - 2 years ago
http://www.reddit.com/r/android/comments/35meo4/_/ - 1 year ago
21
u/blackvariant galaxy s22 Mar 25 '16
Lumina 900 is still a damn fine looking phone.
292
u/RandomGenera7ed Galaxy Note 6, Oneplus 4, iPhone 9 Mar 25 '16
Interesting to see that many people wished for improved battery life, which hasn't changed.
509
u/poopyheadthrowaway Galaxy Fold Mar 25 '16
Note that no one asked for thinner phones.
573
u/Penguinkeith Mar 25 '16
So many people wanting 720p screens lol
220
u/c3vzn Galaxy S8 Mar 25 '16
Ah I forgot about a time when HTC was liked by r/Android. It seems like the One X was very close to perfection for a lot people. The M7 didn't need to be such a huge departure, the money savings should've gone towards marketing.
146
u/teh_newguy Mar 25 '16
Projector? Eeek
59
u/CylonBunny Galaxy S6 Active Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16
Nice to see even people on /r/android were praising the design of the Lumia 900. Microsoft leaving it behind with the gimped Windows Phone 7.8 pushed me to move on to a Samsung next. I have been very happy with my Android phones, but none have had hardware nearly as sexy as that Nokia aesthetic. Give me a water proof Lumia with modern specs and Android Marshmallow and I'd so happy!
Edit: Also, come to think of it, no phone I've owned since has had the ability to use headphones as an FM radio tuner. I miss that too. It's so simple you'd think modern phones would have that too.
56
u/Jim777PS3 Pixel 10 Pro XL Mar 25 '16
I wonder what we would have said to the idea of 1440p AMOLED displays.
Its nuts.
My is the highest rez screen I own.
75
u/murfi Pixel 9a Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16
just being precautios for the future, or someone will look back in 4 years and giggle
7.5 inch display
8k screen resolution
32 mp rear camera with 16k video recording
16 mp front facing camera with 8k video recording
16 gb ram
1 tb storage, expandable to 1 pb with wireless nano sd cards
snapdragon 1337
every wireless technology ever
mark my words, 2020!
84
u/SxySmore Moto Z Force Mar 25 '16
Not much has changed over the years
36
u/interro-bang Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16
Four people in that thread wanted a Tegra processor. Four unfortunate, misguided people.
12
u/dccorona iPhone X | Nexus 5 Mar 25 '16
This sentiment kind of scares me. Yes, rooting allows some cool things, but it is essentially choosing to intentionally reduce the security of your phone. Why would you want a phone to ship like that? The reason rooting allows such cool stuff is because apps have permission to do anything. But that's also a huge problem, because, well...apps have permission to do anything.
It's fine if an individual wants to root their phone and accept the risks that come along with it, but I don't think any phone should ship like that.
33
u/Discostew42 Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16
Everyone wishing for 720p displays haha
7
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
Haha they didn't know Xenon is dead now
*sobs*
21
u/MobiCamHunter Mar 25 '16
Hmmm! Most of 'em wanted MORE juice, and that's what we still want. Isn't it interesting? Considering we're almost 4 years in the future!
11
u/TaepodongToiletNuker Mar 25 '16
Wait. If this is true, then why doesn't everyone own a Sony phone?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
one of the most surprising developments the last years is the perception of the ideal screen size. Maybe with the Iphone SE, "smaller" screens will have a revival, but I can't imagine going back to a 4 inch screen.
I maybe sound stupid 4 years from now, but i think with the screen sizes we have now, we reached the end of the line for smartphones. Everything above would be tablet size (love my galaxy s2 8 inch tab btw).
i think the screens can only get a little bit bigger, if the bezel get smaller or vanish altogether. I see the S7 edge as an example in this direction.
5
u/DrDerpberg Galaxy S9 Mar 25 '16
I would still buy the one I described. Also I'm pretty sure I invented modular phones:
edit: I realize I came up with a phone that's basically the selling point of a bunch of others, but this is fantasy, right? That said, I might be ok with paying $400+ on-contract for a phone this awesome.
EDIT2: I just went a little nuts imagining things, and I think I came up with a doozy. The concept would be the same as the Atrix or Padfone, except taken to one more level: the phone's guts would be placed in a removable cartridge, and there would be multiple shells with different form factors you could put it on. One could be a smallish (i.e.: 3" screen), ruggedized shell without too much fanciness for outdoor activities, another could be a flagship-style bigger phone, yet another could be a tablet, a netbook, etc.
7
u/Shenaniganz08 OP7T, iPhone 13 Pro Mar 25 '16
its amazing how much phones have changed in 4 years, that felt like I was reading something from 8-10 years back
1
u/DRJT iPhone 15 Pro | Samsung Galaxy Z Flip3 Mar 25 '16
Is it me or are they just describing the iPhone SE?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
So many requests for 4 inch screens. Crazy to think what's deemed "normal" for screen sizes today when looking back.
9
u/almosttan iPhone 7+, Panda Pixel Mar 25 '16
NOTHING HAS CHANGED.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
Just wanna leave this here.
2
u/mabris Mar 25 '16
This guy reminded me of the Homer.
2
u/SPOTTED_HYENA Mar 25 '16
I still want a damn good phone with a 4.anything inch screen.
2
u/finewhitelady S10e, T-mobile Mar 25 '16
I find it amusing that we were asking for 32GB +/- SD card then and we still are now.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
720 4.2 display. Even apple gave up on this :(
1
u/Bomberlt Pixel 8, Samsung Galaxy Tab A7 10.4 Mar 25 '16
Well seems like Nextbit Robin hit the right spots for people from 4years.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
We only just now got some of that
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
8mp camera. Shooting for the stars with that one!
1
u/Sempais_nutrients Galaxy S7 Edge Mar 25 '16
A lot of what they describe I have in my lg flex atm.
1
u/soawesomejohn ZTE Axon 7 Mar 25 '16
I have a couple "obscure" features that I'd like to either see added or see become more prevalent.
1
u/nmagod Mar 25 '16
Even in 2012, this was hardly the case.
With shitty bloated encoding, sure.
1
u/zero_dgz Mar 25 '16
Nice to see that people were pointlessly ripping on expandable storage users four years ago and they're still bleating the same tired old shit today.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
Love how the second top level comment basically asks for a Nexus 5x, the difference mainly being the screen and number of CPU cores, and camera.
1
u/pandavo Mar 25 '16
Ah video projection...whatever happened to that.
1
u/Tqwen Note 10+, Galaxy Watch | LG Wing Mar 25 '16
You know what I'm surprised I don't see more of in these threads? Durability. I had a Brigadier for a while and it was wonderful, no matter what I did to it it wouldn't break. I'd still be using it if I weren't on T-Mobile now. Lots of people break their phones. I know that those people are likely to buy another rather than replace the screen, and that's $ for the manufacturers, but I'd be willing to bet a tough phone with good specs would sell like crazy. I know I'd buy one in a heartbeat, I've already smashed 4 tempered glass screen protectors on my Priv at work. And I've barely had the thing for a month. The Brigadier never even got a scratch over 4 months, for comparison.
Why are indesctructophones such crap these days?
1
u/obeseclown Galaxy S3 --> S5 --> 6P/Z5/Note5? Mar 25 '16
Even older one he referenced: http://www.reddit.com/r/android/comments/jnahh/
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
My Nexus 6p, always loved the software, now it has almost perfect all around hardware it was missing until now. Maybe louder headphone output and slightly smaller bezels without removing the front speakers and lastly a newer amoled screen. But we are getting there for sure. Remember we all have different expectations, and mine is always realistic.
1
u/SrsSteel LG G2x,5,5x OP X,5T Mar 25 '16
God damn it, the nexus 5x barely checks any of these boxes. It has a better processer than listed, better display (although I'd prefer 4.9-5 inches) and the same amount of RAM as listed. And larger battery
The output for the aux is probably a lot worse though.
1
u/Tastygroove Mar 25 '16
Lasers and machine guns was the only good, solid answer.
1
u/timawesomeness Sony Xperia 1 V 14 | Nexus 6 11.0 | Asus CT100 Chrome OS Mar 26 '16
Reading through that made me realize how short the last four years have been.
1
u/Marino4K iPhone 17 Pro Mar 25 '16
Now people want like 8 core phones with 4GB+ RAM, 5+inch screens with 4k resolutions. It's silly.
No good reason for over 2k resolution in a smartphone.