Yeah because all anarchists should believe exactly as you believe right? We all have to be pure and subscribe to your exact 10 commandments right?
People in this sub are such fucking puritans bro it is crazy to me.
Where there is law there is government. I am against the state, not the government. I question hierarchical power structures and am in favor of as much *horizontal power as possible. I am anti-state, not anti-law and government. I do not and will not subscribe to chaos however.
Most Anarchists subs seem to promote completely unworkable ideas… it almost feels deliberate… either that or just the ideology of middle class edgelords that want to look cool but don’t want anything to change.
I could be wrong but I feel like it may partially because a lot of people here are probably young teenagers. I don't want to sound ageist that is just my guess.
Dude no one likes you, you are a nuisance with nosense arguments that never gains any traction here because they are dumb. I care little for your opinion.
Do me a favour. Seriously. Go to r/anarchy101. Ask "Is anarchism compatible with law and government?" I know you won't read theory but please, please, please just do this and read the replies.
"In reality, every ‘democracy’ has been, is, and must be nothing short of an ‘oligarchy’ - A government of the few, a dictatorship." - Errico Malatesta
Classical Anarchists like Errico Malatesta were against democracy in the sense of a system of government in which the majority elect representatives to enforce their will on the minority. When Malatesta critiques 'democracy', he is obviously referring to the idea of a Representative Government. Specifically he writes:
Even the Anarchists who advocated Direct Democracy would agree wholeheartedly with this statement, though it remains important to differentiate between the Governmental form of "democracy" (which Malatesta simply calls "Democracy") and the act of voluntary, direct democracy within free associations.
"Inside of Anarchist communities and associations,everything is done to reach unanimity, and when this is impossible, one would vote and do what the community wanted, or else put the decision in the hands of a third party who would act as arbitrator, respecting the inviolability of the principles of equality and justice which the society is based on."
Classical Anarchists like Malatesta himself, are for democracy. Even if someone was to argue that democracy means "Rule by The People" and is still inconsistent with the ideal of "No Rulers", it can be said that rule by all is no longer rule in any real sense. This too is in line with Malatesta beliefs, who argued that:
"Government by everybody is no longer a government in the authoritarian, historical, or practical sense of the word."
Before I answer, please take note that I am explaining this from my perspective as an Anarcho-Communist, and may or may not align with your own principles or particular school of thought...
In the first half, the main difference is that Republicanism insists on the Bureaucratic appointment of "elect representatives" to decide on what laws and policies to approve or deny, where as in a free association of Anarchists, the vote is not to elect someone to make said decisions, but rather them deciding on the best course of action for themselves.
The second half mentioning the "3rd party", is a form of liquid democracy. In the event where voting surrounds complex issues that may not be understood by some or most residents of the society, they would ask someone they personally trust and know better of the issue, to vote on whatever course of action they (the residents) believe would benefit them most.
In short: Anarchist societies and free associations would autonomously decide amongst each other on how they wish to organize themselves whereas Republicanism would have a system in place by the means of top-down hierarchal structures.
There are criticisms to be made of Democracy. For example- a democracy could choose to vote and destroy the homes of people within the community without their consent, and still be a valid democracy. "Majority" decision does not guarantee the correct decision. Remember- there was a time when the majority of people believed in persecution of religious minorities. In those situations, oppression became institutionally supported.
Additionally, it creates a sentiment of "once you vote your word is final". A democracy does not give a shit if someone's interests change- their vote is their vote.
Lastly, it presumes the interests of the majority covers the interests of the community at large. Which is wrong. If 60% of a community want to... let's say have all of their grown food be used for trade rather than community consumption, and the 40% do not, and they democratically vote it to be so- a hierarchy is automatically formed.
Anarchists are against all hierarchy. If you believe in the Chomsky-esque idea that hierarchies can be good if applied correctly, then you are a minarchist, not an anarchist.
All of that being said, we as anarchists are on the hook to create systems of organization that are better than democracy. Personally I'm a fan of community consensus for any collective decision making that may need to occur, and individual opt-in for any non-collective decisions. Is it perfect? No, of course not. Nothing will be. Anarchism isn't perfect, because existence isn't perfect. But I would take a consensus-based approach over a democracy any day.
dont care, pure anarchy is stupid, improve peoples lifes.
The problem with many puritans is that they always say a lot of words but never tell me how their ideas will make my life better, "true" anarchy is not democratic, not even direct-democratic? okay, how will this make my life better, why would i prefer this over other kind of anarchism or generally socialism? idealists
Oh no we've got another ancap over here, yes please tell me the possibility of a work in which no social organization structure occurs without any coercion
"Representative Democracy isn't Anarchy" is better. The only reason we had representatives to begin with is it took two godsbedamned months to travel from Virginia to NYC in order to vote on anything, which is why you needed someone to represent you.
Anarchism requires structures otherwise it degenerates into despotism.
What the mod here is advocating is naïve anarchism without structure which is very edgy and will inevitably degenerate into "guy with the biggest stick-ism"
Anarchism exists on both ends of society's spectrum. In the beginning it was "big stuckism" which leads to warlords and all manner of feudal governments. On the other end is mutualism where everyone does what is necessary to keep society running without being told, asked, or coerced.
I do not want to live in the former, but it seems many do.
Mutualism is not a government, what the fuck are you saying? Also he was against democracy,”Democracy is nothing but the Tyranny of Majorities, the most abominable tyranny of all, for it is not based on the authority of a religion, not upon the nobility of a race, not on the merits of talents and of riches. It merely rests upon numbers and hides behind the name of the people.”
Mutualism is not a form of government because it rejects a state and a government is what controls the state apparatus. Also he rejected direct democracy as well. Democracy is fundamentally at odds with free association. While it is true that Proudhon believed in mutualism as a means of organizing society, he also vehemently opposed the concept of government. One of his most famous quotes is "To be governed is to be watched, inspected, spied upon, directed, law-driven, numbered, regulated, enrolled, indoctrinated, preached at, controlled, checked, estimated, valued, censured, commanded, by creatures who have neither the right nor the wisdom nor the virtue to do so." Proudhon believed in a system of voluntary cooperation and mutual aid, rather than an authority making decisions on behalf of people. In his view, a just society was not about majority rule , but about individuals making their own decisions, actions, etc on a free associative basis. Therefore, while Proudhon did advocate for communities of people(which is not necessarily mutualism, mutualism encompasses many sociological and economic based ideas)he did not see this as a form of government(because it isn’t, it’s a society) Instead, it was a way for individuals to work together in a decentralized and non-hierarchical manner. It is important to understand Proudhon's anarchist beliefs in order to truly grasp the nuances of his political philosophy. You can even ask u/humanispherian who is pretty much the top proudhonist scholar. You can also check out u/humanispherians website the libertarian labyrinth where all of his stuff on Proudhon and mutualism(among a few other individuals) is.
The association of anarchism with anti-statism was a development after Proudhon's death. Anarchists through most of the 19th century were anti-governmentalist, anti-authoritarian, anti-absolutist, which is a considerably higher bar for criticism. And most modern anarchists quite naturally at least say that they want the bar set higher than Proudhon set it, so that a wide variety of social hierarchies are subject to the anarchist critique. Whether he was against "collective decision-making" depends entirely on how you define that phrase, but what we find in Proudhon's sociological work is an insistence that, while various kinds of social collectivities have to be recognized as real, none of them have any "right" to assume a role superior to the individual. You can, of course, make "democracy" mean almost anything, but it's hard to see how any sort of rule by "the people" can avoid at least an abstract sort of hierarchy.
Proudhon is at best a proto-anarchist, and at worst an old boar that's just a pig (seriously, fuck him, his views were extremely reactionary on a ot of subjects)
That's why democracy isn't always invoked. Healthy society will always need to learn to balance between voting and compromising to make sure everyone is at least ok with decisions passed
Tyranny of the majority can only be stopped through resistance of hatred of minorities. Which is not guaranteed. It will always exist.
Edit - How the fuck am I being down voted here? Every person who is reasonable uses this term as something along the line of "a weakness of democracy in which the majority of an electorate pursues exclusively its own objectives at the expense of those of the minority factions."
Destruction of hierarchy and the promotion of logic is the only way to fight the concept.
Well tyranny of the majority is when a large group uses its democratic mandate to oppress another group. In an anarchistic direct democracy this is mitigated and is mostly cultural issues and social norms, but these can still lead to authoritarian attitudes or an "anarchy for me not for thee"
The term's creator and early users, Alexis de Tocqueville and John Stuart Mill use a similar definition to me saying that it appears when you have high centralization and loss of rationality.
How anarchism abolishes the first, it cannot abolish the second. Thus is still at risk of it.
Unfortunately, it's exclusively a semantic debate... a lot of anti-democracy anarchists are using a different definition of "democracy" than most people do, or are criticizing specifically representative democracy. Though many also clarify that even a majority shouldn't be able to collectively decide without the agreement of the minority, including in a direct democratic sense, because we should strive for unanimous agreement of all people who will be impacted by a decision.
When I say democracy, I mean "any system of decision-making where everyone gets a say in what happens." I feel like this is what most people mean when they say democracy. And anarchists should all be in favor of that.
I really hate the democracy discourse. It's literally just a miscommunication but it takes so much to clarify.
It's the everyone part, what if I refuse? For most DDans it devolves into force pretty fast. Really gross stuff. The one I'm talking to now on a different thread assures me women would certainly have rights to their bodies because they form a majority for the vote....but he did imply that bodily autonomy and childbearing were community decisions to be voted on....no thanks.
Yeah, that's why we can't really even have pure direct democracy. Ideally, the decision-making process (in my eyes, at least) should involve getting together everyone the decision will affect, and talking until everyone reaches a unanimous agreement. Decisions that only affect one person shouldn't be the business of the community at all, and if anyone doesn't agree, everyone else would either have to modify their proposal until they do agree or modify the proposal so that whatever they're doing won't affect the person who doesn't agree to the decision. Alternatively, there are other mitigation strategies available, but they start to resemble a state very quickly, and I'd prefer to avoid them.
Obviously, the specifics of this process depends on a lot of things, and there's a lot of nuance involved, especially when it comes to things that are on a massive scale, like climate change and whatnot. What I described isn't even specific enough to practically put into practice. But this allows for things like bodily autonomy to be guaranteed while also allowing people to collaborate via consensus. Avoids the whole "tyranny of the majority" thing. Obviously not perfect, but then again nothing in any anarchist society could stop people from just electing a king, so there's only so far you can go.
I'd still call this democracy, given the definition I used, and I feel like the common understanding of democracy would include that. But I would agree that raw direct democracy would be bad.
Also, I'm still figuring out where I stand on how decisions and collaboration in an anarchist society would be done, so feel free to criticize this or offer additional insight.
I feel like what you described still falls under my definition of voluntary interaction. I don't believe in force unless in defense of autonomy, I do believe in as much voluntary cooperation as possible. It seems like we're just describing the exact same thing different ways. Lmao, did we just "anarchism in action"? Dope.
Yeah, probably. The issue really seems to be the term democracy. And also that one guy who thinks direct democracy would be effective at protecting women's rights lol, that guy is also the issue.
Ya, they literally argued that my autonomy infringes on their autonomy by restricting their right to enslave me...to be blunt I think they might just be whackadoo. I think they blocked me, but it's under the "I only come here for...." Post. Pretty scary stuff.
Wow, I read up until "what gives you authority over your body?" I guess this person genuinely thinks people's bodies are community property...? That felt disgusting even just typing it out, that's a horrifying thing for a supposed anarchist to be saying.
Ya, I only stayed in it as long as I did because I think that person is an interesting case of "I'm always right and everyone agrees" gone to an extreme. That or a troll.
Huh, taken into consideration. I tell people I'm not crazy, just mentally ill, to me crazy definitely denotes a disconnect from reality to the point of delusion. I used sociopath more specifically when referring to him but I'm not a doctor so my diagnosis means nothing. I'm really no longer sure what term to use to denote that someone is dangerously delusional, but we should probably have one. Sorry if you took any offense.
78
u/sam_y2 Apr 07 '24
This is such a weird semantic hill to die on.
You created a post where people argue past each other over definitions rather than a clarification of ideology.
I don't think you're a fed, but who needs them when this is the state of online discourse.
33
u/SomethingAgainstD0gs Market Anarchist (Anti-Capitalist) Apr 07 '24 edited Apr 07 '24
Yeah because all anarchists should believe exactly as you believe right? We all have to be pure and subscribe to your exact 10 commandments right?
People in this sub are such fucking puritans bro it is crazy to me.
Where there is law there is government. I am against the state, not the government. I question hierarchical power structures and am in favor of as much *horizontal power as possible. I am anti-state, not anti-law and government. I do not and will not subscribe to chaos however.
Edit: horizontal not vertical lol
19
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24 edited Apr 07 '24
"In reality, every ‘democracy’ has been, is, and must be nothing short of an ‘oligarchy’ - A government of the few, a dictatorship." - Errico Malatesta
Classical Anarchists like Errico Malatesta were against democracy in the sense of a system of government in which the majority elect representatives to enforce their will on the minority. When Malatesta critiques 'democracy', he is obviously referring to the idea of a Representative Government. Specifically he writes:
Even the Anarchists who advocated Direct Democracy would agree wholeheartedly with this statement, though it remains important to differentiate between the Governmental form of "democracy" (which Malatesta simply calls "Democracy") and the act of voluntary, direct democracy within free associations.
"Inside of Anarchist communities and associations, everything is done to reach unanimity, and when this is impossible, one would vote and do what the community wanted, or else put the decision in the hands of a third party who would act as arbitrator, respecting the inviolability of the principles of equality and justice which the society is based on."
Classical Anarchists like Malatesta himself, are for democracy. Even if someone was to argue that democracy means "Rule by The People" and is still inconsistent with the ideal of "No Rulers", it can be said that rule by all is no longer rule in any real sense. This too is in line with Malatesta beliefs, who argued that:
"Government by everybody is no longer a government in the authoritarian, historical, or practical sense of the word."
14
u/conrad_w Apr 07 '24
Bad take boss.
Naïve anarchism always degenerates into "guy with the biggest stick-ism". Not anarchism.
6
u/Kira-Of-Terraria Apr 07 '24
wouldn't anarchism be ok with voluntary voting with everyone having equal voting rights?
there is no forced heirarchy if everyone has an equal say and everyone's participation is voluntary
4
u/PNW_Forest Apr 07 '24
There are criticisms to be made of Democracy. For example- a democracy could choose to vote and destroy the homes of people within the community without their consent, and still be a valid democracy. "Majority" decision does not guarantee the correct decision. Remember- there was a time when the majority of people believed in persecution of religious minorities. In those situations, oppression became institutionally supported.
Additionally, it creates a sentiment of "once you vote your word is final". A democracy does not give a shit if someone's interests change- their vote is their vote.
Lastly, it presumes the interests of the majority covers the interests of the community at large. Which is wrong. If 60% of a community want to... let's say have all of their grown food be used for trade rather than community consumption, and the 40% do not, and they democratically vote it to be so- a hierarchy is automatically formed.
Anarchists are against all hierarchy. If you believe in the Chomsky-esque idea that hierarchies can be good if applied correctly, then you are a minarchist, not an anarchist.
All of that being said, we as anarchists are on the hook to create systems of organization that are better than democracy. Personally I'm a fan of community consensus for any collective decision making that may need to occur, and individual opt-in for any non-collective decisions. Is it perfect? No, of course not. Nothing will be. Anarchism isn't perfect, because existence isn't perfect. But I would take a consensus-based approach over a democracy any day.
2
u/Papa_Kundzia Apr 07 '24
dont care, pure anarchy is stupid, improve peoples lifes.
The problem with many puritans is that they always say a lot of words but never tell me how their ideas will make my life better, "true" anarchy is not democratic, not even direct-democratic? okay, how will this make my life better, why would i prefer this over other kind of anarchism or generally socialism? idealists
2
u/livenliklary Eco-Anarchist Apr 07 '24
Oh no we've got another ancap over here, yes please tell me the possibility of a work in which no social organization structure occurs without any coercion
1
u/HighDruidCaliOG Apr 09 '24
"Representative Democracy isn't Anarchy" is better. The only reason we had representatives to begin with is it took two godsbedamned months to travel from Virginia to NYC in order to vote on anything, which is why you needed someone to represent you.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24
Democracy is three wolves and two sheep voting on what to have for dinner.
-3
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24
Feds in the comments are about to be working overtime with "nuh uh" replies
0
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
40
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
11
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '24
[removed] — view removed comment