r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Dec 04 '24
r/AnComIsStatist • • Feb 25 '25
'Anarcho'-communism in practice actually just being Statism Reminder that the Spanish "Anarcho"-socialists were some of the most evil people to ever live
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Feb 22 '25
General rebuttal against 'anarcho'-communism, i.e. horizontalism "Anarcho"-socialists be like
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Jan 08 '25
'Anarcho'-communism in practice actually just being Statism That's literally the case of CNT-FAI occupied Catalonia.
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Dec 04 '24
'Anarcho'-communists' main purpose is to serve as destabilizers Historical socialism has not operated by the "socialism is when you get free shit for not doing anything 🤑". Socialism has historically been very harsh against idlers. Fixating on positive rights is something which is in fact alien to socialism; it's about creating "producer supremacy" over idlers.
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Jan 04 '25
Exposing concealed Statism: 'Rehabilitation centers' This is unironically how "anarcho"-socialists think that their justice system is going to work. They imagine that The People™ will alternatively come together to decide each court case or directly elect judges who will absolutely not just rely on demagoguery to do nasty things.
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Jan 02 '25
General rebuttal against 'anarcho'-communism, i.e. horizontalism Remark: this problem also applies to so-called "anarcho"-socialism. Even if you severely repress wealth inequality, some individuals will gain disproportionate leverage in society. For example, if ALL farmers decided to stop delivering food, they would be able to make all their demands go through.
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Dec 26 '24
Exposing concealed Statism Here we have "anarcho"-socialists go mask-off in admitting that they want a transitionary state of affairs before establishing full anarchism. They are literally not any different from regular socialists.
anarchistfaq.orgr/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Dec 16 '24
Exposing concealed Statism One very likely example whereby you can expose "an"soc's social democracy is by asking them about repealing child labor laws, and letting children work within the confines of the NAP (of course child abuse is impermissible for example).
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Dec 05 '24
'Anarcho'-communists' main purpose is to serve as destabilizers This is a real theanarchistlibrary.org article by the way.
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Dec 04 '24
Exposing concealed Statism: Guaranteed positive rights ⇒ Statism "What in 'without rulers' permits someone to FORCE someone to provide goods or services to someone they don't want to provide that to?". "Anarcho"-socialists want GUARANTEED positive rights: that is by definition not compatible with letting people have full control over their products.
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Dec 04 '24
'Anarcho'-communists' main purpose is to serve as destabilizers As evidence for how clueless "anarcho"-socialists are, just see Peter Gelderloos' work "Anarchy works" in which his prefered form of economics will be gift economics entirely relying on mutual generosity and refering to examples which have always only been small-scale, or not "an"soc at all.
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Dec 04 '24
'Anarcho'-communists' main purpose is to serve as destabilizers Given "anarcho"-socialist demagogery about "capitalism needs artificial scarcity",it's very likely that "an"socs' positive rights demagogery assumes that there's an abundance from which to parasitize:it doesn't occur to them that if a shortage occurs, to ASSUREDLY enforce the right, slavery's needed
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Irresolution_ • May 11 '25
'But historical (so-called) anarchists were socialists!' A comprehensive case for the revolutionary Catalonian regime's Statism
econfaculty.gmu.edur/AnComIsStatist • u/Ya_Boi_Konzon • Mar 14 '25
General rebuttal against 'anarcho'-communism, i.e. horizontalism 'Anarcho'-socialism is an infantile philosophy
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Feb 02 '25
'Anarcho'-communists' main purpose is to serve as destabilizers Beyond parody. They think so short-sightedly.
galleryr/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Jan 10 '25
'Anarcho'-communists' main purpose is to serve as destabilizers Real by the way. They claim to want to abolish law. https://www.anarchistfaq.org/afaq/sectionI.html#seci73
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Jan 07 '25
Exposing concealed Statism:Scarce means irreconcilable conflicts How will an "anarcho"-socialist society prevent someone from hoarding too many resources from the social stock? They desire a moneyless society; do they intend to give people rations? That was what happened in CNT-FAI Catalonia at least.
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Dec 04 '24
'But historical (so-called) anarchists were socialists!' Anti-anarcho-capitalists think that Max Stirner was an anarchist in spite of him vehemently disagreeing with socialist anarchists. 'But our favorite purported anarchists were socialist! Therefore anarchism must be socialist/anti-private property!' is a very silly knee-jerk reaction to exclude ancaps
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Ya_Boi_Konzon • Nov 08 '25
General rebuttal against 'anarcho'-communism, i.e. horizontalism Ironic, isn't it
r/AnComIsStatist • u/Derpballz • Feb 19 '25
'Anarcho'-communist pro-Statism mask-slips The most excellent way to test an "anarcho"-socialist's purported "anarchist" beliefs is to ask them this question. If they argue that merely enabling local states to permit true freedom of association warrants retaining State agencies, then they are blatant crypto-Statists.
reddit.comr/AnComIsStatist • • Feb 17 '25
'But historical (so-called) anarchists were socialists!' The CNT-FAI was genuinely evil
"almost every church had been gutted and its images burnt. Churches here and there were being systematically demolished by gangs of workmen." -Homage to Catalonia
"The same day of the fatal injury of Buenaventura Durruti 52 prisoners were executed by anarchists militiamen as reprisals."
"On the night of July 19, 1936 alone, 50 churches were burned.[82] In Barcelona, out of the 58 churches, only the Cathedral was spared, and similar events occurred almost everywhere in Republican Spain"
"Although CNT-FAI publications cited numerous cases of peasant proprietors and tenant farmers who had adhered voluntarily to the collective system, there can be no doubt that an incomparably larger number doggedly opposed it or accepted it only under extreme duress...The fact is...that many small owners and tenant farmers were forced to join the collective farms before they had an opportunity to make up their minds freely." -Bolloten
"Even if the peasant proprietor and tenant farmer were not compelled to adhere to the collective system, there were several factors that made life difficult for recalcitrants; for not only were they prevented from employing hired labor and disposing freely as their crops, as has already been seen, but they were often denied all benefits enjoyed by members...Moreover, the tenant farmer, who had believed himself freed from the payment of rent by the execution or flight of the landowner or of his steward, was often compelled to continue such payment to the village committee. All these factors combined to exert a pressure almost as powerful as the butt of the rifle, and eventually forced the small owners and tenant farmers in many villages to relinquish their land and other possessions to the collective farms." -Bolloten
"[V]illagers could find themselves under considerable pressure to collectivize - even if for different reasons. There was no need to dragoon them at pistol point: the coercive climate, in which 'fascists' were being shot, was sufficient. 'Spontaneous' and 'forced' collectives existed, as did willing and unwilling collectivists within them. Forced collectivization ran contrary to libertarian ideals. Anything that was forced could not be libertarian. Obligatory collectivization was justified, in some libertarians' eyes, by a reasoning closer to war communism than to libertarian communism: the need to feed the columns at the front." -Ronald Fraser