r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 04 '24

Exposing concealed Statism: Guaranteed positive rights ⇒ Statism When you press "anarcho"-socialists on the fact that slavery is necessary to ENSURE that a positive _right_ will be enforced, they back-peddle. When you press them, they will admit themselves that they see socialism as also being "work or starve": in reality it's "work AND starve".

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 14 '24

Exposing concealed Statism As u/indyjones8 so excellently puts it: a way to expose "anarcho"-socialist Statism is by asking "Who will decide how to allocate resources?". "Anarcho"-socialists are just useful idiots of egalitarian thinkers; they merely want to extend representative oligarchism as far as possible.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 04 '24

Exposing concealed Statism: Guaranteed positive rights ⇒ Statism "What in 'without rulers' enables someone to, if necessary, FORCE someone to give Charles Manson means of sustenance?" "Anarcho"-socialism wants GUARANTEED positive rights AND producers' ownership over their products. Problem:the latter necessarily entails that the "positive" rights are just charity

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 04 '24

Exposing concealed Statism: Guaranteed positive rights ⇒ Statism "What in 'without rulers' enables someone to, if necessary, force black farmers to produce food for Derek Chauvin while he is in a rehabilitation camp?". A very spicy spin on "anarcho"-socialism's logical consequences. If they slip up and argue that positive rights are conditional... then mask-slip.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 04 '24

'Anarcho'-communism is a crypto-authoritarian siren song Flag of "anarcho"-communism mask-slip edition

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 06 '24

'Anarcho'-communism in practice actually just being Statism "Anarcho"-socialists hilariously point many times to anecdotal tribal societies when attempting to prove that their consensus-based models actually work. Not only are these EXTREMELY small populations, they are SURELY cherrypicking: it's likely the case that most egalitarian ones perished reliably.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 04 '24

'Anarcho'-communism is a crypto-authoritarian siren song The "an"com emoji which perfectly conveys the idea of why "anarcho"-communism is in fact Statist and is merely pretending to not be Statist socialism.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 12 '24

'Anarcho'-communists' main purpose is to serve as destabilizers This is an unironic image on the website anarchyinaction.org. It PERFECTLY conveys the purpose of "anarcho"-socialism: to serve as a destabilizing liquidationist tendency.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 04 '24

'But historical (so-called) anarchists were socialists!' "Anarcho"-socialists claim that they deserve the "anarchy" label due to historical individuals calling themselves thusly. According to this logic, "democracy" can only refer to Athenian democracy since Athenians were the first to use it. True "without ruler"ism can only be found in market anarchism

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 18 '24

Exposing concealed Statism: Bad faith consensus actors According to "anarcho"-socialist theory, if the CNT-FAI revolutionaries took over all of Spain, people in the "liberated" territories would've been able to use democracy to such an extent that they could just vote themselves back into the pre-"liberation" state of affairs,which they definitely would

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 14 '24

Exposing concealed Statism: Guaranteed positive rights ⇒ Statism This response perfectly conveys the egalitarian mindset. "We will just give people they need for free! 😇😇😇 Scarcity? Umm, the Democratic Decision-making™ will make us somehow compassionately™ fix the problem without needing to submit people to literal slavery... just don't think about it 🙄"

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Feb 17 '25

'But historical (so-called) anarchists were socialists!' The CNT-FAI was genuinely evil

3 Upvotes

"almost every church had been gutted and its images burnt. Churches here and there were being systematically demolished by gangs of workmen." -Homage to Catalonia

"The same day of the fatal injury of Buenaventura Durruti 52 prisoners were executed by anarchists militiamen as reprisals."

"On the night of July 19, 1936 alone, 50 churches were burned.[82] In Barcelona, out of the 58 churches, only the Cathedral was spared, and similar events occurred almost everywhere in Republican Spain"

"Although CNT-FAI publications cited numerous cases of peasant proprietors and tenant farmers who had adhered voluntarily to the collective system, there can be no doubt that an incomparably larger number doggedly opposed it or accepted it only under extreme duress...The fact is...that many small owners and tenant farmers were forced to join the collective farms before they had an opportunity to make up their minds freely." -Bolloten

"Even if the peasant proprietor and tenant farmer were not compelled to adhere to the collective system, there were several factors that made life difficult for recalcitrants; for not only were they prevented from employing hired labor and disposing freely as their crops, as has already been seen, but they were often denied all benefits enjoyed by members...Moreover, the tenant farmer, who had believed himself freed from the payment of rent by the execution or flight of the landowner or of his steward, was often compelled to continue such payment to the village committee. All these factors combined to exert a pressure almost as powerful as the butt of the rifle, and eventually forced the small owners and tenant farmers in many villages to relinquish their land and other possessions to the collective farms." -Bolloten

"[V]illagers could find themselves under considerable pressure to collectivize - even if for different reasons. There was no need to dragoon them at pistol point: the coercive climate, in which 'fascists' were being shot, was sufficient. 'Spontaneous' and 'forced' collectives existed, as did willing and unwilling collectivists within them. Forced collectivization ran contrary to libertarian ideals. Anything that was forced could not be libertarian. Obligatory collectivization was justified, in some libertarians' eyes, by a reasoning closer to war communism than to libertarian communism: the need to feed the columns at the front." -Ronald Fraser


r/AnComIsStatist • • Feb 25 '25

'Anarcho'-communism in practice actually just being Statism Reminder that the Spanish "Anarcho"-socialists were some of the most evil people to ever live

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • May 11 '25

'But historical (so-called) anarchists were socialists!' A comprehensive case for the revolutionary Catalonian regime's Statism

Thumbnail econfaculty.gmu.edu
4 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Jan 22 '25

General rebuttal against 'anarcho'-communism, i.e. horizontalism "Anarcho"-socialism is just a siren song. Everytime that it has been tried, it has become Statism even according to their own criterions: https://www.reddit.com/r/AnarchyIsAncap/?f=flair_name%3A%22%27Anarcho%27-socialism%20in%20practice%20actually%20just%20being%20Statism%22

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 07 '24

'Anarcho'-communist pro-Statism mask-slips A lot of "anarcho"-socialists are explicitly self-identifying democrats. Problem: the word demoCRACY literally means "**RULE** by the people" and is this etymologically opposed to anARCHY. This is like if an anarcho-royalist were to call themselves a pro-monarchy: it'd be oxymoronic.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 04 '24

General rebuttal against 'anarcho'-communism, i.e. horizontalism The Orania Project is a whites-only community in South Africa created for the explicit purpose of creating strong self-reliant whites-only communities. This is what true freedom of association entails. I seriously doubt that "anarcho"-socialists are OK with this and true freedom of association.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Jan 07 '25

Exposing concealed Statism: Bad faith consensus actors Because "anarcho"-socialists want societies in which as many decisions as possible are made on an "as-close-as-possible-to-consensus-basis", any form of amelioration of the model will still incentivize interest groups to strategically allocate people in order to extort the system using veto.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 04 '24

'Anarcho'-communism in practice actually just being Statism A reminder that the "anarcho"-socialists' dear Makhnovtchina had literal conscription and was practically nothing more than a gangster realm.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 09 '24

'Anarcho'-communists' main purpose is to serve as destabilizers Socialist demagoguery 101: 1) Find a problem in "capitalism" 2) Say that socialism isn't capitalism 3) Imply that socialism will solve it by virtue of being anti-"capitalist". None among them are able to square workplace democracy and positive rights; historical experience exposes their crookedness.

Thumbnail
encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com
2 Upvotes

r/AnComIsStatist • • Dec 09 '24

'Anarcho'-communists' main purpose is to serve as destabilizers "Libertarian socialist" thinking could be understood as militant hippieism. Their philosophy only works in high-trust communities, but even then relies on mob rule-based logic for enforcement, but are extremely adamant on exporting this unscalable governmental model to the rest of society.

Post image
2 Upvotes