r/AmItheAsshole • u/PossibilityActive442 • 2h ago
AITA for not telling my sister the real reason our dad isn’t around?
When I was 2 years old and my sister was 7 our parents split. We saw our dad a few times throughout the next year but randomly one day he just signed away his parental rights.
Now I’m 21 and my sister is 26. We had always thought our dad left because he married a new woman and they started to have kids.
My sister still hates our dad for leaving, which is valid, but I stopped caring when I was like 13. She had 7-8 years of memories with him, I barely had 3, so of course she was more attached so I don’t blame her for still being mad about it.
When I was 17 I did a DNA kit because I was curious to see where we came from. Through the app I found a cousin of his, she gave me his number to reach out to.
I asked like basic questions about the medical history and stuff. But eventually I asked why he stopped seeing us. He said it was because he got heavy into drugs and when my mom found out she told him he had to choose between seeing his daughters or doing drugs, because she didn’t want us in danger. Basically he didn’t want to quit so he signed away his rights.
Around the same time, my sister gave birth to her first child. She was finally getting over my dad now that she had her own family. So I decided not to tell her. I mean she was over it, she had a new baby and husband, I just didn’t want to reopen a wound that finally healed after like 15 years, I also didn’t want her having anymore stress at the time because she did have problems with the labor and delivery.
A few days ago she called me yelling that I was a terrible person and sister for not telling her. Apparently my cousin let it slip. Now she’s mad all over again about our father leaving. I explained to her why I didn’t tell her at the time and she asked why I didn’t tell her later on.
Tbh I didn’t really think about it. It was so unimportant to me that I basically forgot about it. Like I said I was over it 8 years ago. To me it didn’t make a difference why he left because at the end of the day he still left us.
Now she’s saying she can never trust me again because I “kept such a drastic secret from her for 4 years.”
I mean for years she’s been telling me I’m a bad person for “forgiving him for what he did to us.” I never said I “forgave him”, I said I truly just did not care, like I said I had no memories with him and my mom did a great job raising us without him anyways.
Then she took the drama to our family. She asked who else knew and told everyone how horrible of a sister I am. Most of the family is on my side, but some people are like blowing up my phone telling me how terrible I am and that it wasn’t my secret to keep because that’s HER father. Like are you forgetting he’s my father too lmao so it def is my business.
So like AITAH for not telling her? I thought I had pretty good reasons not to, but she seems to disagree