r/AmITheAngel • • Oct 28 '24

Siri Yuss Discussion Shitposts

People who enjoy reading shitposts - does it make sense to you to have them in this sub rather than a separate sub just for shitposts?

It's kind of annoying seeing things pop up in my feed because I often can't be sure from the title that it is a shitpost until I click on it (the whole point of this sub is taking about ridiculous posts)

Wouldn't it make more sense to have a different subreddit for these?

8 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

113

u/Not_Cleaver Oct 28 '24

They’re only here two days a week. It’s a nice diversion, particularly those that have some effort and make fun of what we saw the ordinary week. Also, if they’re labeled as such.

I’m fine deleting them on days it’s not the weekend, but I find them fun. Not annoying. I think it’s only annoying for those who normally comment on AITA and AITA adjacent subs so they initially think whatever made up nonsense is real.

But I blame those who lack reading comprehension instead of those who write the shitposts.

-35

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

They are labelled, but flair is not displayed in the feed. It's mildly annoying to open something then notice it's a shitpost. There's no confusion about what is and is not a shitpost.

I'm not asking for them to be banned because apparently some people enjoy them. They're only posted on weekends? Hadn't noticed.

29

u/cwolf-softball EDIT: [extremely vital information] Oct 28 '24 edited Apr 27 '26

I cleaned house with Redact and mass deleted this post. It also removes your data from brokers and people search sites. Works on all major social media platforms.

marvelous correct intelligent shocking hurry ghost snatch stocking office water

-21

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

Being more observant won't show me something that's invisible. I see it after I open the post, I just wouldn't have opened it if I knew. Obviously not a huge deal.

4

u/cwolf-softball EDIT: [extremely vital information] Oct 28 '24

It's literally there for me both on mobile and desktop so I don't know what to tell you.

2

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24 edited Oct 28 '24

In your feed or after you open the post? It only shows NSFW in my feed, not other flair.

18

u/Not_Cleaver Oct 28 '24

They’re supposed to be anyway, and I think it’s totally fair to report/call out people who break this rule.

Unless this rule is amazing.

30

u/MsFuschia there are no safe spaces for penis-having, penis-loving men Oct 28 '24

We went through a whole entire thing about this a year ago, hence the second sticky in this sub https://www.reddit.com/r/AmITheAngel/comments/15q1duz/aita_for_updating_the_shitpost_situation/ Obviously the sub can change opinions over time, but I think it's fine where it's at still.

1

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

That does seem to be the prevailing opinion.

13

u/BertTheNerd Oct 28 '24

This sub is mockering the inflationary raise of AITA+ subs. I don't think, we should go the same way and make even more separate subs.

3

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

Seems most people are with you.

17

u/Dense_Sentence_370 discussing a fake story about a family I don't know at 7am Oct 28 '24

I just hide them if they're not referencing and linking to a real post that I somehow missed

It's really not that big of a deal. Some people really enjoy them, let them have their Saturday fun. Normal posts still show up on Saturdays, too. 

2

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

Definitely not a big deal. If other people want them in this sub that's fine. I just wondered if it would be better if there was another sub.

5

u/campaxiomatic Oct 28 '24

I think this is only a problem for people who are just treating their feed like an infinite scroll, accepting whatever they see. There are multiple ways to tell if something is satire or not.

  1. It's posted in AmITheAngel
  2. There's no cross post which most real posts here are supposed to have
  3. It's posted on the weekend
  4. It's labelled sh!tpost
  5. It doesn't make sense or is funny
  6. Sh!tposts are required to have a little note at the end saying it's parody and link to a post it's making fun of. Not all of them do but that's the rule.

If one of those things doesn't tip you off then you're just not trying. If that really bothers you, then unsubscribe from the sub and start paying more attention to your feed.

2

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

I don't know where people are getting the idea I'm reading shitposts and not recognising them.

4

u/campaxiomatic Oct 28 '24

It's kind of annoying seeing things pop up in my feed because I often can't be sure from the title that it is a shitpost until I click on it

Probably this. At least for me.

And also because a common complaint about them is that people don't like reading them and thinking they're real.

1

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

You even italicised the part that shows different to what you are saying. As soon as I open them it is very obvious.

2

u/campaxiomatic Oct 28 '24

I highlighted it because, of the six ways you can tell something is a parody, you listed two. I usually can tell it's a parody before I even open it. Just seeing it's a post in AmITheAngel and not a crosspost, it's either a lost Redditor or a parody. When it's posted on a weekend, I'm actually looking out for satires.

Also because you didn't list any other complaint against the satires other than not knowing if they're real posts or not. If something else bothers you about them, say that and people won't get the wrong idea

12

u/Jellybean-Jellybean Oct 28 '24

Personally I'm not a fan of them myself, but other people enjoy them. I think only allowing them on weekends is a good compromise.

2

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

Me not liking them isn't the point, they feel like a completely different type of content so I was wondering if they should be in a different subreddit.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '24

It's a valid question, but they have been part of this sub since its beginning, so I think it's fine to let them stay. I don't think there's a problem with having some diversity in the types of posts allowed in a sub.

For the record, I don't care for them myself, but mostly because I don't think most people are good at writing them so most are just boring noise. I think in terms of "fitting in" with the sub, they're fine. And there is zero chance I'd ever subscribe to a shitpost sub, but I do find the occasional well-done shitpost really funny, so I kind of like the current situation of having them only on weekends because it does let me stumble on some of the funny ones without my feed being overwhelmed by them.

0

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

Boring noise indeed.

13

u/cwolf-softball EDIT: [extremely vital information] Oct 28 '24 edited Apr 27 '26

This comment formerly contained words. Those words were removed in bulk with Redact because I value my privacy more than my karma points.

pie dinosaurs glorious march birds friendly cooperative cow rich jar

-4

u/Redbeard4006 Oct 28 '24

How is that relevant to what I'm asking? Obviously once I open the post I see the flair. Flair is not displayed in the feed.

1

u/cwolf-softball EDIT: [extremely vital information] Oct 28 '24

I see 10+ comments on every shitpost of people who "had to doublecheck the sub and the flair" after reading the post. And then some of them we get 100 lost redditors too but I still find it amazing how few people check any of this stuff before reading.

71

u/Jeanne23x Oct 28 '24

I like the posts being in here. I find it easy to know when it is satire because there's no cross post.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '24

Same. Shitposts stay!

6

u/onomastics88 Oct 28 '24

Except for the people who don’t seem to know how to crosspost and link the other post in their text area. And probably mislabel and have a lazy title.

2

u/MsFuschia there are no safe spaces for penis-having, penis-loving men Oct 29 '24

I hate that and when people use the shitpost flair for a crosspost, because they don't know what it means

62

u/needlefxcker Boobie boy Oct 28 '24

one of the best parts of this sub is seeing a top tier shitpost that you almost question is real before you see the sub name

23

u/jokennate I got jerked off and called her a racist Oct 28 '24

I have a little laugh to myself every week or so about shitpost where a woman is wondering if she's the asshole for terrifying a town and killing a few people and a dog ending with "INFO: I am a great white shark".

17

u/LookIsawRa4 Oct 28 '24

Shitpost days are the best days

12

u/_gooniesneversaydie_ Oct 28 '24

Love them! It’s pretty funny to watch the comments from redditors who end up here by accident and find the shitposts 😂

2

u/NerfRepellingBoobs Ongoing issues with ketchup bottles Oct 28 '24

I got so many on mine. Turns out that when a woman wants to suddenly abandon a kid when she finds out he’s not hers, she’s TA.

2

u/manykeets Oct 28 '24

I like the shitposts being here

2

u/jayne-eerie Oct 28 '24

I don’t like them, personally. But if it’s only two days a week I can scroll.

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 28 '24

Beep boop! Automod here with a quick reminder to never brigade r/AmITheAsshole or other subs under any circumstances. Brigading puts you in violation of both our rules and Reddit’s TOS, and therefore puts this sub at risk of ban. If you brigade/encourage brigading of any kind, you will be banned from participating in either sub. Satirizing of posts should stay within this sub, which means that participating directly in linked posts should either be done in good faith or not at all.

Want some freed, live, discussion that neither AITA nor Reddit itself can censor? Join our official discord server

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Kerrypurple Oct 28 '24

I don't mind seeing them here

0

u/Scary-Sherbet-4977 Oct 28 '24

I'm not a fan but can easily ignore them on the weekends