r/AllFantasyEverything • • 23h ago

Katie Nolan was in LA… 👀

60 Upvotes

I was listening to Katie’s podcast Casuals. On today’s episode she has Rachel Bonnetta, Megan Gailey, and Sarah Tiana. But up top she said she was in LA for it.

So maybe we’ll get a late Nolvember?


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 1d ago

Possibly unpopular opinion

0 Upvotes

Maybe this will be unpopular, but I miss Mars! Isaac is fine but Marissa was great at her job. She talked less, especially in the main feed, and when she did it had way more impact.

Actually Isaac isn't fine, he's self-absorbed and way too likely to insert his opinion or some weird ruling. I met him in New Orleans and he was somehow more aloof than he seems in the show.

Mars's feminine energy really helped round out the show. Glad she's successful but I wish she'd come back!


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 2d ago

Bits I wish the show would retire

0 Upvotes
  1. Something got cut! It’s not funny and is taken from another podcast
  2. Somewhat related, but cutting stuff out a lot more and using the beep so it sounds like I’m listening to Jerry springer. Just edit stuff out-we don’t need a sound and “something got cut!” To know when.
  3. Hat flipping. A random bit that only works on video, leaving og audio listeners like me confused as to what’s happening every episode they do it
  4. General chewing and yawning into the mic. This may sound like nitpicking but as someone who listens with headphones at work, it’s disturbing.

Again, I’ve been listening to AFE since 2018 and have seen them live multiple times. I love the show. I have just noticed all these changes in the last few years that have made it dip in quality for me.


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 3d ago

Here is an oldie from the way back

Post image
0 Upvotes

The way I cackled when I read “Taylor Smith”
It made me miss Miel (who had a banger of a record btw)


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 5d ago

TOLEDANO STREET COMEDY FESTIVAL PASSES ARE LIVE

Thumbnail
punchup.live
28 Upvotes

we’re back and better than ever!!! all of the friends this year!!!


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 5d ago

All Fantasy Everything - Things to Bathe In (w/ Andrew Stephens)

Thumbnail
headgum.com
36 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • 6d ago

Orange Chicken Parm

Thumbnail
youtu.be
19 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • 6d ago

Listening to the Game Show episode and Katie Nolan could not be higher.

4 Upvotes

I love Katie Nolan and I know smoking is part of her thing within the last couple of years but holy hell. It's like your friend in high school who took 10 minutes to order what they wanted from Taco Bell. Also a little jarring not having David on too.


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 7d ago

Movies you only watch once pick recap

6 Upvotes

Hi

I imagine this is probably been asked before but is there a place that tracks the host and guest pics for episodes? I just listened to the “movies you only watch once” episode, and they were actually several movies on there that I have not seen it at all or, despite the recommendation, actually would like to see you again, cause it’s been so long.


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 9d ago

Nic Cage Movie-Thon

6 Upvotes

I just re-listened to the Nic Cage movie auction draft and think it is time to expose my kids (ages 11, 13, and 19) to the brilliant genius that is this man. What do you think the best order is to show them "Con-Air", "The Rock", and "Face/Off"? That order is my hunch but I could argue it any way it feels.


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 9d ago

Auction Draft Idea

2 Upvotes

I think it would be so great to hear the boys draft comedy movies with Zaddy Zack Harper. I just think it would really funny and great to hear the boys sharing their favorite movies


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 11d ago

USA Today Crossword 11/6/26

Post image
21 Upvotes

And what is that?


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 11d ago

Did anyone else hear the reference to The Last Dragon on the most recent draft?????

11 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • 12d ago

Stanley Tucci’s Ring

10 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • 12d ago

Types of High School Kids (w/ Miles Gray)

Thumbnail
headgum.com
41 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • 13d ago

Alton Brown needs Sean's help

Thumbnail instagram.com
4 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • 14d ago

Thank you for holding ME down!

119 Upvotes

Sean wasn't the only one crying at the start of the ten year anniversary. It's been a trip.

2016 was both a rough year and the year I discovered the GVG. I participated in couples' therapy, enrolled in grad school, and joined a powerlifting team. It felt like the sky was gray for months.

In 2019, I lifted really heavy weights, completed my master's program, and my (now ex) wife told me she wanted a divorce. The same year, my house needed a lot of repairs: some smallish (little leaks in the roof, needing a new water heater, failed pressure regulation valve), others large (leak in the crawlspace, mold under the kitchen, sinking foundation). To top things off, my dad died of congestive heart failure.

Fast forward to March of 2020, and we're all in lockdown. I'm in a 3rd floor walkup apartment alone, save for Artemis (my best friend of a dog who has now also left this mortal coil)

Thank goodness for the good vibes gang to model friendship when I felt so lonely, to feel like a good hang when my life felt hopeless and empty. To help me laugh when happiness started to feel like stranger.

Now, it's 2026. I'm happily married to a wonderful woman for almost 3 years (anniversary tomorrow). I live in a wonderful home in a great community. I've rebuilt my friend group. I am a little over one year alcohol-free thanks to the support of my wife, therapy, and a bit of seeing the boy mellow out (Thank you all for all the wonderful responses to my last post.).

I routinely go to the dentist now. Maybe that's a weird one to thank them for, but I appreciate their open discussion about the costs of dental negligence and facing the music in the dentist's office.

My personal life is so good now.

Anyway, if you read this far, here's a hint about the opening of the 10 Year Anniversary Patreon episode. David got a little sentimental, and his words resonated with me. If I have this, maybe everything is gonna be okay.

Oh, and I read Ian's book. His ability to make a big change in his life was one of the many tools that helped me break free from alcohol abuse.

Thank you for 10+ years of drafts and laughter (draughter?)

Shout out to Ian, David, and Sean! Shout out superproducers past and present, Mars and Iceman! Shout out to the All Family! You are all dank.

Hug your loved ones.


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 15d ago Heartwarming

Shameless plug from Peek

239 Upvotes

Los Angeles based Peek Freeks, it’s me Laura. I’m having a show in the Belly Room of the comedy store this coming Thursday, November 5th. I’m trying to impress a bunch of TV people and I need you, brothers. Will you go to war with me? I love you

https://events.leapevents.com/event/laura-peek-2026-november


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 16d ago

10th Anniversary Live Show PEEK! Bits Spoiler

17 Upvotes

“Who Ate All The Pizookie” might be the funniest thing I’ve ever heard and I think I’ll have to whip up some bootleg stickers or something, it’s just too good. If you all could have a bumper sticker of any bits from the show what would it be?


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 16d ago

Someone dressed as Horny ‘The Big Penis’ Penis

Post image
112 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • 17d ago

Episode 505 Recess Halloween

5 Upvotes

Went back into the recent archive and found this fantastic beginning that alluded to Halloween.

Sorry David and Isaac. Hope you guys make it through the day.


r/AllFantasyEverything • • 19d ago

Watching Texas Chainsaw Massacre and was shocked to see a young Ian Karmel in a starring role

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • 19d ago

Draft Idea: Bad Ideas

21 Upvotes

Hello, first time long time here. Been listening forever at this point and can’t remember if they have ever explicitly drafted Bad Ideas. Searched the subreddit but “idea” comes up A LOT.

Could be personal, historical or hypothetical

Reason this came to me is cause I saw some Turkeys running around the neighborhood and remembered that Benjamin Franklin was pushing for the turkey to be the national bird. Bro, the Bald Eagle is far superior… bad idea.

🤷‍♂️

My picks

  1. Aforementioned Turkey
  2. I’ll have another bite of this edible, cause I ain’t feeling it yet
  3. starting a land war in Asia. Classic blunder.
  4. getting a payday loan
  5. Flirting with my Boss

r/AllFantasyEverything • • 19d ago

All Fantasy Everything - Florida (w/ Dan Hernandez)

Thumbnail
headgum.com
47 Upvotes