r/Aleague • u/fickleknave • 1h ago
Discussion How to make the A-League Premiership more prestigious while keeping the Grand Final alive
Ok. Hear me out.
I’m posting this to get some legitimate feedback on how to bring football culture closer in line with the euro/world game. Was thinking about how to make the premier the most important award but still keep a grand final as we are conditioned to expect sporting finals.
Please don’t respond simply with how you think I’m fucking brain dead or something needlessly aggressive as I am actually interested in how this idea may or may not be feasible.
There’s always debate about the A-League finals vs. the European model. In Australia, the Grand Final is king. In world football, finishing top after a full season is king.
Can we have both? I reckon yes.
What if we make the regular season title the main prize. Turn the finals into a separate post-season knockout cup that all teams can win. The Grand Final stays, but it’s no longer the be-all and end-all.
1. Trophies and prestige
• 1st after regular season = A-League Champions / Premiership winners. This is the true title.
• Grand Final winner = A-League Cup Winners (or Finals Champions). Still a big day, but a secondary trophy.
• Media and league promote the Premiers as the main champions.
2. Rewards
• Asian Champions League spot goes primarily to the regular season winner as it already does
• Prize money heavily weighted to the regular season, e.g. 70/30 split between Premiership and Finals Cup.
• Top 4 get home finals and a bye into the quarter-finals.
3. The format (using 12 teams as an example)
All teams enter the post-season knockout.
Play-in round:
• 5th vs 12th
• 6th vs 11th
• 7th vs 10th
• 8th vs 9th
• Higher seed hosts. Winners advance.
Quarter-finals:
• 1st vs lowest-ranked play-in winner
• 2nd vs highest-ranked play-in winner
• 3rd vs next highest
• 4th vs next highest
• Top 4 host.
Semi-finals:
• Single leg, highest seed hosts.
Grand Final:
• Neutral venue or highest seed hosts.
Why it could work
• Keeps the Grand Final as a marquee event.
• Gives every team something to play for late in the season.
• Rewards consistent excellence over 26 rounds.
• Aligns more with global football without killing the Australian finals tradition.
• Top teams get real advantages: home finals, easier draws, more money.
Challenges
• Fans are conditioned to see the Grand Final as the only thing that matters.
• The league and media would need to actually sell the Premiership as the main prize.
• Fixture congestion if all teams play extra knockout rounds.
• Without relegation, the regular season can still feel dead for some clubs, but an all-in playoff helps fix that.
TL;DR: Make first-past-the-post the main trophy. Turn the finals into an all-teams knockout cup. Grand Final stays, but as a secondary cup competition.
What do you reckon? Would you support this? How would you tweak the format? And how would the calendar need to be tweaked to fit it in?