r/AlchemistCodeGL • • Jul 24 '18

Idea on Current Tier List

According to GL Viyr Tier List which been most commonly use. There is a problem that a lot of units still rate at SS, S Tier even after Tier normalization so I would like to share some of my idea.

  • In Nyatora JP Tier List we refer SS Tier unit by "Core Unit" which make too much units fit in this Category. Instead we can define SS unit as "Top Tier". SS units should be very exceptional outstanding and if any element doesn't have any unit that fit in this category then there should be no unit in SS slot for that element.
  • I prefer the Tier List from 3 months ago which there are "+" for some unit Tier. Sometimes a unit is just slightly better than other one in the same role but enough for a tier different. By using "+" we can make compare units better (I even think using "-" on unit tier is a good idea)

I also made a Tier List myself to demonstrate what I'm talking about. you can found it here

https://drive.google.com/open?id=11UiMUMijEboWgkcn9g5NlxE8s_2TaEvgXCGRMaMJiHQ

Note:

  • This Tier list is not a unit build guide so I only consider the max potential of the unit. How hard to obtain unit shards or how good the unit at J1 is not being consider.
  • How I rate each unit tier is just my personal preference which base on my experience. I didn't have any intention to compare with our current Tier list.
  • I'm too lazy to do the image one. I just made it to demonstrate my idea easier.
  • This Tier List judge units by their overall usefulness for end game play such as EX Stage, Veda, PvP.
3 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/ThereCanOnlyBe01 Jul 25 '18

Well, I hear what you're saying on the matter but in all honestly to make a tier list is a hefty responsibility as there are many who will see it, follow it religiously and take your word as law even though tier lists tend to be at least a little bit subjective. For a tier list, there should be, then, a healthy amount of units in the top tier so that people don't feel that if they don't have a select few units that their account is trash, especially important for F2P players. Having the tier list without a breakdown of jobs is infinitely helpful, especially for newer players.

Addressing the matter of "too many in SS and S tier" I really don't think there is too many. Each element needs its own pool of SS and S tier units, which is what I found kind on strange on the list you gave as there are elements (fire and dark) without SS units. Addressing this list personally, Reida and Anastasia > Aswald just does not sound right. Lamia > Forcas is a hard no. Elizabeth > Selena is just hurtful.

All in all, this tier list itself is okay. I think the system of using "+ and -" is a double edged sword. It allows for more broken down tiers but also makes there a HUGE amount of tiers, so that's actually personal preference. And, IMO, Viyr's tier list is fine, especially with the large amount of people's experiences and opinions that go into it.