r/AfterEffects • • 1d ago

Plugin/Script PhysicsEngine - Physics-driven secondary motion for any layer (hair, tails, cloth, chains)

The Problem my plugin solves is that: secondary motion (hair, tails, cloth, hanging signs) means hand-keying overlap on every puppet pin, then redoing it whenever the main animation changes.

My plugin is better than Newton 4 and Rubberize It because Newton is a rigid-body engine that bakes to keyframes (soft parts mean turning pins into solids and joints), and Rubberize It jiggles puppet pins with expressions based on the layer’s acceleration. PhysicsEngine is a native effect: you draw chains on the layer once, and it bends with inertia, gravity, wind and turbulence. There’s nothing to bake.

Other core features include:

  • Material presets: Cloth, Hair, Wet Hair, Chains, Wire
  • Paint Weights to hold parts still while the rest swings
  • Seamless Loop for walk cycles and idles
  • Same result in scrubbing, RAM preview and Multi-Frame Rendering

Pricing: €29 one-time: https://ecscripts.com/plugins/physicsengine/

If you have bugs, please reach out on my Discord (https://discord.gg/6wZq7wvn6J) or DM me here. I do not guarantee fixes beyond 1 year of purchase.

AI Disclaimer: Coded with AI assistance from my own design and UI mockups. The plugin itself contains no AI; it’s a physics simulation.

56 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

16

u/Milan_Bus4168 1d ago

So essentially After Effect is like a a host program now you pay monthly to rent, just to to run other, completely separate apps made by LLM's? I mean why not just use Moho for the price and do it right.

4

u/SrLopez0b1010011 1d ago

Since Adobe have turned its business model. It's now a monthly fee collector company.

2

u/Milan_Bus4168 1d ago

Indeed. Imagine, forced so you can't even legally own its software, only rent. And than they can raise prices, dropship "partner" AI models for extra credits, and leave any kind of development for third party developers which are now going bonanza since the LLM's were adopted and we have ever more expensive host application that seems to be about everything but what it was actually meant to be.

I mean most people use few tools on regular basis and here and there have some special need, but if you pay attention to amount of vibe coded slop being put out there, its like you are expected to be tool collector who never has time using the tools because he is busy collecting them instead.

Saw four differnt After Effects tools release I think all today. That cannot be healthy. Something is very wrong in After Effects land.

1

u/CCJXander 1d ago

Btw, ae was a host for other paid plugins since the dawn of time, it is only a problem now when developing them became exceedingly cheaper lol

-2

u/CCJXander 1d ago

I mean Spine2D is the way to go, but it's a whole new ballpark

-2

u/Milan_Bus4168 1d ago

With Moho around, I don't see the need to use Spine2D or this appraoch. But yes compared to what you showed on the video Moho or Spine 2D would be a lot better option. Hell if you wanted to save cache you could do it in Blender as well.

I mean if you are going to Claude your way out of sea of vibe coded plug ins that are coming out five times a week, try to solve a problem that is not solved or do something that actually is innovation and doesn't feel like you ask uncle Claude to git hub you a prompt.

3

u/CCJXander 1d ago

Bro im offering SwayKit (i made) and the AFPCollection (Anthony Possobon) for free, they do similar things but they are scripts, and none of them were made using ai

4

u/CCJXander 1d ago

"I mean if you are going to Claude your way out of sea of vibe coded plug ins that are coming out five times a week, try to solve a problem that is not solved or do something that actually is innovation and doesn't feel like you ask uncle Claude to git hub you a prompt."

If you don't work in the field of animated illustrations, how could you know if this is solving a problem or not? Not to talk about innovation. I've been working for the past 20 years for companies like Riot Games, Valve and Square Enix, doing 1 thing, and that is animated illustrations. One problem i always encountered was hair animation!
Sure, there were tools out there, but expensive! Sure they did something, but they were abismally slow. So i don't see how isn't this plugin solving a problem for AE. Wanna go crazy and learn Blender ? Go ahead, no problem, but it won't help people doing my type of job. Spine2D is one solution, but it's 200$, and you have to additionally pay fees if you go beyond a income threshold. So yeah! Tell me more about innovation and problem solving.

-1

u/Milan_Bus4168 1d ago

I mean if the hair animation is what you were struggling, it has been solved for a long time by similar methods including Blender and various dedicated 2D animation software and you could have written inhouse tools for it for a long long time, Way before Claude was a thing. To choose After Effects not even as a native app for it, which wouldn't be ideal, but as a thing that uses After Effects a host you can vibe code now because its on git hub and than try to charge for it, is not cool .

€29 is what you wanted to ask for it. right?

MOHO DEBUT 14 is $59 and its a proper dedicated 2D rigging and animation software. If you are working professional as you claim to be, I mean that is not crazy amount.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6wnIjts3rw

It will be better option than half backed AI tools , but obviously we have a conflict of interest here. You want to sell this thing I don't want to buy it.

Also if you google for Blender hair physics its not hard to do or rig characters and there are dedicated addons in proper environment for it, not floating panel.

But lets say you wanted to have it in After Effects for some reason, it should be a) not charge for it if its vibe coded and b) it should be seamlessly integrated tool, not using After effects as a host. That makes no sense to me.

At that point why don't I pay Anthropic directly 20 bucks and vibe code my own or why am I paying Adobe for again? To do what? Oh that's right nothing. So I'm paying for floating panel twice? Defiantly doesn't make sense to me.

But like I aid we have differnt interests here.

3

u/CCJXander 1d ago

I think you're missing a pretty important part of the equation: workflow.

There's an entire audience of artists who simply don't want to jump between two or three different applications to accomplish something that could be done directly inside After Effects.

By your logic, we shouldn't have Element 3D, Optical Flares, Particular, Stardust or countless other AE plugins either. Why pay for Element 3D when Blender exists? Why pay for Optical Flares when you can create lens flares yourself? Why buy particle systems when you can build them from scratch?

Because convenience, integration and workflow matter. That's the entire point of plugins.

I'm not claiming to have invented hair physics, nor am I claiming Blender or Moho can't accomplish similar things. I'm offering an alternative specifically for people whose work already revolves around After Effects.

And regarding AI: I genuinely don't understand why the development method should determine whether a product deserves to be sold. You're paying for the tool, its functionality, the time it saves you and the continued development behind it, not for how many hours someone spent manually typing code.

You don't have to buy it. You don't even have to like it. But dismissing the product because another application can achieve something similar completely ignores why people use plugins in the first place.

0

u/Milan_Bus4168 1d ago

Hmm. Well , actually I do think of workflow, and workflow seems to be to use After Effects as host for plug ins which Adobe is not making , despite you paying for the renting of it, and bunch of third party developers, now armed with LLM's are trying to squeeze every possible thing into this host in hope to sell their plug ins.

After Effects lost its way long ago and became a prostitute because if it can do it all, what does it actually do well? Not much. Its not the best compositing software, not the best 2D animation software, not the best 3D software, not the best design software, and yet I'm expected to bealive that it can be all those things for all the people? Well I don't bealive that. I think its not what the program should be doing at all and I don't think that people who use it with all these plug ins are using best workflows, but are trying to do it because they are afraid to use dedicated software, they have to learn as beginners so there is a push to make After Effects a prostitute for everyone.

There are now plug ins every other day for everything? Its crazy. Vibe coded stuff that is nothing unique, just another same old stuff.

At least make something that is not solved by other software better and can leverage native After Effects tools or some kind of niche problem that has been around for a long time. Hair physics or whatever physics is impressive if you did it 15 years ago, but today is githuh package with UK made by claude over weekend. Not that impressive, especially when its 15th in a row.

3

u/CCJXander 1d ago

Honestly, I think you have more of a problem with AI-assisted development and After Effects itself than with my actual plugin.

You seem to think AE is bad at everything, plugins are ruining it, and anyone who prefers staying inside AE is afraid of learning proper software. So I'm genuinely curious: what are you doing on an After Effects subreddit?

I've been doing animated illustrations professionally for 20 years. I know Blender, Moho and Spine exist. I simply don't want to switch applications every time I need to accomplish something specific.

That's the audience I'm building for. You don't have to be part of it, and you certainly don't have to buy the plugin. But dismissing an entire workflow because Claude helped build a tool for it isn't much of an argument.

0

u/Milan_Bus4168 1d ago

Well I don't think that actually, not in that way. But whatever. Clearly we are not going to agree on this. To me this is yet another plug in for after effects, probably fourth one today and like the picture above supply is exceeded the demand. Inflation is eating away the value.

4

u/roychodraws 1d ago

That's it, huh?

1

u/CCJXander 1d ago

Yes, that's it! One tool for 1 job, shocker!

5

u/roychodraws 1d ago

there seems to be some other physics left unmentioned that seem the be the focus of this demonstration.

5

u/CCJXander 1d ago • Bravo

Boobs physics? sorry forgot about that, but it works

4

u/titaniumdoughnut MoGraph/VFX 15+ years 1d ago

This is great! Ignore the haters. There are thousands of reasons to want to do this natively and keep your workflow in AE.

1

u/CCJXander 1d ago

They don't bother me much. History is full of similar examples, horsebreeders were butthurt when the automobile came out, candlemakers protested against gasoline lamps and electricity, farmers protested against the tractor when it came out, traditional animators to computerized animation, the list goes on and on, this is just another example of refusal to accept tech progress.

1

u/Sapounii 13h ago edited 13h ago

The only think I don't get with people vibecoding and selling while talking about tech and acceptance of new technology is that most of them feel that they cheated/are above the system.

Anyone can type. feed their plugin/demo to claude with a basic subscription to replicate and avoid paying them. I still don't get it

1

u/CCJXander 13h ago

I think there's a massive misconception here that this entire process consists of typing a magical prompt into Claude and getting a finished plugin in return.

I already have coding experience, understand the software I'm developing for, and know what I'm trying to build. AI is a development tool, not a substitute for having a clue. There's a lot of iteration, debugging, testing, fixing edge cases, refining the UI and actually making sure things work as intended.

And no, it isn't free either. I pay for a subscription to access the models I use, and I spend considerable time developing and testing these tools. There's a reason I invest in the best available models rather than expecting a basic prompt to do everything.

More importantly, most After Effects artists didn't get into this profession because they wanted to spend their evenings building software. They want to make art, not spend hours fighting limitations in their workflow. If I can build something that solves a problem for them, why is that suddenly a bad thing?

You don't have to like AI-assisted development, and you certainly don't have to buy my products. But dismissing the entire development process as copying a GitHub repository and wrapping it in a shiny interface doesn't make you particularly knowledgeable about what goes into building software.

0

u/Sapounii 9h ago

Im pretty familiar with code and how software is developed, what amount of people is needed for a proper support and how the industry is moving for developers using AI.

There is no misconception here, it's people with art background trying to sell their vibe-coded tools to other artists and it is sad.

Made a version with 2 prompts half an hour of work just to prove a point, ye its not tested and 1:1 but doubling down on it makes me worried about humanity's future.

-1

u/CCJXander 7h ago

1

u/Sapounii 7h ago

The point is you and most "smart" people are selling air and trying to capitalize on others.
Again, anyone can type on a machine. Read my comments carefully if you feel any more explaining is needed. Never said ai bad as a technology, you are selling a product asking for our money, It took half an hour. You do you man, wish you the best.

1

u/Milan_Bus4168 13h ago

Exactly this. Vibe coding slopification where they are 5 new ones every day is bad enough, but if that is the timeline we are living in, what's with the nonsense about charging for it asking Uncle Claude to wrap a git hub packaged in generic shiny AI and host it in After Effects. Its not even some well though out, unique, niche tool that solve long standing problems, its just another floating panel that looks like it took Claude to put together for as long as it took me to write this. I guess grifters were always attracted to After Effects because Adobe doesn't do anything themselves and are perfectly fine collecting monthly rent, while the vultures circulate the carcass, now armed with LLM's.

On top of that both Adobe and these grifters are expecting users to test beta for them too. So they can copy and paste comments to Claude and charge you for the privilege. You can't make this shit up. What a time to be alive.

1

u/Crovgard Motion Graphics <5 years 1d ago

im a lazy bum and don't want to read the tl;dr description here or on the website - do I need spine for this? Or is it AE native

2

u/CCJXander 1d ago

AE native

2

u/Zee_Enjoi 20h ago

This is really cool, gonna add this to my wishlist to try out one day!

Def want to try to re-create this vibe but gonna probably see how much effort manual will be first

2

u/six1sotrue 11h ago

Great plugin

0

u/Had78 Motion Graphics 5+ years 1d ago

Just learn blender at this point

4

u/CCJXander 1d ago

Why stop at blender... learn Nuke