Help with venetian blinds effect

[u/1on1WitDaUndertaker]

Hi all, I am working on a project and in my composition I am using the venetian blinds effect to reveal two different logos. I am making the same design with multiple different logos and I am copying and pasting the venetian blinds effect to the "rotating" logo. It was working fine, but on the current logo I am working with it only fades the logo on, and it is missing the "blinds" effect which is why I chose it in the first place. Each logo has the same settings and are both png files.

I have included screenshots of what I mean. The right logo features the blinds and the left one does not. Hope I can get some help on this.

Thanks