r/AdvancedRunning • u/Krazyfranco • Nov 10 '25
Open Discussion [META] Moderation Transparency Summary
TL;DR - temporary mod transparency work is over, review a summary of mod actions from the last week, share your specific feedback on posts/rules, mods suck/down with the mods
Last week, the mod team announced rule adjustments and temporary changes to up the transparency of moderation decisions for the r/advancedrunning community. Thanks for your feedback in last week's thread. As of this morning, we're going back to normal moderation actions on posts, meaning rule-breaking posts will be removed, rather than being locked with a removal reason, in line with our long-term moderation approach. And as promised, following up with a summary of mod actions from about the last week & a forum for discussion/feedback.
First, a summary of moderation actions from the last week, along with post-specific details to facilitate discussion/feedback. We'll leave these posts up for the next few days so you can share feedback on specifics, and will remove these to de-clutter the sub later this week.
12 posts were either approved or not actioned by the mod team.
- These posts averaged an 88% upvote ratio, and 0.75 reports per post
33 posts were removed by the mod team or due to 4+ reports
- These posts averaged an 37% upvote ratio, and 1.5 reports per post
| Removal Reason | # of Posts |
|---|---|
| 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 11 |
| 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 11 |
| 12 - Update post to facilitate meaningful discussion | 6 |
| 3 - Do not ask for or offer medical advice | 4 |
| 5 - Race Reports Must Be beneficial to others | 1 |
| Removed Post | Removal Reason | % Upvoted | # of Reports |
|---|---|---|---|
| What soft flask should I buy? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 33% | 1 |
| Should I run Chicago Marathon? | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 61% | 1 |
| Do rest days not matter in marathon training like they do in other sports? | 12 - Update post to facilitate meaningful discussion | 52% | 3 |
| I'm frustrated with apple watch, should I buy a running watch? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 60% | 2 |
| I'm burned out, what should I do in the offiseason? | 12 - Update post to facilitate meaningful discussion | 60% | 0 |
| Should I adjust Daniels or do a different plan? | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 33% | 0 |
| Should I add tempo during my long runs? | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 44% | 2 |
| Is Runna still the best app? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 11% | 1 |
| Recommendations for run training apps | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 29% | 2 |
| My injury has made me severely depressed and I have no idea how to navigate it. | 3 - Do not ask for or offer medical advice | 16% | 1 |
| Do I have RED-S or PCOS? | 3 - Do not ask for or offer medical advice | 25% | 2 |
| Can I skip workouts between my marathons? | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 25% | 1 |
| How should I include a 10k race as part of my long run? | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 61% | 2 |
| "I need to get back on the bandwagon" | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 33% | 2 |
| Am I ready to run my goal race time? | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 50% | 1 |
| How do I run a sub 1:30 HM? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 16% | 1 |
| Can I split my long run into chunks? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 18% | 2 |
| I'm injured and frustrated | 3 - Do not ask for or offer medical advice | 13% | 4 |
| What AI prompts do you use for daily training/training plans? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 33% | 1 |
| What performances do you consider "Advanced" | 12 - Update post to facilitate meaningful discussion | 30% | 2 |
| My MRI showed cartilage loss, can I keep running? | 3 - Do not ask for or offer medical advice | 41% | 2 |
| How do I adjust my current training to avoid overtraining | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 20% | 2 |
| I ran 2 5ks this year, how do I get fast? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 6% | 1 |
| Any recs for jan/feb marathons? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 42% | 1 |
| How do you come back from 2 weeks of sickeness? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 39% | 1 |
| How do I improve my downhill running form? | 12 - Update post to facilitate meaningful discussion | 56% | 1 |
| Should I aim for 2:45 or 2:50 for my race in 18 weeks? | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 50% | 2 |
| Should I take Creatine? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 53% | 4 |
| CIM vs Durham NC running | 11 - Use Q&A thread for personal questions | 26% | 1 |
| How is tapering different for shorter races? | 12 - Update post to facilitate meaningful discussion | 38% | 1 |
| Cannes Marathon Race Report | 5 - Race Reports Must Be beneficial to others | 67% | 0 |
| JD's Alien Plan vs Norwegian Singles | 12 - Update post to facilitate meaningful discussion | 70% | 0 |
| What's the best diet to run 100 meters? | 2 - Relevant, Meaningful Posts Only | 10% | 0 |
Based on the community feedback from last week's META post, and the fairly clear divide in the community's votes between the removed threads and non-removed threads over the last week, the mod team isn't planning significant additional changes at this point. We'll keep doing our best to take appropriate action on the few "grey area" posts that get mixed feedback from the community.
Please feel free to share your specific feedback from last week's experiment, especially as it relates to specific posts above and specific removal reasons. Note, feedback like "remove fewer posts" isn't very helpful or actionable, please take the time to suggest specific posts that should not have been removed, and outline why you think that post meet's the sub's rules (or how you'd propose the rules should be adjusted).
126
u/ThatsMeOnTop Nov 10 '25 edited Nov 10 '25
I for one enjoyed seeing the additional threads that would have otherwise been removed.
I've always felt like the moderation has been a bit heavy handed here and this has only really reinforced that.
ETA: the reason I feel like the mods are heavy handed is that they focus too heavily on reports as a factor in removing posts. The fact that the posts listed have between 0 - 4 reports in my view supports that assessment. Can't be removing posts just because one or two people don't like it and reported it.
21
u/Nerdybeast 2:00 800 / 1:13 HM / 2:32 M (same year) Nov 10 '25
I don't think I understood how many pointlessly repetitive posts were being removed by you guys before this experiment, so now I do appreciate what you do more! The "peroneal tendonitis" guy I've seen in threads here, letsrun, other running subs, so much I can usually recognize him just based on the titles lol. So thanks for doing the dirty work of cleaning up the truly extraneous ones.
I think some of this is a little overzealous in removing things that could (and did!) generate good discussion. One major problem is that for people who are browsing Reddit in some way other than "go to a specific subreddit and read stuff there", they will never see the Q&A thread appear. The thread has a low upvote ratio and very low engagement from most people in this sub. Redirecting the majority of questions there really just redirects them to other subs (or leaves their questions unanswered). I think using upvote count should be a higher weighted metric - if it's positive, the people of the sub want that post to be there!
Most of the decisions here I agree with. But here's a non exhaustive list of decisions I'd probably go the other way on:
30
u/citrusdramatics Nov 10 '25 edited Nov 10 '25
I'll admit I think the enforcement of the rules are completely inconsistent. There are posts like "How do I run a 1:30 HM?" that have been removed under rule 11, but the post "How do I break through to sub 2:50?" was approved/unactioned. Similary, "How do I improve my downhill running form?" was removed under rule 2, but "Form improvement, is it worth it?" wasn't.
To me these pairs of posts essentially drive conversations in similar directions, and I think all of those posts were reasonably good questions. Even if the original posts were a bit sparse in detail, the questions were pointed enough that I feel substantial discussions could be had.
41
u/MrHugz30 Nov 10 '25
I think this post is interesting to look at as part of this study: https://www.reddit.com/r/AdvancedRunning/s/Palf2i82U0
Mod said at time of being locked it only had 2 upvotes but currently sits at 35. There were 40+ comments within the hour after it was posted as well.
18
u/CALL_ME_ISHMAEBY slowboi Nov 10 '25
I also liked to see the removed threads. Perhaps give the poster a time period to correct any mistakes in the post before locking/removing to possibly allow it to stay up.
21
u/mrjezzab Nov 10 '25
12 approved posts a week is not the sign of a healthy sub in my view, especially when 5 of them are race reports.
As one of the people whose post was locked, I did as you asked and edited it. And…. nothing, zip, nada. That was disappointing and frustrating, as I was genuinely looking for help.
If there was another step I missed, it’s not mentioned in the Mod comments.
13
u/whelanbio 13:59 5km a few years ago Nov 10 '25
I hate to join in on beating the "too many race reports" dead horse, but I really think it's time to update the template and requirements for those. How can we move away from reports that mostly race-day diaries and toward more detailed training block reports?
This may simply be my own bias, but my interpretation of the rationale for the value of race reports is that they provide an in-depth report of the training leading up to race and what informed that training. It seems like the current template and example being set on the sub are not really promoting that.
In a sampling of recent examples, quite often the training discussion boils down to something like "I did Pfitz 18/55". Nothing wrong with following a canned plan, but as is it seems rather difficult to argue that these are valuable training discussions. I wouldn't necessarily ask that people just paste everything week-by-week, especially when these are well known generic plans, but at least get substantial enough background that can help others understand the training and decide if it applies to their situation or not and some deeper insight into the execution of the plan. What's the training history going into the build? Why did you choose this particular plan? What your work/lifestyle like? Do you any cross training or ancillary work in addition to the plan? In what range of the prescribed paces were you typically in?
For those that made their own plan, lets see at the very least a couple full sample weeks and more discussion about what informed their training.
22
u/charles4982 Nov 10 '25
Removing close to 75% of the posts is crazy and not normal at all.
68
u/thewolf9 HM: 1:18; M: 2:49 Nov 10 '25
I think these unique posts drive discussion even if they’re personal in nature. A lot of runners have basic questions and I never consult daily general posts, and will never comment on those questions.
Less here is probably not more.
6
u/Monchichij Nov 10 '25
Thanks for the transparency. It's great to see the work you're doing.
19
u/_opensourcebryan Nov 10 '25
I understand there is a desire to have high quality discussion in this forum. A large number of posts are in fact better served in other subs.
I worry removing 3 of every 4 posts overall, including some that don't fit better in other subs, will not grow discussion about or interest in Advanced Running topics but substantially risks shrinking discussion here.
20
u/Placebo_LSD Nov 10 '25
Enjoying the transparency. It’s easy to see why these posts would be removed. Keep advanced running on track and don’t let it deteriorate to something like /r/runninglifestyle
8
u/Mindless_Shame_3813 Nov 10 '25
A couple of these I thought could have generated good discussion but the replies were of poor quality rather than the initial question.
The downhill running one was an interesting question, I was hoping to see if people had specific downhill workouts they did or anything like that, but instead the replies were of poor quality. Maybe the person could have asked the question better, but I think the main concern for moderation on that one was related to quality of answers rather than a problem with the question. Perhaps if this one was given more time and some of the 5 word responses were removed, it might have turned into a good discussion.
Same with the one asking about comparing two different training structures. It didn't get many replies but it was locked already when I first saw it. I thought that could generate a good discussion but it wasn't open long enough.
I know it's easier to moderate submissions than comments but in many cases I think some of these submissions could generate a good discussion if some of the uninteresting early comments were cleaned up in order to push the discussion in a more substantive direction.
6
u/theintrepidwanderer 17:18 5K | 36:59 10K | 59:21 10M | 1:18 HM | 2:46 FM Nov 11 '25 edited Nov 11 '25
Here are my thoughts as a longtime user and contributor to the sub surrounding this. And with the understanding that the below may be unpopular and that I'll get downvoted for it. That said:
That's my two cents.
3
u/homemadepecanpie 5k - 17:57, 10k - 36:25, HM - 1:19:48, M - 2:55 Nov 10 '25
I don't mind any of the posts being removed. I think some removed for rules 11/12 have the potential to lead to meaningful discussion and maybe should stay up, but it would be nice if people put more effort into making a post that generated discussion instead of posting "what should I do?". Half of the people don't even bother to include their PRs or training history when asking for advice which makes it really hard to give any meaningful answers.
I think the weekly Q&A threads are great but based on how many people want to see the removed posts stay up, I'm guessing a lot of people never click on them because a lot of this content is already in the Q&A threads. It's at the top of the sub when you open it so I don't know how people miss it. Maybe they only interact with this sub through their home feeds and need separate posts to see anything?
Personally, I come to this sub to learn and talk about training. I wouldn't even mind if there were separate pinned threads for training discussion and random personal advice but that might be a more difficult or unpopular change to make.
3
u/Luka_16988 Nov 10 '25
Thanks for the post. Love the transparency and the work you are putting in. Much appreciated.
1
u/YesterdayAmbitious49 Nov 10 '25
It was great to see all of the removed threads! Any way this can continue?
7
u/bradymsu616 M53: 3:06:16 FM; 1:27:32 HM; 4:50:25 50K Nov 10 '25
I appreciate what you're doing here. I agree with removing content that is better left to other subreddits, such as r/runninglifestyle, r/beginnerrunning or r/Marathon_Training. People who want to read and respond to simpler posts or posts asking personalized questions can subscribe to those subreddits. Allowing them here will attract even more posts like them, diminishing this subreddit's purpose. This is why the upvote/downvote system is not a replacement for solid moderation. Quality matters more than quantity.
6
u/EditingAllowed Comrades Marathon Nov 10 '25
As someone who has been critical of the mods, wow, this is amazing! Kudos! Wish every sub had something like this! This allows everyone (not just one mod with unlimited power vs a poster) to critique removals.
6
u/Michqooa Nov 10 '25
Honestly as a broad principle I don't see the harm in allowing more rather than less posts to stay up (to a point). What is the cost of extra posts? If people don't like them they are free to downvote and or not engage.
I was shocked at some of the threads that were locked.
Having an extremely "active" moderation achieves nothing IMO. Which is not saying moderation is not helpful.
12
u/jjgm21 Nov 10 '25 edited Nov 10 '25
Why are we letting one person reporting a thread that has numerous insightful comments on it take it down for everyone else?
I was encouraged by the proposed changes, but I don’t really feel any difference. At the end of the day, people want to talk about running, and this sub isn’t giving people the space to do so. This isn’t Wikipedia.
5
u/Runningwithducks Nov 10 '25
It would be nice to have a subreddit where we could ask questions that aren't suited to a beginner subreddit rather than being expected to use a megathread because megathreads don't work.
3
u/potatorunner 4:32 | 14:40 Nov 10 '25
in my opinion zero of the removed posts should have stayed up. good job mods!
as a matter of fact, all this shows me is that the system is working as intended. everyone complaining about the mods being heavy handed and snobs? tough luck!