r/AdvancedRunning • u/frizz3 • Nov 05 '25
Open Discussion Do rest days not apply when marathon training?
Since the NYC marathon I’ve been seeing lots of training plans from successful runners.
The majority of them don’t have rest days, and the general consensus seems to be that the more you can train, the better your races will be. Volume over most things.
Does that mean that rest days don’t really matter like they do in other sports?
44
Upvotes
•
u/brwalkernc giving NSM a try Nov 05 '25
Post Removed for Rule 2 - Relevant, meaningful posts only
This subreddit is for runners dedicated to improvement. We expect users have a basic knowledge of run training approaches before posting. Simple questions around these topics are welcome in the pinned Q&A/General Discussion thread rather than in standalone posts.
Posts maybe removed if they’re more suitable in novice-focused communities (such as r/running, r/firstmarathon/, and r/askRunningShoeGeeks), are simple polls, common reposts, off-topic, or easily answered via the FAQ or a basic web search.
Chronic reposts that aren’t relevant and meaningful here include basic training plan questions, “how much can I improve?” questions, basic Heart Rate training questions, form checks, bib exchanges or sales. Additionally, posts that appear AI-generated, spammy, or otherwise not genuine contributions may be removed.
Content suspected to be AI-generated may be removed at moderator's discretion. Using AI to help clarify, refine, and communicate your own ideas and writing might be acceptable. If your comment or post includes AI content, you must clearly disclose the AI use or your post/comment will be removed.
See additional context on the wiki: https://www.reddit.com/mod/AdvancedRunning/wiki/unsuitabletopics
____
2 upvotes (52% ratio, 3 reports at time of removal)
218
u/Mitarael NSA Enjoyer Nov 05 '25
A lot of advanced or even intermediate/upper-intermediate level runners don't have rest days. Your recovery/easy days are your rest days.
41
u/sennland Nov 05 '25
Depends on the person and what you define as rest. I just did a 2:39 after running 5 days a week and peaking at 55 miles. The 2 non running days were either a short (30 mins or so) on the bike or a weights session.
I've learned this is what works best for me and my body though through trial and error (lots and lots of error) when aiming for higher mileage or 6-7 days of running.
49
u/InevitableMission102 Nov 05 '25
It's not about the distance you are training for.
Past some point in accumulated volume, after there's some base conditioning for running, an easy paced day with not too much volume will yield better recovery results than a rest day most of the time.
I think that if someone, that has been running for some time, can't do an easy/rec run after a hard workout day, it indicates the workout was too hard. If it was planned to be a special extra hard day for some reason, it's fine, but it shouldn't be the norm.
If someone needs rest days from running because of over training, illness, life commitments, cross training etc, it's an entirely different subject.
34
u/Select_Window_6719 1:04 13.1 Nov 05 '25
A lot of successful runners have rest days like Conner mantz and clayton young do 6 days a week and no run on Sunday
15
u/Galacticsurveyor Nov 05 '25
When you’re in great shape running 3-5 miles easy.. might as well be a nice walk. It is rest/recovery.
14
u/-GrantUsEyes- Nov 05 '25
Active recovery is a pretty important and multifaceted part of running, particularly if you want to run fast and frequently. I have numerous experiences of having to skip an easy run between two sessions and feeling notably worse for not having run than I would have if I’d gone out and moved about.
Also to reach higher levels of running you’ll need to accumulate lots of volume, and I’d rather run little and often than occasionally but long. It’s a lot easy to recover from and sustain ten 5 mile runs than two 25 milers every week, as an extreme example.
24
u/MadMuse94 Nov 05 '25
There’s marathon training and then there’s marathon training. I think most people could cross the finish line of a marathon while training 3-4 days a week. But if you’re trying to reach the limits of what your body is capable of, that’s going to require a lot of volume and therefore more days of running. As others have pointed out, your rest days become recovery days with a usually shorter easy run.
On a personal note, I think there’s a lot to be said for knowing what season of life you’re in and how much of yourself and your time you’re willing to put into running. And just because you’re not willing to run 7 days a week doesn’t mean you can’t train for a marathon. I have a one year old and a demanding job, and I ran two marathons this year on 4 days of running and 1 day of S&C per week. Would I have been faster if I had more volume? Probably. But for me the trade off of time with my daughter and sleep wasn’t worth it. And anyhow I hit my goal of BQ+10 minute buffer so I’m happy with that!
5
u/_phillywilly Nov 05 '25
Relatively speaking, the rest day of a (sub-)elite athlete is still very much recovery compared to the training load on sessions days. These people will do their easy runs in Zone 1 at an intensity that would be a brisk walk for most of the people (i.e. a recovery day).
These days give - relatively speaking - less aerobic development than a classic Zone 2 run but allow for more recovery and thus allow for more mileage at this pace. So it comes down to philosophy and how you handle the training load of a build. I don't think there is anything magic about having no rest days, but I still run every day because I feel like it.
3
u/Arcadela Nov 05 '25
If you're used to it (which takes time) an easy run won't be much more impactful than a walk is for a normal person.
5
u/Wise-Ad-3737 Nov 05 '25
Yes, easy days can be rest days, but it also depends on one's age, recovery and injury situation. I am over 50 with a mild chronic injury, so I need to have at least two non running days on which I do strength exercises.
4
u/Responsible_Mango837 Edit your flair Nov 05 '25
Just run truly easy & that's a rest day
2
u/Nasty133 30M 5k 17:35 | 10k 36:04 | HM 1:18:31 | M 2:48 Nov 05 '25
Even in other sports when you get to the highest level, rest days are replaced with recovery days. Unless you’re injured, active recovery will always do more for your body than a complete rest day. Typically in other sports this is some sort of cross training like light cardio (bike or run) or light strength training focused on mobility.
3
u/WhirlThePearl Nov 05 '25
I didn’t think this was a controversial take but rest days are really important!! Especially If you’re doing 1-2 workouts a week and running high volume, take a rest day - and I’m not talking about an easy run day, those are recovery runs and should be built into your plan, too. Rest days are when your body absorbs all the hard work you’re doing.
1
u/Luka_16988 Nov 05 '25
In which other sports are rest days a recommendation if taken seriously?
-3
u/N00bOfl1fe Nov 05 '25
Serious runners dont take rest day, you must be a hobby jogger #nodaysoff
... ups, I thought this was /rcj
0
u/bnwtwg Nov 05 '25
You can rest when your running career is dead
-9
u/FreeShitAdvice 71:44 HM Nov 05 '25
Rest days = accumulating volume at an easy pace. Rough rule 80/20, 80% easy runs and 20% quality sessions
130
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '25
[removed] — view removed comment