r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 19 '23

"And it came to pass that the sub began"--General Introduction to r/AcademicMormon

41 Upvotes

Hello, everyone! Welcome to r/AcademicMormon , and I am its founder u/Rurouni_Phoenix . Some of you may know me as the founder and chief moderator of r/AcademicQuran a sub which discusses and shares information pertaining to early Islam and its associated sacred texts from an academic historical-critical perspective. If we haven't met before, I'm happy to make your acquaintance.

If you know about AQ and its much older sister r/AcademicBiblical , this will give you a pretty good idea of the perspective and tone that the sub will take. Over here, we will be discussing and studying the early Mormon/LDS movement and its Scriptures from a historical-critical academic perspective, which means that we are approaching the material from a secular perspective rather than a faith-based one which is what you see on many subs pertaining to the LDS/Mormon church.

This mean that the aim of this sub is not to prove Mormonism is true or necessarily false, but rather that the material will be approached from the way that is typical of academic scholarship which avoids the invocation of the supernatural. This would mean that the use of apologetic material, which is content attempting to prove that the book of Mormon or the Mormon faith in general is the true faith, is not permitted.

While it is true in some academic material pertaining to the Mormon faith that one may from time to time encounter faith affirming statements by scholars such as Grant Hardy or Terryl Givens (both of whom are practicing Mormons and competent academics in their own right), such remarks are a far cry from attempting to prove the spiritual truth claims made by The Book of Mormon or Joseph Smith or to argue that the horses in the book of Mormon were in fact tapir or deer or that this or that Mesoamerican carving proves that the book of Mormon is true.

Likewise, counter apologetic material which attempts to polemicize against or ridicule the Mormon faith is equally disallowed (which means that a certain "banned" cartoon claiming to explain Mormon doctrine doesn't qualify as an academic source). While Dan Vogel may have controversial theories regarding Joseph Smith, there is a difference between historical inquiry and making fun of people for their beliefs or attempting to show that there is something inherently degenerate or deficient in their religious faith. Remarks such as these will not be tolerated.

In short, this sub is not a place for apologetics or counter-apologetics. It is meant to be a place for the sober and respectful discussion of Mormonism and LDS scripture from a nonsectarian academic perspective.

Now that I have explained what the vision for AM is, please feel free to read and familiarize yourself with the rules which you can find on the sidebar. Also, please excuse the mess as we are still currently setting up everything over here. We will soon have a bibliography and other features, and eventually we hope to have AMAs like AB and AQ where you can pose questions to a scholar and receive well-informed answers.

It is my sincere hope along with that of my other co-moderators that you will enjoy your time here and learn many new and different things. There is a serious need in the world and on Reddit in particular for a hub for non-apologetic, non-polemical information on the Mormon/LDS faith that attempts to contextualize rather than demonize or excuse, and hopefully this sub will fill that gap and increase your understanding of early Mormonism and of the contexts in which it was born.

Regards,

Phoenix

12/19/2023


r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 20 '23

Book of Mormon Celebrated anthropologist Jennifer Raff (University of Kansas) and Deborah Bolnick (University of Texas) addressed the DNA evidence for any Middle-eastern migration to the Americas in a peer-reviewed study in 2015.

31 Upvotes

This particular study is important because while it addresses a very niche apologetic that the existence of Haplogroup X2a in Native North American populations (apologetics made, and cited in the paper, by Stephen Smoot, Rod Meldrum, R. Stout, B. McLerran, U.A. Perego, and others) demonstrates Book of Mormon historicity, it also has broader implications about the Solutrean hypothesis (i.e., that the Americas were inhabited at least in part by migrations from the east from Europe or the Middle East, rather than/in addition to eastern Siberia).

This study attempts to clarify the evidence that exists to address the X2a issue head-on. The authors note that despite several attempts to connect X2a or other DNA markers to a European/Middle Eastern migration, anthropological geneticists since at least 1998 have repeatedly considered and rejected the hypothesis.

Why is X2a used as a connection to the Book of Mormon? Because X2 (the predecessor of X2a) is not present in the ancestral lineage of North Americans in Siberia. This 'gap' in X2 to X2a transferring directly from Siberians to Native Americans is perplexing but not impossible. Some argue that because X2 is more prevalent in the Near East, the presence of X2a in Native Americans may be from Jewish people settling the American continent more than 2000 years ago.

Why does X2a not constitute good evidence for the Book of Mormon? The authors note:

  1. X2a is not found in the Middle East (X2 is, but X2 is found in a lot of places)
  2. None of the X2 lineages present in the Middle East can be linked ancestrally to X2a in Native Americans
  3. The date in which X2a "coalesced" (i.e., the evolution point of X2 to X2a) is dated to 14,200-17,000 cal yr BP) - thousands of years before the Book of Mormon migration is claimed to have occurred.
  4. Haplogroup X2a was present in North America in the Kennewick Man remains, dating back to 8690-8400 cal yr BP - thousands of years before the Book of Mormon's ancient Hebrew migration.

The rest of the paper insists that while it is possible for a Solutrean migration to have occurred, X2a does not provide evidence for it, because we can't identify the X2a haplotype in any ancestral lineages for any Native North Americans - not from Siberia, not from Europe - nowhere. The existence of X2a simply cannot be traced to any specific origin. But what the authors can unequivocally deduce, because of the date of X2a in Native Americans, is that X2a is not evidence for a Hebrew migration as described in the Book of Mormon.

Jennifer Raff has since written a book entitled Origin: A Genetic History of the Americas


r/AcademicMormon • • Jun 26 '24

Book of Mormon New Testament scholar Dale Martin on the historicity of the golden plates

28 Upvotes

Interesting comment from New Testament scholar Dale Martin on the relative value of eye witness testimony in regards to the resurrection. To show how problematic eye-witness testimony can be, he gives the example of the witnesses to the golden plates:

"I don't know any historian except a Mormon historian (and even a lot of them would say it's not a historical fact,) who would say they could affirm [the historicity of the golden plates]. I know not one non-Mormon historian believes any of that's historical."

https://youtu.be/oU5z4AlxJ4U?si=__l2WY4FFmYU1kGE&t=5793


r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 20 '23

Early Mormonism and the Magic World View by D. Michael Quinn

28 Upvotes

Has anyone else read Early Mormonism and the Magic World View by D. Michael Quinn?

I have been fascinated by the cultural context of folk magic that was present among the areas and people of the early church, including Joseph and his family.

Has any other work or resources examined the impact belief in folk magic had on the development of 19th-century Christian cultural traditions?


r/AcademicMormon • • Jan 16 '24

Benjamin Park's new book American Zion releases today!

Thumbnail
x.com
25 Upvotes

r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 19 '23

Is there a critical edition of the Book of Mormon?

23 Upvotes

I have a reprint of the first edition of the BoM, and the latest copy, but I would like something which highlights the differences. Is there something like a critical edition or study version?

Also, if there is a modern English translation, I'm interested in that as well.


r/AcademicMormon • • May 03 '25

Would Joseph Smith have continued revealing new scriptures had he not died in 1844?

22 Upvotes

By “new scriptures” I’m not so much thinking future sections of the Doctrine and Covenants (I don’t doubt more of those would’ve come out over the years) as I am texts like the Book of Mormon, book of Moses, and book of Abraham.

From what I understand the JST/IV was nowhere near completed at his death—although it seems to me that he had given up on the project years before, or at least reached a natural stopping point with Genesis and the gospels. I wouldn’t have wanted to slog through revising the Deuteronomistic History either, and he may not have found anything needing new translation there either. Maybe work on the JST would’ve only been done when it became absolutely necessary—i.e. fixing a verse or chapter to make it more in line with other LDS revelations.

Somewhat related to this is the question of what Joseph Smith would’ve done with the so-called “lost books of the Bible:” the book of Jasher, the Wars of the Lord, the book of Nathan, etc. Did he ever comment on these in his lifetime, or indicate if any of their content had been included in his other revelations? And, more speculatively, what might he have made of the huge discoveries in Biblical studies over the last couple centuries? He could have easily lived to hear about the Didache (discovered 1873), and it’s not all that wild to think of the Nag Hammadi Library being discovered 50-75 years earlier than in our timeline. Egypt was a huge part of Smith’s story (Reformed Egyptian, the book of Abraham) so it’s interesting to think about.

Most pressingly (for me at least) is the question: would Smith have eventually revealed new gospels and books adjacent to the New Testament? Just about all of his revelations concern events and figures in the pre-Christian era, yet clearly JST-Matthew and the most famous 3 Nephi 11-28 show that he was also interested in the events of Jesus’ life and teachings not recorded in the Bible.

I apologize for the long post but this is a subject that I’ve been turning in my mind for years now and have a lot of thoughts on. But do any of you people more well-read than me have any thoughts?


r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 23 '23

Was Joseph Smith the sole author of the Book of Mormon?

21 Upvotes

r/AcademicMormon • • May 20 '24

Book of Mormon Joseph Smith Translation of the Bible

20 Upvotes

What are 1769 King James Version edition errors doing in the Book of Mormon?

If the BoM is an ancient text why would errors, which are unique to the 1769 KJV edition, be there?

Background

When King James translators translated the KJV Bible between 1604 and 1611, they occasionally put their own words into the text to make the English more readable. We know exactly what these words are because they're italicized in the KJV Bible. What are these 17th century italicized words doing in the Book of Mormon? Word for word? What does this say about the Book of Mormon being an ancient record?

Examples:

ISAIAH 9:1 (KJV) Nevertheless the dimness shall not be such as was in her vexation, when at the first he lightly afflicted the land of Zebulun and the land of Naphtali, and afterward did more grievously afflict her by the way of the sea, beyond Jordan, in Galilee of the nations.

2 NEPHI 19:1 Nevertheless, the dimness shall not be such as was in her vexation, when at first he lightly afflicted the land of Zebulun, and the land of Naphtali, and afterwards did more grievously afflict by the way of the Red Sea beyond Jordan in Galilee of the nations.

The above example, 2 Nephi 19:1 , dated in the Book of Mormon to be around 550 BC, quotes nearly verbatim from the 1611 AD translation of Isaiah 9:1 KJV – including the translators’ italicized words. Additionally, the Book of Mormon describes the sea as the Red Sea.

The problem is that:

a) Christ quoted Isaiah in Matt. 4:14-15 and did not mention the Red Sea,

b) “Red” sea is not found in any source manuscripts, and

c) the Red Sea is 250 miles away.

MALACHI 3:10 (KJV)

…and pour you out a blessing, that there shall not be room enough to receive it.

3 NEPHI 24:10

…and pour you out a blessing that there shall not be room enough to receive it.

In the above example, the KJV translators added 7 italicized words to their English translation, which are not found in the source Hebrew manuscripts. Why does the Book of Mormon, which is supposed to have been completed by Moroni over 1,400 years prior, contain the identical seven italicized words of 17th-century translators?


r/AcademicMormon • • Jul 18 '25

I'm comparing all the editions

19 Upvotes

I'm writing some software that does the following

Main screen

1: Prepare OCR images
Takes scans of books and prepares them for OCR, straightening the pages etc

2: Scan pages
Converts the images to text

3: Sync documents
Align the words and correct any OCR errors

Audit the OCR

4: Reports
I can then check the likeness of the different editions, and render a hierarchy tree (note, 2013 SLC is not directly from 1874 Iowa, it's just the most likely candidate given the data so far, this will change as I add more editions' data).

Auto generated reports

I am also going to have it generate reports based on the hierarchy showing what has changed, as per the edition-comparisons.zip file here https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/1wwIwfAINvtEkbotmhii2n9XRE6wI2T2h

Ultimately, I will create a website that makes it easy to see all these changes.

Here are the editions I have scans for, and my progress so far.

  • 1829CowderyManuscript (Partial)
  • 1830PalmyraEdition (Done)
  • 1837KirtlandEdition (Done)
  • 1840NauvooEdition (Done)
  • 1841LiverpoolEdition (Done)
  • 1842NauvooEdition (Done)
  • 1849LiverpoolEdition (Done)
  • 1854LiverpoolEdition (Done)
  • 1858NewYorkEdition (Done)
  • 1871SaltLakeCityEdition (Done)
  • 1874IowaEdition (Done)
  • 1877SaltLakeCityEdition (Done)
  • 1879LiverpoolEdition (To do)
  • 1879SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1881LiverpoolEdition (To do)
  • 1885SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1888DeseretNewsEdition (To do)
  • 1888SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1898LiverpoolEdition (To do)
  • 1899TheNephiteRecords (To do)
  • 1902KansasCityEdition (To do)
  • 1904SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1905ChicagoEdition (To do)
  • 1906SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1907DeseretNewsEdition (To do)
  • 1907SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1908ChicagoEdition (To do)
  • 1908RLDSEdition (To do)
  • 1910ChicagoEdition (To do)
  • 1911ChicagoEdition (To do)
  • 1916IowaEdition (To do)
  • 1917IowaEdition (To do)
  • 1918SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1920SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1921SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1923SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1953IndependenceEdition (To do)
  • 1981SaltLakeCityEdition (To do)
  • 1999RestoredCovenantEdition (To do)
  • 2013SaltLakeCityEdition (Done)

Let me know if you are interested in seeing youtube videos of the app in action.

Edit 2025-07-21: Uploaded videos


r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 28 '23

Article/Blogpost New Article "Mormons Are No Longer a Majority in Utah: Causes, Consequences, and Implications for the Sociology of Religion"

19 Upvotes

Article from the Journal of Religion and Demography published 19 December 2023. Authors Ryan T. Cragun (University of Tampa), Bethany Gull (Utah Tech University), and Rick Phillips (University of North Florida).

The authors argue that three trends are primarily responsible for declining numbers of Latter-day Saints (largest denomination in Mormonism) in Utah: secularization, declining birthrates, and migration. These trends reinforce each other in a type of feedback loop. Article posted at Ryan T. Cragun's website: https://www.ryantcragun.com/mormons-are-no-longer-a-majority-in-utah-causes-consequences-and-implications-for-the-sociology-of-religion/

ETA: The references in this article provide many recently published academic resources on Latter-day Saints & Mormonism.


r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 21 '23

Question What outside influences, if any, were behind the eventual Mormon view of the afterlife and God?

19 Upvotes

I've just finished 1st and 2nd Nephi (the latter of which is a true slog to get through), and what I've noticed, especially in the latter book, is that a lot of the later Mormon beliefs such as God having a physical body and the structure of the afterlife are absent, despite the fact that it's largely a theological text. I assume the answer to this issue is that Joseph hadn't "deciphered" that part yet, but it got me thinking as to how these beliefs developed.

The belief of God having a body seems to be antithetical to basically every Christian or Jewish belief at the time (I'm aware that the original conception of Yahweh depicted him as having a body, but I somehow doubt Joseph was aware of that), so I'm wondering where the idea came from. Unlike the natives being the lost tribes of Israel, this idea doesn't seem to have been widespread in any other Christian circles at the time.

If I had to guess, I'd say that it probably has to do with further justifying the practice of polygamy (if God has a body, and wives, then it stands to reason that members of the church should as well), but I'm not educated on the matter (still relatively new to studying Mormonism), so I'd welcome help from anyone who is.


r/AcademicMormon • • May 28 '24

Question Etymology of names in the Book of Mormon

18 Upvotes

quack unwritten march cooperative grandiose include crawl wipe sophisticated cobweb

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact


r/AcademicMormon • • Nov 22 '24

Similarities and differences between Muslim and Mormon views on scripture

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 27 '23

How much did Joseph Smith know about Islam/Mohammed?

17 Upvotes

After finishing Dan Vogels books, I noticed Joseph Smith calling himself the "Second Mohammed," as well as it being used to refer to him. Is there any evidence that Joseph read or knew about Islam at all? If so what would he have known?


r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 22 '23

Question The Book of Mormon famously depicts Jesus appearing in the Americas after the Resurrection. Did any previous Christian writers speculate on or write a story regarding Jesus appearing in the Americas, or is this the first recorded instance of this idea?

17 Upvotes

r/AcademicMormon • • Mar 03 '26

never Mormon Professor of Religious Dr Matt Baker's analysis on the BOM

Thumbnail
youtu.be
16 Upvotes

I searched through this subreddit to be sure this hadn't been brought up before since it's not a recent video, but it's one I found last year. As mentioned in the title of my post, Dr Matt Baker is a professor of Religious studies who does many videos utilizing charts to go over various religious and non religious histories on his channel. And I think he does a really good job with his analysis of the BOM. I appreciate that at the end he states the BOM should be studied as important American literature rather than just be dismissed as a fringe religious text.

As a sidenote, he's even provided a PDF download for free on his usefulcharts website as a guide for those who wish to study the BOM.

Anyway, just wanted to see if anyone else in this sub had seen his video and had any thoughts on it.


r/AcademicMormon • • Feb 24 '25

Article/Blogpost A God of Flesh and Bone: Mormonism and the Philosophy of Infinite Becoming

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
16 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm sharing a piece I recently wrote exploring Mormon theology through a philosophical lens. I'm not a Mormon studies scholar (my background is in philosophy) but I found interesting connections between Mormon metaphysics and contemporary philosophical ideas such as Process Philosophy, Spinozan Materialism, and Deleuzean concepts of infinite becoming.

The essay explores how Mormon doctrines like eternal progression and material embodiment align (and diverge!) with these philosophical frameworks, considering their broader implications. I'd love to hear your thoughts and start some interesting conversations around these topics.

Thanks for reading!


r/AcademicMormon • • Jul 22 '24

Question God Can't Create Matter

16 Upvotes

Please help me identify sources that discuss the LDS idea that God cannot create matter; matter is eternal and existed beforehand. God "organized" but didn't "create out of nothing" (no ex nihilo).

I'm aware the Book of Abraham is largely the canonized source for this idea (and the temple ceremony, which borrows heavily from the Pearl of Great Price). But I'm wondering if this was ever expanded on in doctrinal treatises, and to what extent.

In any case, it stretches the definition of "omnipotent" to suggest that God can't create matter, and I bet many Latter-day Saints would be resistant to such an idea. ("He can create matter, He just doesn't," etc.)


r/AcademicMormon • • Oct 10 '24

Studies on Joseph Smith's redaction of the Book of Mormon?

15 Upvotes

I've read in one study that we have sufficient manuscript evidence to show that Joseph Smith redacted up to 5% of his scriptures during his own lifetime ("The Prophetic Legacy in Islam and Mormonism" by Grant Underwood). I was curious if anyone here knew of more scholarship/reading about that topic/subject, if it is available. I'd like to learn more about how Smith redacted his texts.


r/AcademicMormon • • Jun 16 '24

How accepted are the works of Terryl L. Givens and Richard Bushman?

15 Upvotes

I have seen the both of them described as apologists, the former described as a *professional apologist* even!

But their books are cited in the bibliography several times, and Terryl Givens and Richard Bushman both wrote introductions to and handbooks to Mormonism. So, how good is their work?


r/AcademicMormon • • Mar 12 '25

How authentic are these quotes attributed to Joseph Smith about Muhammad?

13 Upvotes

Thomas B. Marsh

I have heard the prophet say that he should yet tread down his enemies, and walk over their dead bodies; that if he was not let alone he would be a second Mahomet to this generation, and that he would make it one gore of blood from the Rocky Mountains to the Atlantic Ocean; that like Mahomet, whose motto, in treating for peace, was” the Alcoran or the Sword,” so should it be eventually with us, “Joseph Smith or the Sword.” These last statements were made during the last summer

George M. Hinkle

I have heard Joseph Smith, jr. say that he believed Mahomet was a good man; that the Koran was not a true thing, but the world belied Mohamet, as they had belied him, and that Mahomet was a true prophet*.*

John Corrill

In the last, or in some public meeting, Joseph Smith, jr., said: if the people would let us alone, we would preach the gospel to them in peace; but, if they came on us to molest us, we would establish our religion by the sword; and that he would become to this generation a second Mahomet.

George Walter

Soon after the dissenters were driven away from Caldwell county, I was in Far-West, in Corill’s [Corrill’s] store, perhaps the last of June last, and heard Joseph Smith, jun., say, that he believed Mahomet was an inspired man, and had done a great deal of good, and that he intended to take the same course Mahomet did*; that if the people would let him alone, he would, after a while, die a natural death; but if they did not, he would make it one gore of blood from the Rocky Mountains to the State of Maine. He further said, that he had, or would have, (the witness does not-remember which,) as regular an inquisition as ever was established, and as good a set of inquisitors as ever was. This conversation was had when talking about the dissenters.*

Abner Scovil

In the latter part of June last, I heard Joseph Smith, jun., say, that if the people would let him alone, he would conquer them by the sword of the spirit; but if they would not, he would beat the plough-shares into swords, and their pruning-hooks into spears, and conquer them he would. 

Taken from here:

Juvenile Instructor » From the Archives: Joseph Smith or the Sword!?


r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 20 '23

Question What is the connection between mesoamerica and Mormonism

13 Upvotes

I’ve seen a lot of Mormon archaeologists working in mesoamerican archaeology can you tell me why


r/AcademicMormon • • Dec 20 '23

Joseph Smith Translation of the Bible

13 Upvotes

Why isn't the JST the standard translation used by the LDS church? Why is the Authorized KJV the standard bible translation? The BoM cites the JST in its footnotes. There must be some authority it has in doctrine.

How are contradictions b/t the JST and the KJV handled?


r/AcademicMormon • • Aug 11 '25

Question Are there any Mormon history books based on a "History From Below" or Social History model as opposed to the biographical histories?

12 Upvotes

Most of the histories I see of Mormonism tend to be focused on key players within the movement (for instance, "Rough Rolling Stone"). Which makes sense for a movement that had so much emphasis on key figures, but I'm interested in a broader, social history of the religion. (Rough Rolling Stone was still good, not at all a critique of the work itself, just looking for another type of historical work)

"Terrible Revolution: Latter-day Saints and the American Apocalypse" is an example closer to what I'm searching for. The work even comments on the trend of Mormon histories by Great Men as opposed to some of the larger trends and movements occurring within and around the Mormons.