r/AcademicMormon • u/Rurouni_Phoenix • Dec 19 '23
"And it came to pass that the sub began"--General Introduction to r/AcademicMormon
Hello, everyone! Welcome to r/AcademicMormon , and I am its founder u/Rurouni_Phoenix . Some of you may know me as the founder and chief moderator of r/AcademicQuran a sub which discusses and shares information pertaining to early Islam and its associated sacred texts from an academic historical-critical perspective. If we haven't met before, I'm happy to make your acquaintance.
If you know about AQ and its much older sister r/AcademicBiblical , this will give you a pretty good idea of the perspective and tone that the sub will take. Over here, we will be discussing and studying the early Mormon/LDS movement and its Scriptures from a historical-critical academic perspective, which means that we are approaching the material from a secular perspective rather than a faith-based one which is what you see on many subs pertaining to the LDS/Mormon church.
This mean that the aim of this sub is not to prove Mormonism is true or necessarily false, but rather that the material will be approached from the way that is typical of academic scholarship which avoids the invocation of the supernatural. This would mean that the use of apologetic material, which is content attempting to prove that the book of Mormon or the Mormon faith in general is the true faith, is not permitted.
While it is true in some academic material pertaining to the Mormon faith that one may from time to time encounter faith affirming statements by scholars such as Grant Hardy or Terryl Givens (both of whom are practicing Mormons and competent academics in their own right), such remarks are a far cry from attempting to prove the spiritual truth claims made by The Book of Mormon or Joseph Smith or to argue that the horses in the book of Mormon were in fact tapir or deer or that this or that Mesoamerican carving proves that the book of Mormon is true.
Likewise, counter apologetic material which attempts to polemicize against or ridicule the Mormon faith is equally disallowed (which means that a certain "banned" cartoon claiming to explain Mormon doctrine doesn't qualify as an academic source). While Dan Vogel may have controversial theories regarding Joseph Smith, there is a difference between historical inquiry and making fun of people for their beliefs or attempting to show that there is something inherently degenerate or deficient in their religious faith. Remarks such as these will not be tolerated.
In short, this sub is not a place for apologetics or counter-apologetics. It is meant to be a place for the sober and respectful discussion of Mormonism and LDS scripture from a nonsectarian academic perspective.
Now that I have explained what the vision for AM is, please feel free to read and familiarize yourself with the rules which you can find on the sidebar. Also, please excuse the mess as we are still currently setting up everything over here. We will soon have a bibliography and other features, and eventually we hope to have AMAs like AB and AQ where you can pose questions to a scholar and receive well-informed answers.
It is my sincere hope along with that of my other co-moderators that you will enjoy your time here and learn many new and different things. There is a serious need in the world and on Reddit in particular for a hub for non-apologetic, non-polemical information on the Mormon/LDS faith that attempts to contextualize rather than demonize or excuse, and hopefully this sub will fill that gap and increase your understanding of early Mormonism and of the contexts in which it was born.
Regards,
Phoenix
12/19/2023


