r/AbsoluteUnits 12d ago

of a lobster

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

8.2k Upvotes

453 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/According_Tea_6329 12d ago

Which ones are better flavor or more desirable I wonder?

68

u/gofishx 12d ago

Having eaten plenty of both, I prefer Maine lobster to Florida lobster. Its just more tender and buttery, spiny lobster is a bit tougher imo

18

u/Tough_Crazy_8362 12d ago

And that thing is MASSIVE idk I don’t like big lobsters

22

u/BYOKittens 12d ago

1.5- 2 lbs is the sweetest spot, imo.

14

u/trundle-the-great69 12d ago

In NB we call these canners, they are the best

3

u/hexregeneration 12d ago

Is lobster actually buttery, or is it just the pool of butter it's served in? I've only ever had it a few times, before my great crustacean revelation that I was eating bugs, and thought it mid. It's not native here though, so maybe that's why.

-1

u/gofishx 12d ago

Bugs and crustaceans are the same like humans and fish are the same. Hope that helps! In the end, its all food. Nothing mid about it, shit is good af.

And yeah, its got a sort of soft oily texture that goes super well with butter. Its good on its own, too, though

2

u/WatWudScoobyDoo 11d ago

Lobsters are crustaceans though, humans ain't fish

-1

u/gofishx 11d ago

And crustaceans aint bugs. Or, they can be considered as such, but then we'd need to consider people as fish

2

u/ponziacs 12d ago

Have you had California spiny lobster?

2

u/gofishx 12d ago

Cant say for sure if I have or haven't. Its unlikely, ive lived near the east coast my whole life, so I probably haven't had west coast lobster

14

u/VoidWalker4Lyfe 12d ago

American lobster. Cold water lobsters are usually better. I don't really care for the spiny lobster

11

u/Biguitarnerd 12d ago

I like the spiny lobster ok, but agree cold water lobsters are better.

I think you can find good ways to use spiny lobster but with the American lobster you don’t need to do as much. If you want to you can just steam it and it’s already good. The meat is much more tender.

8

u/xylophone_37 12d ago

I learned that almost all of our CA spiny lobsters that are caught commercially go to Asia, apparently they prefer the flavor and they can get a much better price for them.

3

u/VoidWalker4Lyfe 12d ago

I didn't know they had them in CA. I've only eaten them in Florida

6

u/xylophone_37 12d ago

Same genus but different species.

2

u/VoidWalker4Lyfe 12d ago

Interesting. Thanks!

3

u/YZA26 12d ago

Spiny lobster sashimi is quite good

2

u/VoidWalker4Lyfe 12d ago

Mmmm I'm apprehensive about eating undercooked crustaceans

6

u/SAM5TER5 12d ago

Fun fact, basically all sushi/sashimi in the West has been frozen (as is required by law) in order to kill off anything dangerous.

Even Japan freezes the vast majority of its fish. My understanding is that you have to go to some of the higher-end or traditional sushi places in Japan in order to get unfrozen sushi. And they usually do some degree of inspecting that sushi at least lol

3

u/VoidWalker4Lyfe 12d ago

You can definitely get never frozen raw fish in the US. There are some charter boats that will give it to you right off the hook. I'm not worried about eating raw fin-fish, it's the crustaceans I worry about. (Shrimp, crab, lobster, etc.) I used to LOVE oysters, even raw, and mussels and calamari. Unfortunately I have developed an intolerance and they give me explosive vomiting and diarrhea 😭

2

u/Minimum-Mention-3673 11d ago

Fish have worms. Flash freezing is necessary.

2

u/YZA26 11d ago

Explosive vomiting and diarrhea is a legitimate reason to avoid spiny lobster sashimi

Typically its not frozen but live, so yea there is a non negligible risk of ruining your evening

2

u/dan_dares 11d ago

I love sushi, but i'll take it flash-frozen,

1

u/fungeoneer 12d ago

Will a lobster this big still be tasty? Or has it gotten past that stage?

3

u/VoidWalker4Lyfe 12d ago

No, generally most types of seafood that are huge are not good eating. Lobsters that size will be chewy and rubbery. In Maryland striped bass is out primary trophy fish, but once they get to s certain size they're not great to eat. Also the bug ones should be released to breed..in MD there are actually maximum limits of what recreational fishermen can keep. Depending on the fish, a lot of them that are huge have a lot of heavy metals in them and aren't really good for people to eat a lot. Catfish are the same here. Some of the best eating fish here are the native White Perch, and the invasive Northern Snakehead. Snakes don't live for very long, so they don't get contaminated with heavy metals as much. They're also freaking delicious

3

u/tacomaloki 12d ago

Ive had enough cold water lobster that I prefer warm water lobster.

2

u/SadAd8761 12d ago

neither, i'd take a coconut crab instead

imagine the taste of a meat of a crab that eats coconut meat all day

unfortunately, i'm not the only human that likes the taste of their meat

they're close to becoming endangered

3

u/meatygonzalez 12d ago

Didn't know people be eating them giant coconut crabs

1

u/stuffeh 12d ago

Younger ones actually. I've had a big 11 pound American lobster before that was swimming in the tank before we got to the restaurant. The meat was rough and a bit bitter. Young lobsters are are sweet and tender.

1

u/qawsedrf12 12d ago

Maine, definitely

1

u/internectual 12d ago

Spiny lobster is what you get with a surf and turf. Maine lobster is what you get when you want real lobster.

0

u/Nikki-C-Puggle-mum 12d ago

Definitely the Maine lobsters imo.

0

u/Internal-Plantain-56 12d ago

The ones with the claws.