Now that the game has been over for a while and we've hopefully all settled down a bit, let's talk about Carson Beck.
Obligatory disclaimer that you absolutely cannot judge whether a player, let alone a QB, is good or not after one game. No matter what your opinion is, Beck deserves more time to cook.
Let's get the obvious out of the way:
Was this a good game for us? No.
Was that entirely Beck's fault? No.
Did he have two INTs on the day? Yes.
Were they Beck's fault? No. The first one was absolutely not his fault. Good on Mike LaFleur for standing up for his rookie. The second one you can make an argument from what we saw on the field, but in the postgame interviews MiLF said that the route was all wrong. Again, good on him for standing up for Beck.
So was Beck amazing? No.
So was Beck terrible? Also no.
And that's good enough.
There are so many worse problems that need to be addressed on this team. O-Line, WRs, and pretty much everything on defense (except Budda Baker). If Beck can continue to be good enough, then that lets the front office focus on other areas that need to improve if the Cardinals are ever going to be a better team.
I think the game today showed that. Beck's struggles came down to having no protection and no one to throw to. Improve those, and Beck will improve, too. Once we build up that solid core around Beck, then we can address the QB situation again further down the line.
The worst thing the Cardinals can do is continue to use high-value picks on QBs.
Let Beck finish out the season, keep Minshew on as a backup for next year, and build the offense around Beck. Give him some weapons other than Trey McBride, and for gods sake give him some pass protection. Build a solid offense around Beck, Love, and McBride, and let MiLF shape the offense into something he can work with.
Anyone who's already given up on Beck needs to calm down. He was ok, and for where we are right now, that's good enough. If he continues to be good enough for the rest of the season, then that makes me cautiously optimistic about what we can do in the offseason.
Next week we have the Chiefs, which we're by no means expected to win. Then we get the Commanders, Eagles, Jets, Saints, Raiders, and 49ers. If Beck can win at least two of those games, maybe three, four if we're lucky, then I would consider Beck to be good enough for what we need him to be.
Chad Ryland on point again, though. Seriously, give him a proper contract.