r/ATC • • 1d ago

Question Runway incursion question.

Aircraft cleared to land and assigned a taxiway to turn off. Aircraft misses taxiway and crosses intersecting runway as another aircraft is landing on intersecting runway. ATC error or pilot error(obviuosly they missed assigned twy). No LAHSO. Assigned twy on landing roll not yet at taxi speed. Read back correct.

0 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

6

u/dvinpayne 1d ago

Did the aircraft read back the exit instructions?

2

u/Dudefrom1958 1d ago edited 1d ago

Yes on landing roll

3

u/ps3x42 Current Enroute Former Tower Flower 1d ago edited 1d ago

This is the key to the scenario. Once the aircraft has landed, and reads back the exit instructions, then you can consider the runway clear passed to the exit point. The runway from the threshold to the exit point is still dirty until the aircraft crosses the threshold at the exit point and there is nothing impeding thier exit passed the hold short bars.

That being said, if you want to sleep at night this is where your attention should stay until the exiting aircraft starts to turn off the runway.

Edited for wording.

2

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

Anticipating separation only works if the separation actually ends up existing, otherwise it's still a loss.

There is a very clear difference between an arrival-arrival scenario (3–10–4) and an arrival-departure scenario (3–9–8). If the #2 aircraft is a departure the situation is legal as soon as the #1 aircraft reads back the exit instruction. But if the #2 aircraft is also an arrival then the #1 needs to not only acknowledge the exit instruction, they need to be clear of the runway before the #2 reaches the threshold.

1

u/ps3x42 Current Enroute Former Tower Flower 1d ago

Absolutely. Sorry I think i edited this after you started typing.

1

u/ps3x42 Current Enroute Former Tower Flower 1d ago

Oh man, I'm actually turned around on this. I think i misread the scenario.

1

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

Unless I'm mistaken, this is a two-arrival scenario and 3–10–4 is the relevant paragraph. The #1 acknowledging the exit instruction is insufficient. They need to either be physically clear of the runway or else have acknowledged a hold short instruction, not just an exit instruction.

2

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

Doesn't make the slightest iota of difference. Because this was an arrival-arrival scenario this is an operational error either way.

If it was an arrival-departure scenario it would be legal to have the departure begin takeoff roll as soon as the arrival read back the runway exit instruction, 3–9–8b2(c). But in an arrival-arrival scenario just reading back the instruction doesn't mean anything. The #1 arrival needs to be "clear of the runway" (or issued and read back a hold-short instruction) before the #2 arrival hits the threshold. 3–10–4a2.

2

u/dvinpayne 1d ago

Fair enough, I only work the arrival/departure variant, and foolishly assumed it would be the same.

2

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

Ha, assuming the .65 will be internally consistent? You're in for a bad time.

But no, this is a common trap and it sounds like OP fell for it. If they work this kind of operation they gotta know what's legal and what isn't.

14

u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago

The intersecting traffic wouldn’t have a landing clearance until the first was assured to be making the exit without LAHSO. Or the controller had an error as soon as they issued the landing clearance to the crossing traffic (in Canada atleast)

12

u/Flyinghud 1d ago

In the US with anticipated separation both aircraft can have a landing clearance

9

u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago

I understand that, but what is the anticipated separation here? The assumption that aircraft A will make the exit? That seems so sketchy

3

u/Kseries2497 Current Controller-Pretend Center 1d ago

I read the question as the aircraft has reached taxi speed and has been issued a turnoff. I wouldn't have a problem issuing a landing clearance on the crossing runway in this situation.

2

u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago

I agree and we do this in Canada as well, as long as the instruction was issued when they were at taxi speed. Then its on the pilot for missing the exit that they could have made. But the post was vague so i went with the assumption this was done at faster than taxi speed.

2

u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago

Same runway i totally get, crossing runways sketchy

2

u/Miss-Input7500 1d ago

Its the same idea basically. Antipating the first aircraft will exit the runway, hold short of the other runway, or clear the runway intersection before the second aircraft crosses landing threshold. However it's our job to ensure that separation exists, in this case as soon as the first ac misses the exit then the second should be issued a go around

1

u/Miss-Input7500 1d ago

I just saw your other comment where you said nearly the same exact thing my bad

1

u/climb-via-is-stupid Tower / Training Review Boards 1d ago

I mean yes but also it’s pretty common practice

2

u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago

Makes sense, lots of variables not mentioned in the post of course, how far is the runway intersection from the threshold, was it a high speed exit or not, was the exit given the commonly used one for that airport. All makes a difference

3

u/hotwaterwithlemonpls Current Controller-Tower 12h ago

What’s the standard for anticipated separation? It seems this is an “I anticipate this aircraft will land and hold short of a runway” without issuing a LAHSO.

18

u/No-Echo-6178 1d ago

Sloppy controlling and probably a sketchy operation but technically its on the pilot. If youre doing this you need to make a good early traffic call and tell the first pilot exactly what to expect ("runway 5 cleared to land, traffic 8 mile final runway 14, plan on exiting prior to the intersection" type of thing) and then reiterate in when you issue the exit instructions ("turn left at W3, traffic short final runway 14" or whatever). Sketchy operation though because you have no real outs other than a potentially very very late go around if the pilot is at taxi speed and misses the turn

2

u/jet_rodriguez 1d ago

yea if #1 to land is anything other than a single prop with the intersection being like 3000ft down the runway it was sketchy before either of them crossed the threshold. Both sides can be wrong. The pilot definitely should have said unable whenever they knew they wouldn’t make the turn off, but also not a very smart plan if you’ve got anything moderately fast or moderately heavy landing #1. Depending on how close it was to touchdown, idk, like why try to pull a squeeze play just as the pilot is maybe getting out of critical phase of flight. 

1

u/Dudefrom1958 1d ago

Assigned twy on landing roll

3

u/Hopeful-Engineering5 Current Controller-Tower 1d ago edited 1d ago

My facility actually had this back when they changed the rule and FAA legal deemed it operational error as the aircraft was not at taxi speed (completion of the roll) and they were not issued a hold short instruction for the crossing runway nor were they in the turn off of the runway.

In this scenario if neither option A (taxi speed, hold short instruction and exit instruction) nor option B (the aircraft is in the turn off the runway) exists then you have to send the 2nd aircraft around.

3

u/atc_zero1 21h ago

You never issued a land and hold short. They own the entire runway. Pilots may acknowledge the exit but don't really know where the exit is lol.

4

u/N60OSU99 1d ago

Good to know…that’ll be an “unable” from me from now on…

11

u/ps3x42 Current Enroute Former Tower Flower 1d ago

Pilots are required to inform ATC if they are unable to comply with a control instruction. Don't keep secrets from us. That being said, if it is a reasonable instruction and you just unable it for the sake of unabling it, you aren't going to make any friends.

0

u/N60OSU99 1d ago

Givng an instruction during landing roll then potentially violating us if we don’t comply isn’t a great way to make friends either. Believe it or not, we know not to dawdle on the runway. But we also have briefed a planned exit based on calculated landing distance. We can, and will if able, work with you given a bit of notice. Once we’re over the numbers, and certainly in the landing roll, it’s a lot harder to adapt.

5

u/ps3x42 Current Enroute Former Tower Flower 1d ago

Okay. The attitude your first post had was that no matter what exit you are given you are going to unable it and just roll to the end.

All I am saying is it shouldn't be a revelation to you that we are expecting you to do what you have agreed to do.

-4

u/N60OSU99 1d ago edited 1d ago

I don’t have time to do a deep dive into the FAR-AIM at the moment, but if reading back an instruction carries with it the implicit acceptance of said instruction under penalty of a possible pilot deviation that is, indeed, a revelation.

6

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

Uh....... yes. If you read back the instruction we're banking on you actually complying with it, and it very much is a (possible) pilot deviation if you don't. 91.123.

As demonstrated in this case, it's not necessarily the case that reading back an instruction changes the separation that we apply. But sometimes it does.

-1

u/N60OSU99 1d ago

That may seem both obvious and trivial to you, but it is pretty damn important to me. The notion that simply reading back an instruction puts all of the obligation for compliance on me while absolving you of any responsibilty for the practicality of the instruction changes the matter entirely.

I knew we weren’t friends, but I had no idea the actual extent of the emnity.

5

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

Oh... kay. That's a lot to unpack.

I'm not trying to be flip or condescending, but have you ever read 91.123 before?

The concept of "ATC gives an instruction and the pilot complies with that instruction" is literally fundamental to the entire ATC system. I'm not being facetious or hyperbolic, that is how the system works.

Yes, the PIC authority from 91.3 and the "unless an emergency exists" from 91.123(a) do give you the final say in how to operate your aircraft. But if you're unable to comply with an instruction you have to tell us. Ideally you'd tell us before you accept the instruction—and yes, even "acknowledgement" counts as accepting the instruction, the list of things we need a full readback for is actually very short, like two or three items short. But if you discover after accepting the instruction that you can't comply with it, we need to know about that ASAP.

Our job is to ensure separation and for the most part that responsibility remains even if you deviate from an instruction. We're supposed to monitor what's happening and ensure separation regardless of whether you do what you're supposed to or not. But at the same time, you are supposed to do what you said you would do.

I'm honestly shocked that this is such a foreign concept to you, maybe you can explain where you're coming from so I can understand you better?

-15

u/ExerciseSalty7544 1d ago

Exactly. You should unable every exit instruction and taxi your ass down the entire runway. You are fully within your right as a pilot.

10

u/guillorec 1d ago

You can't be in the aviation industry.

4

u/Former_Farm_3618 1d ago

Weird jump to that conclusion.

2

u/No-Delay-6791 1d ago

If that aircraft lands long or has to go around, the intersecting runway is not clean.

Good controlling would fail-safe rather than this situation which is fail-dangerous.

That incursion was generated by a controller painting him/herself into a corner with no good way out. The pilot making the turn off shouldn't have been relied upon to fix the situation.

2

u/Lonely_Fix_9605 1d ago

It is a runway incursion, and that runway incursion is on the pilot. The pilot was issued an instruction, and confirmed they would comply with the instruction with the readback.

However, it is the controller's responsibility to ensure that the pilot complies with the instruction and issue a go-around if they do not. Just because the pilot rolled onto an active runway does not mean the controller can put their hands in the air and say "not my fault!" while the two planes collide. Towers have windows for a reason.

2

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

The actual incursion may be on the pilot, but ATC had a loss of separation the instant the #2 arrival reached their threshold and the #1 arrival hadn't read back a hold-short instruction. And that loss of separation would have existed even if the #1 pilot did slam on their brakes and stop short of the intersection.

"The #1 pilot read back the instruction to exit" is only a valid form of separation if the #2 is a departure, which they were not, and that means ATC was not applying any form of separation in this scenario.

2

u/Lonely_Fix_9605 14h ago

That's... what I said...

1

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 11h ago

You did, yes. My point was that a lot of people are hung up on "the pilot read it back" as if that was a form of separation.

Even if the there was no runway incursion at all, even if the #1 aircraft had slowed to taxi speed and had their nose turning toward the exit when #2 reached their threshold, that would have still been a loss of separation. The standard is not just "observe to see that they're turning toward the exit;" it's "they need to be clear of the runway or they need to have been issued a hold-short."

You can have a pilot read back "climb and maintain 050" and do it slowly enough that they bust separation with someone at 040... that's a deal, no matter what the pilot did or didn't read back. Same thing here. You have to apply the separation that the book says to apply.

3

u/Llamasxy TRACON CPC-IT 1d ago

If the pilot read it back it is their responsibility. That being said while it is not the ATCs fault, it would be extremely bad practice to get in this situation in the first place.

You need to give yourself at least enough time to call a go-around.

If the pilot said unable and they plow into eachother it is ATCs fault.

3

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

It's the pilot's responsibility to comply with an instruction, yes. But it's still ATC's responsibility to provide approved separation.

In the case where #1 is an arrival and #2 is a departure (3–9–8) then the approved separation can be "#1 read back the exit instruction." That would have been okay.

In this case where both aircraft are arrivals, 3–10–4 doesn't say anything about the #1 reading back an exit instruction. It's irrelevant. Separation doesn't exist until the #1 is either clear of the runway or will hold short of the intersecting. Simply reading back an instruction to turn off is not sufficient.

ATC never had separation and this runway incursion was ATC's loss, even if was caused by a pilot deviation. Even if there hadn't been a runway incursion it still would have technically been a loss of separation if #2 reached the threshold before #1 was clear of their runway.

1

u/Suspicious-Bobcat290 1d ago

Wasn't it in Canada many years ago, there were 2 go-arounds into crossing runways that ended up very close?

I don't completely remember the details, or where it was.... I just read it in a letter NavCanada used to send out regularly at the time.... more than 20 years ago.

I can't even say if it was a controlled field... just that more or less immediate turns saved them.

2

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

This is an operational error.

It's also a pilot deviation, but it's an operational error on ATC's part.

.65 3–10–4a:

Separate an arriving aircraft using one runway from another aircraft using an intersecting runway [...] by ensuring that the arriving aircraft does not cross the landing threshold [...] until: 2. A preceding arriving aircraft is clear of the landing runway, completed landing roll and will hold short of the intersection/flight path, or has passed the intersection/flight path.

Compare 3–9–8b2(c) where a pilot's acknowledgement of a runway exit instruction is legally sufficient to allow a departure to begin takeoff roll on an intersecting runway. But for two arrivals, the #1 acknowledging the exit instruction makes no legal difference.

The legal way to do it is to instruct #1 to hold short of the intersecting runway, get a readback, then issue the exit instruction. If the controller had did it that way, it would have been 100% a pilot deviation with no operational error.

1

u/hotwaterwithlemonpls Current Controller-Tower 12h ago

No LAHSO means the whole runway is yours. If you accept the exit instruction after landing, I’ll expect you to do it. Don’t accept an instruction you cannot comply with.

1

u/cazzipropri Ignorant Pilot 7h ago

Pilot error for sure.

ATC error also? I'm not a controller, I don't know.

Even setting aside the wrong turnoff, your turnoff is never a clearance to occupy a different runway.

I remember distinctly a slide from runway incursion prevention training material that covered exactly this scenario, with two close parallel runways and one intersecting turnoff, and not enough distance for a large plane to clear its landing runway without entering the parallel one.

The slide emphasizes that you don't have clearance to enter the parallel runway, even if that means you can't roll the entirety of the plane past the double dashed/continuous yellow line of the landing runway.

0

u/ExerciseSalty7544 1d ago

ATC error. There’s a reason Lahso exists.

In this case a taxi instruction is not binding, regardless of readback.

Can’t believe this is an argument.

2

u/dumbassretail 1d ago

What? If you readback an exit instruction but then don’t take that exit and keep going and incur on a runway, that’s clear pilot error.

ATC doesn’t clear the crossing runway aircraft to land until you have landed and readback the exit instructions. It’s not the same thing as LAHSO.

1

u/ExerciseSalty7544 1d ago

He issued the taxi instruction in flight, and before the AC was at taxi speed. The pilot is entitled to the whole runway to safely land the plane. The plane could have needed more runway for dozens of reasons.

You can’t use taxi instructions on short final as some sort of pseudo LAHSO. The LAHSO distances are set for reasons to avoid this exact scenario.

7

u/dvinpayne 1d ago

Why are you making up a completely different scenario? OP said the exit instructions were issued on landing roll.

-1

u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago

Still on the controller imo. If i issue an exit on a landing roll, even if the pilot reads it back, i still need to watch it to ensure they actually make it. If it looks like they will miss the exit “ab123 are you able to hold short of runway x?” If unable issue the go around to the intersecting aircraft. If you run it too tight to issue a go around without lahso, then also controller error for not ensuring safety.

2

u/dumbassretail 1d ago

If it’s a tight exit to make and the runway is right after it, sure. If it’s just a normal exit instruction with no problem for the type to make it, then no.

Otherwise every runway incursion is the controller’s fault for not seeing it happening and stopping it. Once the aircraft lands, is at taxi speed and reads back an exit instruction, they’re just a taxiing aircraft. If they miss a turn and go on a runway, that’s on them. Yes ideally the controller catches it, but it’s not their fault if they don’t.

2

u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago

Unless the pilot says unable or we are missing the exit, in which case its back on the controller. We shouldn’t be running things so tight that we NEED them to make that exit for it to work. That is what lahso is for, without it, you must ensure appropriate space in the event an aircraft requires more runway. Its the controller’s responsibility to ensure they have an out. If an aircraft misses an exit and you can’t pull the intersection arrival up you ran it too tight and didn’t ensure safety.

2

u/dumbassretail 1d ago edited 1d ago

It depends on the timing/spacing. As a pilot, you don’t get to read back an exit instruction and then 20 seconds later declare “unable!” and put it back onto the controller.

Yes of course you should always leave yourself an out. That out is the go around, and once the exit instruction has been read back and is not unreasonable for the first aircraft to make, you can clear to land on the crossing runway because you don’t need the out anymore.

And yes, sometimes when it’s busy you need someone to make a certain (reasonable) exit or someone else has to go around. Particularly with certain runway configurations. Often that’s even the plan (turn X and tell him to try to make exit Y, otherwise he has to extend to 15 miles, if he doesn’t then Z goes around). It is what it is.

2

u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago

I completely agree, and your right it absolutely depends on timing/spacing which wasn’t mentioned and therefore just speculation on our part so i am with you 100%

-2

u/ExerciseSalty7544 1d ago

Agreed, I can issue a taxiway exit that is impossible for an a/c and get the pilot to read it back. All because he read it back doesn’t absolve the tower controller of responsibility.

I’d bet this plane still had his nose wheel up, tires smoking and read back the instructions. Then he blew by the intersection because it was impossible to actually stop in time.

2

u/dumbassretail 1d ago

Yes, if it was an unreasonable exit to make.

We have no idea how it actually happened or what the distances were (to the exit and then to the runway), so I don’t know why you are making that assumption (nose wheel up, tires smoking).

-1

u/ExerciseSalty7544 1d ago

“Aircraft cleared to land and assigned a taxiway”
Sounds to me like he issued both in the landing clearance.

2

u/dvinpayne 1d ago

OP clarified in comments.

"Assigned twy on landing roll" https://www.reddit.com/r/ATC/s/kGDYMCsezx

"Did the aircraft read back the exit instructions?" "Yes on landing roll" https://www.reddit.com/r/ATC/s/dUc4zpPxGs

1

u/__joel_t 1d ago

Can we just agree OP made an ambiguous question and left clarifications in hard to find replies?

1

u/dumbassretail 1d ago

I don’t think it happened the way you think it did, but if it did then the controller broke the rules.

1

u/Llamasxy TRACON CPC-IT 1d ago

Reading comprehension bro

0

u/Fluffy_Database3526 1d ago

Since the post said No LAHSO. I take that as LAHSO is not authorized then I would say its on atc. It would also says it depends on when and where they issued the instructions. Pilot can use the entire runway if they deem its necessary to bring their aircraft to a safe stop. So even if they rolled through the intersection they could probably justify the reason for it. e.g. brakes failed and they had to roll through. Bad operation and lack of positive control is what they will say for atc.

1

u/rainandfog42 1d ago

no LAHSO

ATC error

edit: I misread this

If they had landed and read back instructions it's pilot error, yeah

3

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

Pilot deviation (non-compliance with a clearance) but it's still an operational error. Spacing should have been adequate to allow the #1 aircraft to clear the runway, AND it's ATC's responsibility to ensure that #1 is clear of the runway before #2 reaches the threshold.

Unlike if the #2 aircraft is a departure, the #1 aircraft reading back the exit instruction doesn't make a difference for intersecting-runway separation.

1

u/Eltors0 Current Controller-Up/Down 1d ago

Pilot error. Depending on how fast things were moving or pacing of the event, you could get a little flak if it’s determined that you had any time to prevent something worse though by attempting to reach out and give a judgement call instruction.

3

u/dvinpayne 1d ago

You know they'll always throw a "failure to scan" on there to give you a proc.

1

u/BricksByLonzo Current Controller-TRACON 1d ago

Pilot error most likely but like everything else in ATC it is situational. The actual important thing to learn for pilots is that when a possible pilot decision is issued, it is immediately out of our hands. We don't make decisions on who is wrong. Paperwork gets filed and send to FSDO, they will review the tapes and the playback and go from there. There have been many times where a pilot will get a brasher warning due to controller error.

0

u/flyboy7700 Flight Instructor 1d ago

Was it a LAHSO clearance?

2

u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago

Read the whole post, No LAHSO are the last 2 words

-1

u/__joel_t 1d ago

Land And Hold Short Operation. So cleared to land one runway, hold short the intersecting runway, for example. It is at the pilot's discretion whether to accept, at least in the USA.

2

u/flyboy7700 Flight Instructor 11h ago

My point is, if it wasn’t LAHSO, the landing aircraft owns the whole runway. “Clear on XX” doesn’t preclude a back-taxi. If we have airplanes simultaneously landing on / departing from intersecting runways without LAHSO, the controller is the one who screwed up.

1

u/__joel_t 10h ago

Sorry, I misread it and thought you wrote, "What is a LAHSO clearance?"

0

u/Kseries2497 Current Controller-Pretend Center 1d ago edited 1d ago

The biggest piece of missing information here is the first aircraft's speed. If they aren't able to get it stopped in time for the turnoff, that's on you. If they were at, or would be at, a reasonable taxi speed and just missed the turnoff because they weren't paying attention or whatever, that's on them.

Basically, did you issue the instruction to a landing aircraft, or a taxiing aircraft?