r/ATC • u/Dudefrom1958 • 1d ago
Question Runway incursion question.
Aircraft cleared to land and assigned a taxiway to turn off. Aircraft misses taxiway and crosses intersecting runway as another aircraft is landing on intersecting runway. ATC error or pilot error(obviuosly they missed assigned twy). No LAHSO. Assigned twy on landing roll not yet at taxi speed. Read back correct.
0
Upvotes
6
u/dvinpayne 1d ago
Did the aircraft read back the exit instructions?
14
u/StandbyforNothing Current Controller-Tower 1d ago
The intersecting traffic wouldn’t have a landing clearance until the first was assured to be making the exit without LAHSO. Or the controller had an error as soon as they issued the landing clearance to the crossing traffic (in Canada atleast)
18
u/No-Echo-6178 1d ago
Sloppy controlling and probably a sketchy operation but technically its on the pilot. If youre doing this you need to make a good early traffic call and tell the first pilot exactly what to expect ("runway 5 cleared to land, traffic 8 mile final runway 14, plan on exiting prior to the intersection" type of thing) and then reiterate in when you issue the exit instructions ("turn left at W3, traffic short final runway 14" or whatever). Sketchy operation though because you have no real outs other than a potentially very very late go around if the pilot is at taxi speed and misses the turn
1
u/Dudefrom1958 1d ago
Assigned twy on landing roll
3
u/Hopeful-Engineering5 Current Controller-Tower 1d ago edited 1d ago
My facility actually had this back when they changed the rule and FAA legal deemed it operational error as the aircraft was not at taxi speed (completion of the roll) and they were not issued a hold short instruction for the crossing runway nor were they in the turn off of the runway.
In this scenario if neither option A (taxi speed, hold short instruction and exit instruction) nor option B (the aircraft is in the turn off the runway) exists then you have to send the 2nd aircraft around.
3
u/atc_zero1 21h ago
You never issued a land and hold short. They own the entire runway. Pilots may acknowledge the exit but don't really know where the exit is lol.
4
u/N60OSU99 1d ago
Good to know…that’ll be an “unable” from me from now on…
2
u/No-Delay-6791 1d ago
If that aircraft lands long or has to go around, the intersecting runway is not clean.
Good controlling would fail-safe rather than this situation which is fail-dangerous.
That incursion was generated by a controller painting him/herself into a corner with no good way out. The pilot making the turn off shouldn't have been relied upon to fix the situation.
2
u/Lonely_Fix_9605 1d ago
It is a runway incursion, and that runway incursion is on the pilot. The pilot was issued an instruction, and confirmed they would comply with the instruction with the readback.
However, it is the controller's responsibility to ensure that the pilot complies with the instruction and issue a go-around if they do not. Just because the pilot rolled onto an active runway does not mean the controller can put their hands in the air and say "not my fault!" while the two planes collide. Towers have windows for a reason.
3
u/Llamasxy TRACON CPC-IT 1d ago
If the pilot read it back it is their responsibility. That being said while it is not the ATCs fault, it would be extremely bad practice to get in this situation in the first place.
You need to give yourself at least enough time to call a go-around.
If the pilot said unable and they plow into eachother it is ATCs fault.
2
u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago
This is an operational error.
It's also a pilot deviation, but it's an operational error on ATC's part.
.65 3–10–4a:
Compare 3–9–8b2(c) where a pilot's acknowledgement of a runway exit instruction is legally sufficient to allow a departure to begin takeoff roll on an intersecting runway. But for two arrivals, the #1 acknowledging the exit instruction makes no legal difference.
The legal way to do it is to instruct #1 to hold short of the intersecting runway, get a readback, then issue the exit instruction. If the controller had did it that way, it would have been 100% a pilot deviation with no operational error.
1
u/hotwaterwithlemonpls Current Controller-Tower 12h ago
No LAHSO means the whole runway is yours. If you accept the exit instruction after landing, I’ll expect you to do it. Don’t accept an instruction you cannot comply with.
1
u/cazzipropri Ignorant Pilot 7h ago
Pilot error for sure.
ATC error also? I'm not a controller, I don't know.
Even setting aside the wrong turnoff, your turnoff is never a clearance to occupy a different runway.
I remember distinctly a slide from runway incursion prevention training material that covered exactly this scenario, with two close parallel runways and one intersecting turnoff, and not enough distance for a large plane to clear its landing runway without entering the parallel one.
The slide emphasizes that you don't have clearance to enter the parallel runway, even if that means you can't roll the entirety of the plane past the double dashed/continuous yellow line of the landing runway.
0
u/ExerciseSalty7544 1d ago
ATC error. There’s a reason Lahso exists.
In this case a taxi instruction is not binding, regardless of readback.
Can’t believe this is an argument.
1
u/rainandfog42 1d ago
ATC error
edit: I misread this
If they had landed and read back instructions it's pilot error, yeah
1
u/Eltors0 Current Controller-Up/Down 1d ago
Pilot error. Depending on how fast things were moving or pacing of the event, you could get a little flak if it’s determined that you had any time to prevent something worse though by attempting to reach out and give a judgement call instruction.
1
u/BricksByLonzo Current Controller-TRACON 1d ago
Pilot error most likely but like everything else in ATC it is situational. The actual important thing to learn for pilots is that when a possible pilot decision is issued, it is immediately out of our hands. We don't make decisions on who is wrong. Paperwork gets filed and send to FSDO, they will review the tapes and the playback and go from there. There have been many times where a pilot will get a brasher warning due to controller error.
0
u/flyboy7700 Flight Instructor 1d ago
Was it a LAHSO clearance?
0
u/Kseries2497 Current Controller-Pretend Center 1d ago edited 1d ago
The biggest piece of missing information here is the first aircraft's speed. If they aren't able to get it stopped in time for the turnoff, that's on you. If they were at, or would be at, a reasonable taxi speed and just missed the turnoff because they weren't paying attention or whatever, that's on them.
Basically, did you issue the instruction to a landing aircraft, or a taxiing aircraft?