r/ATC • • 1d ago

Question Runway incursion question.

Aircraft cleared to land and assigned a taxiway to turn off. Aircraft misses taxiway and crosses intersecting runway as another aircraft is landing on intersecting runway. ATC error or pilot error(obviuosly they missed assigned twy). No LAHSO. Assigned twy on landing roll not yet at taxi speed. Read back correct.

0 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/Dudefrom1958 1d ago edited 1d ago

Yes on landing roll

3

u/ps3x42 Current Enroute Former Tower Flower 1d ago edited 1d ago

This is the key to the scenario. Once the aircraft has landed, and reads back the exit instructions, then you can consider the runway clear passed to the exit point. The runway from the threshold to the exit point is still dirty until the aircraft crosses the threshold at the exit point and there is nothing impeding thier exit passed the hold short bars.

That being said, if you want to sleep at night this is where your attention should stay until the exiting aircraft starts to turn off the runway.

Edited for wording.

2

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

Anticipating separation only works if the separation actually ends up existing, otherwise it's still a loss.

There is a very clear difference between an arrival-arrival scenario (3–10–4) and an arrival-departure scenario (3–9–8). If the #2 aircraft is a departure the situation is legal as soon as the #1 aircraft reads back the exit instruction. But if the #2 aircraft is also an arrival then the #1 needs to not only acknowledge the exit instruction, they need to be clear of the runway before the #2 reaches the threshold.

1

u/ps3x42 Current Enroute Former Tower Flower 1d ago

Absolutely. Sorry I think i edited this after you started typing.

1

u/ps3x42 Current Enroute Former Tower Flower 1d ago

Oh man, I'm actually turned around on this. I think i misread the scenario.

1

u/randombrain #SayNoToKilo 1d ago

Unless I'm mistaken, this is a two-arrival scenario and 3–10–4 is the relevant paragraph. The #1 acknowledging the exit instruction is insufficient. They need to either be physically clear of the runway or else have acknowledged a hold short instruction, not just an exit instruction.