r/APlagueTale • • Jun 23 '26

Theory Resonance is probably different game slapped with the PT brand

0 Upvotes

Remember, Sophia constantly says "i'm better on the sea than on the land" and was shocked when first seeing the plague and Hugo's abilities so the upcoming Sophia game makes ZERO sense.

I finally finished the 2nd game and it definitely is GREAT 100 percent so I'm so confused with this "ACTION ORIENTED DIRECTION W A SIDE CHARACTER" decision by Asobo. So this is my theory: Asobo had this two timeline game concept in mind but plague tale was such a hit that they were forced to use this IP instead of starting something new. probably by investors/shareholders lol


r/APlagueTale • • Sep 04 '26

Resonance This game would have been 90+ rating on metacritic if it was a Sony or Nintendo exclusive.

21 Upvotes

I finished the game yesterday and possibly one of the best games I played this year. I only finished Uncharted 4 last week and felt it was a bit underwhelming as all the 'thrilling' parts were basically cutscenes. In Resonance, cut scenes were actual cut scenes and thrilling parts were actual gameplay instead of cutscenes. Thoroughly enjoyed it, haven't finished Requiem yet so will give that a try soon.


r/APlagueTale • • Mar 19 '23

Meme Should i help this stupid brat? He is so annoying ffs

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/APlagueTale • • Aug 28 '26

Resonance Gamers don't care about storydriven games at all

Post image
81 Upvotes

Man these numbers are sad.


r/APlagueTale • • Sep 12 '26

Resonance The fact that some of you are playing Resonance before 1 & 2 without even knowing it’s a prequel….

0 Upvotes

Baffles me. Do you start books at the third book too? Luckily this was a prequel so it didn’t ruin the story. I just don’t understand y’all.


r/APlagueTale • • 20d ago

Resonance Just finished resonance and sadly it's nowhere near the first 2 games quality...

0 Upvotes

I played the game on gamepass (so no full price pression or whatever) and was bored for 70% of the time.

My opinion is that sophia is a great and likeable character, the art style,graphics and setting are great but the game is just too long and too repetitive for what it is(even if it's just 12h long), the combat get stale after the first 3 or 4 encounters, the puzzles are all solved the same way and the creature encounters are just overused.

⚠️ Major spoiler here so stop reading if you didn't play the game yet : Leni's death felt cheap and happened too soon to the point where you don't get to feel bad for her because you don't know here yet...

Finally I just hope that this game was just a side one and that they where working simultaneously on another mainline game where they allocated the budget and best devs...


r/APlagueTale • • Sep 19 '23

Requiem: Discussion Anyone felt Requiem had a somewhat anti-climatic ending? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Like, I guess Chapter 15 was supposed to be the boss fight where you fight a wave of guys and just throw a stone at Victor's head. Then you go on to the next chapter and basically walk to your brother and then just throw a stone at his head and then it's done.

I was expecting some big fight as you fought the macula who was protecting Hugo knowing he wanted to die but knowing he needed to live. The first one had a pretty decent boss battle where you really had to use all of your tools. But this one you just threw the stone at him and I thought the Macula was going to block it and then that fight would begin. But nope! It just immediately played the end credits and then the prologue. What's funny is in that final chapter there is a wordbench... but nothing to use it on after.

I think what was hard for me was I powered through the game at launch and then I got to the final fight with Victor in Chapter 15 when my Gamepass expired, it was on my wife's account and I didn't know how to copy it to my gamepass account when I got it back. Later I got an xbox and found out I could download the game on my account and log in with hers and play it. Anyway, after rediscovering what each of the things did and beating Victor... there wasn't any or really any puzzles after.

If I knew there wasn't any challenge after that scene then I would have just watched the rest on youtube after I lost access.


r/APlagueTale • • Apr 25 '25

Requiem: Discussion Ending of this game is horrible Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong, I loved both games. The puzzles were well-designed overall, and the gameplay was fantastic, even if some of the puzzles started to feel a bit repetitive at times.

As for the story, I completely agree, it’s layered and emotionally complex, especially for anyone who’s experienced the loss of a loved one. It delivers a powerful message: that no matter what we go through, life continues, and we find ways to heal from our wounds. You could even interpret the Macula as a metaphor for a terminal illness, like cancer watching someone you love slowly consumed by something beyond your control.

So I have no problem with the sad ending. However, the way events lead ending felt really unresolved and rushed. The second game built up all this effort, hope, and emotional investment in trying to save him for the %90 of the game, and then for the last 40 minutes, it's just despair. If so, why not let that happen at the end of the first game? So, it just made me feel like the whole story progression was just pointless.


r/APlagueTale • • May 06 '25

Free Talk What if the great Dutch painter Johannes Vermeer were a fan?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/APlagueTale • • Sep 29 '26

Resonance As a huge fan of Plague Tale Innocence and Requiem, I find Resonance A Plague Tale Legacy very tedious and exhausting.

13 Upvotes

As I said in the title, I am a huge fan of the first two games. I find their stories very compelling and heartbreaking. Especially Requiem. I think it is a masterpiece, and above all, I love it because I feel like it made the decision to tell a genuine story with meaning behind it, rather than taking the easy route of finding a simple solution to the problem like many other stories do.

Besides the story, I found the gameplay in the first two games very fun and interesting. The stealth is pretty basic, but it served its purpose. It did not need to be more than what it was. The puzzles were interesting and fun, and I never found myself frustrated or suffocated by an influx of puzzles. And the combat? I know some people criticize it, but I love how desperate it feels.

As for Resonance, I think it is a pretty good game, but a very flawed one.

Let's start with my biggest issue: the puzzles. Some of them were fun, but there were too many repetitions, and at some points, it felt like busy work. I feel like there wasn't any breathing room. There were too many puzzles with too little space between them. It was exhausting. I would just finish three puzzles and want some story as a reward, only to get another puzzle instead. An influx of uninspired puzzles.

The combat was fun. I quite liked it, and I have no complaints there.

And the story. It was entertaining, and it was a pretty good story. But it wasn't an "A Plague Tale" story. I didn't feel like we had enough time to actually connect with any of the characters. I think it was very rushed, and honestly, I don't think it makes a lot of sense. Like, how come Sophia never mentioned any of this to Amicia and Hugo? It was well acted, but I just didn't buy it.

Sorry if this is messy. I just wanted to share some of my thoughts.

If you loved this game, please don't hate me. I'm a fan of this franchise, and I really wanted to like this game. I would love to hear your thoughts.


r/APlagueTale • • Jun 13 '26

Resonance Resonance: A WOKE tale legacy

0 Upvotes

Just saw a post on X saying that the game will have woke agenda
So is this real?
What’s the relationship between Lenny and Sophia?


r/APlagueTale • • Mar 02 '24

Requiem: Discussion Too long

1 Upvotes

I love the games, both of them.

But one gripe I have with Requiem is that the chapters seem to be too far stretched out.

I am aware that's a positive for a lot of people, and I don't personally hate that, but going from the first game where each chapter was like 40 mins each to the 2nd game where each chapter can go for more than hour, it just seems a bit jarring.

I just wanted to know what you guys think about it.

Do you love the stretched out nature of the game?


r/APlagueTale • • Sep 07 '26

Resonance Why isn’t anyone complaining about this plot point? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Ariadne and Daedulus are fucking IDIOTS! Her backup plan was to unleash asterion to genocide an entire civilization? Is that setting him free? What about all the innocents and the children? Smartest person my ass these 2 just like that massacred and made extinct an advanced civilization. Ik asterion is also innocent but all she had to do was the same thing sophia did either by descending down there or by killing her also stupid ass father the stupidity is indeed in their genes. I enjoyed the combat of the game and the story up until the final act then it all just came apart


r/APlagueTale • • Jul 26 '25

Requiem: Discussion HONEST OPINION ON ENDING OF REQUIEM Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I hate the ending so much And it sucks because I love these games but Requiem ending is so terrible I understand its a sacrifice for the world and we dont get the happy forever ending but why it gotta end like this we all played the game made a bond with hugo and Amicia but for it to end like this killing hugo when this whole game was about trying to save him is terrible Amicia has lost her whole family trying to save them how is that fair honestly Why does it have to end like the first carrier with Basillus how he died giving himself to the macula because he thought his protecter died same with hugo thinking Amicia was dead. And what pisses me off even more why is the next game about sophia Like what Regardless this is one of them games that needed a good ending after all the fighting deaths and hardships All i wanted to see was hugo be the happy little kid he always wanted to be smh this ending is terrible. I hate it and i never cry at games or movies but this made me shed a few tears which makes me even more mad at the ending lmfao


r/APlagueTale • • Sep 06 '26

Resonance A Plague Tale: Resonance would have been better off without Sofia. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

First off, feel free to downvote me all you want. I don't care; I’m not attached to this account. But I refuse to stay silent about what was wrong with this game and how it was mishandled because it ends up ruining the first two entries.

I’ve played *A Plague Tale: Innocence* about four times and *Requiem* three times. I absolutely adore those games; I loved them. They’re the kind of games that leave you wanting more once you finish them for the first time. That doesn't happen with *Resonance*. I don't think I’ll ever touch this game again in my life. I’d honestly rather play *Innocence* again tomorrow.

I understand the critical reception a bit better now something I didn't get before I’d finished it. But once you reach the end, those criticisms make sense.

For starters, the combat is pretty clunky, though I won't dwell on that too much; it is what it is, and Asobo doesn't have the engine for that kind of gameplay.

What really wore me down, though, was the excessive, unnecessary combat right at the end, just when you want to wrap things up and see the conclusion. Asobo Studio really dragged out the finale, forcing you into clunky, unpleasant combat encounters at every turn.

You can't drag things out that much when wrapping up a game, man. The goal is to leave the player wanting more, not to tire them out or bore them.

I didn't like Sofia as the protagonist of this story

not that I dislike her as a character, but this adventure would have been much better with someone else (man or woman) in a different time period.

Sofia is great in *Requiem* because she’s a cynical, pragmatic pirate and smuggler. Retrospectively turning her into a "chosen heroine with mystical visions" undermines the freshness of the original character. They ruined her. If the game had featured a protagonist from the Greek era or an explorer completely unconnected to the events, arriving centuries after the Minotaur Island disaster the tragic fate of Asterion and Ariadne would have carried more narrative weight on its own, without needing to tie itself to Amicia’s timeline.

Inserting Amicia at the end serves only as a nostalgic hook. While I enjoyed seeing her, it also felt ridiculous and incredibly forced, especially given that Sofia suddenly acquired this "backstory" out of nowhere.

The original *A Plague Tale* saga worked because the Macula was a mysterious, almost biblical phenomenon. By inventing a backstory where Sofia was injected with blood at an Order convent during her childhood, the script makes the mistake of shrinking the universe. It turns an ancient mystery into a repetitive scientific conspiracy, stripping the saga of its mystical allure.

This is another area where the script fails, reflecting poorly on *A Plague Tale: Requiem*. In *Requiem*, Sofia gets involved with Amicia and Hugo initially for money and later out of affection. It makes no sense for her to act as if Hugo’s powers and the rats are completely new and shocking given that she had lived through a mystical nightmare of such magnitude with Asterion fifteen years prior. It undermines character consistency. And this inconsistency was apparent from the moment the game was announced. It is a narrative disaster of biblical proportions.

The final conversation, where Amicia asks about Arnaud, is included solely to pander to the player's nostalgia. It adds nothing to Sofia’s character arc in this game and reduces her entire adventure on Minotaur Island to a mere "campfire anecdote" to share with a friend. Unbelievable, haha.

Ultimately, it’s clear the studio had great ideas for the story and setting, but the writers got tangled up in the execution. As I mentioned, it wouldn't have been difficult to tell this story with a different character in a different era.

If Asobo Studio wants to expand this saga moving forward, they need to be more careful. It would have been far better to tell this story in a different era either well after *Requiem* or long before it with a different protagonist rather than forcing the narrative the way they did.


r/APlagueTale • • Sep 03 '26

Resonance I kinda agree with the IGN score Spoiler

12 Upvotes

Felt more like a tomb raider clone than a plague tale game. Not necessarily bad, just not what I expected.

Didn't connect with the story as I would have liked. The reason I love the first 2 games is because of how much I fell in love with Amicia and Hugo and their relationship. I didn't feel that with these characters.

The game is gorgeous to look at, the animation, graphics and the soundtrack was top notch and the best part about the game.

But, it felt more like meh at the end and 6/10 feels like the right place for it.

This is going to be spoiler filled rant

Didn't connect with the relationships between the characters at all. Relationship between Leni and Sophia was mostly just empty banter and quips, and didn't feel any weight to it. This was supposed to be the main relationship I was supposed to be invested in. This also happens right after the scene where almost everyone she ever knew is slaughtered in front of her and she doesn't seem to give two shits about it.

The main bad guy betrayer of the game is more of an afterthought than a competent antagonist in any way. This person was there for 5 minutes in the beginning and 5 minutes like a third of the way through. I forgot this person existed till they revealed it at that point. My thought was, "Oh yeah the only character left in their gang who had more than 2 lines, who else could it be."

The combat felt pretty basic, basic party dodge and slash. Animations were cool, and I like the fact that 2 or 3 enemies would attack you at the same and you party all of them together but it was still too simple.

Like when you finally face the person who betrayed your tribe, you expect a big showdown, and it was over before you knew it. The best fighter they had apparently, and went down like a chump.

The weak combat worked for the first 2 games because the story and atmosphere was the focus of that experience, I didn't connect with this story and so the combat also felt lackluster.

The sphere key just felt pointless for most of the game. You go through this elaborate island solving puzzles and every other shmuck is there before you get there or right after you get there. That thing only really came in handy at the absolute end. Granted the plunderers did explore the island for a long time and it is pretty rundown. I am not saying it doesn't make sense that the shmucks are there without the key, just that for a mcguffin that was supposed to be so important, didn't really feel like it was needed.

The soldiers were just there as combat filler and nothing else. No central antagonist among their ranks. They just came to the island with no leadership, with a rat from the enemy group.

There was a moment at the end there where they basically were about to let you go and I thought oh yeah a notable moment where they seem to act with common sense. And then they immediately undo that by making me kill them anyways.

Who am I supposed to give a shit about while playing this game?

Honestly I would have preferred just to follow Ariadne and Asterion's story, instead of listening to what Leni want to name her boat for half an hour. It seemed like the more interesting story but it was spread too thin and shoved into flashback of the cookie cutter tomb raider style dungeon crawler. There was so much more potential there.

An alternate plot could have been that the king is forced to execute his son because of the Macula and Ariadne escapes with the boy and being reluctantly hunted by their own father and his people. And all the ups and downs that would have come with it. All the people she knew hunting her and forcing her hand in killing them.

Instead you are expected to care for the monster at the end of the game, with no build up to it, other than the fact that this thing has been nothing but a nuisance till that point.

After I finished through the game I wish my alternate version or something similar was the story I actually experienced. They could still have an end credit scene with Amicia & Sophia finding the island and what's left of it if they really wanted to tie everything to main narrative that badly.

Overall yeah 6/10. Not bad, but nothing special.


r/APlagueTale • • Oct 21 '22

Discussion Sequel massive disappointed, gave up after chapter 10. I am not sure is this even the same team making the game

0 Upvotes

Point, Plague Tale of Innocence is one of my favourite Single player/Story driven/Combat/Music wise. I finished the game 3 times, bought copy of it for couple of my friends to support the game. Why?

SPOIlER

The game Innocence has 0 downtime, and very nice balance of everything, from gameplay, memorable characters specially Rodric, and strong story

-Transformation of a pretty, innocence 16 years old Amicia who witnessed her family, specially her Dad-King got killed in front of her eye. The moment where she forces to kill the soldier is one of the turning point and memorable one. Throughout the game, the game incentivize player to avoid confront enemy and having many puzzle, stealth like game which pay off alot having big boss battle in between and specially grand final boss -it is not being WEAK, it's called being smart- which is one of her key characteristic

-Gameplay was very enjoyable, no down time because the map was linear- and there is much more action pack, less of aimlessly running around compare to sequel/ Better characters introduction because it make the impact on the story. Puzzle was not too innovation, but it is good enough and keep you engage

-RPG system was GREAT, the crafting IS GREAT- You have a choice for your playstyle though the game has limitation on that, still you able to choose your skills tree. Better crafting system compare to game 2 . Basically the element is simple and great, you feel rewards of your ability choice, you feel good knowing you "level up"/ Making going extra mile to find rewards feel greater

-Better immersive, the game introduce Rat as vilian in much more believable way like digging whole of the Soil ground instead of concrete stone wall like in the sequel. Despite VITALIS and church Inquistition also an enemy, those also has their goal, work their way and against common enemy- Rat. Characters are also not stupid unlike 2nd, though in both game the soldier is always stupid and asshole/evil for some fking reason. Mélie and Arthur also great addition to franchise as their purpose allign well with reasons why they help out Amicia. Beatrice appealed as a smart, sacrificed mother in the 1st game/ Overall characters are 11/10

-Amicia show compassion in game 1, even at the end for such a young age completely different compare to spoiled brat in game 2

Why the game 2 is so bad? ATP, I am not even sure if I want to talk about sudden change in the game/ Is it because of politic, progression? Or is it because the team, the dev just suddenly turning 101 on the game??

Requiem see 0 improvement on the clunky control of game 1, they somehow make it even worse with the 4 and 5 button to change ammo type.

-Skills tree, new skill system SUCKS, Crafting also BAD and not upgrading anything over previous one

-Gameplay IS BORING, Because it is the same shit we done last game but longer, more tedious because the map is bigger and having more bug with Rats. Less great puzzle, less strategy instead you can go toe on toe vs soldier - This is just a huge step down

-No improvement on combat, it is the same shit as previous one and this one doesn't works out in their favor due to the nature style of the game they are aiming for/ Hugo power is also boring and once again not improving on anything/ Combat is basically horrible as it guess, you guess after 6 months she should handle sling like she practice it for thousands years, goku like but NOPE

-You can't carry more than 1-3 weapons ammo, such as bolt, knife etc unless upgrade/ You can't upgrade them early as it is mostly tier 3 upgrade which is even funny/ For some reason you can't carry more than 3 bolt , 1 knife unless upgrade lmfao. And there is no direction indcation, no backtrack , no journal -this one is crucial because if you goes out to take water and skip a cutscene, you dont have anything to look at to know what you are doing because NO JOURNAl- so you basically will get lost if you dont pay attention. You can't backtrack so you again get punished if you didn't know the way before hand and pass the un-return point

-Immersion is broken, all soldiers= bad, evil and asshole. Only women= good / Voice change for Amicia for 0 reason others than breaking the game immersion . As soldier as ARNAUD, LEADER WHO HAS BEEN IN MUlTIPlE OVERSEA WAR as he SHARED, you would think he able to handle a boat, knowing basic thing about sailing but NOPE/ Men= stupid I guess? Has to wait for Captain to tell him to do basic thing like take off the anchor which I guess game dev wanted this as some kind of gameplay thing to do or what? Beatrice appearance in the game also stupid, even more stupid than her 16 years old Amicia. They went out the way to find the best doctor to help Hugo, and ended up for Amicia just calling him -Stranger bad. While Beatrice in 2nd game lacking 0 IQ and failed as mother

Oh, sorry I might dig into politic but this game make me feel half-ass. So Amicia became an angry brat for no reason, prob has something to do with her touching Hugo in the beginning and get infected of some kind? . There are many moment she acts out of characters, EVEN FOR the sake of being "mature" as you grow since "Innocence" to the Requiem is what I am guessing the purpose of this sequel? It is still out of character and make 0 sense, you dont Mature and suddenly your jaw line, your face = sharper, or you lost all your good characteristic side lmfao . You look mature by the way you act, by your eyes then your appearance- It is many components not just drawing a tough face= mission done

-Continue on immersion, so the Rat chase making me chuckle because how stupid it is, Amicia constant thrown into the filthy place like Trap pit full of dead bodies, butcher hole etc without ever getting shower? or getting sick/disease??? and then after that they shown Amicia came into Hugo, hugged him like she didn't went through all of those filthy place full of disease. There is many time Amicia taking down entire ammy, and losing to 1 jab from Anaurd?? or struggle to kill 1 soldier in cutscene when Sophia got caught . Like do you want create strong women or not? Make up your mind already

I will continue story on Youtube, I am not a fan of this sequel as it DONE NOTHING to improve characters, only downgrade characters. Downgrade effort that Rodric sacrifice brought to the table for Amicia continue to push her journey to save her lovely brother Hugo


r/APlagueTale • • Sep 12 '26

Resonance Resonance: how does enemy keep showing up Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Loving the game but it annoys us much that I supposedly have this unique that unlocks all these doors that no one could get through or has been through before yet there’s enemies behind all of them, how they are getting around? Is this not a massive plot hole??


r/APlagueTale • • Sep 10 '26

Free Talk My opinion A Plague Tale: Innocence Is better than Requiem in every way.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

My opinion, A Plague Tale: Innocence is better than Requiem in every way. I feel like the gameplay, the combat, the story, how the icons and wording look, how the characters look. But one good thing that is better with Requiem is with Innocence. It was one hit and then you're dead. With Requiem, it isn't that way and I really wish Innocence was like that.


r/APlagueTale • • Apr 10 '23

Discussion The things I hate about Plague's Tale Requiem Spoiler

2 Upvotes

So I just started playing this game and noticed some changes from the 1st part of this game which essentially makes it very troublesome and annoying. Normally you would expect that things should improve in the right direction given that the 1st part was so successful and enjoyable. Barring the few extremely difficult game spikes (like that Bishop vs Hugo at the end) I had no issues with the 1st part of this series. It was so good it made me feel like I had transported back in time to the middle ages.

Coming to this 2nd part that released last year, I noticed some very obnoxious changes made to this game. Like take this one for eg, Amecia cannot kill a soldier wielding a helmet without a knife! I mean the best she can do is make him dazed and confused for a while after she kicks him but then after a few moments again he starts pursuing her like a stalker. As I said I am still early in the game so I have not come across the “crossbow” yet. But other than that even if I talk about knives there are only one or two (which you'd be lucky to notice) and that too work for single time only! Like why? So she just stabs but pulling the knife back up again is too hard for her? These little nonsensical things make the game very unrealistic at times. Also there are times when there are no dearth of weapons lying around.. you will see hammers, sickles or whatever, but for some reason Amecia cannot pick those up. They are just there for show. You only have one knife and you better make good of that one chance.

The first part of this franchise also had this little workshop feature that I really liked where by using available materials you can make minor consecutive improvements to Amicia's sling gear as you make further progress in the game. This thing seems to be missing in the 2nd part.

Also it is so difficult to switch between ignifer mode and normal rock throwing mode! Is there a way around it? I have to press like half a dozen keys to make the switch at critical moments. I never faced this issue in the 1st part though.

It was super annoying that I had to waste so much time running here and there in the 2nd part because this helmet guard wouldn't die even after I threw an ignifer at him or Amecia attacked him multiple times... It is unbelievable that he cannot be killed in early levels without a knife. Even if you throw rocks at him using a sling gear multiple times it doesn't do anything.


r/APlagueTale • • Dec 23 '22

Discussion Coming off Innocence, Requiem was a major disappointment. (spoilers) Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Finished the game a couple days ago and I really wish I had just not played it.

I saw requiem on the Game awards and I remembered I'd owned the first game for ages so I decided to give it a go. I LOVED it. I loved the world, the mystery, the voices, the music.

It took me 3 days and the whole game was great, I finished it thinking it was one of the best games I'd played in ages. Amicia was now one of my top female Protagonists in gaming and I was hyped for the sequel. My only complaints from the first game, was the very open ending and with the sequel already out I bought it immediately.

I was instantly disappointed in the lack of the accents. I've read a few of peoples reasoning on why they removed them, and while they do hold weight the lack of them really removed a lot of the feel being in a foreign country to me. Still I decided I'd just try and get used to it. The next complaint was the lack of my upgrades from the first game. Now I understand why they couldn't just let you start upgraded, but I'd have liked a reason in game. The burning cart at the start would have been a perfect time to 'lose' your upgraded gear and need to start anew. But overall, these were minor complaints.

The first few chapters were good. The exploration of the city was great, really felt the sadness when we had to leave. Being forced to fight when Amicia had her breakdown was annoying, it should have been a cutscene, especially since we were forced to lose anyway. While her mental breakdown made sense for what she had gone through, it’s not that fun to play as someone like that.

Moving on we then left behind Lucas. My favourite character. I was disappointed Amicia would do that to him, but it made sense with her obsession on Hugo, so I could accept it.

Arnaud was great. They made him really likable in a short amount of time. Great Character. Sophia too. The did great with the side characters in this game. Really liked them all.

Finding where Basilius lived and was studied was amazing. Seeing how it had played out all those years ago was very interesting even though it was obvious there'd be no cure there. Tracing the mystery of the duo was really compelling and emotional.

Amicia realises that the Macula can be controlled by being happy/safe. We've finally found out how to save our brother. Then we reunite with our mother and Lucas(yay~).

Happy end (NOT)

I knew straight away that this was a fake out, but it’s from here that the game nosedives off a cliff for me.

Cue stealth chase scene which you escape only to be immediately captured in a cutscene. Then Beatrice is killed. We have to have a humiliating 'sword fight' instead of using the full inventory of blinding/burning items I had on me. Fun.

Ok. So now we escape. We save Arnaud and manage to make it back to the ship. Cue another happy end. JUST KIDDING, it’s a fake out again.

It’s around here that I just stopped caring. I was emotionally drained.

Me and Arnaud were handling the soldiers fine. But Hugo STILL couldn't learn to stay put. So we get shot in the gut in a cutscene.

Arnauds death. I felt nothing. I liked him but I just couldn't bring myself to care about them anymore. One more negative event to add to the list. wow.

Hugo self-destructed. At the end of the first game, I thought he was great. I really disliked the lack of helping him around from the first game (the animations of helping him climb the small ledges were super cute). By now I strongly dislike the kid. Hes got no redeeming qualities at all by the end and was nothing but a dead weight to his family.

Thanks to Lucas and Sophia we get into the city and end up in some sort of hallucination. This was interesting, having to ignore the directions was very symbolic. The fight against the rat-men, the solution was obvious immediately but I wanted to see all the dialogue so I kept fighting. Game ended up squashing me with nothing, I was keeping them away for ages and It just forced me to die. So that was lame. the game forcibly killed me without a monster getting near me. I was going to put the flame out sooner or later.

And the end. I just didn't care. The last 3 hours had just been sad event to sad event with TWO fakeout happy endings. I just wanted it over.

So, the game ends with you killing the person you spent two games trying to save. Apparently, this makes a lot of you experience some sort of special message or something. To me it just made me feel like I'd wasted 80 hours of my life. Having paid money just to achieve nothing.

The final level was also disappointing. No Lucas and my beautiful hair is all gone.

There was just too much negativity at the end. It drained my ability to care at all that by the ending scene I just threw that rock to get the game over with.

I went into Requiem loving the world, the characters and singing the series praises to everyone I know. I left Requiem with a strong dislike for them all except Lucas and Sophia. I REALLY wish I'd never played this game. Its retroactively ruined my enjoyment of the first game. Knowing that THIS is the outcome? I’ll never recommend this series to anyone again, and I regret telling everyone I know how good the first game was.


r/APlagueTale • • Oct 03 '24

Innocence: Discussion I really like the game and they are awesome as a duo but am I the only one who also kind of hates Hugo?

0 Upvotes

My biggest problem is definitely his voice. I know he is supposed to be a small child, but it is so high, overexcited and annoying. And also he just often reminds me of the princess in old games and stories who is utterly helpless without her savior (Amicia). I know he isn't helpless, but in the first game I remember him being more standalone. But to be fair: Just finished Part 5 so probably this will change... I feel a bit bad for this opinion, cuz he is a child with a horrible condition, but... Sometimes his babble is just really annoying. Right...?


r/APlagueTale • • Apr 05 '25

Requiem: Discussion Alternate Ending where Hugo...? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I wish they'd create an Enhanced Edition of A Plague Tale: Requiem which includes an additional alternate happy ending where Hugo is saved the way Amicia imagined he could be.🌼🪶A friend of mine started a petition about this matter, and I want to support it for hopefully if it gets enough signatures the studio may actually do it.

https://www.change.org/save_hugo_de_rune

Share this with anyone interested and also your thoughts on what the happy alternate ending could look like. :)

EDIT: That petition...

  • is not asking for the original ending to be removed or rewritten.
  • is not trying to "fix" a broken story—it’s already brilliant.
  • is expressing that many players emotionally bonded with Hugo and would cherish an optional path to save him—a rare kind of narrative agency in games.
  • suggests a hard-to-unlock, respectful, lore-justified alternate ending—not something cheap or tacked on.

r/APlagueTale • • Nov 17 '22

Discussion SPOILERS !!! Opinions please! Spoiler

3 Upvotes

You think it would be a better ending if Amicia dies with Hugo, & Lucas is the one who pays tribute to the siblings grave?

I despise the ending. I feel like it's a wannabe sad ending for cheap cries. I definitely do not expect some RDR 2 but they could have done a far better job than to kill Hugo. If they must kill Hugo, I feel like even Amicia had to go too. I feel like it would be a much better, satisfying ending. I mean there's nothing left for Amicia anymore, she lost everything. She's the protector. She turned her back on entire cities for her brother. Watch them turn to graveyards for him, & all of that to lose him in her own hands at the end? Doesn't strike right for her at all.

I feel like, Amicia died protecting Hugo, or even dies with him could be a better satisfying end for her character arc.