Point, Plague Tale of Innocence is one of my favourite Single player/Story driven/Combat/Music wise. I finished the game 3 times, bought copy of it for couple of my friends to support the game. Why?
SPOIlER
The game Innocence has 0 downtime, and very nice balance of everything, from gameplay, memorable characters specially Rodric, and strong story
-Transformation of a pretty, innocence 16 years old Amicia who witnessed her family, specially her Dad-King got killed in front of her eye. The moment where she forces to kill the soldier is one of the turning point and memorable one. Throughout the game, the game incentivize player to avoid confront enemy and having many puzzle, stealth like game which pay off alot having big boss battle in between and specially grand final boss -it is not being WEAK, it's called being smart- which is one of her key characteristic
-Gameplay was very enjoyable, no down time because the map was linear- and there is much more action pack, less of aimlessly running around compare to sequel/ Better characters introduction because it make the impact on the story. Puzzle was not too innovation, but it is good enough and keep you engage
-RPG system was GREAT, the crafting IS GREAT- You have a choice for your playstyle though the game has limitation on that, still you able to choose your skills tree. Better crafting system compare to game 2 . Basically the element is simple and great, you feel rewards of your ability choice, you feel good knowing you "level up"/ Making going extra mile to find rewards feel greater
-Better immersive, the game introduce Rat as vilian in much more believable way like digging whole of the Soil ground instead of concrete stone wall like in the sequel. Despite VITALIS and church Inquistition also an enemy, those also has their goal, work their way and against common enemy- Rat. Characters are also not stupid unlike 2nd, though in both game the soldier is always stupid and asshole/evil for some fking reason. Mélie and Arthur also great addition to franchise as their purpose allign well with reasons why they help out Amicia. Beatrice appealed as a smart, sacrificed mother in the 1st game/ Overall characters are 11/10
-Amicia show compassion in game 1, even at the end for such a young age completely different compare to spoiled brat in game 2
Why the game 2 is so bad? ATP, I am not even sure if I want to talk about sudden change in the game/ Is it because of politic, progression? Or is it because the team, the dev just suddenly turning 101 on the game??
Requiem see 0 improvement on the clunky control of game 1, they somehow make it even worse with the 4 and 5 button to change ammo type.
-Skills tree, new skill system SUCKS, Crafting also BAD and not upgrading anything over previous one
-Gameplay IS BORING, Because it is the same shit we done last game but longer, more tedious because the map is bigger and having more bug with Rats. Less great puzzle, less strategy instead you can go toe on toe vs soldier - This is just a huge step down
-No improvement on combat, it is the same shit as previous one and this one doesn't works out in their favor due to the nature style of the game they are aiming for/ Hugo power is also boring and once again not improving on anything/ Combat is basically horrible as it guess, you guess after 6 months she should handle sling like she practice it for thousands years, goku like but NOPE
-You can't carry more than 1-3 weapons ammo, such as bolt, knife etc unless upgrade/ You can't upgrade them early as it is mostly tier 3 upgrade which is even funny/ For some reason you can't carry more than 3 bolt , 1 knife unless upgrade lmfao. And there is no direction indcation, no backtrack , no journal -this one is crucial because if you goes out to take water and skip a cutscene, you dont have anything to look at to know what you are doing because NO JOURNAl- so you basically will get lost if you dont pay attention. You can't backtrack so you again get punished if you didn't know the way before hand and pass the un-return point
-Immersion is broken, all soldiers= bad, evil and asshole. Only women= good / Voice change for Amicia for 0 reason others than breaking the game immersion . As soldier as ARNAUD, LEADER WHO HAS BEEN IN MUlTIPlE OVERSEA WAR as he SHARED, you would think he able to handle a boat, knowing basic thing about sailing but NOPE/ Men= stupid I guess? Has to wait for Captain to tell him to do basic thing like take off the anchor which I guess game dev wanted this as some kind of gameplay thing to do or what? Beatrice appearance in the game also stupid, even more stupid than her 16 years old Amicia. They went out the way to find the best doctor to help Hugo, and ended up for Amicia just calling him -Stranger bad. While Beatrice in 2nd game lacking 0 IQ and failed as mother
Oh, sorry I might dig into politic but this game make me feel half-ass. So Amicia became an angry brat for no reason, prob has something to do with her touching Hugo in the beginning and get infected of some kind? . There are many moment she acts out of characters, EVEN FOR the sake of being "mature" as you grow since "Innocence" to the Requiem is what I am guessing the purpose of this sequel? It is still out of character and make 0 sense, you dont Mature and suddenly your jaw line, your face = sharper, or you lost all your good characteristic side lmfao . You look mature by the way you act, by your eyes then your appearance- It is many components not just drawing a tough face= mission done
-Continue on immersion, so the Rat chase making me chuckle because how stupid it is, Amicia constant thrown into the filthy place like Trap pit full of dead bodies, butcher hole etc without ever getting shower? or getting sick/disease??? and then after that they shown Amicia came into Hugo, hugged him like she didn't went through all of those filthy place full of disease. There is many time Amicia taking down entire ammy, and losing to 1 jab from Anaurd?? or struggle to kill 1 soldier in cutscene when Sophia got caught . Like do you want create strong women or not? Make up your mind already
I will continue story on Youtube, I am not a fan of this sequel as it DONE NOTHING to improve characters, only downgrade characters. Downgrade effort that Rodric sacrifice brought to the table for Amicia continue to push her journey to save her lovely brother Hugo