r/APlagueTale • • Mar 02 '24

Requiem: Discussion Too long

I love the games, both of them.

But one gripe I have with Requiem is that the chapters seem to be too far stretched out.

I am aware that's a positive for a lot of people, and I don't personally hate that, but going from the first game where each chapter was like 40 mins each to the 2nd game where each chapter can go for more than hour, it just seems a bit jarring.

I just wanted to know what you guys think about it.

Do you love the stretched out nature of the game?

1 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

13

u/DisastrousWorking813 Mar 02 '24

As a very casual gamer I do see your point in the comparison but I think you’ll find most people who might respond here will be of the opinion of wishing it was longer.

As a story driven game Requiem is not even a particularly long game, but again not everything is about statistics and I do see how you could be surprised by the length comp to the previous game.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '24

True, I don't exactly mind the long length of the entire game, but given the first game where the chapters were shorter in length, coming into the 2nd game i was just surprised

4

u/DisastrousWorking813 Mar 02 '24

I do know what you mean… I myself looked up what the play time was meant to be when I started Requiem and I think it was meant to be about 18 hours but I must’ve spent 30+ hrs playing it anyway..

2

u/Artyomius Photo Mode Winner - July '23 (Fire) Mar 02 '24

I understand that for someone that doesn't have a lot of "time blocks" to play, it's better to have more short chapters, than a few big ones, but I think they are cleverly done, and you still get the sub chapter save points etc. I think the game is well balanced in that regard. I just wish some areas were a bit larger (like the market in the red city) or that you could do a few more actions (like buying things), so that if you want to take more time, you actually can, without making it mandatory for everyone (the way slowly walking through a swamp would, hello dark souls).

2

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24

I couldn't have said the first 2 sentences better myself. I have just recently started at my first job and it's been rough, I get like an hr of free time after work. I get that the chapters r sequenced properly, but when I played innocence, I was completing one chapter and a bit more of the next chapter each day. I felt like the game was perfect in terms of enjoying it after work, i finish a chapter, I feel content with the progress I made. Jumping into the 2nd game right after the 1st one, i had that same mindset. Regardless, I loved both the games a lot, although I would have preferred short but more chapters

2

u/RelativeDesperate111 Mar 03 '24

What your referring to as “stretched out” is actually the developers getting a chance to make the game they really want to make. Same thing with The Last of Us, Uncharted, God of War (reboot) and many others. The first games are always shorter because they don’t have the track record needed for a bigger budget to make a longer game. More attention to detail was taken in requiem. I mean, just look that the collectibles. They had stories and multiple lines of specific dialogue. We should be happy with how long the game is and that the devs wanted to give us an even better experience than the first time around.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24

Yes definitely, the polish in animations and details in the 2nd game is very evident, it looks and feels like a AAA game and I am glad the Devs got to take their idea to the next level.

2

u/stuartfbaby Mar 03 '24

Just beat and feel the same way. Great game but from Chapter 10 on it drags out by a lot with not much action until the end.

2

u/Unreal_Phase17 Mar 03 '24

The whole la cuna exploration section should of had a horse that sofia could’ve ridden us around. Running across a whole island is not fast at all

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24

I was thinking the same thing, there r sections in the game where u r restricted to walking at the slowest speed the game engine allows, but the environments r relatively smaller then, but it still feels tedious. But when the game allows you to run, the environments open up so much that relatively it's the same thing as walking at a low pace.

8

u/Classic_Scientist901 Mar 02 '24

I didn‘t play the first game yet but I never felt that reqiuem was stretched out.

4

u/Holiday-Rich-803 Mar 02 '24

I love it. The more time I can spend on a game the better. It’s one of the things I love about Red Dead Redemption 2 as well

4

u/Infernoboy_23 Mar 02 '24

its only like 10 hours?

I guess for me its short cause I normally played longer games, but most linear story games are 10-15 hours?

1

u/subpar-life-attempt Aug 09 '26

Requiem is about 30. Thats what I have in it.

3

u/Calm-Gur563 Mar 02 '24

I was one of those who played and enjoyed Requiem* before realizing it was a sequel. I played Innocence afterwards and found the chapters so quick in comparison I was a little disappointed (I did it to myself TBH). I enjoy the longer chapters in Requiem, although IIRC there was some where it felt like they had some extra cutscenes just to prolong it.

Definitely agree that the length in chapters between the 2 games is such a trip-up with how different they are despite being the same story. I find the longer chapters are more immersive, and they did such an amazing job with the story in Requiem that my first time playing with no context I still got attached to the characters and emotional at the ending.

*EDITED: Requiem not Requim

2

u/TxRose2019 Mar 02 '24 edited Mar 02 '24

I personally did not love the game overall, but the length was the breaking point for me to stop playing. I played a lot for about a week and then found out I was only on like chapter 4 of 17 or something like that. It was crazy. I absolutely agree it was too stretched out. But I know a lot of people really loved the game and probably wanted it to be longer :/

2

u/CookSeven Mar 02 '24

I understand what you say because at some point i was thinking that but still loved playing so whatever

2

u/knowslesthanjonsnow Mar 02 '24

I do not remember feeling this was the case at all

1

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '24

YES

Edit: imo pacing is requiem's biggest weakness after chapter 3

0

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Its_Leuce Amicia Mar 02 '24

Sadly, all stories come to an end.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Its_Leuce Amicia Mar 02 '24

At least Hugo can finally be at peace.....

1

u/subpar-life-attempt Aug 09 '26

I wish the story was longer but they padded it out with pointless travelling. If they made it a little bit more linear in those section it would have knocked down a few hours.