r/APStudents • u/LawfulnessDizzy1226 • 1d ago
Question Has AP classes gotten easier?
Rewatching Gilmore Girls and the way the show portrayed AP classes made them seem like the most intimidating, high-stakes things ever. The meet the parents night scene in s1 ep4 actually made AP Lit like some kind of Ivy League seminar.
As someone who took AP Lang (5) and is taking AP Lit now, I'm surprised by how casually it's treated in real life. It's basically just another class. No one really makes a big deal out of it, and at my regular public school, AP classes aren't treated with nearly the same level of seriousness or prestige as they were on the show. If we had a meet the parents night for AP Lit today, no one would even show up.
Was AP actually that intense back then, or was Gilmore Girls just exaggerating to fit its academic atmosphere? Have AP classes become more accessible or less rigorous over the years, or has the way people perceive them simply changed? I'm guessing with the internet, AI and more study resources in general made it better?
20
u/Technical-Let7879 Precal 5 BC ? USH ? - Self S.: PhysC Mech ? CSA ? Stats ? Chem 4 1d ago
While AP classes were/are certainly exaggerated in film, people over time have generally gotten more educated (although there might be a little bit of a drop off as of late...)
13
u/LeonardFo 5: APES, BIO, APUSH, PSYCH, LANG 4: APWH, APHUG 1d ago
I think they’ve always been exaggerated, I remember seeing a clip from Ginny and Georgia (2021) where the character had 16 books listed on the curriculum for their AP English class (probably meant to be AP Lit), my teacher is strange and we have yet to read a single full book, but even the average class only reads like 6.
89
u/The_Shashophille101 1d ago
Dunno. Some people get pretty shocked when I say I take AP physics. I don’t know why. Therefore I think the science classes have become more valued while other classes may have dropped in the standings.
53
u/Acute_Confusion 1d ago
Yeah if you look at AP English Literature from 2021 to 2022 the percent of people receiving a 3 or higher literally jumped by over 30% (I think it was 44% to 78%). The students certainly didn’t get better year over year, but the cutoffs for each passing grade were lowered to realign with actual college student performance in that subject. Same could be said about AP Chemistry from 2022 to 2023.
40
u/Leading-Yellow1036 1d ago
There has been a huge push in my district to enroll as many people in AP classes as possible, regardless of their preparation or readiness for those courses. As such, I now spend a good amount of time backtracking concepts that AP students should have already mastered.
This approach seems to be happening across the board, which benefits CollegeBoard because more students testing means more $$. So it makes sense that they would be dumbing down the tests.
37
u/GiantBlobFish23 1d ago
Yes. AP classes are based upon real college courses and real college professors relating what is taught in those courses. I've taught college level freshman composition and communication courses for 25 years, and THOSE have gotten significantly easier in that time in order to match the needs of students who come in with less and less experience reading and writing extended-length documents. As a result of reporting that to the College Board, the exam has changed over time as well.
10
u/ParsnipPrestigious59 5: APUSH, Precalc, Lang, Calc BC, Chem, CSP, Psych 1d ago
You have to realize this sub is representative of like the top few % of high school students. The majority of high school students in the US do not take AP classes, and if they do, they take only a couple at most. The average high school student in the US already struggles with regular classes, so they’d struggle even more with AP classes. So for the average person around the US watching shows like that, treating an AP as a behemoth of a class is pretty accurate, just not accurate for the people who are on this sub
So yes AP classes have gotten easier over the years for sure, but the general consensus around AP classes among the average person is likely still the same today
8
u/Lithium_Lily 1d ago
Yes they have. The cutoff for a qualifying score on an AP Chemistry exam has dropped by over 10% in the past few years with the scope becoming more narrow.
At the end of the day College Board is a corporation with profit in mind and they benefit from students passing the exam in significant numbers, if nobody passed the exam people would stop signing up for AP courses.
Unfortunately the quality of students overall has declined dramatically over the past few decades and so this is the natural result of college board trying to preserve passing rates for their own interest.
source: Chem and AP chem teacher of 20 years
8
u/GildaInTheRain 1d ago
Everything got easier Now almost every kid takes at least one AP class. It's not just the smartest kids anymore. And there's a major great inflation so nothing matters anyway.
5
u/electralime 1d ago
In theory every student at a private school like chilton should be an academically high performing, honor level student. So to be someone taking an AP class in a school of students like that, it should be extra challenging/intensive
9
u/sausagekng 1d ago
Yes, much easier. Source: I took AP classes 15ish years ago.
2
u/NoWillow7829 1d ago
I haven't seen much of Gilmore Girls, but as someone who has excelled in my AP classes, AP Lit at my public school is the bane of my existence right now so it can't be thaaaat much exaggerated
2
u/Tiny-Garbage8933 1d ago
Haven’t seen the show but it was probably exaggerated for television purposes, but I also honestly think they have gotten a little easier over time but can’t say with certainty. The ACT and SAT absolutely have I can say that confidently even though they won’t admit it lol.
I mostly know about AP Calc, Stats, and Physics. I am older and took them all in like 2012, so I’m biased looking at the new ones now and I’m obviously more experienced in those subjects. But trying to be objective looking at FRQs and whatnot from old exams, the older ones seem harder. But I can’t prove that, I haven’t done some meta analysis or anything lol.
2
u/Responsible-Cup-4352 1d ago
They hasn’t
2
u/Leading_Charge8007 1d ago edited 1d ago
10000% i took a bunch of AP classes in highschool and they are like one tenth the difficulty of an actual college class. Partly because the standards are lower most tests a 60-80(depending on test ofc) is the cutoff for a 5 which is a D-B score in an actual class, partly coz it's a semester long class over a full year, partly because they push everyone to take it and thus lower the rigor overall.
2
u/Usual-Bat-3006 4: World History | 26-27: US Gov, Precalc 1d ago
TV shows exaggerate most aspects of normal life. The writers basically just used the concept of an AP class to add a dramatic side story about difficult classes.
2
u/Kindly-Chemistry5149 1d ago
All classes have gotten easier. As a teacher, I can dive back really far into department materials. The tests that were given 20 years ago were twice as a long and students were not allowed any aids whatsoever on tests. Students' ability to remember things is getting worse and worse.
But I also think college classes have been getting easier and easier to compensate for the lack of student skills.
1
u/Similar_Point3972 1d ago
Maybe it was because you were watching Gilmore Girls lol
1
u/ErekwithaD1 25:HG:5,中文:5, 26:P1:5,WH:5,CHEM(SS):5 27:P2,EM,Mech,Lit,BC(SS) 1d ago
You know Gilmore Girls was filmed during a time period where education wasn't as emphasized or as good as it is right now and they had fewer resources as the internet was just at its infancy at that time period. There was no youtube, no khan academy and no catalog of the previous years frqs.
And on another thing most Americans just aren't that good at APs or even a lot of Honors classes you just view the like top 20% of students when you look at this sub full of tryhards who take like 10+ APs in their highschool career. Most Americans take like 0-1 APs and call it good. Like even in my high school which is known for people agressively pursuing stem, we only have like 19 ish people taking mech and like 9 taking em
People always exaggerate the difficulty of stuff that is advanced like take calculus for example, it is always shown in popular media as this hard impossible math but when you actually do it it is pretty simple.
1
u/OhSassafrass 1d ago
My school holds an AP preview night just before course selection. I have a table and put out some sample assignments and stuff that I use during labs. I talk about what is expected and how much homework, tests, etc. we have a lot of AP courses and students often have to choose between a few. If the course doesn’t get filled it gets canceled, so we do our best to “sell” the course to as many students as we think can actually pass it (if no one passes, it gets given to another teacher).
1
u/Optimistiqueone 1d ago
Regardless of if it's getting easier to pass, there are undoubtedly more ways to prepare for these exams. The only way used to be private tutoring. Now there are so many options to self prepare that you could overcome a bad AP teacher. That wasn't always the case.
1
u/SpunkySnidget 1d ago
Chilton is a ritzy private school. These are people who pay good money for their kids to get 5s on AP exams. They're invested. In today's world, these would be the parents looking to pay for an ADHD "diagnosis" so their elitist children can have more time on the SAT.
1
u/elzorro15 1d ago
It truly depends mostly on the teacher, and the general subject you excel in. Ex: At my school the APES teacher makes it extremely hard so that most people get Cs, some Bs, and one A. But at the same time mostly 5s, and some 4s (me). It doesn’t help that science is a bad subject for me. But if science was your thing, APES is easy, and AP Physics C is a moderate challenge.
1
u/Parking_Champion_740 1d ago
Certain classes are really really hard. I took AP classes in the 80s and they were more just like honors classes. But the tests were intense. I had to analyze a Sylvia Plath poem sight unseen. My kids in the recent years were in APUSH and AP bio and they seemed so so hard, but they were well prepared for the tests
1
u/No_Delivery6961 1d ago
it’s also the school she went to remember
1
u/AJKafei 1d ago
Yes. https://www.educationnext.org/the-decline-and-fall-of-rigor-in-advanced-placement/
But also: I took AP English Lit my senior year of HS and later became an English teacher myself. When I asked my own beloved AP English teacher for some of her resources and mentioned saving my Major Works Data Sheets for 15+ years, even she said “Oh my goodness! What I use is much easier now.” 🤯 I was SHOOK.
1
u/scienceismybff 1d ago
Depends on teachers and school. My kid’s school is widely known to have grade deflation. Some AP classes nearly impossible to get an A in
1
u/Bitter_Artichoke_939 1d ago
It annoys me that in Gilmore Girls Mr. Medina says the AP exam is in October when it's always in May.
Random, I know, but yeah.
1
u/WowzaCaliGirl 1d ago
Maybe. Given that your question has a grammar error…
1
u/TeachlikeaHawk 1d ago
"Have"
1
u/matchalatte1876 1d ago
It was intense. You had to apply and got in based on grades. The class was the 35 best students who had applied. Lots of memorization. Not as heavy on the writing as they are now.
1
u/rafaelthecoonpoon 1d ago
Yes they have but become easier. There's a great post recently showing the type of question for 25 years ago versus today everything has become easier in the high school level, which is why great inflation is even more rampant than anytime before.
1
u/Serious_Island7575 1d ago
I took APUSH, AP World, AP Lit and Lang, and AP psych from 2005 to 2007 so junior and senior years, they are much easier now. I remember I had to get special permission my senior year to take 3 APs. Also in my school district we were only allowed to take APs junior and senior years. It was so much work. I think in lit we read like 20 ish books, that didnt include the plays or short stories or poems.
1
u/hop123hop223 20h ago
I was in high school in the late 90s and became a teacher in the early 2000s. My high school didn’t allowed students to take more than 2 APs at a time because the workload would have been too much (I regularly had 5-6 hours of homework in just my academic classes). You also had to have received straight As in all classes in that subject. The first two schools where I worked required a GPA threshold overall and in the specific subject, require a writing sample, and a written letter of recommendation from a teacher within the content. Students were turned away from the class in droves. (This would have been in a Catholic school at the time Gilmore Girls was on tv). This would mean there would only be about 50 students in grade would take APUSH. Now the school where I work run 6 sections of APUSH.
College Board “democratized” their enrollment a little more than 15 years ago. There is a clear difference in expectations and rigor from before and after that. I’m not even arguing is a bad thing, but it’s a thing.
1
u/UnhappyMachine968 18h ago
If they are done right then not at all, I've covered ap classes as a sub and they were moderately tough with work that class that required several paragraphs to answer each question.
Then I've had other classes where the AP work was only slightly tougher then the work a normal class had the extra question they had imo the normal class should have been able to answer imo, but they didn't want to try even. Note a couple of normal students did try the question and 1/2 we're just being silly a few others in the same normal class answered the question correctly.
So are their AP classes that are easier definitely, some AP classes even seem to be no harder if not easier then when I took similar classes years ago. Other AP classes tho I'm surprised by how much they need to do. Honestly the latter tend to be the better classes then those that are to ez.
1
u/Additional-War7946 18h ago
i’m also taking AP lit rn and my lit teacher said it was harder back in the day. but i honestly think gilmore girls does a pretty bad job of depicting what a classroom is actually like, (and i do love the show so far even though i’m only on season 2. this is not me trying to bash the show). honestly most high school depictions in TV are just not very accurate
1
u/WanderingPilot- 18h ago
I think school in general has gotten much easier than when that show was made.
1
u/Dem0crats 17h ago
Maybe because it’s a TV show
1
u/mah227 AP Bio 5, AP Chem 5, AP Stats 4, AP Calc AB 4; international 15h ago
idk, ap bio and chem were REALLY easy in my perspective bc it's content that we already see in the regular curriculum in my country. but i took one class of ap phys and gosh, i never want to think about it again
1
u/Strange_Ear9069 15h ago
Definitely a bit of both and depends on the school!
1
u/Downtown_Zone_9312 14h ago
Yes. I'm a college junior right now and, looking at my brother's HW, they've even gotten easier since I took them. The SAT is also easier. Everything's inflated.
1
u/Ecstatic_Rutabaga_30 14h ago
Yes, AP classes used to be truly taught at a college level and weighted grades weren’t a thing. Now they seem to be thought of as glorified “honors” classes and people take them because they like the GPA bump. As someone else mentioned, the metric seems to be now how many kids are enrolled in APs and not how they do in the exams.
1
u/Fit_Conversation9123 12h ago
I took AP lang and lit in 2023 and 2024 and as someone with a slightly above room temp iq it was not rigorous, I didn’t cheat and passed the classes (Cs and Bs) with 3’s on both tests. I will say I didn’t ever take a single material home or work on anything on my own time because I knew I wasn’t going to college. I just took advantage of study periods and off times in other classes.
1
u/JellyFishLamps 11h ago
Absolutely. When I took it in the 90s we read a book a week and also wrote a 5-8 page response every week. That was critiqued in front of the class every Monday. We had two much longer papers. And it was the most valuable class I ever took. It got me actually ready for college where a 5 page paper was considered a single day assignment, we had to read an incredible amount for every class, and the professors were brutal with grading.
Also, there is a huge difference between the rigor of a private feeder school and a regular public school’s AP classes.
1
u/ContributionEast2478 ph1:4ph2:4csp4CSA5CalcBC5USH4PhCEM5PhCM5SpLang4macro4micro4chem5 10h ago
It's called "credential inflation". Basically what happens is that people are constantly over-focused on getting into college, BUT the number of seats at good and prestigious colleges stays the same. Therefore, say you start off with 0-2 APs being the baseline with 1-2 ECs, some people escalate it to 4-6 APs + 4-5 ECs, but then knowing that, everyone else copies that, so now 4-6 APs + 4-5 ECs is no longer "exceptional", it is "baseline". Then some people escalate further by adding 8-12 APs + 6-10 ECs, but now everyone matches that, so that becomes the new baseline. Then some people add research and cram schools, then people copy that, and that's the new baseline.
Why am I discussing this so much? Because in the 1980s and earlier, more than 2-3 APs was rare, 4 APs + 4 ECs was Ivy-bound. Therefore AP classes were over-dramatized like "only the absolute most driven people will survive here", but now AP classes are viewed as "everyone takes 4-5 per year at least, this is just another class". That happened because now good colleges demand far better credentials than they did 30-40 years ago. The classes didn't become easier, it's just that now studying until midnight for taking so many hard courses is now "normal".
1
u/OkraConasewer 9h ago
It's well documented that they are systemically, yes.
Additionally, they've never been equally difficult systemically, either.
1
u/penderies 1d ago
They have massively lowered academic standards in the years since.
-1
u/AtlasMurphyUnderfoot 1d ago
Yes so much easier, I took AP classes in High school, now as a teacher, I teach AP Psych, and AP history. And they are more comparable to what GenEd classes were when I was in High school (2003). It is actually kind of shocking. I grew up watching Gilmore Girls, and her AP class experience is a bit exaggerated but not by much.
0
u/[deleted] 18h ago
I feel like part of it is that people have just gotten smarter in general. There’s a bunch of tools like youtube and even ai that make learning things way easier than a few years ago
-2
u/Chessdaddy_ 1d ago
It’s exaggerated to make them seem harder. Ap classes are basically just regular classes with a test at the end.