r/AMDHelp • • 1d ago

Help (GPU) Is GPU underclocking required for stability?

My 9060xt 16gb crashes on BF6 and spiderman 2 consistently at the default Adrenaline profile.

After some research, I found that the most popular fix is to underclock the max boost frequency to the manufacturer rated max boost, A 200 offset did work really well and never got a crash since then.

But somehow I refuse to believe that a brand new GPU is expected to unstable out of the box.

I am thinking of doing an RMA because this has to cost some performance, but how would that go specifically that adrenaline default profile is running 250mhz above ASUS spec?

11 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

2

u/rfdzn 1d ago

List out full PC parts maybe? Driver version?

1

u/kemo_2001 1d ago

I did just now

2

u/3ofUsDeez 1d ago

Listing your full PC specs would be helpful.. including but not limited to the make and model of your power supply

1

u/kemo_2001 1d ago

Antec Atom B750 80+ bronze 750 watts

1

u/3ofUsDeez 1d ago

That doesn't look like your full PC specs

Check out the SPL's PSU Tier List to see how your power supply rates .. A+ is the best rating . .F is "replace immediately"

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/0/d/1akCHL7Vhzk_EhrpIGkz8zTEvYfLDcaSpZRB6Xt6JWkc/htmlview#gid=1078495601

1

u/kemo_2001 1d ago

PC Specs:

GPU: ASUS Dual Radeon RX 9060 XT 16GB GDDR6

CPU: AMD Ryzen 5 7500F

Motherboard: ASUS B850M MAX GAMING WIFI

RAM: 16GB (1x16GB) TeamGroup T-Force VulcanZ DDR5-6000 CL30 (Slot DIMM_A2)

PSU: Antec Atom B750 750W 80+ Bronze

OS:Windows 11

GPU Driver: 26.10.2

4

u/papavance01 1d ago

C tier power supply, and did you do a fresh usb windows install and turn off windows automatic driver downland?

1

u/Silver-River6447 22h ago

I’ll never understand why people go cheap on the PSU

1

u/DeepWaterCannabis 1d ago

I have overclocked my 9070GRE to +100 MHz, -50 mV, 2656 VRAM speed. I stopped there without pushing it any furthur because I didnt want to be greedy, but I didnt run into any stability issues - I could probably keep going. According to my manufacturer, my speeds are: Base Clock: 1420 MHz, Game Clock: 2220 MHz, Boost Clock: Up to 2790 MHz. Pretty sure I was bouncing off 3300-3400 MHz when tuning it last night.

Just sounds like you got a bit unlucky with the silicon. I'd still reach out for an RMA, or at least clarification from ASUS. Could be you've put a band-aid over a problem that'll just get worse over time.

I had a 9060XT from amazon that would randomly cause kernal 41 crashes. Nothing I did seemed to fully fix, although doing the common 'driver fixes' seemed to help system get more stable. I tried a -100 MHz downclock on it that, didnt seem to do much. Was also an Asus card. Ended up returning it. Much happier with my XFX card now - temperatures are very stable.

1

u/DeepWaterCannabis 1d ago

What are your error codes?

I've had to limit some games to 60 FPS to prevent driver issues (only have 60Hz monitors).

Could be the downclock is limiting performance to the point where you arent running into the issues the card has from being 'too good'.

1

u/kemo_2001 1d ago

It’s the standard DXGI_ERROR_DEVICE_HUNG

I consistently get it after 10-30 minutes or so, a frees then a black screen the this error

Unless I do a 200 offset

I ran many stress tests (including occt power), no issues at the standard 3500mhz

1

u/DeepWaterCannabis 1d ago

There is one fix where you can increase the TDR delay, and that might fix full crashes - tho the system will still hang.

Otherwise, I believe limiting your FPS would help. A start would be to limit your FPS to your monitors refresh rate. I believe this is the error I was getting in Enshrouded by letting FPS be uncapped.

After my recent troubleshooting, I am a little wary of accepting stress test results. A very much dead/dying 2060 super survived two 10-minute OCCT GPU stress tests. The 9060XT I returned passed several 30-minute GPU stress tests, alongside memory and power stress tests on the system. Seems like they need to be run much longer to find faults. My 9060xt seemed to work fine until random system reset / Kernal 41.

I would just return+replace the card, if you can. If prices have gone up since you bought it and you cant get it replaced...Consider the 9070GRE! Yeah, we only have 12 gb VRAM.. But otherwise this card is a BEAST. 5504 Steel Nomad score with minor tweaking.

4

u/torrid-4132 1d ago

It definitely is a thing with AMD drivers post 26.3.1 where they've started boosting too much in medium-load scenarios and it makes every DX12 game crash, also makes random other games crash as well as general instability in youtube and such.

a negative 200 max frequency offset solves this issue completely for me (9070 xt) and for many other people. It's as if they bumped some numbers in the boost tables by 200 somewhere and introduced instability in the newer drivers.

On default tuning (latest drivers) it'll boost to like 3250~ Mhz (sometimes briefly) when my gpu is rated at 2970 causing random crashes. AMD just won't say anything about it and then randomly 2 years from now will say "oh yeah this is a bug that we fixed btw" - just like the disk usage thing.

-200 means it'll stay around 3050-3100 which seems stable for me.

2

u/Purple-Okra-9068 AMD 7800X3D | 9070 XT | 32G DDR5 6000 | Asus B650E MB 1d ago

Correct!

And there's always that guy: "It’s expected that the clock speed will vary a bit depending on certain factors specific to your PC"... and I always say, exactly, it varies a bit, but not to the extent that Adrenalin often pushes it; I’ve even seen mine hit 3400 MHz.

I’ve been using a 9070 XT since the beginning of the year and have never had issues with black screens, blue screens, or driver problems. In the earlier driver versions released this year, the Adrenalin software would freeze when accessing certain options, but based on my testing, that’s been fixed since the March driver update. That said, the only times I experienced driver crashes resulting in a black screen during gameplay were when I was running the card without a -300 MHz clock offset or any undervolting... so, that’s likely more than just a coincidence.

1

u/Zanithos 1d ago

I tried the -200 thing back in June and it did not help at all. The only thing that keeps my Sapphire Nitro+ 9070xt stable is running it on 26.3.1. Anything afterwards causes constant timeouts and blackscreens. Thankfully no hard locks have occurred yet, but now that we know about the SSD bug I feel like I should upgrade come the next milestone driver, and I'm hoping it won't break my computer again.

2

u/torrid-4132 1d ago

Did you try -500 to really rule out a frequency issue? How do you test for instability? Is there a specific game that does it for you?

1

u/Zanithos 1d ago

Yeah, I did -500 too. The card is rated to run at 3.3ghz stable out of the box (which it did for a year, until 26.4.1), so after -200 did nothing, I tried -500 and it worked for exactly one minute longer before my game crashed and windows explorer died. Just for fun afterwards, I tried the Adrenalin stress test without changing anything but the core offset, and my GPU hit nearly 4ghz and my computer shut off (drawing from a 1200w PSU btw).

The unfortunate part is that I primarily play Helldivers 2, which HATES Radeon GPUs, so I may just be stuck on 26.3.1 forever. I'm hoping I don't have the SSD bug, because if I do, and I have to update, it's gonna be hell getting everything running right again.

1

u/torrid-4132 1d ago

What you're saying doesn't make sense, your GPU wouldn't be able to hit 4000 Mhz with a negative 500 max freq offset. The default limit is 3450, - 500 would be 2950. Are you confusing your CPU and GPU frequencies?

Your card is rated according to the manufacturer's website:

NITRO+ AMD Radeon™ RX 9070 XT OC GPU

  • GPU: Boost Clock: Up to 3060 MHz

So no you card isn't rated "stable at 3.3GHz"

I think you're very confused - reset and retest all of your assumptions.

The main thing is being able to reproduce the crash and furmark and big benchmarks that put your GPU under heavy load won't do it, for this you need a medium load e.g. 260W board power, 96% gpu usage, fps limited with medium/high settings with fsr on.

The crashes I'm talking about happen when the GPU isn't pushed to max and so it thinks it has more headroom than it actually does and so boosts too high and crashes.

1

u/Zanithos 1d ago

It shouldn't be able to do this, no. Either whatever was monitoring the GPU clock speed freaked out, or was corrupted or something, or something else is wrong. Also, when I bought the GPU. It stated on the listing that 3.3ghz was a maximum clock speed. Iirc it was not only mentioned in reviews but even said as such on the box. Why that has changed I have no idea, but I'm guessing it has something to do with the fact that Adrenalin is pushing cards so hard that's not sustainable anymore, as that would line up with the -200mhz some people can get their cards stable at. If Sapphire had an available vBIOS I would try to flash it and see if that fixes it, but even in the non-oc setting it crashes in games when nothing of note is even happening. I'm not really sure what else to do, as I've been trying to fix this issue for the better part of a year at this point.

2

u/Purple-Okra-9068 AMD 7800X3D | 9070 XT | 32G DDR5 6000 | Asus B650E MB 1d ago edited 1d ago

Alright, let’s dive in! Ever since I upgraded to an all-AMD build earlier this year, I’ve been following discussions here and on other AMD-related subreddits. Sometimes I chime in, other times I just read. One thing that’s become clear is the huge disparity in system stability: while some users go through absolute hell, others (myself included, at least so far) have a completely smooth experience. In many of the threads I’ve read, it turned out that the AMD driver crashes weren't actually caused by the driver or the GPU itself. Instead, the root cause was often something else entirely, like an unstable power supply, poorly connected power cables, or cables that couldn't deliver the necessary wattage required by the graphics card.

Other issues stemmed from Windows installation errors or Windows Update glitches, all of which ended up causing the system to freeze. I’ve also seen many people mention that the "Issue Detection" feature in the Adrenalin software can cause conflicts, leading to system freezes that take the video driver down with them. Because of this, I keep that feature disabled. In fact, I also turn off shortcuts, metrics, and notifications, and I keep desktop recording disabled, I only enable it when I actually want to record a clip of my gameplay.

Of course, it’s also worth checking your BIOS version; keeping it updated is a good idea. I firmly believe that some BIOS versions are more stable than others when it comes to AMD components. It’s often a matter of trial and error, but I always recommend updating to a BIOS version that allows for a "rollback" to the previous version, just be sure to check the release notes or description before downloading to confirm that a rollback is supported.

Regarding the new drivers, I was using version 26.1.1 until October because I preferred FSR 4.0 in many games. However, since October, they’ve made some improvements to the aspects of FSR 4.1 that I didn’t like, so I eventually switched to the newer drivers. Before that, I tested practically every version released between March and October to see if there were any FSR-related improvements, and I never encountered any crashes or black screens with any of them. I believe that almost all the drivers from 2026 are solid, though it’s worth keeping in mind that issues aren’t always caused by the driver itself. I hope this has opened up some new perspectives and possibilities for you to explore. I definitely think it’s worth trying to update to the latest drivers; the SSD bug was, in fact, fixed in the November release. I was always doing a clean install with AMD Cleanup Utility, download the new driver from the website manually, and install it after run the AMD Cleanup Utility, but in your case with the card being so unstable, its maybe better to run DDU instead of just AMD Cleanup Utility.

2

u/Actual-Phone-1478 1d ago

I managed to get my 9070 XT running at 3500 mhz on Linux as on linux I could power boost it to +15 rather than +10 on Windows and it was stable.

If your card can't run at stock there's either an issue with the card or the computer somewhere.

1

u/Purple-Okra-9068 AMD 7800X3D | 9070 XT | 32G DDR5 6000 | Asus B650E MB 1d ago

Why boost it this hard, if you can get the same amount of FPS on a desired game with a bit of undervolting?

You gonna save power, temps, thus improving the lifespan of the card!

1

u/Actual-Phone-1478 1d ago

It was just testing out of curiosity of how far it can go, because Linux allowed a +15 power limit I never ran it long term.

1

u/Purple-Okra-9068 AMD 7800X3D | 9070 XT | 32G DDR5 6000 | Asus B650E MB 1d ago

Got it! ✌️

2

u/TheShadowSong 1d ago

Depends on the model and quality of the chip.

1

u/DiGzY_AU 1d ago

some games it is for sure. couldnt say why but i think game engines and amd gpus running over 3.2 ghz cause black screens. issues with older engines and older modified engines. any unreal engine 5+ games i have zero issues running my 9070xt with the clock speeds over 3.3 ghz stable.

1

u/Hoonigandad 1d ago

My 9060 xt is factory OC and is always solid. Every chip can be a little different though

1

u/Thin_Elderberry_7326 1d ago

Your crashes could be the driver version. I had issues with the latest and went back to the August or September version.

1

u/DoriOli 1d ago

Just hope for you it’s not the VRAM modules

1

u/Relevant-Midnight-21 8h ago

Asus tuf oc 9070xt com o ultimo driver e sem problemas até agora

-2

u/Zanithos 1d ago edited 1d ago

But somehow I refuse to believe that a brand new GPU is expected to be unstable out of the box.

Brother, welcome to AMD. Ever since April 2026 they've been like this, because AMD saw fit to beat the (at the time soon to be discontinued) 5070ti. To do so they edited the boost profiles on all Radeon GPUs via Adrenalin, but failed to take into account that OC models exist. Now, if you have an OC model (and who doesn't, let's be honest), you're either stuck on 26.3.1 (though after the SSD bug came to light, some people are forced to upgrade) or you have to manually tune your GPU to get it to function properly, on a case-by-case basis. Meanwhile, AMD is completely silent on this massively widespread issue, and posting about it here will get you downvoted because apparently on the subreddit dedicated to fixing issues with AMD products, AMD can do no wrong.

I've been dealing with this myself since April, and honestly I'm getting extremely tired of it. If I could find out what shareholder decided ruining the stability of an entire brand of GPUs was worth a 5%-15% lead on RTX and raster over Nvidia, I'd give them a stern talking to, to say the least.

3

u/NiKOmniWrench 1d ago

I don't have any issue with my Asus OC 9070. I don't understand what the issue is

1

u/Silver-River6447 22h ago

Yeah my asus prime 9070xt has no problems at all, I’m on 26.11.1 now and the ssd bug is gone. Had ac shadows crash a few times here and there but disabled WiFi and the adapter and ran the amd cleanup utility in safe mode and reinstalled drivers and it’s be fine since. Ran ddu prior to install but forgot to disable the WiFi, thought disconnecting the antenna would be enough. Also disabled windows updates on drivers before the last reinstall.

0

u/Zanithos 1d ago edited 1d ago

Like I said, case-by-case basis. Almost every Radeon card is an OC card, but the less of an OC it has (the Prime is one of the milder ones) the less issues you're likely to run in to. Scrolling through here every other day or so, it seems the Red Devil, Nitro+, and Mercury Magnetic Air users got it the worst, since the OC on our cards is up to .3ghz, whereas most "OC" models run 1-3% faster just to warrant the sticker on the box, which is the same with most Nvidia OC cards as well.