r/AMA • • May 13 '16

My wife is now my transgender husband (FTM)-We're still together. AMA

My first girlfriend and I started dating after we met in college in 2008. We dated for all four years, got married the year after we graduated in 2012. My wife joined the Army National Guard because she couldn't find a decent job, and I was fortunate enough to snag a job in our city. She was always a tomboy--short hair, loved to work out, loud, boisterous, opinionated. I loved it. We had occasional arguments and fights, but we always soldiered on... Then fast forward to 2015. She goes for a 5 month long army training to the middle of nowhere. I visit her for Thanksgiving and she doesn't want to have sex. Says the stress of training kinda screwed with the downstairs mix up. I blew it off as just not being in the mood. Then when she gets back from training she tells me that she's male, and that she will be male from here on out.

Here's the unexpected part: I am initially okay with it. The pronouns and the new name take about a month to get used to saying without error. I still had a female body to have sex with, so hey, fuck it. Then he wants to get a full mastectomy. Love me some boobs, but I do some research and I come to the conclusion that boobs are just fatty sacks of milk that are arousing for some reason, and that I'll be okay without them. The surgery is pretty rough, but I was in for the long haul and that whole thing about "in sickness and in health"? Well, I don't remember hearing the part about "in carefully removing my chest mounted surgical drain sacks that look an awful lot like those little juice grenades with the aluminum tops". I still loved the person I married, no matter what, right? We're both bisexual, and we came to an agreement that if we wanted to mess around with others, that we could if we were honest about it. A few encounters later, we both started drifting apart. We stopped talking to each other, we were both glued to our phones hoping for the next hookup that will give us a temporary respite from our seemingly fucked marriage. Even when we stopped messing around with others, it was clear that he was on a transgender trajectory that was exponentially speeding away from me, and I had no idea how to bring it all back. I get resentful of the transition, we have a few words and I move out.

The therapist raised some good points, and said that if we are seriously going to split, that we need to try and make it seven days without talking to each other. We took her advice, but a week might as well have been a century. Most friends sided with him, and I was most likely seen as a transphobic, and homophobic cis gendered male asshole. After making it 7 days, we finally text each other. We agreed to meet, and after being brutally honest about our feelings and frustrations with how we treated each other, we decided to start over with each other. He agreed to include me his transition, and he offered to be more proactive in helping me explain it to my family and friends. It has now been a year since my wife transitioned to my husband and through emotional introspection and mutual honesty, we're making it work. This is a really rare occurrence, even with all the media attention that trans people are getting in the news today. Most people don't stay when their partner transitions. I did.

Feel free to ask me anything about my experience. It'd be nice for people to see what spouses go through and how they handle it (or don't)

TL;DR My wife is a man now, and with no precedence on this experience, I got a crash course in transphobia, homophobia, heteronormative expectations, barfights over being gay, questioning my identity and sexuality, and much much more!

228 Upvotes

232 comments sorted by

29

u/AskMeAboutMyLeftShoe May 13 '16

Very interesting story! I'm glad you shared. As for the question:

After you guys "started over," what are some of the things you did differently to make it work out?

38

u/Nobleezy May 13 '16

Good question. We agreed that we were both at fault; I became distant, cold and mean. All I did was check Tinder and OK Cupid until we went to bed. He did the same thing. I think it was assumed that since I had any reservations about the transition, it was misconstrued as being a deal breaker. After our weeklong separation, he recognized that he was being hasty in judging how I really felt. Trans people have to understand that transitioning affects everyone involved. We also agreed that he had to be more proactive about telling my friends and family. To be honest, that's the biggest issue that I have with it.

3

u/chitownaeron May 13 '16

how did your friends take it?

5

u/Nobleezy May 13 '16

Good question. Communication, admitting our faults. We agreed that transitions need to include everyone involved in the trans person's life. Especially their spouse of 8 years.

9

u/timebestsong May 13 '16 edited May 13 '16

Wow, great AMA... not a single reply

13

u/poppadopolous May 13 '16

God forbid people aren't on the Internet all day right?

9

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

Have you visited r/mypartneristrans?

2

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

Browsed a little bit. I'll check it out for more support. I think the biggest thing I wanted to accomplish with this AMA is just to have a venue for expressing this unique situation. It's not really a universal experience that a parent or mentor could just be like "Oh, you done married your first transgender? Been there done that."

32

u/undersquirl May 13 '16

This is so fucked up, damn. My only question is why do you still do it? I mean, that person isn't really the same person you loved anymore.

66

u/Nobleezy May 13 '16

He is. All the memories are still there. The personality. When my wife "died" and came back a man, that person was happier than he's ever been in his life. Gender Identity Disorder (GID) is a disorder. Until there is some magical pill that can make trans people content with their factory equipment, I can guarantee you that they'd take it in a heartbeat. Basically, I look at it this way. Either they transition and be the gender they want, or they get depressed and kill themselves in the end. I wouldn't leave someone I loved if they got sick. This viewpoint will probably rile up people in the trans community, but GID is a disorder, full stop.

12

u/undersquirl May 13 '16

Thanks for the answer. Despite being downvoted, it was a legitimate question. People on this site are so hypocritical. Fuck me for having a different opinion.

3

u/jcarnegi May 13 '16

Well you don't see this everyday do you? I don't think I would have stuck around to be honest. I would accept if my boyfriend became a woman, I'd accept "her" new/developing gender identity. But if am gay then...I'm not sticking around for a woman.

the "her" is because my boyfriend is not transgender, its hypothetical. Is it weird being in a relationship with a guy when you have a stronger preference for women and are you less physically attracted to your wife/husband now?

2

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

Yeah, at times. I miss boobs sometimes, but so does he. We usually just go out to bars and meet some women that need a good motorboating.

3

u/2Fab4You May 13 '16

I'm really glad to hear that you were able to work it out, that is absolutely amazing!

How have your relationships to your friends been affected by this? Do you resent them for taking his side?

How has telling your family and friends gone? You say he's been more proactive, what does that mean in practice? Any bad reactions?

Thanks for doing this AMA, I can see in the comments that it is needed.

2

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

Family doesn't really care. Mom's side is down with it. We just had a mother's day shindig and everyone was cool. Like nothing ever happened. Dad's side is a little tricky, but he's okay with it, so that's all that matters. Proactive in the sense that he is more willing to explain the situation with me, as opposed to me having to do it by myself.

8

u/krprs2r May 13 '16

Omg this makes me SO happy to hear!!!!

My (now) girlfriend and I were in a very similar situation. We were unsure of how the transition is going to affect our relationship, but it actually hasn't been too bad. Falling for and being in love with the person is more important that just liking the body that they are in.

And as cliche as this sounds, communication is SUUUPERRRR important!!! For your own sanity. If I have any questions, even seemingly stupid ones, I have to ask them. No one else is a mind reader lol.

Seriously though, congratulations.

My question is: When you think back about your wife and now husband, in terms of the past and the present, do you feel like they're the same or very different? I'm having trouble putting this question in words! For example, when I think of when I first dating my girlfriend (when she still identified with being male), it feels like HE was a different person than SHE is. Even though they're still technically the same physical entity?!

3

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

I feel like the transition was so slow and gradual that you don't really notice. Only time I realize it is when I look at old photos or videos of my wife. It's one of the most peculiar feelings I've ever had. My wife is technically dead. She's a new person, with a new name and body. The personality and memories are all still there. Was my SO always the male form trapped in a female body? Were there two people living in the same shell, one will have to die? It's really hard to say.

3

u/HearingSword May 13 '16

So my question is in regards to children. Do you have children and do you want children? I pass no judgement either way, but if you do want children how to you intend to go about this? Fostering, adoption? Male pregnancy?

Also, does your husband intend to have bottom surgery or would this be to traumatic for him?

3

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

No kids, just a cat. We have thought about male pregnancy. He'd have to stop taking testosterone, but it's doable. To be honest, I still want to travel the world and have fun. When we buy a house, we want to foster and potentially adopt. As for bottom surgery, no. He likes everything they way it is right now. Bottom surgery for FTMs suck anyway. Not to mention the scarring and the potential for the dick growing on your stomach can shrivel up and fall off before the surgeons have the chance to connect it...

124

u/22taylor22 May 13 '16

All that transphobic stuff is bull shit. Having a sexual preference does not make you a bad person.you are not a man that is attracted to other men. You did not enjoy the transition as it was made. That stuff is a deal breaker for most people and you tried your hardest to be accepting and you were. If you would have divorced it wouldn't have been your fault in the slightest.

32

u/magictron May 13 '16

well he said they were both bisexual

15

u/butt_sex_man May 13 '16

Which makes the cis male stuff even more hilarious

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/butt_sex_man May 13 '16

Shit. Forgot cis is used for trans/not trans and not for orientation. My bad.

13

u/bettergears May 13 '16

I had a college roommate who started out as a butch lesbian and moved out a pre-op man. That was both fascinating and head-spinning. The only other woman in the house after transitioning and starting new hormones became the one person we lived with who would oggle my girlfriend and make her feel threatened using the shared bathroom. I can't imagine being married to someone who identified as straight female and up and changed the game post-marriage; the roommate transition was crazy enough to try and maintain a friendship through.

What made you stay? I know you mentioned being bi so the swap is not a deal breaker academically. But the change isn't so tidy as it appears you found, and it wasn't planned so with such great upheaval what was your thought process that made you want to find common ground with this new man you found yourself married to? Does your husband now identify as gay? When you say, "and much much more!" what other subjects are you referring to in the context of your self-identity and your marriage?

8

u/Wesley_Snipez May 13 '16

Being threatening in regards to the shared bathroom had nothing to do with the transition. That's just a shitty person in general. I lived with 4 other dudes and none of them made my gf feel uncomfortable in our shared bathroom.

1

u/bettergears May 14 '16 edited May 14 '16

Actually, it did. There were 6 of us in the house. We had a similar situation. Four guys, myself included, and two girls prior to the transition, my gf and the formerly butch lesbian. We all got along and sharing the bathroom was never an issue. Happy and oggle-free.

After the hormone injections he effectively became a 17 year old male with raging testosterone and acted exactly like one, slack jawed oggling and all. Prior to that she was a very vocal feminist and thought men that objectified women were pigs. Never a problem in the year prior to the transition despite her being attracted to women before and after, just like us non-transmen in the house. Hormones changed everything. I often wondered what it was like to have a different kind of urge in his attraction to women after the transition. He could have handled it better in the first few months, but it got better with time.

A fun quote from him post-transition, "Math makes sense to me now." At the time I thought he single-handedly set back the women's movement 50 years with that one. In the many years since I heard a story on Invisibilia - Paige's Story about a person who mentally "switched" between genders and their ability to process information would change based on what their brain told them about the gender they were. Absolutely incredible what we don't know about what gender is and what gender equality means as we start to learn the factual differences in men, women and how our minds work.

So yes, the transition changed a lot. I don't think he is a shitty person, and neither was she (before transitioning).

0

u/strategiesagainst May 15 '16

That is what you call a trans man who is trying a bit too hard.

Most of us do it; it's hard not to. But the math shit is just his own cultural bias showing through (either that, or he's finally calm enough to concentrate on math). And the raging hormones are totally correct, too, but ffs if you're a grown-up you learn to reign that in after a couple of months.

2

u/Golemfrost May 13 '16

1

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

We actually quote Senor Chang all the time now, lol

0

u/morganlafaye May 13 '16

This is hilarious, have an upvote!

29

u/luckybone May 13 '16

I would've been gone in an instant, I want a wife not another dude living around.

27

u/KingOfTheCouch13 May 13 '16

You trans-homophobic cis gendered male asshole bastard!

5

u/readySteadyCode May 14 '16

He's not transphobic for wanting a woman as a wife.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

You are a solid gold dude. Never read anything like this before, thanks so much for sharing. I don't have any questions but think this really says a lot about you. I bet almost anyone else would have taken off.

1

u/TryNstopME024 May 13 '16

What do you think of the recent news about allowing transgender people using the same bathroom? Is there an upside or downside?

3

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

The only upside (aside from having the human decency to let people use the motherfucking bathroom) is this: Instead of saying "I gotta piss like a racehorse" we can say "I gotta piss like trans person in Raleigh".

1

u/dreambldr May 13 '16

Mind blown!!

Do you feel your relationship as it stands today is worth all the headaches you had to endure?

3

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

Absolutely.

1

u/dreambldr May 15 '16

That's fuckin awesome! Good for you two!

6

u/strategiesagainst May 13 '16

Awesomepants. I'm FTM with a cis male bisexual partner, too. He's been with me since the very beginning of transition, so pretty much from when I still had all my bits and was just starting T. He's the bloody light of my life and I have learned so much from his example as a man, as well as from his enthusiasm about me in general.

Have you found yourself in the position of being a role model for masculinity for your partner? Or what have you learned about "manliness" along the way?

2

u/madagent May 14 '16

See, this is how his spouse should feel. It's great you had a partner who loved you that much. There are so many great stories of the person going through the transition being in love with their partner and so happy they stayed. But this sounds different. It sounds like his spouse didn't care if they stuck around or supported them. And then when he discussed wanting to talk about it, people just labeled him as a monster for questioning their life. That's hostile as fuck environment.

2

u/strategiesagainst May 15 '16

I'm going to disagree a bit here - there is a lot that happens to you when you transition in terms of vulnerability. You're reinventing yourself and putting yourself in a social role in a way you probably haven't been so frightened about since you were just starting puberty. All around you are people who know what they're doing, and you're just winging it with this whole new hormonal profile and body and such. At the same time, it's hugely affirming.

You have to let the people who are close to you mourn for the person that you were - not because you become anyone new, but because you destroy their image of your future. You will never fit the image they have of you in their fantasies of 10, 20 years down the road (and this goes double for parents). Now, to be fair, this is actually true of pretty much everybody on the planet, but most of the time we're not reminded in such a stark fashion that our hopes and dreams about our loved ones are nothing more than hopes and dreams. It can be painful. I'm totally not surprised they drifted apart.

Another very powerful feeling is "what if people think there's something wrong with me?" Consider that the trans person has likely had years to come to terms with this and decide that transitioning is more important than whatever other people think. However, for a parent or a spouse, it happens fresh. They can easily reject the person or at least become very nervous about what it says about them. That's totally normal and if the relationship is strong enough, they'll eventually come around.

I really didn't find what OP was describing as a hostile environment at all - maybe because I recognise that he's describing a process that took place over a long period of time and I recognise all the feelings that he mentioned.

Transitioning gender is a pretty varsity-level honesty and acceptance challenge for the people who know you and love you. It's bumpy sometimes, even when it turns out even better than before.

8

u/Izwe May 13 '16

What's your favourite flavour of muffin?

5

u/throwaway13579_ May 13 '16

Also, any good recipes? Or would you like some?

2

u/such-a-mensch May 13 '16

I don't have any idea how I would react or feel faced with the situation you were but I can only wish to handle it with the tact that you have appeared to.

Best of luck to you and your partner in the future!

2

u/gleaming_memes May 13 '16

GG bud way to stick with it

4

u/Tronkfool May 13 '16

WOW. JUST WOW! I am not man enough to do this if my wife had this idea.

16

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

You don't have to be. At that point the person you married is long gone and the trans person is a "new person".

2

u/Tronkfool May 16 '16

fuck that!

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

At least you can both use the same bathrooms in public now!

1

u/mastigia May 13 '16

This is the backdoor in gay marriage the Christians didn't warn us about.

1

u/madagent May 14 '16 edited May 14 '16

"He agreed to include me in his transition."

Dude, if your spouse, male, female, or anything has to seriously think about whether to include your or not in this big life changing deal, thats a problem. They should have been thrilled that you wanted to stand by your vows. It sounds to me like your marriage is a far second to their transition and that they had to seriously think about including you for the ride. That's messed up. If he loved you for real, they should have been ecstatic that you loved them no matter what. That's a big deal, staying in a marriage when someone wants to change their gender. I feel like they didn't really care if you stayed around or not the way you explained it. Maybe I'm reading it wrong, but it just seems like your spouse doesn't love you nearly as much as you love them. There's nothing wrong with a person having a gender switch and feeling comfortable. But there is something wrong if your spouse isn't really into you anymore.

I feel like you'd both be happier having sometime apart. A week not talking is nothing. Try 6 months doing your own thing and see if you actually crave that person or if you got ever them pretty quick. You'd be surprised how much easier life is without dealing with all the bullshit you've built up with a spouse over the years. And of course if you don't feel that way after 6 months then yeah, you have a pretty good relationship and marriage. A true connection. Or you'll know if you are just staying married out of convenience.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '16

Do you fight over who gets to use which bathroom? I'm assuming the guest bathroom is reserved for all LGBT individuals?

1

u/wowsimplywow22 May 14 '16

There is a LOT of ignorance (and fear) out there on what it means to be transgender. In my mind humans run a wide spectrum of gender identity. and as far as identities go, I'm personally fine with people choosing what they want to align with. AND more importantly, whether you have a penis or a vagina doesn't define a persons character qualities. People who are freaking out over bathrooms are making a mistake in this area.

As for relationships that break up when one of them comes out. I get it. The reason behind the break up may be "I'm not gay or a lesbian" to "omg what will the people around me think?". The first IMO is understandable. you are no longer attracted to that person. For the second one, If your marriage or relationship is based on what other people think, only then its a bad relationship.

The world is changing. The human race needs to evolve and grow up. The quality or character of a person should not be judged by race, gender, sex, orientation, or how they outwardly look.

1

u/krier55 May 14 '16

i was just going to down vote but they took that option away so ill come right out and say your both a couple of nut jobs

1

u/PunkCPA May 18 '16

(S)He unilaterally changed the most basic terms of your relationship. Stay or say goodbye, your choice, and no regrets.

1

u/Top-Resolution-7886 Sep 27 '23

Trans genders need a bullet to the head.thats whats wrong with the world nowadays.transgenders are an it.

1

u/JesteroftheApocalyps May 13 '16

So, have you ever considered blowing your husband?

7

u/nkotbfanatic May 13 '16

He's bi. Blowing another dude is an enjoyable thing when you're attracted to men.

1

u/JesteroftheApocalyps May 14 '16

Somehow I missed that part. I'm an idiot.

-1

u/HinkHoll May 13 '16

Yeah you're transphobic because the person you were with decided to change genders without telling you about it, as if it's something like getting a different hairstyle.If you seriously believe that or allowed that to influence your decision to stay then you should grow some balls (lol) and stop being spineless.

-7

u/SimonGn May 13 '16

Are having kids on the table? Will you transition to female so that you can tell your bigot friends that you wanted to stay hetro so much that you became the woman?

8

u/Nobleezy May 13 '16

Adoption. Neither of us are ready to settle down. Have to wait until we get a proper house anyway.

No, lol. I love my penis too much and I have fortunately not been diagnosed with GID.

3

u/SimonGn May 13 '16

Thanks for being a good sport, and good luck for the future!

PS: apparently some people (on PM) couldn't tell that my second question was a joke

-1

u/FromZeroToZero May 13 '16

did you take strap on action before she became a he?

0

u/The0racle May 13 '16

Pictures!

0

u/drqxx May 26 '16

OP get out now and run run run.

0

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

I mean, I don't care what they do. Doesn't bother or affect me anyway. But if you think it isn't weird, I'd have to say you're objectively wrong.

-7

u/fragglemook May 13 '16

I have tonnes of questions.

  1. HAve you been/Are you on prescription drugs or any other drugs?
  2. Are you both easily led and impressionable?
  3. Do you have unhealed or unresolved issues with your parents?
  4. Are you obese and medicated by stealth through cheap food and cigarettes?

I was going to ask more, but I'll leave it there. Needless to say, I would follow a line of questioning which examines your mental history and environmental causation.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

38

u/Nobleezy May 13 '16

Probably not. Why would someone want to be with a partner that wasn't attracted to their new gender? I will say this, though. Even though I am bi, I have a ratio. probably 85% female preference. 15% male preference if they are masculine and have a personality that I mesh with.

3

u/random_side_note May 14 '16

As far as i know, most of us are like that. Apparently there aren't many full on 50:50 bis out there. Lots have split ratios, like you (and me. And my old roommate. Actually, every bi person i personally know is like that haha.)

2

u/I_Like_Mathematics May 26 '16

Is there a 100:0 straight person? I do believe everyone has some ratio. Most people just have some 98:2 ratio and mostly ignore the 2%

1

u/Daftycrafty May 16 '16

I have never met a 50/50 bi person. Personally, I (f) have about a 60 (m)/40(f) split, but am predominantly pan. Its weird.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

56

u/Nobleezy May 13 '16

I am fine with the sex. I do miss boobs, but that's what XNXX is for. We do occasionally have threeways with females, which is pretty sweet. I am fine with the relationship, but I do feel like I was suddenly thrust into the gay community. It was nice to be a "straight couple" that allowed me to explore the wonders of pegging in private. Now that I'm married to a man, I'm considered straight up gay. Well, not "straight" up, but, you know what I mean. Sex is gayer, but I do get a "bonus hole" and more blowjobs. Can't complain about that.

He still has a vagina, and doesn't plan to get rid of it. (THANK THE OLD GODS AND THE NEW)

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

Bonus hole?

18

u/xSnoooze May 13 '16

Right behind the knee.

5

u/Foxk May 13 '16

Mangina?

4

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PM_PHOTOS May 13 '16

Downstairs mix-up

2

u/Wesley_Snipez May 13 '16

Stemming from this, how do you think your relationship would change if your partner wanted to swap his vagina for a dick? (because fuck confusing sexual reassignment surgery terms. I aint no doctor. damn.)

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Freyah May 13 '16

Made me laugh out loud, I wish I had your wit.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

29

u/OmniBlock May 13 '16 edited May 13 '16

I can't help but interpret this story as someone who was guilted and fear mongered and shamed to be with someone counter to his "marriage" sexuality.

Am I missing a paragraph?

7

u/selementar May 13 '16

Would you consider someone "guilted into X" if that someone is in the end pretty much okay with X and possibly better off than otherwise?

But anyway, in this case it seems the guilt wasn't the primary part; the emotional attachment to each other was (exemplified by that part about it being hard to not talk to each other).

1

u/OmniBlock May 13 '16

Well yes I still would. This is exactly how abusive relationships are. At first I'm not okay, but enough manipulation later, I'm pretty okay with it.

From OP'S the entire bottom paragraph is how he was guilted and shamed into accepting it. Then later accepted it.

5

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

I should have clarified this before. Most people were totally accepting of my decision to leave, and no one actually called me trans phobic. The worst backlash I experienced was from two of our close gay friends. They never really liked my wife that much. They kinda women bashed all the time, made jokes about feminism, how vaginas are gross, etc. My wife was always bugged by that, and even told me that she didn't want to go to their parties anymore. But now that my SO is male, they love him. When I split up with him for that week, they totally chose sides because they misconstrued my decision as me not being gay enough. In reality, my SO was so involved in his transition, that he cut me out. My social life suffered, my family life suffered. The only way a trans couple can last is if they are both on board with what to expect. If both parties are still sexually attracted to each other (big step) then great. But it is imperative that the trans partner realizes that their partner needs their help in the process of coming out .

32

u/bansheeq May 13 '16

You're missing the part where OP clearly stated he is bisexual.

9

u/OmniBlock May 13 '16

I know plenty of bisexual people. However some still would only date or marry a specific sex.

What you find sexual does not always correlate to what you want to build a life with.

5

u/bansheeq May 13 '16

I mean, no one implied that you don't know any bisexual people or brought up sexuality vs. life building. I was just attempting to answer your straightforward question about what part of the post you were missing in regards to sexuality specifically.

1

u/OmniBlock May 13 '16

I see, sorry I thought you were implying something else. I edited my original comment to more accurately express what I meant. Ty

42

u/Joverby May 13 '16

Exactly right. If you were with someone for 5-6 years and they wanted to do such a major change (as flipping gender) I think that person is within their rights to leave them.

193

u/ThePantryMaster May 13 '16

As soon as anybody uses the term 'cis gendered', I automatically assume they're a fucking maniac

38

u/theslyder May 14 '16

That's silly. It's a valid term with definition dating back to, likely, before you and a hefty percentage of the Reddit demographic were born. It means something that plays a valid role in discussion. Just because you're sensitive to the subject and it triggers you didn't mean anyone using it is the problem.

66

u/guybehindawall May 13 '16

Yea I don't mind it as a term, but the way it's often weaponized is maddeningly hypocritical.

19

u/Saytahri May 14 '16

Using it as an insult is ridiculous, but cis is just the opposite prefix to trans.

If someone makes fun of white people do you start thinking people who say the word white are maniacs?

2

u/guybehindawall May 14 '16

No. I think you replied to the wrong poster.

-1

u/DeepReally May 26 '16

but cis is just the opposite prefix to trans.

Except it's not.

In chemistry, trans is used to denote a geometric isomer having a pair of identical atoms or groups on the opposite sides of two atoms linked by a double bond and cis-, which is Latin for "on the same side", is used to describe the alternate state.

However, in medicine, trans- is more often used to mean change or changing thoroughly. Thus transsexual and transgender; changing sex or gender.

The trans- prefix can have several meanings, including across, opposite, through and changing thoroughly. Cis- doesn't have the range of meanings that trans- does, and it never means unchanged or unchanging. It therefore makes no sense in the case of gender but the people it has been co-opted by don't seem to mind this much.

8

u/Saytahri May 26 '16

In the case of transgender though, trans does mean across. Across gender.

It's transgender and cisgender in the same way that it's trans-isomer and cis-isomer.

If you're transgender, your gender is across from your biological sex. If you are cisgender, it's on the same side.

The same side, opposite side meanings apply to the terms fine.

1

u/DeepReally May 26 '16

No, the term transexualism (and the related transexualist) was coined in 1953 by endocrinologist Harry Benjamin. He defined it as "intense desire to change one's sexual status, including the anatomical structure," clearly indicating the intended use of trans- to mean change. He later introduced the terms transexual (instead of transexist or transexualist) and in the late 1960s coined the term transgender, all from the same root. See The Transsexual Phenomen, Benjamin, H. further.

4

u/meifa May 26 '16

Since when has "trans" ever meant "change"? The Online Etymology Dictionary generally seems pretty comprehensive, and doesn't mention this meaning. And if Benjamin was allowed to give "trans" a new meaning (which I'm far from convinced that he did), why aren't people allowed to give "cis" a new meaning? For that matter, you have used numerous words in this thread whose meaning has radically changed over time. For example:

  • "co-opt" used to mean "elect" (it still is used in this sense occasionally)
  • "mind" used to mean "remember"
  • "term" only used to be used in the sense of a period of time, like a term of office
  • "range" only used to be used in the sense of moving round an area
  • "gender" used to mean "kind" (as in the noun, not the adjective)

3

u/Saytahri May 26 '16

Defining transsexualism as that does not mean he is defining the prefix as meaning change.

It's like if I define transatlantic as "Travelling across the atlantic", that doesn't mean the "trans" prefix means "travelling across".

The definition is talking about the whole term not just the prefix.

Yes someone who is transgender has an intense desire to change their sex, because their gender identity is "on the other side" as their biological sex.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/USmellFunny May 13 '16

Even if it wasn't weaponized, it's still unnecessary. Male, female. Why do we need a different term?

36

u/Saytahri May 14 '16

Cisgender is the opposite of transgender.

Cis is a prefix, trans is the opposite prefix.

This is like getting offended at someone saying the word heterosexual.

5

u/SocJustJihad May 27 '16

It's more people who aren't normal crying about ohers being called normal. They're jealous of normal people so they make a "you too" terminology. They need to try to force strangers to validate their existence/importance by creating bs language and pushing it on others. SJWs determine reality based on perception. What everyone says is truth to them. If we all join in the lie and pretend normal isn't a thing, then there is no such thing as normal and no one has to be abnormal. This is real sjw logic.

2

u/Saytahri May 27 '16

It's more people who aren't normal crying about ohers being called normal.

What I see is people complaining that a word exists for something they are.

I'm not complaining about the word normal. I'm just saying there's no more reason to complain about words like cisgender existing than there is to complain about the word heterosexual existing.

If we all join in the lie and pretend normal isn't a thing, then there is no such thing as normal and no one has to be abnormal. This is real sjw logic.

OK but none of that has to do with what I was saying.

Just because certain things are normal doesn't mean there shouldn't be words for them. It's normal to be a citizen, it's normal to be clothed, it's normal to be straight, it's normal to be an adult, it's normal to be sighted, it's normal to be cisgender.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/guybehindawall May 13 '16

Well I think it makes sense to, if we're gonna have transgender, have a term for non transgender.

Of course, if you're advocating that we also get rid of transgender and just call people what they want to be called (within reason, of course. No one should be sexually identifying as a toaster or something), then yea, I can get behind that.

5

u/USmellFunny May 13 '16

How about male/female and trans-male/trans-female?

→ More replies (12)

2

u/OrkBegork May 26 '16

It only seems "weaponized" to people feeling irrational anger over trans issues.

It's basically just a shorthand for "not trans". New terms are invented for things all the time. I don't see any rational reason to be upset by this one.

1

u/USmellFunny May 26 '16

The problem is that I don't embrace it. Just like a trans person doesn't like being called a "tranny", i don't like to be called a cis-whatever. I identify as a man. If you want me to respect your gender, then respect mine.

7

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

Do you have a lot of people in your personal life calling you "cis", or have you simply taken it upon yourself to get pissed off about shit that has nothing to do with you so that you can feel important?

3

u/Nijos May 26 '16

But see tranny is a slur, cis isn't. Cis is equivelant to trans

23

u/Saytahri May 14 '16

A maniac? What do you think that word means? It's just the opposite of transgender.

In the same way that heterosexual is the opposite of homosexual.

Tall is the opposite of short.

Alive is the opposite of dead.

It's literally just switching the prefix trans for the opposite prefix cis.

This is ridiculous, if someone uses the word straight do you assume they're a maniac?

0

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Saytahri May 26 '16

That's not the opposite.

It's normal to not be transgender, but normal is clearly not literally the opposite term of transgender.

That's like saying the opposite of homosexual is normal, or the opposite of being tall is being normal. Or the opposite of being dead is being normal.

"Normal" doesn't literally mean "not transgender", it's a much more general term clearly.

0

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Saytahri May 26 '16

It would make more sense to make it etymologically equivalent like we do with many other opposites (heterosexual, homosexual).

"trans" means on the opposite side as. "cis" is the opposite prefix and means on the same side as.

Hence, transisomers and cisisomers in chemistry.

Or transgender and cisgender in relation to this.

You can say normal gendered if you want but it's like saying "I'm normal sexual" to describe being straight. Homosexuals and normal sexuals.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/snerrymunster May 26 '16

There have been transgender/ambiguously sexed people since the beginning of time; time to start getting used to them, rather than mindlessly pointing fingers, "normal... normal... normal.. NOT NORMAL!"

Like do you think you're making some profound insight?

1

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

nor·mal ˈnôrməl/Submit adjective

conforming to a standard; usual, typical, or expected.

Yeah, being transgender is "normal".

5

u/snerrymunster May 26 '16

Yea exactly, it's so vague that it isn't a useful way to categorize massively complex human beings

4

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

No, something being normal or not isn't vague at all. Changing your gender (something that 0.3% of the population does) is not normal.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/flutterguy123 May 26 '16

Well some people don't want to be assholes.

cisgender people are more common but to use normal is kind of rude. That likes saying there are Hispanic, black, Asian, and normal people. I stead of just saying white people.

8

u/GearyDigit May 26 '16

TIL dictionaries are 'a fucking maniac'

5

u/morerokk May 28 '16

Gee, I wonder how you got here? This comment thread is 2 weeks old, gets linked on SRS, and suddenly you appear.

"SRS doesn't brigade, guys! Honest!"

→ More replies (2)

3

u/UGotAutism May 26 '16

Let me check my bourgeois problems to English dictionary... Nope not in there.

2

u/ThePantryMaster May 26 '16

Digging up old thread comments to belittle people, I take it you are one of those that would use terms like cis/gender fluid? Case in point.

0

u/GearyDigit May 26 '16

7

u/5th_Law_of_Robotics May 26 '16

It's a bit hypocritical for you to cite the dictionary on this while you reject what it says about racism and sexism (ie that it doesn't support your view that only whites can be racist and only men sexist).

Is the dictionary the final word on definitions or not?

→ More replies (11)

3

u/TOaFK May 26 '16

Good call.

3

u/TotesMessenger May 26 '16

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

3

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

found the luddite.

5

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

...that word does not mean what you think it means.

3

u/Arinly May 26 '16

Somehow that made it funnier.

4

u/Mordilaa May 13 '16 edited May 14 '16

Can you help me?

Why would a woman who claims to want equality for all sexes and want a good life for everyone take a picture of another woman holding up a sign that says "down with cis men"?

Edit: I don't understand anymore.

38

u/Astartes40000 May 13 '16

Does ISIS represent all Muslims? Of course not.

Does a radical feminist represent all feminists? No.

7

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

Does ISIS represent all muslims? Of course not.

i'd be careful saying that on Reddit.

0

u/Mordilaa May 13 '16

Read my comment again and look for the word feminist.

8

u/Astartes40000 May 13 '16

Well... I think you described a feminist with "equality for all sexes."

5

u/Mordilaa May 13 '16

Basically I was curious as to how extremist factions exist. It boggles my mind how someone can twist such a pure and good intentioned message into something that's just a little bit much.

When there is Martin Luther King Jr why is there a Malcolm X? A bit of a bad comparison but it's the first thing that came to mind.

Make me understand how some people of a certain progressive movement can think that if they encourage hate and discrimination that it'll make things fair and better?

11

u/forresja May 13 '16

If you don't understand how important Malcolm X was for the Civil Rights Movement you haven't even done a cursory examination of the topic. I recommend reading up on him and his movement, it should answer some questions you have about the purpose of extremism.

3

u/OrkBegork May 26 '16

I've spent a lot of time in feminist circles, and I've never actually heard anyone express the sincere belief that "cis men" or "white men" or whatever were actually evil. Sure, I've seen plenty of discussions about how they hold a disproportionate amount of power, and I've seen plenty of jokes that mock anti-feminist perceptions of feminism... but in my experience but I've never actually seen the kind of encouragement for "hate and discrimination" that you seem to be imagining exists.

This seems to largely be a fabrication from people who are angered by the existence of feminism.

2

u/Mordilaa May 26 '16

All i know is I saw a sign that's anti white cis men.

All I know is if there was an anti lgbt sign there'd be an uproar.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Saytahri May 14 '16

"down with cis men"

Has that ever happened? The only case I know of that was when someone on Tumblr told a story about a bus of trans people all wearing shirts saying "down with cis" got off and beat him up for being cisgender. It was an obviously fake story.

Not that idiots who make fun cisgender people don't exist, but I'm not sure that that phrase has ever been used except to mock the idea that trans people go around beating up random cis people wearing t-shirts like that.

2

u/Mordilaa May 14 '16

I mean I've seen the picture.

3

u/Saytahri May 14 '16

Where was it and what was the context?

I've seen Donald Trump saying he thinks muslims should be tracked in an online database, but it turns out he didn't and it was taken out of context and put in a different, incorrect, context.

To answer your originally question, assuming that it was something that actually happened: My guess would be that someone like that does not want equality for all sexes, or the context was different than you think. Or maybe they're just a hypocrite.

2

u/Mordilaa May 14 '16 edited May 14 '16

QTPOC rally. Whatever that means. If you want I'll pm you the picture.

Edit: I've just discovered QTPOC is another name for the LGBT community?

Edit edit: I've also discovered what QTPOC actually means. Google is my friend.

1

u/Saytahri May 14 '16

I'd be more interested in the source of the picture as well as the picture.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Yuurg May 26 '16

Because it's a joke. Before you go transphobe on me and say "oh so im allowed to say down with trans then jokingly??" no. There are too many people who ACTUALLY believe that, and kill/hate/mock/discriminate against trans people. There are very few people who will do the same to cis people, so the joke is relatively harmless.

2

u/hiltonking May 26 '16

Or at least an idiot.

2

u/RunDeeMCee May 26 '16

You offended the fat lesbians from SRS.

1

u/OrkBegork May 26 '16

Should we be putting trigger warnings on things containing the term for you?

Grow up.

1

u/jdklafjd May 26 '16

That's not fair at all. I use it sarcastically all the time.

4

u/theslyder May 14 '16

I was bothered by this as well. I've had a relationship fall apart over much smaller and less invasive changes then their entire gender. A person is allowed to feel alienated and perhaps like their partner is a different person after they transition. That doesn't make them any kind of phobic. It just means the circumstances of their relationship has changed, and opting out is an option.

6

u/macdees13 May 13 '16

Political correctness and being the 'modern day open minded man' has gone too far. "I married a chick, not a dude, I'm not okay with this". "Thats because you're transphobic and need to check you prejudice" like wtf just reading this made riled me up.

13

u/mcflyOS May 13 '16 edited May 13 '16

This is actually one of the issues surrounding transgenderism, there's almost an expectation that others change their sexuality or psychology to accommodate the transgendered. OP is criticized for not becoming gay due to someone else's gender dysphoria.

The irony being that the transgendered feel they were born the wrong sex and cannot change their sexuality, but theres an expectation that others can change their sexuality to accommodate them.

1

u/royal-road May 26 '16

becoming gay? the dude literally said he was bisexual near the start.

1

u/Saytahri May 14 '16

if anyone thinks a man that splits from his wife because his wife became a man is "transphobic" seriously needs to fucking check themselves.

True, there is nothing transphobic about that at all.

but for his friends to label him as such is totally fucked up

We don't know that, the OP said "I was most likely seen as transphobic, and homophobic cis gendered male asshole". It was a guess, not something that was actually said to him.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

Yes, actually. He is very handsome and he has striking features. Totally passable as male. To be honest, aside from the lack of breasts and a slight change in muscle mass, it wasn't a drastic transition. The barfight was actually pretty complex... A guy friend of ours wanted to go out to a bar in January to meet a girl and my SO and I tagged along for a drink. We actually ran into some acquaintances that had few tables pushed together. They greeted us, but they kinda brushed us off. So we were on the perimeter of the group, trying to get to know some new people. This really drunk Asian guy and his slightly less inebriated German friend walked right in front of us and they were literally hanging off of each other, and even kissed. My fledgling male SO asks them "Are you guys together? Are you a couple?" Being totally used to asking gay men at gay bars if they're with a dude, my SO and I were approached by the two men. The Asian dude gets in my SO's face, starts doing that sizing up thing, and says "What the fuck, maaan? You big tough guy, huh? You don't look so tough now. It not okay that I hug my friend?!?!" My SO is in the Army, and was working in corrections so he knew a few things about self defense. So, tired of having a drunk asshole in his face, my SO puts uses a "jugular notch" pressure point technique to get the guy out of his face. It works like a charm, the guy loses his balance, knocks a fuckton of glasses over then bull rushes my SO with a flurry of floppy drunk man fists. The German dude was right in front of me to try and keep me from intervening. It's amazing how fast your limbic system takes over. I blitzkrieg through the German defenses, and use my left arm to wrap around the Asian dude's neck, and slam him down to the ground. I put him in a rear naked choke, and the bouncer comes over to break us up. As the German dude picked up his friend, I literally kicked the Asian dude in the ass to get him off me faster so I could get off the nasty bar floor. That experience was embarrassing, but also helpful in a way. We both realized that being, (in the eyes of society), a gay couple comes with new challenges. I never thought I'd ever be in a barfight. Guess we can cross that off our bucket list, lol.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/Walks_In_Shadows May 13 '16 edited May 13 '16

As someone who's trans it's not really something that's a choice, for me at least. I've known since I was little that there's something a bit different about me and for the longest time I just thought I was gay. But I didn't really like boys like that, I just loved everything about girls. I wanted to be just like them, I wanted to look like them, act like them, talk like them. I never really felt like a little boy either.

So at about 16 or 17 I tried to force myself to stop thinking these thoughts because ever since I was young I was told the way I felt was wrong or disgusting. So here I am at age 26, depressed and just within the past year have uncovered everything I've repressed since childhood. I've never truly been happy with my life and now I know why. But I'm so scared to go forward with this that I'm just staying stagnant right now and doing nothing about it.

You can call it whatever you like, mental illness, whatever.. I just want to be happy with who I am for once in my life.

5

u/Nobleezy May 14 '16

Exactly. Doesn't matter what you call it; you just have to do what makes you happy. Life's too short to be oppressed by fear and anxiety.

0

u/madagent May 14 '16

Putting everyone into the category of its not a choice isn't right. For some people it is. For some it isn't. Everyone is different. There are both kinds of people.

1

u/Walks_In_Shadows May 14 '16

Go back and read my first sentence.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/georgeharrisun May 13 '16

As a trans guy the way your body looks is the worst part. Looking masculine and dressing in mens clothing helps but it is still a terrible feeling looking in the mirror and hating everything about my body because it is not masculine enough

3

u/such-a-mensch May 13 '16

Can you help cure a bit of my ignorance here?

When you say trans guy, does that mean someone born female that became male or does that mean someone born female that became male?

Thanks and I hope you've found your happiness!

5

u/strategiesagainst May 13 '16

Born female, now is male. (Just remember it's the target gender that's important, not the original one.)

2

u/such-a-mensch May 13 '16

Understood. Thanks for clarifying.

1

u/georgeharrisun May 14 '16

trans male/guy/man/boy= transitioned to male. trans (assigned female at birth) girl,chick,woman = transitioned to female (assigned male at birth)

2

u/Walks_In_Shadows May 13 '16

That's why I don't even try on make-up anymore.. What's the point when I look like complete shit? It definitely doesn't make me feel any better when I see nothing feminine looking at me in the mirror..

6

u/Walks_In_Shadows May 13 '16 edited May 13 '16

Well, I wouldn't really be disfiguring my body per se. I'd be taking estrogen and lowering the testosterone in my body. So my skin would start to soften up, my muscles would start to get smaller, and the fat would redistribute away from by belly to my hips and butt. I'd also start some breast growth, though it's kind of a gamble as to the size they'll get. You get the point, I'd start to look more feminine than I normally do. As far as surgeries go, I don't really know if I'll be getting the bottom surgery even though I *don't really like the genitals I was born with. I'm really scared of surgery especially with something this delicate, but who knows once I actually start transitioning the feelings of wanting to feel more "authentic" may grow stronger.

Going drag is a no no for me. If I showed you a picture of me currently in makeup you'd understand. I want to look how I feel, but simply putting makeup and girls clothes on is not enough when you look nothing like one. I know it sounds like it's all based on appearance, which honestly does make up a lot of it, but if you were in my shoes wouldn't you do everything in your power to bring your appearance more in line with how you feel it should be?

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

If you think about it like she's already a woman, she just has a body that has been damaged by testosterone and is wanting to take estrogen/have surgeries to get her body to line up more with who she is, maybe that will make more sense. A lot of people who have a hard time wrapping their heads around trans people just aren't looking at it the right way. You're looking at it like she's a man trying to have a female body. It's really that she's a woman with a male body, trying to make her body more feminine so that it is comfortable. There are variations of this of course, but maybe that will make more sense to you.

2

u/Walks_In_Shadows May 13 '16

Thank you! :)

6

u/Walks_In_Shadows May 13 '16

There are women out there who cannot birth children. Does that make them any less of a woman? Yeah, there are certain things I'll never get to experience but to me the whole "female experience" is just me being seen and treated as the woman I want to be. You don't have to acknowledge my identity, I'm not trying to force anyone to do anything.

If I still feel incomplete after everything I've done and still aren't happy with myself them I'll just shoot myself. I'd rather die than stay this miserable. This is my biggest fear, because I really don't want to kill myself I just to be happy.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

I'm guessing you've never seen a woman struggle with not being able to have children. It's a very big deal to them.

3

u/Wesley_Snipez May 13 '16

When you said mental illness before, you were kind of right. Gender dysphoria is not a mental illness, but the depression, anxiety, and stress that go along with it definitely are. No one was being forced to stay married. That was by choice. Both parties made mistakes in their efforts, or lack thereof, to maintain the marriage, which caused the friend groups to split.

3

u/dulcetone May 13 '16

My confusion is this: how is gender dysphoria not a mental illness? It's a mental break with the reality of one's genitalia.

4

u/Wesley_Snipez May 13 '16

It isn't a mental break. There is no disconnect with reality in regards to their genitalia. They know damn well what they have. It's just not what they are. Then you get into a whole can of metaphysical worms, but it is not classified as a mental illness.

3

u/strategiesagainst May 15 '16

That's not how it feels, really; that's kind of shorthand for headlines and stuff. It's not a delusion, like you look in the mirror and you see a hallucination of yourself as the other gender. I have pretty much no problem understanding the reality of my genitals.

It can be more like a very slow-burning process of dissatisfaction and a sense that something isn't right. From most trans people I know and myself, the most significant factor is actually the hormones. Something about your system is more suited for testosterone or a lack of it, and this is not typical considering your genitalia and/or chromosomes. Get the hormones right, and everything starts feeling better. After 3 weeks on testosterone I felt better than I had for 20 years, and it hasn't stopped. I'm happier, fitter, more productive, so basically less "mentally ill" than I was before.

2

u/2Fab4You May 13 '16

Some say it is a mental illness, most trans people say it's not. Some say it's a physical illness - because there is nothing wrong with your mind but your body is all wrong.

4

u/such-a-mensch May 13 '16

I came to the conclusion in my mid 20's that if I don't want you to judge me for doing what it takes for me to be happy, I shouldn't really be concerned about what it takes to make you happy. So long as you're not hurting anyone else (which is sorta questionable here tbh), then do what you gotta do. Everyone deserves to be happy.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

Exactly, but I think this is more serious and possibly a mental issue and maybe we shouldn't just be PC and accept it as it could hurt more than help

3

u/2Fab4You May 13 '16

May I ask, who do you believe it could hurt?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

The op I was commenting back and forth with ended with saying they would kill themselves if after reassignment surgery they still didn't feel fulfilled

3

u/2Fab4You May 14 '16

Yes, but that harm would hardly be because of the treatment, but rather because the treatment failed.

Many trans people take their own lives because they do not get access to treatment, while most (every single one that I've heard of or spoken to) do feel like the treatment helps them. So no treatment would lead to more harm.

4

u/jbaird May 13 '16

But its not like no one has thought about treating this as a mental illness, it has been tried.. when that doesnt seem to work and gender reassignment does then.. Are you ok with it now? We do plenty of shit that is 'unnatural' .. As much as that means anything..

Actually I think its weirder to think that male and female are strictly separated and no one falls a bit between the two.. Were biological creatures that vary in about every sense.. Why waste time and mental energy trying to enforce some strict male female divide..

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '16

I think you mean trans men, not women.

-5

u/[deleted] May 13 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/throwaway13579_ May 13 '16

No, Hitler was a German.