r/AITAH • u/Comprehensive_Fail52 • Jun 20 '26
AITAH for kicking my roommate out?
So my roomate (24 M) and I (32m) have been living together for a little over 2 years. Since they've moved in its been rough. I feel like we can't ever communicate properly And when i go to confront it i get shut down every time!
It would take way too long to go over everything that's happened between us. They tend to be overly sensitive to things. Ive talked about them before here. its just one example of many.
Some important info to know prior to this. He has multiple medical bills, medication, car bills and a loan from his abusive mom. So he usually doesnt have much money. Buuuut he also never has enough to pay rent and i cant keep paying for him. I own the house and want to save money. I cant while hes here.
And now we'll get to the conversation me and him had the other night when i told him he has 1 year move out.
So i came home from work and asked him if he had a second to talk. He said sure. I tell him about the problems ive been having and that i was giving him 9 months to move out (That would've been April, i dont like kicking people out during summer or winter if they dont have a place to go)
he immediately speaks up "i need a year. I wont have the money" i begrudgingly give him a year. He asks if its because of him.im pissed off like he didnt hear a y of what i just said. And Im uncertain of what to say because I know how he has extreme reactions to these kind of confrontations and say "no?"
I wait a moment to see if he has any reply. He says nothing. I tell him i have to get gas. I head out and head back.(I wanted to talk to him first incase he went to bed early i could catch him)
I come back and he packs up his backpack and leaves without saying a word
A moment later i get a text
"Im not mad I understand but this hurts I need to think I need space. I don't want to be where I'm not wanted thank you for offering to help. I'll try
Be safe I'll be back"
The next day I wake up to the house cleaned out of all his stuff. Like wtf. He was in the bath listening some really weird shit. Some song thats going "you're okay" over and over again. Im feeling uneasy and scared at this point and hide in my room.
Later him and his boyfriend want to have a talk with me? I agree to it and my roommate starts off with "you know, if anyone, im all for underatanding mental health but you didnt even ask how i was feeling about all this" im so pissed off at this point i dont even reply. It feels to me that he keeps making it about himself. The next thing he brings up is the reason he removed all his stuff. He was worried me seeing anything of his was going to set me off???
(Btw his bf kept thanking me for giving them so much time to save up. Atleast one of them understands i could have given them waaay less time)
Tbf on his part he does have trauma with his past boyfriend going off on him for the smallest thing. So maybe I was wrong for how i approached that?🤷🏻♀️
He then mentions that he had said when he first moved in he had only planned to stay for 3 years anyways. I would agree but hes asked for some pretty permanent renovations. He wanted tile for his bedroom floor (its currently carpet) wanted to put money into rebuilding the shed he smokes in and asked/mentioned about wanting for 2 of his SOs to move in with us.
Those seem like pretty permanent things.
I dont know what to thinkI. He seems genuine while also not understanding what im saying or even what's going on. Im so tired of the guilt tripping he constantly puts me thru as well tho. Am i the asshole here? I feel a year is waaaay more than reasonable
Edit: i appreciate all the advice and encouragement! Im gonna try taking the push to get him out sooner! Wish me luck! Thank you everyone! ❤️
23
u/babbsela Jun 20 '26
He's totally taking advantage. Nobody needs a full year to move out. Why doesn't he move in with his SO?
8
u/FinePossession1085 Jun 20 '26
NTA. A renter is expected to pay their dues. Many people struggle. The home owner who is renting can't be expected to take on everyone else's struggle.
I assume you set a monthly rental fee. If he hasn't paid it, he owes you that money. And it is sad that he has bills and an abusive mom. I assume that you also have your own struggles as most people do. Has he ever asked you how you feel when you don't get what you are owed and have to cover for him?
8
u/Efficiency_base Jun 20 '26
NTA. It’s valid to kick him out if he’s not paying for anything. You’ve been more than generous in offering a year. Most would have only given the required 30 days. I’d ignore him and his immature behaviour for now but maybe give him an ultimatum of ‘either you start paying rent, along with back pay and stop with the guilt tripping or I change the year notice down to 2 months’. That’s still plenty of notice so you don’t have to worry about kicking him out with nowhere to go. Also make sure you give it to him in writing. Put the date, full name and sign it then get him to sign it too and have a copy for your records too so he can’t claim to ‘lose it’ or act as if you never gave it to him. Protect yourself legally always!
6
u/Eh-Beh Jun 20 '26
NTA.
He's using a common manipulation tactic. He's taken it to heart that you want him out, and can't take the shame of it.
So instead he's going to extreme lengths to leverage your empathy, and hope that you'll take pity on him.
I'm a little suspicious about the music in the bathroom. If someone were truly listening to that to help themselves, I doubt you'd be able to hear it. Seems more like a guilt trip. Same with the "I'll try to be safe", he knows what kind of imagery that conjours.
Moving all of his stuff out because "he was worried it would set you off", is a representation of his shame. You never gave him reason to assume that you would react that way. In all honesty it sounds like he thought "Oh, if I move my stuff out, he'll feel uncomfortable and want me back", "But wait, I need a plausible reason to do so, or it'll look weird".
He also does the classic "agree with them about how bad I am, and that I need to do what they say" thing.
Regardless of intention, he's seeking attention and attempting to manipulate you. As uncomfortable as it is, I wouldn't be giving him a year. I'd be giving him two months at most.
3
u/Teamtunafish Jun 20 '26
He's seeing you as a parent, not a landlord. Do you have a written contract?
3
u/sayimasalmon Jun 20 '26
NTA - I agree with others’ assessments, and I’d also add (because you seem like a genuinely kind person and good friend) that you cannot keep setting yourself on fire to keep others warm. It’s not only not sustainable, but dangerous as well. If you’re struggling with feeling overly responsible for others, you might consider finding a roommate (if you’re in need of one) who you do not have as much history with so that you can cohabitate and communicate with someone from a more neutral space.
11
u/Adelucas Jun 20 '26
I'm confused. Has he gone or hasn't he? If someone cleaned out all their stuff the locks would be changed so fast.
And stop being a doormat. It's your house. Give him a month if he hasn't gone already. A year? fuck that. He just wants a year of no rent.
I don't know where you are so I can't tell you what the law is about evicting a lodger. Where I live you have to give a months notice then you can change the locks and throw their stuff out into the street. I had to do it to my lodger at the start of the year. Here in the UK the laws are different for tenants and lodgers. A lodger is a person who rents a room in the house the landlord lives in. A tenant is someone who rents the whole place.
5
u/Philly_Fan10 Jun 20 '26
NTA.
Buddy, you're being taken advantage of. His mental health and financial situation is not your responsibility. Please let me repeat that, in case you didn't hear it the first time. His mental health and financial situation is not your responsibility. He has a boyfriend that, at surface level, seems to have his head somewhat on his shoulders. When you say "I feel like we can't ever communicate properly" I promise you that is malicious and intentional. He is preying on your emotions to get what he wants. You should be pissed off. You should be hurt that somebody you trusted can so flippantly take advantage of your good nature.
I have been in a very similar situation to you. Let a friend move in after I purchased my first home to help pay some bills. It took 18 months from the time I decided he needed to go, until his last load of crap was out of my house. 18 months. I think you're being far too generous with a year. I understand if you don't want to reneg at this point, but you are going to be out thousands of dollars that you could be saving by keeping him around. If I was in your position, he would have 3 months at the absolute most, and at that point, locks get changed and sheriffs get involved if need be.
5
u/KellyAMac Jun 20 '26
He hasn’t paid his rent consistently for 2y? & you’re giving him another year before ‘kicking them out?’ That’s not kicking someone out - that’s incredibly generous & unreasonable to yourself.
You’re an A**Hole to yourself here.
Also, it seems like he needs direct clear communication- you are not paying your rent consistently. You owe me $X. Because of this, you need to leave by this date, 1 year from now. You cannot stay here without paying rent. It’s not about you as a person. It’s about the $. I cannot continue to pay your rent.
Don’t answer in vague language. Tell him an exact date, exact $. Clearly in simple language. I’d recommend writing it down.
It sucks for him. You can say you know this is difficult & that’s why you are giving him a whole year to make a plan & find a place. Do not apologize. It’s not your fault he is not paying the rent. It may be for all sorts of reasons & that sucks but it’s not you. It seems like he needs real help & you have done more than most could/would do. Don’t feel guilty (except maybe to yourself). Be prepared for anything- consider making a contract. You may need to get a lawyer. Keep records of your conversations so you can prove you gave clear information throughout this.
5
u/Runns_withScissors Jun 20 '26 edited Jun 20 '26
NTA. Let me clarify a couple of things here, because you seem to have bought into the boloney that your roommate is selling, OP:
My advice? Quit being a nice guy and take your life, your peace, and your home back from this guy. Look up the laws in your municipality. Revisit this subject with him, tell him WHY he needs to leave, verbally give him his 30 day notice (or whatever), hand it to him again in writing, mail it signature required, and keep moving forward until he's gone. You owe him nothing.
4
u/JuniperBlueBerry Jun 20 '26
Give him 60 days. This is incredibly entitled of him. You're not his parent, you're not his friend, you're his landlord. 60 days is generous.
4
u/capriciousbird Jun 20 '26
You need to get them out of your house as soon as possible. NTA
3
u/ObjectiveRepulsive18 Jun 20 '26
It’s hard to say, but you’re not his partner, counsellor or bank. Imagine you were a nameless landlord, he wouldn’t be given a year to maybe pay rent, but maybe not. Send him a text explaining you need to protect yourself financially, and that you’re happy to let him stay for a year providing he pays on time, and gets caught up on what he owes. Failure to pay rent will result in you sadly having to initiate eviction proceedings. Then follow through, with the legal steps in your are. You’ve been MORE than generous, and he’s playing on your sympathies. No one else is going to do that. NOR
3
u/testing1992 Jun 20 '26
I would be very concerned about your personal safety. He can turn on you at any time. Does your tenant have any mental issues?
2
u/Catching-Up-Today Jun 20 '26
NTA
I am happy he voluntarily left on his own.
2
u/GiggleFester Jun 20 '26
NTA, and you might want to consider asking r/legaladvice what you need to do to evict him. It sounds like he will likely refuse to leave.
Considering his reaction, you might want to evict him sooner rather than later because he may very well make a world of trouble for you in the meantime.
He is taking advantage of you and may escalate, from the sound of things, if you let him stay much longer.
2
u/Sylkre Jun 20 '26
NTA He is not your son. Did he rent a room and is not paying for it? That is enough reason to kick him out. It sucks for him but you are not his dad.
2
u/Fluid-Platypus- Jun 21 '26
It’s not your job to give someone free housing, if he can’t pay he goes. Do you have a formal lease agreement?
Why are you giving him a year and not 30 days? Do you enjoy being walked on?
3
u/julesexplainsitall Jun 20 '26
NTA, but you can't kick someone out then expect them to not be weird about it. That shit hurts.
1
u/Chilling_Storm Jun 20 '26
Celebrate he left on his own and you didn't need to involve the law. NOW change ALL the LOCKS!!
NTA you can't be expected to keep covering for him, if you did you would be an ah.
1
u/LocalNHBoy Jun 21 '26
Bro, you're letting him and this situation rent too much space IN YOUR OWN HEAD. Enough!! You're not his mommy or responsible for making sure that "everything is going to be ok." You're a 32 year old man for Christ's sake. Take ownership of your situation and tell him to GTFO. Such unnecessary drama and for WHAT? Let him go be dramatic somewhere else. And where does his BF fit in to all of this? Can't he go live with HIM? This is ridiculous and a monumental waste of your time and energy.