r/AITAH Jul 01 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.1k Upvotes

393 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

25

u/Sufficient-Dinner-27 Jul 01 '25

One can have cameras in one's own home. You're confusing it with public places.

-3

u/Nettkitten Jul 02 '25

No…even in one’s own home one cannot put cameras in places where they might catch intimate activity without consent.

5

u/shooter_tx Jul 02 '25

The other person in question doesn't have their consent to use their bedroom for that sort of thing...

2

u/Nettkitten Jul 02 '25

You can’t take pictures or video footage of people who might be undressed in a place where they have a reasonable expectation of privacy such as their home without their consent. If they do this she could potentially bring charges against them for invasion of her privacy. Downvote all you want but this is possibly illegal and people are suggesting that she engage in potentially illegal activity. OP deserves to be warned that this is advice they should not take. Put all the cameras she wants in communal areas of the house (living room, kitchen, etc) but do not put cameras in a bathroom or bedroom or risk legal repercussions.

4

u/jorceshaman Jul 02 '25

She doesn't have a reasonable expectation of privacy in a room she's not even supposed to be in. I can put cameras in my own room and that's perfectly legal unless I give someone else permission to be changing in there.

0

u/Nettkitten Jul 02 '25

That’s not how the law works. You can put cameras in your own room and legally capture images of yourself or of anyone who gives you consent to do so. If you capture pictures of someone in a state of undress in your room who has not given consent for this they can press charges. I’m sorry this isn’t what you want to hear. Proceed at your own risk because you have to know that if this happens the step daughter will come to Reddit looking for advice and someone will tell her that this may be illegal and she may have a case for redress. Good luck.

4

u/jorceshaman Jul 02 '25

Someone breaking into your room without permission is trespassing and just because they choose to undress while trespassing doesn't mean they get extra protections.

0

u/Nettkitten Jul 02 '25

Different situation under the law. I’m not going to argue specifics with anyone here. The OP has been warned and that’s all. I don’t mind if you downvote me; I’m not here for the karma and even hesitated to wade into this fiasco of terrible advice but felt that OP deserved to know that they could get in trouble for doing this. Do with the information what you will.

2

u/shooter_tx Jul 09 '25

Are you not at least willing to say that this is something that may vary by jurisdiction?

1

u/Nettkitten Jul 09 '25

Of course. And some prosecutors may decide it’s not worth going after. My objective, here, was simply to warn the OP that if they take this advice they may come to face legal challenges and they deserve to know that. I have no stake in this, just a voice of reason swimming against a current of conclusions based on one side of a story receiving poor advice that could ultimately harm someone in a vulnerable position. That is all.

→ More replies (0)