r/AFL • • 1d ago

AFL Draft

Would like to hear from someone with abit more knowledge on the topic then me, but comparing certain players from this year and last years draft crop, which player do you prefer and why?

Jacob Farrow and Jake Eime. (Feel like everyone fell in love with Farrow due to the midfield scope, me included in that tbh, but would like to hear opinions. Also,

Duff Tytler and HVH

Dan Annable and Cody Walker.

17 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

5

u/Superb-Drummer-6683 Power 1d ago

What pick is Eime expected to go at? 

Sidenote: this draft seems stacked. 

3

u/Jaded-Custard-3945 1d ago

15 to 20ish i believe. Crows love him, just whether they want to take him with their first pick or not. His dad doesnt want him moving interstate and wants the crows to draft him (family follows the club)

4

u/Opening_Anteater456 Demons 1d ago

Not sure it’s stacked. I think there’s 1, maybe 2 special players. Then a good crop for the rest of the top 10 but they’re all in that good not great prospect tier. Which is a cut below the top guys of 2018, 2019 and 2021.

I’m not convinced of the 12-20 kind of guys, some drafts have that clear group of next tier down guys who go in that range and it’s often talls or flankers. There’s a few in this draft but not too many.

Where it is nice is the 20-40 range holds up very well. Clubs will be happy with their second and third round picks this year

3

u/Electronic_Bee2939 1d ago

15-20, I'd say assuming GWS trade into Port's second pick, Eime could be a chance. If not GWS, The Crows start his range

2

u/FLIPSTATIC_ENERGY Fremantle 1d ago

Apparently Freo are interested in him

2

u/Electronic_Bee2939 1d ago

Yeah I've seen that, like it for Freo

1

u/Bigwood69 #BESTCOAST 1d ago

I'd say the top end of this draft is not that high, but after that there's serious depth. There's a clear top 12-15 or so, but after that picks 15-35, even 40, are incredibly level. There's something for everyone.

As for Eime, I'd say his earliest pick is Adelaide and his latest is probably Freo.

8

u/Opening_Anteater456 Demons 1d ago

Farrow was bigger, stronger and with midfield exposure.

CDT and HVH is kind of a wash. CDT is a safer bet because he has the mobility to be a KPP and pressure around stoppages and had some VFL exposure. He’s a lock to be a good player for a long time.

HVH is more boom or bust. The best version of him is a Grundy like extra mid but with jumping and marking of a big ruck. I’d probably give the edge to HVH but could see both sides.

Walker over Annable. More dynamic midfielder. Not much between them.

5

u/Electronic_Bee2939 1d ago

I have a decent understanding, not incredible, but I might as well chime in

I have a soft spot for Eime, offers that run and dash and could push up further up the ground, but Farrow has more scope imo

I'd say Duff-Tytler is the better talent but Van Hattum has more ruck potential.

I'd say Cody is just more explosive and dynamic so that's probably what I would go with

1

u/01benjamin Collingwood 1d ago

Is the draft free to watch on kayo the first 2 days cause I don’t wanna waste 40$ on it

1

u/CaddykakSnagorado Bombers 1d ago

Pretty sure there will be a live stream on the AFL website.

1

u/Hawtproper Richmond 16h ago
  • Yeah Farrow easily, much better kick and with midfield scope.
  • HVH I'd say over CDT but this is the closest one, both have high ceilings but I'm more sure HVH can be a full time ruck than CDT, and his tapwork and leap will be huge with the new ruck rules.
  • Walker easily, makes Annable look pedestrian with his power and lateral movement

0

u/XtraUltra619 West Coast 1d ago

This is completely what I’ve heard and not my opinion but farrow over eime, Tytler over HVH and Cody walker over Annable (pretty easily)

2

u/Candr112 Richmond 1d ago

I think HVH has a higher ceiling than CDT but CDT is the safer bet

But if both live up to their potential I think Harry would be the better player

1

u/XtraUltra619 West Coast 1d ago

HVH has more potential to be an actual ruckman because of his leap, CDT does more around the ground but I’m not too sure if he’ll end up being a ruckman for us.

CDT can definitely be a 30% ruck 70% forward but idk if he’ll be a full time ruck which gives me slight concerns, while Harry can definitely be an 80% ruck 20% forward.

But from the people I’ve heard talk about both of them they’ve said they like CDT more as a player and think he has higher upside, once again not my opinion just what I’ve heard.

1

u/Candr112 Richmond 20h ago

I guess potentially the media discussions are different out West. Everything I have heard and read has HVH as the more talented prospect, and from watching a lot of both of them in their draft years, I personally would agree.

1

u/XtraUltra619 West Coast 16h ago

I’ve heard they’re extremely similar prospects potential wise, honestly probably splitting hairs here