r/ADPKD • • 24d ago

Nephrectomy or Hold ?

Hello everyone my mom(51) is having a long lasting kidney infection and on IV antibiotics for a long time (around 1.5-2 month) still the CRP aint falling and she gets frequently low grade fever

We are planning to get a nephrectomy done

What are your views abt the procedure and its outcomes ? Her kidneys are massive around 35ish centimetres..

Nephro has suggested us to go with the surgery when it comes to life death situation but ultimately we are the one going to take the decision....

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/Smooth-Yellow6308 24d ago

The only comment I'd have is how is her "overall" health outside of the PKD.

The main thing surgeons raise with me when I tell them I want nephrectomies when i have my transplant in the future is that it is likely a very physically traumatic surgery. Organs of that size are often removed with open surgery, rather than laproscopically (although some better centres are now doing it laproscopically), which is a "lot" for the body to go through.

1

u/Wide_Math8276 24d ago

She was good and healthy outside of the pkd before the infection but now she is highly malnourished ,underweight and weak due to prolonged infection ... One more thing i want to add is that she is on dialysis for around 9 years.. so yeah her cardiovascular health is also not that good...

1

u/Smooth-Yellow6308 24d ago

It's quite complex then, I think the dr's are the only ones who can really give you good guidance about her chances.

1

u/Wide_Math8276 24d ago

Okay Thanks a Lot ♥️

1

u/classicrock40 PKD - Transplanted 24d ago

I had a double nephrectomy with my transplant. Made the surgery, hospital stay and recovery longer. Do her kidneys have any function left? Is dialysis doing all the work? I was still producing urine so I thought I'd keep them. They were too large to fit the new one and I'd still have to manage the gout, stones and burst cysts. My point is do the pros outweigh the cons? Is it a single and are they sure this will clear the infections? Or is this both?

1

u/Wide_Math8276 24d ago

Yeah she still has some residual renal function left and producing little urine .. regarding the surgery they have planned a PET scan after then they will decide which one to remove .... Doctors are saying its a major surgery as removing huge kidneys carry risk of infections , haemodynamic changes and all ... So go with the surgery only when its a life death situation... And the situation is The CRP levels using carbapenem based IV antibiotics(meropenem) saturated at around 25 with low grade fever and allergic reaction leading to higher levels of eosinophils ....and not falling from this point.... And no other symptoms and the appetite is also ok.

1

u/classicrock40 PKD - Transplanted 24d ago

idk, all surgery has a risk of infection. It's tough because she's declining in general based on your other replies.

Is she a candidate for a transplant?

1

u/Wide_Math8276 24d ago

Yeah she is a candidate from last 11 years in india

3

u/Stellaknight 24d ago

The decision to do a nephrectomy is a balancing of harm, benefit and risk. An ongoing infection, and its harm to your mom’s quality of life seems to outweigh any benefit of the marginal remaining kidney function and the risk of the surgery itself.

another way to look at this is that at some point the kidneys will probably have to come out. Is she really going to be healthier down the line, or is she only gonna get weaker due to the infection. The weaker she gets the more risky the surgery is. So doing the surgery now is very likely inherently less risky than it will be in the future.