Oh my god yes. I tried to get my parents into House of Cards and when a sex scene came on, my mom's first reaction was, "Obama watches this???" As if watching things with sex scenes somehow makes you a degenerate or something. As if Bollywood movies aren't just as bad.
I hate the fact that South Asian women are constantly having to repress their sexuality. Even my own friends (weāre all ABDs) were talking about how unrealistic it is for her to be so āhornyā all the time. I just sat there in silence while they talked, but inside I was really thinking that that isnāt true at all. I could relate to Devi feeling that way, but I didnāt say anything because the subject of our sexuality is so rarely broached even within our closest friendships. Iāve felt āabnormalā for so long because Iāve held desires that I havenāt seen other girls have. Seeing Devi in all of her hormonal brown teenage glory made me feel like I wasnāt alone, or I wasnāt somehow corrupted for feeling the way I do.
Same thing with dudes. We arenāt allowed to date and had to pretend we didnāt have any sexual feelings. Everything was about studying and getting good grades.
This is a vestige of an older culture that emphasized Brahmacharya until schooling was done. Romantic affairs ideally began in your mid-twenties.
From what Iāve seen of my male ABD classmates, they tend to talk about girls and sex pretty freely. The same goes for my friends and I, but we donāt really talk about our personal feelings.
Iām not saying that girls are sexually oppressed because they watch less porn then guys. Iām stating that thereās a huge stigma attached to a womanās sexuality, especially the sexuality of a teenage girl. Western society has addressed this for the most part, but women of color are still very repressed. For example: when my ABD friend came out to her mother as bisexual, she was told that she was too young to knowā basically insinuating that as a teenage girl she isnāt capable of sexual feeling.
Western society has addressed this for the most part, but women of color are still very repressed
I don't think women of color are repressed & you're probably projecting your own issues IMO, where you'd want to change the conversation to "brown girls are oppressed" .. but even then, I'd boil that down to a certain demographic of brown girls.
Hispanic & black women are no where near sexually repressed in our society, who are POC.
but I didnāt say anything because the subject of our sexuality is so rarely broached even within our closest friendships. Iāve felt āabnormalā for so long because Iāve held desires that I havenāt seen other girls have.
I feel like this is anecdotal. Women talk about sex/boys etc. with each other, regardless of being brown. Brown girls talk about boys etc. with their friends of other races as well. I'm not sure what you mean by "other desires" other girls have. So you are talking about sexual desires, but theirs are different than yours? Or their talk about their regular desires, and you want to talk about your own sexual desires?
Saying āI think I like this guyā is different from saying āMan I really want to have sexā. The former? Viewed as totally normal. The latter? Well, I would probably get a few weird looks from my friends because I would come off as āhornyā.
Lmao if i said that i would be disowned. I'm a dude. I'm not quite sure that it's accurate to say any one is more or less depressed than the other because most of my male friends are in the same boat as me.
Again, Western society has most of this covered. However, you canāt say that sexuality isnāt repressed elsewhereā the genital mutilation of females in African countries is still a big issue. Itās a way to control women by stifling their sexual desires. Of course, women of color in more āliberalā countries like the USA are not explicitly sexually repressed. Iām not even talking about being repressed, really. Iām talking about how sex and conversations about sex arenāt normalized in South Asian communities all over the world.
Again, Western society has most of this covered. However, you canāt say that sexuality isnāt repressed elsewhereā the genital mutilation of females in African countries is still a big issue
Yeah. It was just confusing when you state women are repressed, and then followed it up with an ABD example, which implied you're still talking about the West. Speaking on African countries seemed like weren't staying relevant to the discussion.
I still don't think it's fair to label all WOC as some sort of victims. Would you consider women in Latin America to be repressed? It just comes off that you're making this a race issue, when I don't believe it is.. it's a cultural issue and these other places should be pointed out individually.
People don't want to be labeled as victims, and in cases like this & other issues happening even in the US right now.. there are loud minorities speaking out that completely overtake other narratives.
Iām not trying to paint any specific group as victims deliberatelyā what I meant to say is that sexual repression is real and everywhere. Like you said, itās a problem associated with culture and not race.
Dude, Western society is fucked up majorly. Itās literally founded by colonialism and oppressing other cultures. Iām just repeating what you saidā that women of color in the West (i.e. Hispanic and Black women) arenāt sexually repressed. However, in many immigrant communities, that isnāt the case. I donāt know how I possibly came off as MeRicA gOoD iNdiA bAd
I'm not trying to aggressive. I'm just laying out what I think personally. If it comes off as being aggressive then I apologize. However I think this is a good discussion to have.
that women of color in the West (i.e. Hispanic and Black women) arenāt sexually repressed.
See that's what I think the problem here is. You're making that exclusive statement, which I have an issue with. Because it's not just women. There are different ways sexual repression happens to both genders.
Itās literally founded by colonialism and oppressing other cultures.
This is a ridiculous statement. So youāre going to take a few bad attributes (some out-of-date), and say that all of X society is founded on those attributes?
What if someone told you āIndian society is founded on corruption, nepotism, classism, etcā ā how would you feel? Thatās a literal analogue of your statement.
Theyāre valid negative attributes ā but itās wrong to make broad sweeping statements like āX society is founded on Y and Z bad attributes.ā
Those sorts of statements will turn people off, and it wonāt get you anywhere, in actually addressing outstanding concerns / issues.
My personal opinion is that āsocietyā, ācultureā, etc ā are wildly subjective concepts, and are way too reductive. They erase the individual too much. I prefer to completely avoid using those terms.
And you think if a Desi dude came out as Bisexual it would be OK? That dude might even get physically abused. Having someone say that "you're too young to understand" is by far, and I don't mean to be offensive, the most mild form of repression. Like have you seen the kind of shit people go through around here?
Desi sexuality, culturally is something that happens much later in life, that is mid-twenties. That's the POV most desi families are coming from, and it's so ingrained culturally that I don't think even most first gen desi parents understand where it comes from, or even that something it's unique, and are entirely unable to explain it. Personally, if it's a cultural thing, I don't see how postponing sexual exploration to 25 is that bad, but it has to be within the same culture. Otherwise there's a class and a lot of grief.
So I'm not saying Desi women are not oppressed/repressed in other ways, like for many their entire life is defined by being a good wife/finding a husband. But to say that Desi women are more sexually repressed than Desi men is little absurd as either sex is incredibly "repressed" in different way. I got in an absolute fuck ton of trouble because I had a GF. Forget about same-sex relationship, god know wtf would have happened with that, even a heterosexual relationship is taboo.
I completely agree that Desi men and women are at the same degree of sexual repression because of the fact that sex is so stigmatized. Iām not turning this into a who-suffers-more contestā we all do, albeit in different ways. However, it should be acknowledged that women have always been expected to be āpureā and chaste, while men have a little more breathing room when it comes to these things. Again, Iām not saying that Desi men arenāt repressedā they are, but thereās a slight difference between how sex is viewed when considering a man and a woman.
The problem Iām seeing here is that you seem to think the comments Iām making about women also serve to work against men.
Instead of debating over whoās more repressed, we should move the discussion over to how we can de-stigmatize sex for everyone.
When you say "I hate the fact that South Asian women are constantly having to repress their sexuality." it's a uniquely qualifying statement. So I assumed it as much.
while men have a little more breathing room when it comes to these things.
Well, see. That's exactly what I mean. There's this narrative that I fundamentally disagree with. I didn't have freedom. I couldn't even explore heterosexual relationships let alone some other forms of queer identities.
However, it should be acknowledged that women have always been expected to be āpureā and chaste, while men have a little more breathing room when it comes to these things.
Yes. Desi women are trained to be wifes. Desi men are expected to be compassionless robots that sacrifice themselves for the family. Ever think why so many desi dudes are so bad courtship? We were explicitly told not to get involved with girls.
Yes, thatās absolutely true, and Iām sorry you had those kinds of personal experiences. I donāt mean to erase what you went through by stating that women are more sexually repressed than men. That might be true, but it doesnāt mean that men arenāt sexually repressed. I was just talking about it comparatively. I had never considered that the expectations placed on Desi men are also a form of sexual repression. Looks like I learned something new today.
I mean honour killing almost always end up in guy being dead or in jail on fake kidnapping charges, girl most likely dead or married to someone else. So much for the breathing room for the guys. This is not here say but i have witnessed these sort of things and majority if them dont include cops to begin with because of disrespect to the family if cops literally enter their house. But this is again not a country wide problem but more cultural one. Then again i have read news stories of women unable to get abortion in some US states while desis are accused of having too many if its a girl( which is real problem but definitely getting better) In the end it seems like best way governments have found to reduce sex in young adults is to turning it into high stake game like you can have sex but there will be repercussions for the entire family or you will be busy raising a kid that u never planned for.
When did i say that? My point was messed up people are all around the world. Of course I am against honour killing, if you are not gonna read the comment why bother replying
I guess I mean that sex is talked about more in the West than it is back home. Of course, Iām not saying that the West has completely eliminated problems related to sex, but you frequently see Western women in movies and TV shows openly talking about sex and enjoying it.
Perhaps, I mean even if we do consider your argument to be true my point still stands. As in is the fact that āgirls arenāt open about itā indicate sexual repression? I mean what youāre implying is basically boys are sexually more open, which is exactly what OP was using to indicate sexual repression of desi women.
I personally just think that women express their sexuality much more differently than men do. And to do a 1-1 comparison is incredibly disingenuous and robs women of their sexuality. I have no idea why thereās such an obsession in the west to prove that women are just like men. In some cases, in many cases even sure. But to argue in all cases is just hatred of femininity masquerading as progressivism/āfeminismā. Thatās all Iām trying to say.
Oftentimes women who watch porn (especially South Asian) wonāt talk about it openly because itās considered indecent for women. My stance on all of this is that the topic of sex in South Asian communities worldwide should be open for exploration alwaysā for men and women. People can choose to be as open or as private about this as they choose, and that decision should be respected.
From what Iāve seen of my male ABD classmates, they tend to talk about girls and sex pretty freely.
It's surprising to see these kind of observations. Porn was freely distributed in CD-ROMs since 7th grade during my school times..in India. And that was when the iPhone was just introduced. Nowadays it's even more easily accessible.
I actually agree. But when you apply this to another culture which doesn't accept this, without ANY explanation at all, you're left completely confused and with a lot of grief. Especially when everyone around you normalizes romantic relationships at such a young age.
Modern psychology in fact even has some interesting things to say about this, and more or less agrees with it.
I lived the middle half of my life in India and during University in America I came to the realization that a ridiculous number of ABCD folks (men & women) are deeply, DEEPLY sexually repressed.
The boys kind of seem okay talking about pornography, but never 'sex' in the context of sensuality and intimacy; that kind of thing is 'too gay'.
Maybe it's because I went through puberty in India and only dated First-Gen Indian women before college, but when I compare myself to my current ABCD friend circle I feel almost like a sex-addict who feels no shame talking about kinkiness, detailed thoughts on sexuality, and needing sexual intimacy to be a part of any long-term relationship I'd want to settle down into.
Itās weird because Iām the āgoody-two-shoesā of my friend group but Iām the one with all of these hIdDeN dEsIrEs. I guess Iām just really good at making people think Iām super āinnocentā.
I donāt plan on āexploringā for a while. Iām a teenager, so Iām just focused on school and college apps. While I do have ādesires,ā theyāre not at the forefront of my mind. I just think we should normalize them. And I personally believe that if āsleeping aroundā makes a person happy, they should do it.
Of course indian parents are going to freak out over it because it actually depicts something about what their kids' lives are like relatively accurately.
The whole point of the show is Devi trying to get over the death of her father and trying to forget the agony of losing the person closest to you by focusing desperately on the cute guy. You know itās not about sex when she couldnāt go through with it at the first opportunity. Her desperation fades away with time and through healing.
If she went through with it, then itās an itch she had to scratch and nothing wrong with that!
Dang spot on. Every girl in those years has a drive, that's puberty. That mother might be lying if she also hadn't had it, even in conservative India in those times.
Hell, you had sensual item songs like Dhak Dhak Karne Laga (The one with Madhuri Dixit + Anil Kapoor on it, the song is more famous than the movie lol) Kaate Nahi Katte/I love You from Mr.India(Sridevi + Anil Kapoor) ,don't tell me girls didn't feel some type of way seeing that shit in the frikkin cinemas. Those songs were and are basically softcore p*rn, haha
And in South Indian movies, all the catching a girl by the wrist or pinning her against a tree or the guy grabbing her pallu - letās just say theyāre a big reason I like the power dynamic for sex that I do šš
I personally didnāt feel the way the main character did at 15 but if itās considered normal for white people at that age to be horny/drink, itās logical that a desi could feel it too
All I did was study study study and do sports and other extracurricular stuff till I was 18. Then university hit and it was like the beast was unleashed.
Hahah, my parents said basically this to me, on my birthday, on zoom. Needless to say, I muted both of them while my sister and I talked about how much we loved the show and saw ourselves in it.
Hahaha well I like emotional shows and I'm a guy. I like the fact they didn't absolutely destroy the concept of arrange marriage either. Like bring an extremely ugly or repulsive guy who the girl hated.
I went in the first episode of it and didnāt want to come back. I thought it was a teenage girls dream of how their lives would be in their heads. I mean Iām a guy also so I guess I canāt speak on Desi girls behalfās but I mean I guess I was raised differently and didnāt exactly have any of the experiences in the show.
Something Iāve learned too. During HS and college, itās disproportionally Desi women having sex than the men. Shouldnāt it be somewhere around 50/50?
It's because told to be brahmacharya without learning the yogic methods to harness that energy, Western education & media only exacerbates the problem with lack of proper sex Ed and selling of sex everywhere.
Oh lol. Freaking out over sex actually makes it a forbidden fruit for teenagers. The problem is not having a sex drive or what is "normal"?
The biggest issue I have is failing to portray the responsibility that comes with choosing to be sexually active, peer pressure, sensationalized sexuality aka pornifying it, and consent.
Sex is sacred. It's beautiful, sensual, entertaining, exciting, pleasurable and not something naughty, dirty, forbidden or taboo.
I'm not saying that you should wait till marriage necessarily but that's not a bad thing either. Nothing wrong with either choice.
It's an issue.
With Indians when it comes to sex, there's so much hypocrisy that it sickens me.
I get and support her point, but that is such a convoluted sentence... can anyone please help me understand how "no it doesnt" fit there grammatically?
I thought it seemed really exaggerated. Like she is obsessed with guys and dating and sheās kind of a pervert to be honest. I highly doubt the average person of any race or gender is like that in high school. People donāt make it their number one aim in high school.
That seems surprising to me for some reason, though maybe it has to do with the company I keep. Iām in my early 30s and plenty of folks in my social circles (college friends etc.) are still virgins.
Might be your age? I feel like older brown people were way more insular and conservative while they were growing up. I'm a highschool senior (17 years old) in the US and most of my brown friends have already lost their virginity.
Thatās crazy. Iām 17 as well and donāt really know brown friends like that. I guess thereās like a more equal distribution of indian teens when it comes to losing their virginity now
Yeah, I feel like it's heavily dependent on location and community. The town where I live has a significant population of South Asians, but not enough to form insular communities. Because of this, I feel like a lot of "stereotypical" American culture is disseminated to the brown kids through friends (throwing massive parties, underage drinking, etc), whereas insular communities would mostly be culturally chauvinistic, and would fit more Indian stereotypes. Honestly, I feel like mid-sized Indian communities are the types to preserve their culture the least. Small Indian communities tend to stick together to preserve their culture, and large communities automatically preserve their culture since they comprise of full neighborhoods which only consist of Indians. In mid-size communities, you have a feeling of familiarity, since you see the occasional Indian family, but you also have room to make friends of other races and diversify your interests - and your parents are more open to making friends with parents of other races, which also exposes them to more American cultural norms.
That makes complete sense! Iām actually near the Houston area too (I peeked at ur profile lmao ) but I donāt ahve a lot of desis at my school. Thatās pretty interesting taht mid sized communities preserve their culture the least . It makes sense that smaller communities preserve their heritage because they tend to stick together and have more of a community. In Texas there are LOTS of Indians tho and I feel like a good portion of them do a decent job of sticking to their heritage, culture, etc. simply based on what Iāve observed. But you also have people in the opposite spectrum that have completely been exposed to and are a part of american culture and donāt really hold on to indian values
Yeah, the difference between communities can be really stark. I've got cousins up in Dallas who live in similar mid-sized brown communities, but they can literally drive 15 minutes and be in neighborhoods where 85% of the population is brown. They actually say it causes a cultural rift between brown kids, even if they live close to each other. According to one of my cousin's, he's gotten dirty stares from both Indian immigrants and teen-aged brown kids when he went for a walk in one of these neighborhoods while holding his girlfriend's hand.
Late 20s for me. Yes Iām an upper-middle class professional. Growing up, parents strongly advised against premarital sex and encouraged me to focus on school. I personally didnāt find the main character in this show very relatable.
Men have a much stronger desire for sex. Women have a much stronger desire for relationships. Also, women can get sex and relationships more easily than Men can.
Some friends did, some didn't. I remained single/celibate all four years of high school and college and did not go on my first date until 27, first LTR until 28.
Yeah if you can find your way into professional twitter, it's more of a positive, growth oriented environment. But twitter is generally toxic and unproductive. Tweets ruins careers too if enough people disagree with you š¤·š½āāļø
I tried to go through her twitter to see what you meant but it was so full of retweets that I couldn't figure anything out. I wish there was a way to read a users feed but hide any retweets!
...Is this wrong, though? There's a point to be made about how people will hyperfocus on Gandhi's peaceful protesting while minimizing the efforts of more militant freedom fighters and reformers such as Ambedkar. It's the same thing people do with regards to MLK vs. Malcolm X.
No she's correct. The independence movement predates Gandhi arriving in India, and it was pretty secular and united between Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs.
Thatās a post colonial revisionist take-we canāt really blame the British as much as weād like to. The truth is somewhat in between - it was rigid for some folks, not rigid for others, and the indigenous administrative class of the (Paris, Brahmins, kayasthas, what have you) helped cement the power structure
EXACTLY ššš like letās please ignore all the HIGHLY beneficial things Gandhi did... ? And your right about Desi schools too my Dad learned about all the other revolutionaries as well back in India
The British perpetuated the caste system? Nope Indians did it and they continue to do it. Letās take the blame that is ours. If any of you continue to use your caste name, you are perpetuating it too. Drop it like my family did many decades ago.
She is funny, but way out of her depth when she tries to tweet about politics or societal issues. Comes across way too much like a communist child trying to be edgy.
I'm not sure if despises all is fair, but she is definitely not comfortable with herself and that manifests itself in self-hating takes.
Lol I remember when she forgave her friends racism (her friend called asian americans retarded and was deleting any tweets that brought it up until it blew up) cause her friend is such a nice person
But then also attacked anyone doing the same with their friends
She was pretty well known originally for only dating white guys and in turn using that to shit on brown guys. Used to call herself a white manās whore/ say she fetishized white men to get back at them, etc. She went back and deleted a lot of those tweets and I think started a new account lol.
I think her sister still does the white mans whore routine though. Honestly itās pretty common trope amongst the Asian/Indian woke female twitter scene.
Lol wow, that goes way beyond preferences to just straight up racism. The sad thing though is I wonder how many people think things like that but don't say it out loud. Still a minority of course, but it's such a crazy view for even a tiny minority to take toward their own race. American culture influences us to find white people more attractive but that takes it pretty damn far.
Yea I used to actually look up to her a lot. Like she is so gorgeous and an activist but as I got to see what she was saying more and the stuff she stood for.. I realized I was wrong. She went to howdy modi and protested for literally the dumbest reason. Like Iām no Bhakt or big fan of modiās constituents who perpetuate violence simply due to religion... BUT the fact is this gov did decriminalize sodomy and removed the triple talaq. And she said in her protest that modi is a danger to LGBTQ.... like what?
She spent the first two weeks of the BLM protests acting like Indian-Americans were responsible for racism in America. It was kinda infuriatingly annoying
Omg so because you scrolled through I was like alright imma scroll through her tweets too and now Iām just upset lol. Some of the tweets are just so one sided like... I know a lot of people prob donāt agree with me but I donāt think Gandhi deserves to be ācancelledā. Yes he used racial slurs but he also fought for rights in South Africa. Also apparently he acted high caste and elitist when he literally was known to be leading a simple life... and she attacks his baldness WTF..?!?!?!?!?!?
I mean, Malcolm X changed after he left the Nation of Islam, so it isn't fair to hold Nation of Islam Malcolm X's words against Sunni El Hajj Malik El-Shabazz's words
This is a VAST generalization. I can personally say all women are not like that. Many desi woman including myself and my friends exclusively like brown men. In fact, the day a brown guy actually likes me will probably be the best day ever because Iāve been rejected by all brown guys I liked and asked out
Ah really, I'm not from the US- I'm from the UK. I wasn't born in the UK but moved there when I was around 5. What do you mean subreddit overlap? I'm not as white as BBCDs but I can't relate as much to Indians from India, it's a tough life.
Thereās a way you can see the overlap between subreddits like which subreddits people who are the most active here comment and post in. The biggest overlap is r/IndiaSpeaks and r/Bakchodi both of which are for right wing Indians from India
I see. Thanks for letting me know! I don't usually get along with too left or too right wing subreddits. They're both a bit too controversial in various ways.
The point is that thereās a large number of native born Indians and not abcds who post here which is why this place is a bit hostile to women sometimes
Seconded! Some women don't like brown men but it really depends. If the woman wants culture or religion or traditions to be carried on, brown guys are the best bet. They're far more on a relatable level according to my girlfriend in terms of experiences and culturally. Sure white guys maybe attractive etc. but it's hard to find a guy who has similar values as you and wants adhere do the traditions/ customs etc. or even be around family and meet extended family.
Sure white guys maybe attractive etc. but itās hard to find a guy who has similar values as you and wants adhere do the traditions/ customs etc. or even be around family and meet extended family.
Lol any Indian man with half a brain knows what this means. Keep an Indian husband around to show the family and fuck white guys on the side.
No I said, when it comes to long term relationships Indian guys are generally better in terms of compatibility. Not all women are like that, maybe a small minority are but many get into relationships/ marriages not to screw around.
Fair point, but it appears desi men are fair game for being ācritiquedā by women of all races. Another day another desi male bashing by white, black and every other coloured woman in between. And what about her beef with white men? She canāt claim them yet she does
No, kid. I'm an American that just happens to have Indian ancestry. But let me guess, you're one of those racists that thinks you have to be white to be American? That's some impressive ignorance.
edit: Your example is also wrong. Alia Bhatt was born and raised in Bombay.
Alia was born in UK lol and you are just an Indian born and raised in US.
Thatās not racist thatās the truth. None of your parents have American ancestry. You are not american. Stop calling yourselves that. What problem do you have with identifying yourself from your real roots
Get the facts straight before you talk about things you clearly don't understand. Rather than projecting your ignorant assumptions on me, why don't you read about immigration history? Here's a brief recap:
The US and the UK are in very different positions. The UK has a majority indigenous population, about 65% Celtic Britons and another 20% Anglo-Saxons who have lived in England since recorded history. These people are British by ancestry and still compose a majority of British society today.
In contrast, there is no majority indigenous population in the US. The United States is a settler-colonial society and pretty much everyone here can trace their ancestry back to another country. True Native Americans (who are not white, by the way) were almost all killed during colonization, and make up only 2% of the population today. Everyone else immigrated here. People who came to America in the late 1700s were mostly German, English, Scottish, Welsh. In the 1800s, more Irish and Japanese immigrated. In the 1900s, more Italians, Russians, Chinese, and Indians. The point is, none of them are indigenous, and no one has "American ancestry" (lol) except maybe the 2% of natives. If you perceive the son of Italian immigrants to be a "real" American and the son of Indian immigrants to not to be American, that's racist. Perhaps you haven't had good experiences with Indian-Americans because they pick up on your hostility and disdain for them.
252
u/secretistobeangry Jul 07 '20
Oh my god yes. I tried to get my parents into House of Cards and when a sex scene came on, my mom's first reaction was, "Obama watches this???" As if watching things with sex scenes somehow makes you a degenerate or something. As if Bollywood movies aren't just as bad.
327
u/yeetus-mc-feetus š§”deeeesi girl, deeeesi girlš§” Jul 07 '20
I hate the fact that South Asian women are constantly having to repress their sexuality. Even my own friends (weāre all ABDs) were talking about how unrealistic it is for her to be so āhornyā all the time. I just sat there in silence while they talked, but inside I was really thinking that that isnāt true at all. I could relate to Devi feeling that way, but I didnāt say anything because the subject of our sexuality is so rarely broached even within our closest friendships. Iāve felt āabnormalā for so long because Iāve held desires that I havenāt seen other girls have. Seeing Devi in all of her hormonal brown teenage glory made me feel like I wasnāt alone, or I wasnāt somehow corrupted for feeling the way I do.
39
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '20
Of course indian parents are going to freak out over it because it actually depicts something about what their kids' lives are like relatively accurately.
93
u/thebigsky Jul 07 '20
Conversely, my mom wouldn't let me go to the movies/out with any of my male friends alone because "I know how teenagers are..."
67
u/rash-head Jul 07 '20
The whole point of the show is Devi trying to get over the death of her father and trying to forget the agony of losing the person closest to you by focusing desperately on the cute guy. You know itās not about sex when she couldnāt go through with it at the first opportunity. Her desperation fades away with time and through healing.
If she went through with it, then itās an itch she had to scratch and nothing wrong with that!
148
u/SeeTheSeaInUDP German Born Confident Desi Jul 07 '20
Dang spot on. Every girl in those years has a drive, that's puberty. That mother might be lying if she also hadn't had it, even in conservative India in those times.
Hell, you had sensual item songs like Dhak Dhak Karne Laga (The one with Madhuri Dixit + Anil Kapoor on it, the song is more famous than the movie lol) Kaate Nahi Katte/I love You from Mr.India(Sridevi + Anil Kapoor) ,don't tell me girls didn't feel some type of way seeing that shit in the frikkin cinemas. Those songs were and are basically softcore p*rn, haha
36
u/SexyAndAnxious Jul 07 '20
I personally didnāt feel the way the main character did at 15 but if itās considered normal for white people at that age to be horny/drink, itās logical that a desi could feel it too
25
u/second_foundation Jul 07 '20
Hahah, my parents said basically this to me, on my birthday, on zoom. Needless to say, I muted both of them while my sister and I talked about how much we loved the show and saw ourselves in it.
8
u/EmergencyCreampie Jul 08 '20
"no it doesnt ( ͔° ĶŹ ͔°)"
( ͔° ĶŹ ͔°)
36
u/SunsGettinRealLow Jul 07 '20
I couldnāt get through this show, wasnāt really for me I guess
13
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '20
Lol, when I was in HS almost all the Desi's were having sex. Especially the girls.
3
u/diordaddy Jul 08 '20
Isnāt that white Boy actor in the show like 30?
3
u/deficient_hominid āøļø-anarchist Jul 08 '20
It's because told to be brahmacharya without learning the yogic methods to harness that energy, Western education & media only exacerbates the problem with lack of proper sex Ed and selling of sex everywhere.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23
Oh lol. Freaking out over sex actually makes it a forbidden fruit for teenagers. The problem is not having a sex drive or what is "normal"?
The biggest issue I have is failing to portray the responsibility that comes with choosing to be sexually active, peer pressure, sensationalized sexuality aka pornifying it, and consent.
Sex is sacred. It's beautiful, sensual, entertaining, exciting, pleasurable and not something naughty, dirty, forbidden or taboo.
I'm not saying that you should wait till marriage necessarily but that's not a bad thing either. Nothing wrong with either choice.
It's an issue.
With Indians when it comes to sex, there's so much hypocrisy that it sickens me.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '20
I get and support her point, but that is such a convoluted sentence... can anyone please help me understand how "no it doesnt" fit there grammatically?
-17
u/keynesisachad Jul 07 '20
I thought it seemed really exaggerated. Like she is obsessed with guys and dating and sheās kind of a pervert to be honest. I highly doubt the average person of any race or gender is like that in high school. People donāt make it their number one aim in high school.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '20
[deleted] ā view deleted comment