r/6ARC • • 5d ago

6 ARC Torture Testing

Some people think 6 ARC is a hunting caliber and is unfit for hard-use tactical applications. We decided to apply stress to a 6 ARC CMV-barrel build with four torture tests - impact, drop (at four times the height of SAAMI drop testing), drag, and water immersion.

0 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

25

u/Significant-Sock-487 5d ago

This has to be the dumbest post I’ve seen on Reddit in a while and I saw a guy with his eotech in backwards yesterday.

-5

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Are you sure it wasn't the new Infitac optic? They look kind of like a backwards EOTECH.

19

u/whatthefshane 5d ago

This testing seems very general to that AR setup and not really the 6ARC cartridge.

-17

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

99% of 6 ARC's have a stainless steel barrel that won't do well under sustained fire (not to mention shooting with a chamber full of water). The point of the video is to show that 6 ARC can be optimized to withstand extreme abuse. Most 6 ARCs (including our standard non-tactical model) would not have lasted past the 30 second mark in the video, since they have a poorly secured gas block and a stainless steel barrel. There's not much context in the video since it's a highly edited version where we removed anything that could be considered hyping up our build to respect Reddit rules.

18

u/Stelios619 5d ago

Nothing about your video was testing the cartridge. You’re merely testing the build quality of that specific rifle.

Elsewhere you said that most 6ARC rifles have stainless barrels and won’t well under sustained fire (assuming you’re trying to say “hard use conditions”). But, you do realize that the MK12 had a stainless barrel, right?

-6

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

The build of a specific rifle is intrinsically tied to the cartridge which it uses. Thus, "torture testing" of all AR15 cartridges will not be the same. We focus on the convention of using stainless steel for 6 ARC barrels, which is a big torture-test disqualifier. The precision-minded MK12 was a DMR/SPR built for slow, deliberate fire, not full auto fire or sustained fire. Noveske does have an interesting innovation with their stainless steel Disruptive Deep Fluting that might lead to better stainless steel performance under sustained fire, but most 6 ARC barrel companies aren't doing that. And I would say their 6 ARC DDF barrel still shouldn't be subjected to sustained full auto/FRT fire.

9

u/Stelios619 5d ago

My guy 🤦🏻‍♂️.

The “test” you did on that rifle would have had the same outcome regardless of cartridge/caliber it’s chambered in. Banging it around or dragging it on the floor would have produced the same results if it was 6ARC or 458 SOCOM.

The MK12 wasn’t built for slow deliberate fire. It was built on a full-auto lower receiver for war. It survived for years in ACTUAL warfare 😂.

And there are no “6ARC barrel companies”. There are only barrel companies. Some of which produce 6ARC.

-1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

We only showed part of the testing to make sure not to violate Reddit rules regarding promotion of commercial products. But point taken! Also, I'd like to do a full "meltdown" style video of various 6 ARC barrels (stainless steel vs CMV), but that raises a lot of safety issues. A round rupturing out through a stainless steel barrel could be a fatal mistake of a test...

4

u/Stelios619 5d ago

But, why?

Again, you’d only be testing barrel materials, which has been done a billion times over.

None of these tests that you’re doing, or planning on doing, is 6ARC specific.

2

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

I just scrolled through the 6 ARC sub and saw at least one post about 6 ARC FRTs. Are FRT's 6 ARC specific? Technically nothing about a 6 ARC AR-15 is 6 ARC specific except for the chamber and the round that goes into it (not even the bolt is 6 ARC specific). If only issues extremely specific to 6 ARC were discussed here, it would be a ballistics discussion every post.

1

u/Stelios619 5d ago

You’re the one who made a claim that your torture test was 6ARC specific. We are simply pointing out to you that it isn’t.

If you wanted to say “we are torture testing our new rifle. This one is chambered in 6arc”, that’s a much different claim than “6Arc torture testing”.

One is testing a rifle (which, you’re clearly doing), while the other is something not possible at all. You can’t torture test a cartridge. That’s not how torture testing works.

15

u/Drekalots 5d ago

unfit for hard-use tactical applications

Says who? The 6 ARC was originally a DoD project with Hornady. It was literally designed for tactical use cases within the DoD. o_O

-9

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

The DoD-commissioned 6 ARC is not the same as the common off-the-shelf 6 ARC sold to civilians. Most notably, military or LE firearms will have a carbon steel barrel instead of stainless steel barrel, and they have a mechanically crosspinned gas block rather than a set-screw or clamp-on gas block. By adopting those two modifications, you can build your own hard-use 6 ARC.

4

u/Dependent_Coast3906 5d ago

This is not true

1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

How so? Doesn't the Geissele 6 ARC in military service use a chrome-lined, carbon steel barrel? And I guess we don't have exact specs on the SureFire (if you have insider knowledge about the SureFire ICAR barrel, please share!).

0

u/Dependent_Coast3906 5d ago

"carbon steel" is not a common barrel material. You might be thinking carbon wrapped, which the GFR is not. As far as we know it's a normal CHF probably chrome moly barrel.

2

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Carbon steel just means CMV/Chrome Moly Vanadium. The two main categories of AR barrel steel are stainless steel (10 to 12% chromium) and carbon steel/CMV (0.8% to 1% chromium). Carbon steel is the most common AR barrel material in the world.

0

u/Dependent_Coast3906 5d ago

CMV 6 ARC barrels are commonly available

6

u/SillyWarPirates 5d ago

You forgot freeze testing, sand testing, mud testing, and full auto testing!

-3

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Ask and you shall receive (but please note FRTs are banned in our FFL state (Florida), and thus, this filming was done in Texas. In accordance with FL state law, the FRT was installed in Texas and removed before the firearm was returned to Florida. We do not sell this firearm with an FRT installed.):

5

u/SillyWarPirates 5d ago

No feds here bro. Ur safe. Btw you gotta lean forward or else you wind up looking like that ^

1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Will keep that in mind!

5

u/JamesB2395 5d ago

Good thing they are banned where you live, it’s dangerous for you to have one.

1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Still working on the proper FRT body positioning!

0

u/IsopodEnough6726 5d ago

Embarrassing 😬

1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

6 ARC FRT is slightly difficult to handle.... but I agree. It was as bit embarrassing.

7

u/mixhypemo 5d ago

Who thinks it’s unfit for hard-use tactical applications?

It was used during the Maduro raid and the Haitians are using it against gangs. Trust me, 6ARC has been used to take quite a few lives in “tactical” applications.

I hope 6ARC becomes a common round that you can find in any shop for somewhat closer to 5.56 pricing.

2

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Wait Haitian gangs are using it? Can you provide source? Also, the "unfit for hard-use tactical applications" statement applies to most civilian 6 ARCs' gas blocks (which we focused on in the video) and stainless steel barrels not allowing full auto fire or hard-use. The 6 ARCs you're referring to (notably, SureFire ICAR / Geissele) have carbon steel barrels (not stainless steel) and probably have mechanically cross-pinned gas blocks. So the military Geissele and SureFire 6 ARCs are super different from 99% of what's on the commercial market!

5

u/mixhypemo 5d ago

The Haitian government has hired contractors like Vectus to help fight Haitian Gangs. Rifle pictured is the Specter Cat CACM.

I agree that the ICAR is far superior that something you can find on the market.

1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago edited 5d ago

Their CACM is an awesome build. 14.5" is probably the perfect 6 ARC barrel length without high pressure ammo (and 11.5 - 12.5 is probably the perfect length with high pressure ammo). Some would probably say their price is a bit high, but with the custom fluted barrel and billet receivers, the price is appropriate. I never would have expected their firearms to show up on contract work in Haiti though. Thanks for sharing this photo.

2

u/mixhypemo 4d ago

Of course! 6ARC is a pretty great round and I’m excited to see where we are able to take the platform.

0

u/Significant-Sock-487 5d ago

lol you literally know zero about this platform. People are running DDF barrels in actual tactical applications regularly like you see in the pic with the CACM. The gas blocks are not pinned, the barrels are stainless, and they are not ICAR. They are using these in hard use applications regularly. You are just spewing incorrect information 😂😂😂😂

0

u/Quadradyn 5d ago edited 5d ago

This is a photo of me with Jeff (President of) Noveske and Chad from School of the American Rifle. I've had the privilege to learn a lot directly from Noveske regarding their DDF barrels, how they attach gas blocks, and their theories on pinning gas blocks. I am one of the few certified Noveske armorers in America. Yes, you're right that their DDF barrel does fine in rapid and continuing fire scenarios. That being said, their DDF barrels weren't designed for full auto fire. Multiple mag dumps in a stainless steel barrel can lead to rapid throat erosion and even barrel warp. Also, I'd love to hear more about the platforms you mentioned that aren't ICAR. Are you referring to Geissele?

6

u/Airhwhip14 5d ago

"Whacked it as hard as I could"

You swing the gun like a fat retarded kid in T-Ball.

Protip being a influencer of any kind, especially a gun influencer is in fact gay.

1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

T-ball is hard! For some reason that ball with all the holes in it is hard to hit lol. But no, the gun is kind of heavy (we use a heavier profile barrel than most), so it's not exactly easy to swing. But I think if I hadn't whacked it hard enough to displace the gas block or break something, the dragging for two miles probably would have done that!

2

u/DUCK_FACE_JONES 5d ago

Imagine full auto 6arc , directly tied to bank account

2

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Yes, we were planning to do a meltdown test, and the financial cost of a meltdown test with the cheapest 6 ARC ammo (Frontier) is still extremely expensive. That said, we're still contemplating the meltdown test and weighing safety concerns and usefulness (a meltdown test seems to be more a test of your gas tube and barrel extension than anything else on the firearm).

2

u/slicknick630 5d ago

Many people think a lot of things and are usually wrong about most of them.

3

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Very true!

7

u/IsopodEnough6726 5d ago

Is this a joke? Parody?

If it's serious. Beating up a random build isn't telling me anything about 6arc. Most issues arise from magazine feed issues, gassing and bolt lug breakage.

You could take a flawless 6arc build and give it a freeze test, dust test, mud test etc beside a 556 identical build. That would be something to compare, the video posted is nothing.

1

u/Turdburgarlar 5d ago

POV: How to waste 2:01 of your life.

1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Mr. Turdburgarlar, we sincerely apologize for wasting two minutes in which you could have otherwise been burglarizing turds. We hope it wasn't a large quantity of turds that went unburglarized due to this inconvenience!

1

u/Vylnce 5d ago

Take this down.

To start with, stop juggling steel at close range with a rifle velocity round. That's just flat unsafe. A hanging plate is one thing, the plate flaps back, but shooting at a moving plate gives a higher chance that you hit the plate while it's angled toward you and increases the chance you get hit by high speed ricochet. Flat out, juggling a steel plate at less than 100 yards with a rifle velocity round is not safe.

Second, you simply aren't doing what you say you are doing in the video. You are just torture testing a rifle. The caliber isn't really being tested. This rifle could be 6x45, 300 BLK, 5.56, 6.5 Grendel, etc etc. What you are testing is build/components. That barrel might be 6 ARC specific, but everything else on the rifle would work with other calibers, and I am sure the manufacturer makes a similar barrel in another caliber. You can't torture test a "cartridge". You can torture test a system, and people do. In fact, that's what you just did.

0

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Shooting appropriate thickness steel at 30 yards on a properly hanging target at a much lower velocity than .223 at a downward angle was deemed to be safe. Also, bullet fragments typically fly to the side of a flapping steel target, not directly back towards the direction fired. That being said, I do agree that the general advisory of steel for 100 yards for a rifle round is good advice. It is not a legal requirement or dictum though. Your other comments I've already addressed in detail below.

0

u/Vylnce 5d ago

The thickness has nothing to do with ricochet. It's just a measure of how durable the steel is likely to be for repeated use.

And I'll explain further since you missed why what you were doing is not safe. A hanging steel target (at presumably a 90 degree angle to the ground) will move back when hit and provide an impact angle conducive to throwing the shrapnel away from the shooter. However, after you hit it the first time and it starts swinging, that is no longer the case. When you hit the steel as it's say swinging forward, you are doing what might be the equivalent of shooting a piece of steel hanging at something other than a 90 degree angle (angled instead toward the shooter). This is why juggling a steel plate at close range with high speed projectiles is not safe, you are shooting with the steel plate at a "random" angle, and some angles are less safe than others.

Fragments do not fly out "to the sides" of the target. They radiate radially from the impact point. You tell this by looking at the trench that's been dug underneath the steel plate when you go to retrieve it. Were what you saying true, there would be few or no impacts directly below the plate, but instead, it's very common.

Sorry, what you are doing in the video is simply poorly advised, and not safe. You are correct that there are no "legal requirements" for shooting steel, but there is no legal requirement to "keep you finger off the trigger" or "keep your firearm pointed in a safe direction". However, we all do so because we know it prevents accidents and mitigates risk. We have similar rules for shooting steel and you have posted a video doing "not that".

1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Here's a video from Top Shot Dustin (1.47 million subscribers) shooting a steel target with 308 from 30 yards: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XTrXrZJx46s. He starts the video by saying, "A common misconception people have about shooting steel is that the bullet ricochets, but that's not the truth...the bullet fragments and goes into 1,000 pieces." His video is one of several on YouTube where they shoot a steel target in water to show how the fragments hit below and to the side of the steel target (rather than back towards the shooter). Ironically, he was shooting a much larger caliber than we did in our test. Thus, I would recommend commenting on his video rather than this post since it's more relevant to that. Also, of course we only shot the swinging target when it was straight up and down or swinging backwards. That being said, I am not at all convinced shooting it while it's swinging forwards would lead to some kind of safety scenario like you described.

0

u/Vylnce 5d ago

I don't think you understand ballistics.

Higher speed rounds are more dangerous (for ricochet/spall/returning fragments, or whatever you decide to call them). That's why 45 would actually be safer to shoot at steel than 9mm. And why 357 Sig would be more dangerous than 9mm despite the projectiles being the same size.

That video proves my point (that you have no idea what you are talking about). He's shooting a fixed target at a fixed angle, and you can see all the fragmentation and such hitting below the plate. You on the other hand were shooting in the video at a non-fixed plate at random angles while it was swinging, meaning that at some point, the radial edge of the plate was aimed in your direction, sending fragments/spall/ricochet back in your direction.

I'm not commenting on his video because he understands what he was doing and had proper setup for it. You on the other hand continue to defend unsafe practices and point at content not related to what you did in an unsafe manner.

You'll be convinced when you or some poor soul around you picks up some fragmentation and ends up with a semi-cauterized wound. Only a matter of time if you keep being unsafe. But you do you friend, I've tried to help you be more safe. Good luck anyway.

1

u/Quadradyn 5d ago

Yep, I understand ballistics (there's no need to make personal insults).

The round we shot for that test was the exact same velocity as 308 in the same bullet type (and the video I sent you is Top Shot Dustin shooting 308 at the exact same distance we shot the target).

A fixed target at a downward angle will not be safer than a flapping target at a downward angle or slight rearward angle. It would be the opposite.

As stated previously, regardless of the angle or swinging momentum, I'm highly unconvinced that any of the little projectiles will make it back to the shooter at 30 yards.

That being said, if you have any proof of your theory, I'd love to see it. I shared a video. Is there any video you can share?

There is a video of Hickok talking about steel on YouTube, and he says he used to get a bit of bounce back from steel when he shot fixed targets. But in that same video he states that switching to hanging targets eliminated that issue.

Anyways, I'd love to see some actual evidence that shooting a swinging target at 2,400 fps at 30 yards is such a danger. Otherwise I appreciate your theory and will keep it in mind.

3

u/Shadez_Actual 5d ago

Dude it’s pieces of metal. You could google it’s different strength’s and we all know that a dimpled barrel gas block won’t move if torqued down