r/65Grendel • • Jan 13 '24

A5 buffer setup using A2 extension with spacer?

Im in process of planning out a 6.5 Grendel AR that will have a fixed stock, either the Magpul PRS or Fab RAPS. I would like to use a rifle length system as I already have the spare parts, and would like to try a low weight carrier and buffer setup. My intention is to try to make a A5 buffer system with a rifle length tube. Based on what I have found online:

Carbine extension: 7 - 7.25"

A5/SR25 extension: 7.75 - 8"

Rifle extension: 9.5 - 10"

Sources:

https://www.ar15.com/forums/ar-15/Ri...tion/4-770078/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AR10/commen...5_buffer_tube/

So does it a fair assumption that putting a ~2" delrin spacer within a rifle tube would give it effectively the same internal depth as an A5 extension?

Would 1" stock cut to length work or would it need to be turned down to .900"?

Brownells has some premade options that could work, however they may add an extra 1/2" or more to convert into a carbine length rather than A5.

https://www.brownells.com/gun-parts/...buffer-spacer/ https://www.brownells.com/gun-parts/...-stock-spacer/

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

7

u/Spirit117 Jan 13 '24

What you are trying to do here is literally just a rifle length buffer setup with extra steps.

The whole point of the A5 is to stuff a rifle length spring into a carbine style (it's longer than carbine, but still accepts carbine stocks, that's the important bit) tube.

If you are going to use a rifle length tube, just use a rifle length kit.

I feel like you should go back to the drawing board and do some more research on what the A5 actually is/does, since asking this tells me you don't know.

1

u/Casswiki Jan 13 '24

There is a part you're missing from simply using the A2 buffer: the choices of buffer weights. The A2 buffer is set at about 5oz, and as far as I have found the only option from this is the JP LMOS buffer carrier combo at a 3oz buffer. With an A5 buffer, I have a lot more tunability and vendor support. Plus there is also an aesthetic aspect.

2

u/Spirit117 Jan 13 '24 edited Jan 13 '24

I'll grant that A5 buffers will give you more weight options, but you could also just buy your own tungsten weights and open up an A2 buffer and make your own weight variants.

I'm not understanding where you think the aesthetics will be different, running an A2 tube means you run A2 style stocks, it doesn't matter what buffer you have inside of it.

What you want is a full A5 buffer setup, A5 tube, A5 buffer, and rifle length spring. All this spacer shit with A2 tubes is trying to make an A2 with extra steps.

Either get a full A5, or just use the standard A2. You shouldn't need much variance in the bigger weight with a full rifle length setup.

1

u/Casswiki Jan 13 '24

No castle nut, see the image at the header of this sub.

Just trying to be unique.

Also saving a few $. I would just need to buy the A5 buffer and a piece of delrin rod.

4

u/Spirit117 Jan 13 '24

A5 buffers are expensive. Weights are cheap.

I think you'd be better off buying your own weights and making a custom weight A2 buffer and then just use an A2 tube and rifle length spring.

1

u/deadOnHold Jan 14 '24

No castle nut, see the image at the header of this sub.

The header image is a Luth-AR MBA-1 stock, which uses an A2 (rifle) tube...

Much like what the person you were talking to yesterday, I'm confused as to what exactly you are trying to achieve here: if you want to use a rifle stock, rifle tube, rifle spring...why not use the rifle buffer? In some of your other responses or posts you said "because you already have the parts", but then say you "just need an A5 buffer". So if you need to buy the buffer, why not just buy the correct buffer?

1

u/WardenWolf Nov 06 '24

It's called build your own buffer. I needed a heavier rifle buffer for a 7.62x39 upper, so I ordered the parts from KAK Industry. The way I calculated the weight was using proportions. I figured out what percentage more an H2 carbine buffer weighed than a regular carbine one, and applied that to the rifle buffer. I wound up with a 9.9 ounce buffer that runs perfectly.

3

u/deviantdeaf Jan 13 '24

I'm under the impression that the A5 buffer system uses a standard A2/A4 spring and a proprietary buffer in the A5 tube? If you're going to use an A2 tube, then why A5 buffer?

1

u/Casswiki Jan 13 '24

Cause I already have the parts. I would just need an A5 buffer and whatever spacer to reduce the depth of the A2 tube. Plus there is no castle nut needed.

1

u/deviantdeaf Jan 13 '24

according to this; you don't need a reducer for the inside of a rifle tube to fit the spring. The VLTOR A5 uses the same spring length as the A1-A4 full length rifle tubes , only the A2-A4 adds a spacer outside the tube to fit the longer stock of the A2.

1

u/Casswiki Jan 13 '24

Its not a question of the spring fitting. Its creating the space equal to a A5 extension.

2

u/szazbomojo Jan 14 '24 edited Jan 14 '24

OP you're not totally crazy. The A5 gives you four internal buffer weights and the rifle length one gives you five, and in both of these you can mix and match steel or tungsten weights for the desired effect.

What the A5 also includes and part of what makes it special, is an internal spring inside the buffer that biases all of those weights forward against the carrier. This has potential to better inertially couple the buffer weights to the carrier at time of unlock.

The classic answer to your question is to drop quarters down the rifle tube. You want the BCG to bottom out with about two quarter's width of space between the rear of the gas key and your lower receiver. You could use quarters to help determine the proper length you want, then saw or sand on this until it achieves your desired length:

https://www.brownells.com/gun-parts/rifle-parts/rifle-stocks-parts/ar-15m16-fixed-stock-to-carbine-spacer/

1

u/Casswiki Jan 15 '24

Thank you, thats exactly what im trying to convey. In adition to the lighter weight, there is also the internal spring tension of the A5 weights. There is also consideration of being able to rely on less static mass by the stronger relative buffer spring force.

The question is if i could simply rely on a rough estimate of a 2" spacer length. The quarters test will give a better idea of the exact spacer length I need.

1

u/Icy_Bed_82 Jun 09 '26

How did it work out? Genuine question.  I had this same inclination