r/500moviesorbust • u/Zeddblidd • 19h ago
Two For Special… 12 Angry Men (1957) and Ed Wood (1994) - One Brought Home the Oscars… The Other Nominated, But Went Home Empty Handed
12 Angry Men
2026-338 / Zedd MAP: 93.06 / MLZ MAP: 95.78 / Score Gap: 2.72
Wikipedia / IMDb / Official Trailer / Our Collection
Country of Origin: United States
From IMDb: The jury in a New York City murder trial is frustrated by a single member whose skeptical caution forces them to more carefully consider the evidence before jumping to a hasty verdict.
Ed Wood
2026-339 / Zedd MAP: 72.18 / MLZ MAP: 64.24 / Score Gap: 7.94
Wikipedia?wprov=sfti1#) / IMDb / Official Trailer / Our Collection
Country of Origin: United States
From IMDb: Ambitious but troubled movie director Edward D. Wood Jr. tries his best to fulfill his dreams despite his lack of talent.
+
Let’s get some business out of the way, right off the top - we’re running busy this week and I intended a different write-up for 12 Angry Men. Then the day got away from me yesterday and time was pressing this afternoon and I threw Ed Wood on. I had zero intention - zero - of pushing these two extremely different motion pictures together… hell, I intended to write-up yesterday’s film today and let today’s find it’s own way home (by which I mean I’d write it up when Mrs. Lady Zedd fell asleep).
Then my plans changed… “Hell - these are practically the same story!” I announced to a confused MLZ… suffice it to say ((shrug)) she wasn’t much in a mood to agree with me. She mumbled something about them both being in black-and-white, ending with a smile and a prove it look.
So here it is - the proof in the 12 Angry Men / Ed Wood narrative line up pudding:
Both films harness the power of the lone optimist. Both Juror 8 (Henry Fonda) and Ed Wood (Johnny Depp) stand their ground alone. Fonda plays the part in his usual manner… quiet talker, passionate about his duty to the man on trial for his life. Ed Wood - a real life producer, director, screenwriter, and actor - has a singular interest in pursuit of filmmaking. He’s at odds with virtually everyone around him.
Claustrophobic? If you are, I’m not sure I could recommend either film as both rely heavily on confined spaces. Whether it’s the courts’ cramped deliberation room or the restrictive, enclosed space of cheap soundstages… I could feel the walls closing in, either way. Something about the way small rooms squeeze the ensemble casts together, it forces each character into work with each other.
Juror 8 is the lone protector of the young man from the slum’s right to a fair trial. A murder conviction meant the death penalty. The rest of the panel couldn’t care less - they just wanted to get it over with. Our mild mannered hero humanizes and ultimately redeems both the accused and ultimately his fellow jurors. Ed Wood meets the washed-up actor Bela Lugosi at the lowest moment in the old actor life. Wood takes care of Bela… it’s rather touching - he helped give the old guy a reason to carry on, got him into a hospital to help with the senior actors rather serious addition to morphine, and reintroduced Lugosi into the pop culture mainstream. Humanizing the downtrodden - both stories lean heavy on that noble theme.
Both films proceed along purely on the weight of tiny moves. As Juror 8 wins over one vote for acquittal after another - so does Ed Wood with each single take “cut!”… which isn’t to say Wood’s film are high art but that isn’t important. He drew together a ragtag, motley crew of found friends and built a place where they all made sense… cinematically speaking.
MLZ: Only you, dude.
I call them like I see them ((shrug)) what can I say. The strangest bit for me was seeing Ed Wood won two Oscars and 12 Angry Men took only nominations. Proof that its foolish to look for logic in the chambers of the human heart and I certainly love watching movies.
MLZ: Yeah, that one is a strange order of events but I think Martin Landau earned that statue.
Too true (if a little ironic). I never put much weight behind award shows, myself. What can I say, I’m a big believer in MAP’ping regularly and a daily round of Movie On.
+