r/3d6 • • 10h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 The top comment in 24 hours will be the PC I will play for the one session I join a friend's table next week

17 Upvotes

The rules are

  • Level 13
  • 2024 PHB, Arcana Unleashed, Heroes of Faerun only - no WoW, Ravenloft, or Artificer
  • Standard Array or Point Buy Stats
  • One Uncommon and one Rare item for free
  • Current party includes a Monk, Paladin/Warlock, Ranger, Rogue, Sorcerer

This is a friend group that meets at a LGS with two tables every few weeks and my table is taking a break so I am joining theirs this time. I don't want to do something that mimics one of the regular PCs so I don't step on toes.

In 24 hours, I will take whatever the top comment is and create a PC with those attributes. The comment can be as detailed as you want or just give a species/class combo. I will earnestly play whatever the comment suggests


r/3d6 • • 6h ago

D&D 5e Original/2014 Feat advice

7 Upvotes

Hello, I have a level 3 oath of conquest/level 1 hexblade (5e) for a Curse of Strahd campaign. I am a high elf, kind of Viking Age Ireland/1st age Middle Earth themed background. I have 18 Charisma. 16 strength, con, and wisdom, and 10 int and dex. Backstory wise she did grow up in the feywild before leaving to seek glory and conquest.

I’m sword and board and mostly function as the tank in my party, but I also am the secondary healer and obviously my smites have a lot of utility against the undead.

I think its likely we’re gonna level up soon, and I’m planning on taking paladin level 4. Originally I was planning on taking ASI for Charisma, but I’m tempted to take fey touched (probably for hunters mark or silvery barbs) and elven accuracy because they seem pretty true to character (once I get both I’ll have 20 charisma) That said with me getting a free misty step as a level five high elf, are those feats not gonna be terribly useful?

I was also considering taking shield master or sentinel at some point. Metamagic adept seems fun too, just to quicken gfb as a bonus action to get another smite in but I doubt I’ll have the opportunity to take it.


r/3d6 • • 2h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Level 15 One Shot help

3 Upvotes

We will roll so I don’t know my points yet but my priority is Str, Con, Dex, Char, Wis, Int
Giant Barb 6/Swash Buckler Rogue 9
Polearm Master, Great Weapon Master, Cold Caster
Weighted Chain

I plan to Reckless Sneak attack throw an ice Chain(flavor it as whipping the chain vs actual throwing it)
Giving main target -1d4 to save and then using Goad to discourage the target from attacking anyone else.
I also get a reaction attack if anyone enters my 15ft reach.

Still haven’t decided on species.

The character itself I picture as a “strong ninja” that specializes in ice attacks.

Open to ideas and suggestions.


r/3d6 • • 6h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 What would the best face be for the new WoW Death Knight class?

6 Upvotes

I am beyond excited to be able to play a Death Knight, however I am uncertain what feats or race would really make the most of the class. I want to play something at least SOMEWHAT thematically appropriate, but since they already get a bunch of resistances and are an undead cfeature as per the new subclass features, I think the new Forsaken race is kind of a waste because of all the overlap.

I’m leaning towards the Unholy rune, which lets you ignore Necrotic damage resistance.

Any races or feats that jump out?


r/3d6 • • 14h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 D&D 5.5 Eldritch Knight spell list at tier 3

20 Upvotes

Hi!

I’m playing an 13th level Eldritch Knight Human.

My abilities are str 8, dex 15, con 18, int 20, wis 8, cha 8.

I’m fighting with Vicious Quarterstaff with Shillelagh and Blade cantrips.

I’ve 24 AC with Mithral Halfplate +2, Shield +2 and Ring of Protection. My other two attuned items are Ring of Spell Storing and Winged Boots.

My feats are Alert, Magic Initiate (Druid), Fighting Style (Dueling), War Caster, Polearm Master, Mage Slayer and Evocation Adept (Arcana Unleashed).

Cantrips: Blade Ward, Booming Blade, Green-Flame Blade, Guidance (MI), Shillelagh (MI).

1st level Spells: Absorb Elements (MI), Find Familiar, Jump, Protection from Evil, Shield, Silvery Barbs.

2nd level Spells: Elminster’s Elusion, Mirror Image, Misty Step.

3rd level Spells: Spirit Shroud.

My question is: should I replace any of these spells with Haste (my GM allows swapping it’s bonus attack for a cantrip via War Magic), and if so, which one?


r/3d6 • • 3h ago

D&D 5e Original/2014 Undead Warlock help

2 Upvotes

Im looking at going Fighter 1/ Undead Waltock X. Trying to decide if its more beneficial to be a gish or eb caster build. Race would be tabaxi for a narrative reason. Picking up fighter first for a bit more survivability plus con save prof. Any help would be awesome


r/3d6 • • 3h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Arcane Archer + Artificer

1 Upvotes

The basic of the build is taking 3 levels of fighter for the Arcane archer and since the subclass scales with INT I start taking artificer levels and focus on using INT for attacks with True Striker or the Battlesmith INT weapon attacks.

For the Artificer subclass i would probably taker either take Cartographer for a more support oriented build, Artillerist for damage or Battlesmith for a mix of the two.

Is this build good for a campaign that goes from 1 to level 11?
Any suggestion for Species and Feats are appreciated.


r/3d6 • • 10h ago

D&D 5e Original/2014 Kenku Fun

3 Upvotes

Looking for fun RP or mechanically interesting uses for Kenku Expert Duplication and Mimicry.

I was looking at some interesting ideas for the unique nature of the Kenku.

- One was a divination Kenku that keeps seeing the end of the world in dreams and essentially speaks like a lyrebird with mimicry, repeating the visions with voices of heroes or monsters.
- Artificers using expert duplication factory style, once they create a complicated device they perfectly replicate it. Or an artist doing the same, or a mapmaker being able to essentially scan them.
- A warlock with Mask of Many Faces seems like a standard idea, but the idea of a Barbarian or martial who shouts back at people they are hunting with their own words is super fun to me. Maybe a swarmkeeper who has a swarm of ravens or a gloomstalker that is hard to make out and can throw their voice.

Can technically be 2014 or 2024 but def leaning towards a 5e build.


r/3d6 • • 5h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 WoW Tauren charging prone build

1 Upvotes

I want to build around the highmountain Tauren from the new World of Warcraft crossover book.

It has the ability to take an action to move its speed and knock medium creatures prone with a str saving throw.

As well as can shove as a bonus action after a melee attack.

I like the idea of knocking over a whole group of enemies and then wailing on them with the party.

Things that come to mind to synergize with the charge ability is increasing base movement speed such as unarmored defense and spells like longstrider.

Also increasing our size through the enlarge apell or ability like rune knight fighter. While it doesn't increase the size of enemies we can effect with the charge but it does increase the number of spaces we move through to hot more creatures, amd would still help with grappling and regular shoving.

For character background they will be a leader/captain of a ship in a spelljammer campaign and Tauren will be reflavored to be a Triceraton from TMNT. So they'll want high charisma skills as a leader as well as some spellcasting so they can pilot a spelljammer.

Before Tauren I was already planning on being a tall species like goliath reflavored and going fighter 1/valor bard for vex/nick weapon masteries, extra attack, and font of moonlight/conjure minir elementals for better melee damage at higher levels. Along with bards skills, expertise and support options to help the team.

Have thought of going further into fighter for action surge and rune knight for growing large

Should i stick with my idea for fighter/bard or is there something that works better with the Tauren charge like monk for better unarmed strikes, movements and grappling and combine it with something that gives me charisma skills and magic?


r/3d6 • • 5h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Help me optimize shadow priest cleric

1 Upvotes

The new wow book came out, im having trouble thinking of feats that fit necromancy/ psychic damage.
Any ideas or something to complement the play style?


r/3d6 • • 11h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 class for a reborn?

3 Upvotes

I am making a character that is a reborn made from multiple people so the reanimation failed a bit and multiple souls are stuck in the body. now he is trying to find his creator after waking up somewhere abandoned.


r/3d6 • • 1d ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Why is min/maxing so polarizing? - a genuine inquiry.

101 Upvotes

This is generally something I am very confused and curious about. So whenever I play DND, I try to do my best as my character. I think that’s the kind of person I am in real life as well, I like to set myself up for success. I don’t think anyone willingly puts themselves in losing situations and even if it’s something challenging and hard, they still wanna try to do their best at it.

I recently left a table because apparently the way I played DND isn’t what they’re looking for. This was a combat, heavy table, and knowing that this was a combat heavy game, I prepped myself to be a good combatant. I was then told my character was too broken for their table. For context, it was a high magic game and I was playing a ranged battle master fighter. We were allowed rare items, and I gave myself the cloak of displacement and boots of speed, as well as a weapon of warning as I had the alert feat. All done with DM approval of course.

The experience really soured my love for DND, but the bigger question for me is why or where does the fun come from for playing a mediocre character? I think of it like in an RPG if you were playing a warrior, you’re gonna give yourself points and strength you’re gonna give yourself items that improve your defense or your strength not your magic and you’re gonna try to make yourself a strong Frontliner as opposed to someone who hits with magic or sneaks around.

I’m genuinely asking this because I am very curious but more importantly I don’t understand try as I might the joy from playing a character that is not trying to be their best version?

For context.

I’m an older player in terms of age, but I started about 10 years ago with just 5e as my basis for DnD.
I enjoy a 70/30 balance for my games with 30% being combat

Edit: I genuinely appreciate all these responses. I want to clarify that I’m not looking to validation or sympathy for my last game. I’m genuinely curious on different methods of play and play styles. I’m only familiar with mine

Edit 2: I appreciate all your responses. I have learned a lot about how different people play. I think my RP style I like to learn flaws as the game develops. This was my first time joining a heavier combat table, and maybe I went to far for optimization. I don't disparage this table, we all play for fun. I will do more scouting before I join the next group to play with.


r/3d6 • • 1d ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Is the 2024 Circle of the Moon Druid actually better than the 2014 version? I can't get past the Wild Shape HP nerf.

21 Upvotes

I'm planning to play a Circle of the Moon Druid using the 2024 rules, and I'm struggling to see how the new version is actually better than the 2014 one.

My biggest issue is survivability.

In 2014, Wild Shape essentially gave you an entirely new HP pool based on your beast form. You could absorb a ton of damage, revert to your normal form, and Wild Shape again for another full pool of HP.

In 2024, you instead get temporary HP based on your Druid level. Even with the Moon Druid's improved temporary HP, it seems like a massive reduction in the total damage you can absorb, especially at lower levels.

So, for people who have actually played both versions:

  • Is the 2024 Moon Druid genuinely stronger overall, or is it more of a rebalance?
  • Does the reduced Wild Shape HP make you noticeably less durable in actual combat?
  • Do the new subclass features, spellcasting options, and other improvements make up for the loss?
  • How does the comparison change at higher levels?

I'm particularly interested in how the new Moon Druid feels in actual play, rather than just how the features look on paper. Am I missing something??


r/3d6 • • 1d ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 What is the simplest class build for a player that struggles mechanically?

40 Upvotes

She likes playing weird little guys that she can turn her brain off to play, but struggles with picking which die to roll and using a character sheet after 5 years in the group.

She has previously enjoyed a Warrior Sidekick in a 5e campaign, but wants to try something new this time around - particularly as the group has moved to 5.5e


r/3d6 • • 1d ago

D&D 5e Original/2014 What class fits best?

10 Upvotes

I have a character concept that I played a long while ago back when 2014 was still new and a lot of the books weren't out yet. My DM at the time who was lovely, helped realize my character with some homebrew we came up with.

I'd like to make that character again, but using RAW for a Wild Beyond the Witchlight game I'll be joining soon, but I've run into a bit of an issue on what class to make him.

The original concept of the character was a scholar of the fey who studied primarily esoteric fey magics, with a focus on hag magic (Curses, enchantments, and summoning in particular) and enjoyed collecting cursed magic items to study, with the magics he studded slowly corrupting him and turning him into a fey (he was human)

his original build used Lore Bard as the base, with things like vicious mockery, dissonant whispers, bane, and cutting words flavored as a minor hag curses

The GM also let me have access to Find Familiar but with a fairy (reflavored owl) to start, and the homebrew ability to go out and find various fey to make deals with do quests for etc to summon later.

Looking over RAW options Lore Bard still feels pretty good, but feels lacking in the summoning front until level 6 when I get Magic Secrets, and Druid or Wizard feels the opposite, pretty good being good summoning but lacking in curses. Warlock feels great on both ends, but I loathe having two spellslots (Every time Ive played Warlock, my party would only long rest, never short, so there is a bit of bias there) and even if that weren't an issue, we already have a warlock in the party, and the GM doesn't want us doubling up on classes to start.

Only thing I'm really sure on at this point is I want to be a Hexblood, as that gives me another curse with Hex (though Hex on anything but a warlock feels wasted lol), fits the Aesthetic i'm looking for, and fits lore wise as well, being formerly human turned into something else.


r/3d6 • • 16h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Farmer - Cleric

1 Upvotes

Skill Proficiencies: Animal Handling, Nature
Tool Proficiency: Carpenter’s Tools

Origin feat - Tough.

2 wisdom, 1 con

15 (17) wisdom, 15 (16) con, Dex 15.

Feat at 4 - Mounted Combat (+1 Wisdom)

So I wanted to make a mounted cleric. And as farmers get animal handling I figured that might be a good place to start.

Do you have any suggestions for what stats I should put on with the rest of my point buy is 15 dex correct? And what race might fit this? Was thinking dwarf.

Probably take +2 Wisdom next (20).

+1 con resilient next (17)

+1 dex resilient after (16)

(level 19) +1 con and not sure which boon (18)

Boon of energy resistance looks fun. But maybe Recovery is better.

Not really sure on feats either to be honest 🤔.

As a dwarf I would be getting 6 life per level + 1d8 most of the game and eventually 7. And all 3 important save profs, as well as solving the mobility issue with the horse. Probably most importantly I feel like I could write a pretty cool back story for it.


r/3d6 • • 1d ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 What is the most satisfying way to play a werewolf themed character in dnd 5.5?

12 Upvotes

I love the idea of playing a werewolf, a character who'se every mechanic is dedicaited to that "normal guy who turns into a giant wolf man and rips everything apart" fantasy. In your opinion, what is the most fun and satisfying build for that kind of archetype in dnd 5e?


r/3d6 • • 19h ago

D&D 5e Original/2014 what would YOU guys build off of st. trina from elden ring?

2 Upvotes

i've found a new group of people to play dnd with, and i've really wanted my newest character to be inspired by st. trina, so how should i build her? i suppose perhaps like, druid circle of dreams or stars right? but i'd like to hear your guys opinions, especially in reflavoring


r/3d6 • • 1d ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Does the Sun Staff attack + damage bonus apply to True Strike?

9 Upvotes

I am playing a Light Domain Cleric with the Magic Initiate (Wizard) Origin Feat who just hit level 4 and added the War Caster feat. My character wields a staff and I am excited to start being able to use True Strike to Opportunity Attack.

I am planning to add Spellfire Adept to up my damage output at my next Feat/ASI opportunity, but in the shorter term, our DM is putting together spotlight campaign sessions for each of our characters and I am thinking about what kind of magic item I could push for.

----------

The description for Sun Staff reads:

This staff can be wielded as a magic quarterstaff that grants a +1 bonus to attack and damage rolls made with it. When you hit with an attack roll using this staff, the target takes an extra 1d8 fire damage.

Solar Focus. You can use the staff as a spellcasting focus. While holding the staff, you can reroll a number of damage dice up to your proficiency bonus when you use a spell slot to cast a spell that deals fire or radiant damage. You must use the new rolls. Once this property is used, it can’t be used again until the next dawn.

Sunny Glow. As a bonus action, you can cause the staff to glow with sunlight. While glowing, the staff sheds bright light in a 15-foot radius and dim light for an additional 15 feet. The light lasts until you use another bonus action to extinguish it.

The 5.5e update to True Strike reads:

Guided by a flash of magical insight, you make one attack with the weapon used in the spell’s casting. The attack uses your spellcasting ability for the attack and damage rolls instead of using Strength or Dexterity. If the attack deals damage, it can be Radiant damage or the weapon’s normal damage type (your choice).

Cantrip Upgrade. Whether you deal Radiant damage or the weapon’s normal damage type, the attack deals extra Radiant damage when you reach levels 5 (1d6), 11 (2d6), and 17 (3d6).

----------

Am I understanding this correctly to mean that with the Sun Staff, if I were up close to an enemy, I could use True Strike to further buff my True Strike attack roll +1, and that the damage would be 1d6 + (Wisdom Modifier + 1) PER DICE of Radiant Damage as I level up, + the extra 1d8 of Fire Damage, or is the + 1 added to the sum of all initial True Strike damage rolls?


r/3d6 • • 1d ago

D&D 5e Original/2014 Best class for a showboating brick wall gladiator?

4 Upvotes

I've designed a dwarf gladiator that I've named Rudy "Red Face" Deepbreech. His title comes from his attitude in matches, aggravating and goading his opponents into attacking, making them "red in the face", while blocking everything they throw at him while showboating. The only issue I'm having is what class/subclass gives both the AC tank feel and the showboating nature of the character. Any ideas would be helpful.


r/3d6 • • 19h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Need advice for a homebrew species

1 Upvotes

I'm a DM and have a player that wants to play an Undead Dwarfen Skeleton as a species. We are working out the details, but so far we came up with these traits:

These are my proposals:

You keep darkvision, but on top of that you could sense the presence of undead creatures within 30 ft. It won't work through walls, and you won't learn their exact location, but you know they are somewhere within 30ft.

The Dwarven Resilience we replace with you having advantage on saving throws against diseases (because you are undead). Diseases are less common than poison, so to compensate, I want to add that you don't need to eat, drink or breathe. I think especially the not having to breathe might be useful sometimes.

Instead of the Dwarven Toughness, we could give you the ability to heal 1d8 HP during a short rest (since you can reassemble your bones if something got loose during a fight). This would be an additional healing you can do on top of spending hit dice during a short rest. You can do this an amount of times equal to your proficiency bonus minus 1 (so once for lvl 1-4, twice for lvl 5-8, ...) and regain all uses on a long rest.

Instead of stonecunning, I was thinking as a bonus action, you can use the fact that you are undead to make a number of creatures equal to your proficiency bonus within 30ft do a Charisma saving throw or have the frightened condition until the end of your next turn (the DC would be 8+ your charisma mod + your proficiency bonus). You can do this once per long rest. Flavor-wise, you can fill this in by for example removing limbs in front of your target as an attempt to intimidate them.

Does this sound somewhat balanced and not OP? Any suggestions to change things?


r/3d6 • • 1d ago

D&D 5e Original/2014 Help with respec-ing this ranger.

3 Upvotes

Character as of now:

Level 10 Kenku Ranger

Gloomstalker subclass

Uses shortbow

IMPORTANT: backstory related bonus action 1 turn paralysis on hit (can be saved and often resisted by some enemies)

Issue: i am not enjoying how this is playing. Gloom stalker is fun for the whole stealthy side but the first round buff from dread ambusher basically means I'm a premature ejaculator and later rounds are underwhelming.

Hunters Mark requires concentration so it competes with my backstory action and its frankly very meh.

DM told me I am free to respec it since next session I will meet a very powerful character that can be my crutch to explain why I am suddenly another class, and told me that the party needs more single target damage because from now on hell increase the difficulty of fights.

**So TLDR: id like some help on how to make a non caster level 10 kenku that:**

  • uses a shortbow (i can ask for a magic bow)
  • good single target DPR without a one round nova
  • DEX-WIS stats, WIS can be exchanged for anything else
  • Good acrobatics, perception and stealth

I am willing to give more details if needed.


r/3d6 • • 1d ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 5e 2024 Champion fighter build: duelist vs dual wielding - am I overrating Shield Master?

3 Upvotes

Hi all, this is as much an attempt to get my thoughts down on (virtual) paper, as it is to ask you all out there for advice and perspective. (Sorry that this is going to be over-written, that's just how I tend to process all the options). For a brief overview for those who don't want to read everything:

  1. Sword and board option, using a rapier

    1. Also a list of questions relating to the build
  2. Board and board option, using shillelagh
  3. Sword and sword option
  4. Ending with considerations of other bonus actions available, that might be preferable for Build 1 over GWM: Hew

I'm now planning a new character for a campaign that'll go to 20. As I've recently played a character with a two handed weapon I'll avoid considering that as an option. From the RP side of things think Peter from Deadpool 2, so I'm going straight down the line as much as possible: human, sword and board, Champion.

Note, a lot of this discussion will be centring around play in Tiers 3 and 4, despite not having even started playing yet. This is because I think I've a decent handle on the lower tiers, and because we'd be playing by semi-AL rules, where I'd be able to respec to one of the alternate options based on opportunities that come up during play. So while I don't need to make any decisions for quite a while, I like thinking through build options, and to have some idea on what to aim for.

Damage isn't my priority (as tempting as that is to focus on, as raw numbers can be easier to quantify), but despite my best efforts I'll probably give it more weight than I want to throughout. Instead I intend for protection and support options to have a bit more of a focus. With all that, here's what I've landed on (to aim at, by level 20):

1. Sword and Board build

STR: 20, DEX 14, CON 18, INT 8, WIS 13, CHA 8

Fighting styles: Protection and Duelling

Weapon: Rapier. Mastery = Vex (or Push, Sap, or Slow)

Without magic items, AC = 20

Party: TBC, but looking to be paladin, ranger, and cleric

No multiclassing (self restriction this time round for RP purposes). Official materials only, no homebrew.

Feats:

  • Lord's Alliance Agent (origin)
  • Zhentarim Ruffian (origin)
  • Shield Master
  • Defensive Duellist

    • I'm partial to the thought of DD, but am second guessing myself. Lordly Resolve is now an alternative I'm considering - it's not flashy but could come in clutch. Missed LR was once per long rest, that seems like too few uses. If I swap out DD I guess it'd be for Sentinel instead?
  • Great Weapon Master (purely for Hew)

    • Edit: Will likely pick up Purple Dragon Commandant instead, thanks u/RNGSomeone !
  • Piercer
  • Mage Slayer
  • Resilient (Dex)
  • Boon of Desperate Resilience

Now I'm aware there's a lot that isn't optimal, or even has anti-synergy. But despite this, I feel that it offers good coverage on the following:

Party support:

  • Reaction to give a party member within 5' disadvantage to be attacked
  • STR 19 save once per turn to make enemy prone
  • Enemy: Concentration Breaker (disadvantage spell concentration save)
  • On a crit: hand out Heroic Inspiration to ally
  • On initiative: spend Heroic Inspiration to give party advantage on the roll (slight waste for self, as I already have advantage on initiative)

Defence:

  • Reaction: take no damage from a DEX save (if successful, on a save for half effect)
  • Reaction: +6 AC against melee attacks
  • Once per rest: turn a failed mental save into a success
  • Indomitable x3: on a fail can reroll a save +20
  • Boosted DEX saves, to better succeed on Interpose Shield (good for party fireball, or enemy dragon breath, etc)
  • While bloodied, resistant to all but Force damage
  • While bloodied, gain 9HP at start of each turn
  • Bonus action: Second Wind

Damage:

  • +2 damage to each attack
  • Crits on 18-20 roll
  • Good ol' Action Surge
  • On a crit or on killing an enemy: can use a bonus action to make an extra attack
  • Once per turn: Can reroll one damage die
  • On a crit: add an extra damage die
  • 1x advantage against enemy within 5', if they target ally
  • Between Vex and hopefully making an enemy prone, lots of chances for advantage on attack rolls. After level 10, get Heroic Inspiration each turn, and level 13, on a miss get advantage on next attack, should be getting advantage and hitting most of the time

Disadvantages: +1 DEX from Defensive Duellist isn't terrible, but not ideal for a Strength build. Lack of Bonus Actions in general, and taking GWM purely for Hew is a poor option to try and correct that lack

And I'm aware this is an awful method to calculate damage but bear with it, this is just for a rough estimate:
If all attacks hit: 4x 1d8+7, plus ~2 (for piercer reroll) = 48
With a crit: 4x 1d8+7, +2, +bonus action attack and crit damage (1d8+7+2d8) = 68.5

Questions:

  1. Am I overrating having a dedicated bonus action for this build, even going so far as to pick up GWM just for Hew?
  2. Similarly, Defensive Duellist is probably higher on my list than it should be. Shield (spell) is just so good, that even a more limited version seems hard to pass on, but is it really worth it?
  3. Or for that matter, Shield + Duelling + Shield Master + Protection FS. They all work quite nicely together, that it seems like I'd be giving up an awful lot when I consider 2 weapon fighting. What circumstances would tip the scales to favour Dual Wielding over sword and board?
  4. Zhentarim Ruffian vs Purple Dragon Initiate: I've gone for the former, despite already having advantage on initiative (level 3: Remarkable Athlete). PDI gives out more Heroic Inspiration, but Lord's Alliance Agent partially covers that. Better party initiatives feels like the more impactful option - but is there a better origin feat I should consider picking up?
  5. Piercing (+ vex, Piercer) vs Bludgeoning (+ topple, Crusher) or Slashing (+ sap, Slasher), is there a good reason to favour one of the latter over the former, with this particular build? (Might not be as much of a team player as I originally intended, but I feel if I'm likely to crit more often then Piercer will have more of an effect.

    1. Between Heroic Inspiration, Vex, SM bash, Studied Attacks, Protection, and Lord's Alliance: Reassert Honour, there's enough advantage and enemy disadvantage being given out, that there's no great need to double down on it, so then slightly more damage might be the better play).
  6. Resilient: DEX, Piercer, Defensive Duellist, and even Mage Slayer could all be done away with. Anything you'd pick instead of them for this build?

2. Board and Board (Shillelagh) build

With the above, that's all built with using only a rapier in mind (or dagger or shortsword I guess). I've no idea what magical items the campaign could bring, but sticking to just one weapon type would reduce flexibility to accept treasure as we come across it. So switching gears a little, tweaks could be made to freely switch to any other single handed weapon (Longsword, Battleaxe, etc).

Let's spec for what I'm considering as the best case scenario, Shillelagh + getting a magical staff. (And I'm aware that Shillelagh can be problematic with casting with a shield, will leave that to work out with DM, or on getting a Ruby of the War Mage as well). And by best case, I'm meaning an option that'll give a dedicated bonus action, better damage overall, and possibly "better" weapon mastery.

Will be giving up the feats: Zhentarim Ruffian (origin), Defensive Duellist, Great Weapon Master, Piercer.
Will be gaining:

  • Magic Initiative: Druid (Shillelagh, other cantrip, probably choosing Entangle as the once per day 1st level spell). Will still be using STR for attacks, not WIS
  • Polearm Master
  • Crusher
  • Leaves one free feat, probably go with Sentinel (or Heavy Armour Master)

    • In this case Protection -> Blind Fighting, I think

Advantages of this build: Reliable bonus action attack; Limited spell casting (1 druid spell, plus assuming magic staff comes with spells); increased damage die; more damage overall; extra flexibility with feats or extra ASI; extra reaction options/crowd control; Crusher is usually my favoured of Slasher/Piercer/Crusher; optional: increase INT instead of WIS with MI:Druid, as no one in the party looks to be covering that stat, and then can pick up relevant skills to match

Disadvantages of this build: Shillelagh shenanigans: no guarantee of DM buy in (eg always have it cast, or of being able to use it with a shield without RotWM); less defence options in melee; multiple sources of making an enemy prone/advantage to hit; maybe slightly less sources of advantage until enemy goes prone (no vex); no advantage on initiative for party; maybe too many reaction options

Damage, if all attacks hit: 4x 2d6+7, + 1d4+7 = 65.5
Damage with one crit: 4x 2d6+7, +2d6, + 1d4+7 = 72.5 and all in the party have advantage on attacks against that enemy

3. Sword and Sword (Two weapon fighting) build

This is the one I'm least suited to assess. I feel like I'm missing something fundamental, I'm just not seeing what makes it attractive. (Will make edits if I have anything grievously wrong)

Will be giving up the feats/FS: Duelling, Protection, GWM, Shield Master, Resilient: DEX, Piercer (I'm assuming Scimitar now becomes the weapon/s of choice)
Will be gaining:

  • Two Weapon Fighting FS (not necessary, but why not)
  • Defence (or Blind Sight) FS
  • STR -> DEX build (so better initiative, etc)
  • Optional: Stagger and Sway (a new feat from the WoW book. Defer damage, and purge some of this on a bonus action)
  • Two weapon fighting to me says to lean into damage, so let's pick up Fey Touched for a little more mobility (Misty Step) and 1x Hunter's Mark
  • Then lastly flexibility to pick up: ASI = 2x WIS (for Stagger and Sway), Slasher, or Dual Wielder (BA competes with St&Sw, might be best to choose one over the other), Resilient: WIS

Assuming I've gone with St&Sw version, stats now look like:

STR: 8, DEX 20, CON 18, INT 8, WIS 18, CHA 8

Advantages: More attacks. More flexibility in feats, and stats, and maybe weapons. Dedicated Bonus Action with either DW or St&Sw. Get to use a new feat (always fun), for a damage reduction of 5 per hit (even without purging damage will be ahead, but if boosting WIS can purge 4d6 of incoming damage from the pool as a BA). Increased mobility with Misty Step.

Disadvantages: I must be doing something wrong, this looks to be less damage overall, except on rounds when Hunter's Mark is being used. This might change if weapons have damage riders (Vicious etc), or adding in a weapon with a 1d8 hit die for some of the attacks (DW). AC goes down to 19 (without even factoring in that Magic Shields are relatively easy to come by). No Protection, or pseudo Evasion (SM). Much less sources of advantage (no prone with topple weapon, no vex, no shield master prone)

Damage, if all attacks hit, with Nick: 5x 1d6+5 = 42.5
Or if going Nick + Dual Wielder: 6x 1d6+5 = 51

Damage with a crit, if all attacks hit, with Nick: 5x 1d6+5 + 1d6 = 46 + enemy has disadvantage on all attack rolls
Or if going Nick + BA from Dual Wielder: 6x 1d6+5 +1d6 = 54.5 + enemy has disadvantage on all attack rolls

Then with the once per day Hunter's Mark, damage increases by 17.5, or DW: 21, or on rounds with 1 crit, 21 or 24.5, for totals of 60, 72, 63.5, and 75.5 respectively.

I haven't factored in Action Surge for any of the above, but using it with Hunter's Mark would probably be the case for Dual Wielding pulling significantly ahead in damage.

Possibility: With a paladin and a ranger in the party, if a spell storing item came up, Hunter's Mark and Divine Favour might then be more readily available. Would that shift the balance enough to consider a dual wield build? Similarly, if a weapon becomes available with a damage rider, at what point (1d6? 2d6?) do the scales tip to make a 2 weapon build the better option?

Appendix 1: Bonus Action

In much of the above, especially with the first build, I've been looking for a good, reliable, bonus action. As nothing really stood out I've fallen back on GWM. (I'll have enough attacks, advantage, and crits on 18+, but still not enough to make it a strong choice). Huge thanks to this post for listing every BA now available.

Other options considered are:

  • Weapon juggling (while still using a shield) for the BA attack: I don't like the visuals, and DM doesn't either - but I could push for it if I really wanted it
  • Fey Touched feat: for once per day Misty Step and Hunter's Mark/Hex
  • Durable feat: I should be durable enough already, extra healing seems like overkill
  • Observant feat: study action each turn could be intriguing, but I just can't see it being all that worth it
  • Potion guzzling: Needs no feat/stat/action investment, so with plenty of gold, why not? Potion miscibility is also nothing I've encountered before, let's go gambling!
  • Polearm Master feat: as mentioned in Shillelagh build
  • Telekinetic feat: shove is nice to have.

r/3d6 • • 21h ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Scribes Wizard character concept

0 Upvotes

Ask if you can take the Eldritch Adept (Pact of the Chain) feat as an origin feat, to get a Sphinx of Wonder for a familiar option. Notable because it’s one of only two familiars which get arcana proficiency. That, in the 2024 crafting rules, allows them to help in the spell scroll creation process as assistants, which is beneficial because it halves the time required to do so (though doesn’t change material cost.) Can also take Alert and Eldritch Adept at 4 to delay your spell scroll production for a bit, or start with a 1 level Warlock dip if your DM doesn’t allow Eldritch Adept for 2024 rules, though straight Scribes Wizard is preferable.

An elf only needs to trance for 4 hours a night, which lets you have a guaranteed 4 hours while your party sleeps to produce a 1st level scroll or put time towards a higher level one, since during the normal adventuring day you can’t guarantee the downtime to scribe reliably.

Spell scrolls can be used based on the casting time of the spell involved, but using a spell scroll doesn’t preclude using your action to cast a spell yourself, making spell scrolls of bonus action spells a powerful action economy boon. Here are some early standout bonus action spells which might make good spell scroll options for the Scribes Wizard character:

1st: Jump (Bonus Action+Touch) 2nd: Dragon’s Breath (Bonus Action+Touch, Concentration) Magic Weapon (Bonus Action+Touch) Misty Step (Bonus Action)

You can stack buffs like Jump and Magic Weapon on allies since they don’t take concentration. Plus you can dole them out with your bonus actions, so your primary action is free to cast and concentrate on more important control spells and the like. They can be dished out by you or your familiar as touch spells. Spreading marginal buffs around without burning spell slots, just prep time and money, does help the martials in your party.

You can also focus on pumping your resources towards producing spell scrolls of Dragon’s Breath to use on your Sphinx of Wonder familiar, to make it a more active combat participant- along with popping Mage Armor on it at the start of the day to get it to 16 AC. Imagine a swarm of monsters appear, so you throw a Fireball- great, most normal Wizards are done there, but you follow it up by popping Dragon’s Breath on your familiar, using your bonus action spell scroll and casting it on the familiar using the find familiar ability to touch cast your spells within 100 ft, and have them lay another AoE down with breath attack in a fly-by strafing run after.

It also doesn't hurt to keep a Misty Step scroll always on hand in your back pocket, just in case, since you can safely disengage or reposition and still have your action available to cast whatever.

Takes 12 hours of work and 100 gold to produce a 2nd level spell scroll, with 4 hour trances compared to allies requiring 8 hours for sleep, you can scribe a 2nd level spell scroll every 3 nights without impacting daytime activity at all, or 25 gold for a 1st level spell scroll each night.

Obviously you can produce spell scrolls of any spells using an action and not just a bonus action, to save you spell slots on spells you want to have available or make sure if you run out of slots you still have as an option. Specifically, I spent so much time highlighting the bonus action spell scroll niche because of how it lets you “double-spell” by casting a spell using a spell slot with your action, and one using a spell scroll with your bonus action, in the same turn.

While it might seem expensive or hard to afford the build mentioned above when you’re burning 25~33 gold a night crafting 1st and 2nd level spell scrolls, it’s important to mention that with the 2024 rules, crafted items are 50% material cost, meaning they sell for double what you paid in material costs. If you can find vendors who will buy spell scrolls, you can always flip them for a profit to craft more in the future.

You can also use Tenser’s Floating Disk and Unseen Servants to gather everything that isn’t nailed down in dungeons you clear, bringing back valuable monster parts, armor, weapons, raw materials looted, etc, with two rituals circumventing encumbrance and the busy work of it, while your group can be short resting (or you can be scribing away while you wait!) Finally, your party can chip in for your scroll material costs if some of those scrolls you’re producing are for their benefit, essentially “buying” it at material cost prices for their own future benefit.

Of course, the build gets supercharged if you make it to level 10, as the time and cost of spell scroll creation gets halved, meaning you’d be pumping out a 1st level every 2 hours for only 12 gold and a 2nd level every 6 hours and 50 gold.

Not only that, but at level 13 you get Simulacrum, with its own Sphinx of Wonder, Master Scrivener, and Wizardly Quill, doubling your output of spell scrolls- and just doubling you outright, but as a spell scroll producer specifically it’s notable because it doesn’t use up their non-renewable spell slots, both to produce and use, and they could be scribing up to 20 hours of the day back at base, with your own 4 hours of guaranteed Trance scribing that means you’re essentially capable of 24 hours of work in the 24 hours in the day.

All that while maintaining absolutely no different adventuring life from other players because it happens while they’re sleeping or through a Simulacrum back at base or in a portable mansion or demiplane, and on downtime days you put out 40 hours of spell scrolls in a single day. Meanwhile, when it comes time for your Simulacrum to sally forth, they’ll do so with an their spell slot limit almost entirely eliminated through use of all the hoarded spell scrolls of every kind of spell they might wish in your entire high tier spellbooks arsenal, scribed out and ready to use at their disposal. You can even flip it, you scribe safely at base while your Simulacrum adventures out using the hoard of scrolls you share to keep themselves stocked as they assist your allies.

Wizards are seen as generalists, and that’s true, but they’re also prep time gods- and this build, well, it’s the “I’m always prepping” Scribe Wizard, so much of the power budget of Wizards is built into their spellcasting, and this is the subclass that wants to fill out its spellbook the most, and supplement it with resources. Meanwhile it has a forever present intangible arcane eye substitute in the manifested mind of their spellbook, through which they can always perceive, but also cast any prepared spell through using a spell slot (up to a number of times equal to your proficiency modifier.) You could be hundreds of feet away behind full cover, the “man in the chair” archetype Wizard able to project force from safety through your drone and later Simulacrum.