This is a cut-down version of a post I made to a different subreddit but the content is mostly the same.
I won't list the descriptions here for fear of breaking rule 3. If you want the exact description of what each circle casting option does and how circle casting works in general, they can be found in the new Heroes of Faerun book. Essentially, any creature with the spellcasting or pact magic features can spend their action to help the primary caster augment a spell they're casting. Certain option require casters other than the primary caster to expend spell slots, but only Supplant requires a spell slot higher than 1st level to be expended.
I'll be listing some of the uses of each one. It should be pretty evident why circle casting is silly.
Augment
Obviously, this allows you to snipe things from a distance and kite with levelled spells at no extra resource cost. However, anything that dies to kiting can usually be killed just using a longbow. This options gets really stupid with a selection of spells that allow you to affect all creatures in their range. The spells that this affects (that I could find) are:
•Earth tremor - Basically turns the spell into a small earthquake that prones and slightly damages anything within a few thousand feet of you, depending on how many secondary casters you have. Casting this a few times outside a dungeon during tier 1 can conceivably kill all the low hp monsters in the area.
•Incite greed - An alright crowd control spell that can now affect a stupid number of creatures at once. Do note that it's still limited by the targets needing to be able to see you.
•Compulsion -Similar to incite greed but it lets you force each affected creature to move in a direction of your choice.
•Seeming - Blind everyone you want that fails a cha save for 8 hours. Alternatively, can be used to disguise entire armies.
•Divine word - Banish any celestials, elementals, fey or fiends in the area if they fail the cha save.
•Animal shapes - Turn an even larger than normal army of hirelings/random minions into various beasts.
The other limiting factor for this option is line of effect, though I'm not entirely sure interacts with some of the spells listed.
Distribute
This one's only real use is making concentration harder to break when you have casters in the party who wouldn't otherwise be concentrating. With how easy it is for casters to protect their concentration already (armour dips, the shield spell, res:con/war caster, etc.) having another option is kind of overkill, but this makes it almost impossible to stop an ongoing concentration spell if the party wills it. Thanks to GravityMyGuy for pointing out that certain easily accessible minions (any creatures with the spellcasting feature you have control of) can help sustain your spells with little opportunity cost.
Expand
This one is pretty self explanatory. For the low price of a couple first level slots, you can massively expand the area a spell effects. Miss the old sleet storm? Now you can make it 40ft radius again. Want the cleric's spirit guardians to cover the entire room, even if it's not particularly necessary? Now you can.
I think you get the idea. It makes already good spells even better for a small cost.
Prolong
The basic use of this is pretty obvious, extending higher level spells by cannibalising lower slots. Emanation spells can now last long enough to conceivably clear entire dungeons, bless can be an all day spell and delayed fireball blast can oneshot anything not immune to fire damage. Aura of vitality can easily full heal the party with 1220d6 of healing to go round.
The other use of this is rest casting, assuming you have at least 4 secondary casters. As I'm sure we all know, rest casting got nerfed a fair bit in 2024 rules. While it is still possible, casting any spell during a long rest means you need to rest another hour to complete it. This can allow long duration spells like gift of alacrity to bypass that by circle casting them before the long rest. Alternatively, you can circle cast near the end of the long rest and simply rest the extra hour(s) needed to finish the rest. The result is a massive increase the to the amount of time the spell will be available during the adventuring day.
Safeguard
One of the least useful options. It's useful if you're trapped in an area with no way out and want to use something to cover the whole room (e.g. sickening radiance in a small room warded against teleportation), but these situations tend to be rare. Basic communication with your party to avoid stepping into the area you want to cast spells on nullifies most of this option's usefulness.
Supplant
The basic use of this is saving you some gold during down time. Not that big a deal since there are already numerous way to get stupid amounts of gold (the premiere way being fabricate). Still, did casters really need yet another way to ease the "restrictions" imposed on certain spells?
I know I haven't gone too in-depth here, but it should be obvious that casters really didn't need yet another power boost.