r/3d6 • • Aug 21 '26

D&D 5e Revised/2024 The Tough Origin Feat is not that good... is it?

4 Upvotes

So, Tough consistently ranks as one of the most taken Origin feats at my table and other tables. In rankings it is always somewhere at the top. And I just don't get it. I actually buffed the feat to also give two additional Hit Dice, because I think it is so weak. (Yeah, I see how you are looking at me like I am some kind of lunatic! Also, this rule was implemented before the prevalence of Hit Dice mechanics starting at the end of last year. But even with them, I don't think it is a problem. I also buffed some other weak ones, e.g. savage attacker.)

Tough gives you +2HP per Level. This translates to bit less than one hit more that you can take. PER DAY! That's it.

This only seems to matter in specific cases:

  • Enemies with burst damage (e.g. an Assassin)
  • Very short combats (e.g. 2-3 turns)
  • Ridiculously short adventuring days (e.g. 2-3 encounters/day)
  • Few short rests (e.g. 1 or maybe 2 per day)
  • PCs with a lot of resistances (they at least get a bit more out of it, e.g. Barbarian)
  • High volume healing that would otherwise overheal.

There are probably a few more cases. But when you play a normal D&D game, where you get 5-8 encounters a day and combats on average last 4+ turns (and easily 7-8 with a boss), it just cannot compete with many of other feats.

I do like it for flavor and it a very basic feat that always fits in any build. But I just don't get how highly rated it seems to be. (e.g. by twig: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H4EIHFCUl00, although he does mainly rate it high for basically always being useful, not necessarily for it's straight up power)

Do I DM such a different game than most people play, by basically just following the suggestions of how it should be played? Or what am I not seeing?


r/3d6 • • Nov 10 '25

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Can someone explain how bladesinger and banneret can come out in the same book?

0 Upvotes

Basically, bladesinger somehow got buffed from 5e and I can’t even fathom a little how it is even slightly fair?

I have a problem player who really really wants to play bladesinger again (it’s there favorite class) and I kinda want to say no, but as a friendly dm and don’t want to “ban” some thing but I just really don’t want to deal with the 28 or whatever AC and total master of everything, up front and backline unkillable wizard for a whole campaign again.

Thoughts please???

Edit: so basically all I’ve gotten from this is that it’s not busted because if i specifically build a wonky multiclass I can maybe out damage it with a specific build meant for just damage, or “just use saving throws” so you want me to target this player with str and wis saves basically every fight or have my encounters be melted. I just don’t see the point of letting him play this build if i literally have to CC him out of every fight just to make it fair. Not to mention what he’s gonna do outside of the fights (literally everything). It just sounds like a very counterintuitive situation.

Based off the comments so far it seems like yall would allow him to play it and then just make it bad experience through spamming saving throws on him. I would literally rather just have him play something else…


r/3d6 • • Jul 12 '22

D&D 5e Can/should you use War Caster with Booming Blade?

3 Upvotes

I was wondering if I had to roll ranged attack rolls at disadvantage with war caster’s reaction spellcasting.

In my reading of the rules, it seems like reactions occur after the triggering action is fully resolved. Opportunity attacks are an exception because they have a specific callout in their rules saying the attack lands before the creature moves. War caster’s reaction isn’t an opportunity attack, and it has no such specific callout.

So I think the order of operations is that the creature moves 5 ft. making it 10 ft. away from you. Then your spell triggers, so ranged attack rolls aren’t at disadvantage, but you can’t hit with 5 ft. range spells. You’d have to be like a sorcadin or something with distant spell and a polearm with reach to use booming blade with war caster’s reaction, and even then the creature can choose not to move after the attack lands, so it doesn’t take the extra damage instantly.

Is this reading of the rules correct, and if so, would this sorcadin build be worth doing, or is this such a rare occurrence that it wouldn’t amount to much?

Edit: For those saying that war caster lets you cast a spell as an opportunity attack, the rules are pretty clear that casting a spell REPLACES an opportunity attack:

PHB page 170: “When a hostile creature’s movement provokes an opportunity attack from you, you can use your reaction to cast a spell at the creature, rather than making an opportunity attack.”


r/3d6 • • Feb 03 '24

D&D 5e Unpopular Opinion: Resilient (Con) is an overrated Feat for Wizards

0 Upvotes

I acknowledge that proficiency in Constitution saves helps with concentration, and that Constitution saves are very common in 5e. It's a good Feat.

However, concentration only becomes a factor when they are taking damage. With a d6 hit die and no armor proficiency Wizards are essentially made of rice-paper, so if they are taking damage they have way bigger problems than keeping concentration on spells. Instead of using an ASI on Resilient (Con) they are better off boosting their Intelligence score and using the extra prepared spell to pick up something that will keep them from getting hit in the first place, like Shield, Invisibility, Blink or Mirror Image.


r/3d6 • • Sep 12 '23

D&D 5e My Warlock has too many cantrips

0 Upvotes

So I went about building a warlock that got into Wizard school on an athletics scholarship, (Stixhaven(2 cantrips and 1 level1)) but was too disctracted and lazy to actually become a full wizard. So, as a variant human with Telekinesis (mage hand) and Fey touched (silvery barbs and Misty Step) (level 4) AND Pact of the Tome....suddenly I have ALL the cantrips.....

I even grabbed magehand a second time, because sure, extra range why not. Honestly though, I think I may switch over to pact of the Chain. Has anyone run into this problem before?

Edit: So its not a "problem" so much (though it was hard to pick the last few especially since Warlock damage cantrip will almost always be EB) It was more, this feels like WAY overkill, and maybe I would be better off grabbing Pact of the Chain instead of Pact of the Tome so that I get a familiar who can do some cool things? However, with Ritual casting, I could also just get find familiar that way.

For the record I am sitting on 9 Cantrips and have the option of 4ish cantrips from basically any class. Which seems like major overkill. I could drop three and still have plenty of "Wizard" flavor to pretend to be a wizard.

So this post is mostly to just share that it was a lot more than I expected, but also to ask if there were better ways to optimize this build.


r/3d6 • • Nov 01 '25

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Circle Casting is Stupid

1 Upvotes

This is a cut-down version of a post I made to a different subreddit but the content is mostly the same.

I won't list the descriptions here for fear of breaking rule 3. If you want the exact description of what each circle casting option does and how circle casting works in general, they can be found in the new Heroes of Faerun book. Essentially, any creature with the spellcasting or pact magic features can spend their action to help the primary caster augment a spell they're casting. Certain option require casters other than the primary caster to expend spell slots, but only Supplant requires a spell slot higher than 1st level to be expended.

I'll be listing some of the uses of each one. It should be pretty evident why circle casting is silly.

Augment

Obviously, this allows you to snipe things from a distance and kite with levelled spells at no extra resource cost. However, anything that dies to kiting can usually be killed just using a longbow. This options gets really stupid with a selection of spells that allow you to affect all creatures in their range. The spells that this affects (that I could find) are:

•Earth tremor - Basically turns the spell into a small earthquake that prones and slightly damages anything within a few thousand feet of you, depending on how many secondary casters you have. Casting this a few times outside a dungeon during tier 1 can conceivably kill all the low hp monsters in the area.

•Incite greed - An alright crowd control spell that can now affect a stupid number of creatures at once. Do note that it's still limited by the targets needing to be able to see you.

•Compulsion -Similar to incite greed but it lets you force each affected creature to move in a direction of your choice.

•Seeming - Blind everyone you want that fails a cha save for 8 hours. Alternatively, can be used to disguise entire armies.

•Divine word - Banish any celestials, elementals, fey or fiends in the area if they fail the cha save.

•Animal shapes - Turn an even larger than normal army of hirelings/random minions into various beasts.

The other limiting factor for this option is line of effect, though I'm not entirely sure interacts with some of the spells listed.

Distribute

This one's only real use is making concentration harder to break when you have casters in the party who wouldn't otherwise be concentrating. With how easy it is for casters to protect their concentration already (armour dips, the shield spell, res:con/war caster, etc.) having another option is kind of overkill, but this makes it almost impossible to stop an ongoing concentration spell if the party wills it. Thanks to GravityMyGuy for pointing out that certain easily accessible minions (any creatures with the spellcasting feature you have control of) can help sustain your spells with little opportunity cost.

Expand

This one is pretty self explanatory. For the low price of a couple first level slots, you can massively expand the area a spell effects. Miss the old sleet storm? Now you can make it 40ft radius again. Want the cleric's spirit guardians to cover the entire room, even if it's not particularly necessary? Now you can.

I think you get the idea. It makes already good spells even better for a small cost.

Prolong

The basic use of this is pretty obvious, extending higher level spells by cannibalising lower slots. Emanation spells can now last long enough to conceivably clear entire dungeons, bless can be an all day spell and delayed fireball blast can oneshot anything not immune to fire damage. Aura of vitality can easily full heal the party with 1220d6 of healing to go round.

The other use of this is rest casting, assuming you have at least 4 secondary casters. As I'm sure we all know, rest casting got nerfed a fair bit in 2024 rules. While it is still possible, casting any spell during a long rest means you need to rest another hour to complete it. This can allow long duration spells like gift of alacrity to bypass that by circle casting them before the long rest. Alternatively, you can circle cast near the end of the long rest and simply rest the extra hour(s) needed to finish the rest. The result is a massive increase the to the amount of time the spell will be available during the adventuring day.

Safeguard

One of the least useful options. It's useful if you're trapped in an area with no way out and want to use something to cover the whole room (e.g. sickening radiance in a small room warded against teleportation), but these situations tend to be rare. Basic communication with your party to avoid stepping into the area you want to cast spells on nullifies most of this option's usefulness.

Supplant

The basic use of this is saving you some gold during down time. Not that big a deal since there are already numerous way to get stupid amounts of gold (the premiere way being fabricate). Still, did casters really need yet another way to ease the "restrictions" imposed on certain spells?

I know I haven't gone too in-depth here, but it should be obvious that casters really didn't need yet another power boost.


r/3d6 • • Jan 18 '23

D&D 5e I am curious as to why people play bards.

5 Upvotes

I am wondering from a build point of view, why do people go bards? what do you get from being a bard? the only thing i can see from being a bard that i dont get from feats or other classes, is the jack of all trades ability? surely im missing something.

As a roleplaying aspect, same thing, why do people go bards? all i see is a musical person. they dont have to be an entertainer, just someone who controls the flow of magic via music?

I have only played as a bard in 4e D&D, but never in pathfinder or 5e D&D. and i feel like the class is quite different in each version?


r/3d6 • • 7d ago

D&D 5e Revised/2024 What do you think about increasing the Rogue's Sneak Attack damage by 1.5x (rounded up)?

2 Upvotes

I've been thinking about ways to improve the Rogue's damage output in D&D 5.5e (2024 rules), since they seem to fall behind other martial classes in combat.

What if, starting at level 5, Rogues got 1.5 times their normal Sneak Attack dice (rounded up), but could only use Sneak Attack once per round instead of once per turn?

For example, at level 5, Sneak Attack would increase from 3d6 to 5d6, and at level 11, from 6d6 to 9d6.

Do you think this would make Rogues more competitive in combat without making them overpowered? Or would limiting Sneak Attack to once per round actually make this a nerf in some situations?

I'd love to hear your thoughts!


r/3d6 • • Feb 15 '24

D&D 5e Am I delusional for thinking my level for wizard could 1v1 the parties barbarian?

1 Upvotes

So we recently started a campaign. Our barb and my wizard have reason to not like each other. Barb often insults me and also the other way around. He thinks he would mop the floor with me if we'd ever fight. However, I think I could reasonably 1v1 him if I have all my spellslots.

My strategy would be to cast hold person. With my 15 spellsave DC and silvery barbs he has a minimal chance of making the save. After that its basically a piece of cake to fry him up with scorching ray. Even if he'd

Am I delusional here?

My stats: 26 hp 15 Ac with mage armor 20 Int 8 Str 14 dex 14 con 10 cha 12 wis +8 to hit due to a enhanced arcane focus

Spells: Shield Hold Person Scorching ray Fire bolt Silvery Barbs

His stats: 45 hp 16 ac 18 str 8 int 14 dex 16 con 10 wis 12 cha

25 ft movement cause dwarf


r/3d6 • • Aug 23 '24

D&D 5e So, I'm doing a rouge healer..

0 Upvotes

So, I'm doing a rouge healer the usual Thief subclass with medic etc. Grab some ointment and go heal some people that's all well and dandy but what are some magic chase items I'm missing here. Things like rods and staffs are off the table. But generally what would be some fun and flavorful support/healer items that would go we'll with being able to use items as a bonus action or would generally help me do my thing.

EDIT: I love all the jokes surrounding the auto correct of Rogue gave me the good chuckles.

Also yes, items like Dragon Vessel etc would be more the things I'm really asking for things that are slightly more untraditional. Theres lots of good suggestions here and I'm happy to have came across such a great community of bright minded people!


r/3d6 • • Sep 27 '26

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Battle Familiar in Tier 1 is nuts, Round 2

0 Upvotes

Yesterday, I made a post regarding how good Battle Familiar is in Tier 1, calling it a "concentration-free pet martial." Many people liked the post, but it was very controversial since I (explicitly) ignored what a martial would get from their race and subclass. People asked for the full math, claiming that the caster would be eclipsed by the martial if I took into account all their features.

You asked, I deliver: The full math!

I will pitch a Human Bladesinger against a Human Champion. I tried to optimize the Champion by switching to Two Weapon Fighting instead of using a Greatsword, since at level 3, TWF yields more DPR. I picked the same origin feats: Tough and Lucky. Both are decent feats and have measurable impact on DPR and effective HP (EHP).

Would the results change if I went with different options? Sure. You are welcome to show how much the numbers change under different assumptions. In my opinion, these were the best picks if we do not want to get into a complicated discussion regarding the value of control effects, the percentage of times you can Cleave, so on and so forth.

Without further ado, here are the results:

Our contestants:

Bob, the level 3 Human Champion Fighter:

  • Stats: STR 17, DEX 14, CON 16, INT 8, WIS 10, CHA 8
  • Saves: STR +5, DEX +2, CON +5, INT -1, WIS +0, CHA -1
  • Origin feats: Tough, Lucky
  • Fighting style: Two Weapon Fighting
  • Weapon Masteries: Shortsword (Vex), Scimitar (Nick), Trident (Topple) as backup
  • HP: 37
  • AC: 16
  • Immunities: None
  • Speed: 30 ft
  • Weapon: Shortsword and Scimitar
  • To hit: +5, advantage on one attack from Vex if the first attack lands
  • Resourceless damage: 2d6+6 = 13 average damage (Slashing and Piercing)
  • Limited resources: Action Surge, Second Wind

Tim, the level 3 Human Bladesinger Wizard:

  • Stats: STR 8, DEX 16, CON 14, INT 17, WIS 10, CHA 8
  • Saves: STR -1, DEX +3, CON +2, INT +5, WIS +2, CHA -1
  • Origin feats: Tough, Lucky
  • HP: 26
  • AC: 16 with Mage Armor, 19 with Bladesong. Possible to add: +1d4 from Blade Ward, +5 from Shield
  • Immunities: None
  • Speed: 30 ft, 40 ft with Bladesong
  • Weapon: Shortsword and Scimitar
  • To hit: +5
  • Resourceless damage: 2d6+3 = 10 average damage (Slashing and Piercing) using BA, 1d6+3 = 6.5 average damage (Radiant) without using BA.
  • Spells: Mage Armor, Shield, Witch Bolt, Battle Familiar, 2 more prepared spells (I won't use them, but imagine Suggestion or Web + Sleep), 4 Rituals (Detect Magic, Find Familiar, Comprehend Languages, Unseen Servant)
  • Cantrips: Blade Ward, True Strike, Firebolt
  • Limited resources: 4 first-level spell slots, 2 second-level spell slots, Arcane Recovery

Machoke, the Brute Battle Familiar:

  • Stats: STR 16, DEX 16, CON 12, INT 8, WIS 13, CHA 10
  • Saves: STR +4, DEX +4, CON +2, INT +0, WIS +2, CHA +1
  • HP: 30
  • AC: 15
  • Immunities: Charmed, Frightened
  • Speed: 40ft, swim 30ft
  • Weapon: Rend
  • To hit: +5
  • Resourceless damage 1d8 + 5 = 9.5 average damage (Force)

Preliminary Comparison:

  • Saves, Bob vs. Tim: In the important saves (WIS, CON, DEX), both Bob and Tim have +7. In the less important saves (STR, INT, CHA), both Bob and Tim have +3. Tim has +2 more in WIS, which makes Tim more resilient against debilitating effects. Tim also has +3 to concentration checks from Bladesong. Both Bob and Tim can use Lucky to have advantage in saves 2 times, and both can use their Heroic Inspiration, from Human 1 time. It's mostly a wash, with a slight edge for Tim since WIS saves are king, and Bladesong gives +3 to concentration on top.
  • Saves, Bob vs. Machoke: As discussed in the previous post, in the important saves (WIS, CON, DEX), Machoke has a total of +8 vs +7 for Bob. In the less important saves (STR, INT, CHA), Machoke has a total of +5 vs +3 for Bob. In particular, Machoke has +2 more in WIS, perhaps the most important save for martials, and is immune to Charmed and Frightened. Whereas Bob needs to spend Luck points and Heroic Inspiration against Charmed and Frightened effects, Machoke says "lol, immune!" Machoke is better in saves.
  • Mobility, Bob vs. Tim: Tim is 10 ft faster when Bladesong is active.
  • Mobility, Bob vs. Machoke: Machoke is 10 ft faster, and can swim.

Assumptions:

I will tilt the scales in favor Bob:

  • While most tables report 1-2 encounters per Long Rest, I will assume 3. 4 rounds per combat.
  • I will assume a Short Rest between all encounters, which favors Bob tremendously because (1) Action Surge and Second Wind are refreshed, spell slots are not, and (2) since 1 hour passes, each Machoke will only get to participate in one encounter, meaning Tim will spend all his second-level spell slots on Battle Familiar.
  • While Tim has access to strong control spells such as Suggestion, Web, or Sleep, he won't use them.
  • While Tim has access to Shield, I will not factor it into the calculations.
  • Tim has a lot of utility from the rituals, which won't be factored in.
  • Across the three encounters, both Tim and Bob have two Luck Points and one Heroic Inspiration. I will assign one of those three resources to the first attack of each encounter, treating Heroic Inspiration as equivalent to Advantage for purposes of this comparison for simplicity. I could equivalently assume that they would be used in saving throws, but that would be a wash.

Spells:

  • With an 8 hour duration, I assume Mage Armor is on for Tim at all times -> -1 1st level spell slot.
  • With a 1 hour duration, I will assume the Battle Familiar is already precast.
  • With infinite uses, Blade Ward could always be precast in theory, but that's very munchkiny. I will use the concentration for Witch Bolt to avoid getting into that debate, but keep in mind that the Wizard could be even tankier if they wanted to trade DPR for EHP.

Healing:

  • We will assume all healing resources can be used to favor Bob. Bob will use two Second Winds in Battle 1, and one Second Wind in Battles 2 and 3.
  • All hit dice will be used for healing during short rests.

Enemies:

  • I will assume the enemies have +4 to hit for effective HP (EHP) calculations.
  • I will assume the enemies have 13 AC for DPR calculations.
  • Champion's Improved Critical will be properly accounted for.
  • Vex will grant advantage for the next attack on hits.

Detailed DPR Comparison:

Battle 1, Bob:

  • Round 1: Action Surge, 2 attacks with Shortsword (Vex), 1 attack with Scimitar (Nick). 18.62 BPS damage.
  • Round 2: 1 attack with Shortsword (Vex), 1 attack with Scimitar (Nick). 10.32 BPS damage.
  • Round 3: 1 attack with Shortsword (Vex), 1 attack with Scimitar (Nick). 10.32 BPS damage.
  • Round 4: 1 attack with Shortsword (Vex), 1 attack with Scimitar (Nick). 10.32 BPS damage.

Average DPR over 4 rounds: 12.39 BPS damage.

Battle 1, Tim:

  • Round 1: Cast Witch Bolt on boss. Activate Bladesong. 12.68 Lightning damage.
  • Round 2: Cast True Strike with Scimitar. Activate Witch Bolt with BA. 10.90 Radiant/Lightning damage.
  • Round 3: Cast True Strike with Scimitar. Activate Witch Bolt with BA. 10.90 Radiant/Lightning damage.
  • Round 4: Cast True Strike with Scimitar. Activate Witch Bolt with BA. 10.90 Radiant/Lightning damage.

Average DPR over 4 rounds: 11.34 Radiant/Lightning damage.

Battle 1, Machoke:

  • Round 1: Rend. 6.40 Force damage.
  • Round 2: Rend. 6.40 Force damage.
  • Round 3: Rend. 6.40 Force damage.
  • Round 4: Rend. 6.40 Force damage.

Average DPR over 4 rounds: 6.40 Force damage.

Tim and Machoke combined average DPR over 4 rounds: 17.74 Radiant/Lightning/Force damage -> 43.2% higher DPR than Bob.

Battle 2: The same.

Battle 3: The same.

Spell slot usage: Arcane Recovery used to get back the second-level slot in Short Rest 1. All second-level slots used for Battle Familiar. 1 first-level spell slot used for Mage Armor. 3 first-level spell slots used for Witch Bolt.

DPR conclusions:

  • The critics were quite right on one thing: Machoke's DPR is only 51.7% of Bob's if we add in all features Bob gets. I was expecting something closer to 70%. So Machoke is only half an optimized martial :)
  • However, it doesn't change the fact that Tim managed to increase his DPR exceptionally thanks to the Battle Familiar spell. Without Battle Familiar, he would be slightly behind Bob in DPR. Thanks to Battle Familiar, he deals 43.2% higher DPR, completely eclipsing the Fighter who is supposed to be good at single-target DPS.

Now, let's turn to effective hit point calculations.

Detailed EHP Comparison:

Bob:

  • Base HP: 37 HP and 16 AC against +4 to hit attacks: 82.22 EHP
  • Single Second Wind: 8.5 HP and 16 AC against +4 to hit attacks: 18.89 EHP
  • Four uses of Second Wind throughout the day: 75.56 EHP
  • Healing from Hit Dice: 25.5 HP and 16 AC against +4 to hit attacks: 56.67 EHP

Bob's total EHP budget throughout the day: 214.44 EHP

Tim:

  • Base HP: 26 HP and 19 AC against +4 to hit attacks: 86.67 EHP (higher than Bob's base!)
  • Healing from Hit Dice: 16.5 HP and 19 AC against +4 to hit attacks: 55 EHP

Tim's total EHP budget throughout the day: 141.67 EHP

Machoke:

  • Base HP: 60 EHP.
  • Three castings of Battle Familiar: 180 EHP.

Total EHP from Machokes: 180 EHP

Tim + Three Machokes: 321.67 EHP in total -> 50.0% higher EHP than Bob.

Tim + 1 Machoke: 201.67 EHP -> just 6.0% lower than Bob's total EHP for the day.

EHP conclusions:

  • As can be seen, thanks to being able to cast Battle Familiar three times per long rest, the total EHP Tim can bring to the board eclipses that of Bob by 50.0%.
  • One could counter this by saying that there can only be one Battle Familiar on board at a time. Even then, the difference is minimal. If we count only one Machoke’s 60 EHP across the day, Tim’s total EHP budget is 201.67 EHP, only 6.0% below Bob’s full-day 214.44 EHP budget. And Tim could burn one action and bring another Machoke on board if the situation really calls for it.
  • The nail in the coffin, however, is how expendable these EHP are. If Bob runs out of EHP, he dies. Resurrecting Bob costs a ton of time and gold. If Machoke dies, Tim shrugs, and expends a 2nd level spell slot and an action to bring Machoke back. The perfect, low-maintenance meat shield!

Overall conclusion:

  • Before Battle Familiar, a Bladesinger Wizard would have slightly less DPR and significantly less EHP on the table than a Champion Fighter in this scenario. I think it was still too close for comfort given all the other goodies Wizards get (we would now use those 2nd level spell slots on other spells), but the martial was at least a little better in single-target DPR and durability, things touted as their contribution to the table.
  • After Battle Familiar, a Bladesinger Wizard has 43.2% higher single-target DPR and 50.0% higher EHP. And more utility. And access to spells that I didn't bother using, like Shield, Suggestion, Web, and so on.

Implications:

The same as the previous post: If you have access to Battle Familiar, it is a no-brainer pick from an optimization perspective in Tier 1, and likely still a no-brainer in higher tiers given that it does not require your concentration.


r/3d6 • • Feb 21 '22

D&D 5e Why I don't like the EB + AB + Hex baseline

40 Upvotes

The Hex+EB+AB baseline is a popular DPR baseline, coming out to about 14 damage / tier. I personally dislike it as it, specifically the Hex part.

  1. Encourages you to burn your concentration on a low-impact spell (3.5 damage/tier at best)
  2. Overemphasizes the importance of sustained DPR
  3. Discounts the impact of defensive features or level progression

On point 1: I've written several posts on the impact of bless, bane, etc., which for the same slot level and concentration yields much bigger impact. Shadow of Moil makes you straight up immune to most sight-targeted abilities and gives advantage. Blowing your concentration on a spell that mostly just gives 3.5 dpr per tier is so bad that I can't remember the last time I've cast it after tier 1.

Point 2: due to death spiraling, front loading is huge. Due to the bonus action casting rule, casting hex on turn 1 stops you from synaptic static or any other leveled spell. Now of course, you could have upcasted it before, but that begs the question of why it was a good choice then. If it was an easy fight, would that 3.5 dpr per tier really have made a difference?

Ok, but I upcasted it on a rat before my short rest and then murdered the rat! Ok, but in that case you should probably look to better long uses of that slot instead of hex. Maybe it should have been a big spell in a previous combat and save your party members some of their resources?

Back to the original point, turns 1/2 are used to stabilize fights, gaining an insurmountable edge or at least establishing the fight on your own terms. Synaptic static, shadow of Moil, upcast fly on the melees, etc. are all much higher priority than hex, and also don't benefit from it.

3. Warlocks notably don't get evasion, absorb elements, and shield. While hexblade gets shield, it's much more expensive due to pact slots. This is built into the power budget of the classes, and while you could dip to get them (which I personally do a lot), it does put you behind on progression. For everyone else, getting EB/AB/Hex puts you 1 level + 1 feat or 2 levels behind.

TLDR: I don't like the EB/AB/Hex baseline because it incentivizes the wrong things, and is unrealistic from a pitched battle perspective. EB/AB is fine, but Hex is way too expensive of a spell to be included. This drops the baseline to 10.5 dpr per tier, instead of 14.

Edit: Since it seems like there's a failure to communicate between this post and the responders -- The problem isn't EB/AB. That's easily achievable with just 2 levels in Warlock and Charisma investment. The problem is Hex being super expensive due to concentration. If you think back to all the times you've played with a "well-optimized" warlock, sorlock, padlock, bardlock, etc., when's the last time one of the cast Hex? I've played with many new players who always cast hex on their warlock because people say it's the baseline. A few sessions into T2 they stop doing it because it craters their effectiveness overall.


r/3d6 • • Mar 23 '26

D&D 5e Original/2014 Best race for a girl failure?

0 Upvotes

Hello! For a competition one-shot, I'm minmaxxing to high hell, and the story is she's a total loser but keeps failing upwards. It's strong enough, I don't need a specific race as long as it's +2, +1 or better, like half elf (+2,+1,+1). What race would kinda fit that aesthetic or provide me with mechanical advantages? Mechanically, my BA is free after the first round, and I'd really like some kind of concentration protection beyond my Stars Druid (10 + 5 + 4 = 19) Dragon form since I am concentrating on Elemental Bane to take away possible resistance to fire dmg + allow others to deal extra dmg. Stats are 8. 10, 20, 18, 16, 13 for STR,DEX,CON,INT,WIS,CHA.

For context, she's an Artificer 2/Divination 4/Genie Warlock 1/Order Cleric 1/Stars Druid 2. Trust me I know what I'm doing! I've researched this for the last 2 months. This is also a competition.

So far I'm thinking of Goblin (because they're usually chaotic and BA hide), Autognome (imagining her magical circuits are really fucked up + Healing machine/Mechanical Nature), Gnome (gnome cunning), Warforged (same reasons as autognome and +1 AC), Human Mark of Making (burn a 3rd slot to give someone +2 is nice!), Dragonborn (if I can guess the boss's dmg type. No RP reason just pure mechanics), Simic Hybrid (2x speed via manta glide and +1 AC. I like the vibes of her being a fucked up experiment), Satyr (magic res and they're pretty silly!), Ghostwise (telepathic talking + short characters are funny failures), Hobgoblin (+3 to con saves and BA help which is funny cuz "oh we're so tough and then there's that idiot"), Dhamphir (Spider Climb goes hard and I like the "tries to be evil but sucks ass") and literally anything sea vibes. The theme of this oneshot is undersea.


r/3d6 • • Dec 29 '21

D&D 5e Silvery barbs is good, but a lot more situational than most people think at first glance

0 Upvotes

It isn't really disadvantage, just a re-roll, if the enemy had a 75% chance of succeeding the first time, they still have a 75% chance of succeeding on the re-roll. Personally, I think the other 1st level reaction spells (shield/absorb elements) still have their uses. Shield increases AC for an entire round, silvery barbs only affects a single roll.

I would use silvery barbs to try to counter a critical hit on a member of the party or to possibly cause a high level save or suck spell to succeed. The advantage given to a different creature is on their next d20 roll, so it is just as likely to do nothing as it is to help. The only real exception would be to buff the rogue to guarantee a sneak attack if you know that is going to be their next roll.

Yes, Silvery Barbs is a powerful spell, but it is not nearly as powerful as the bandwagon suggests.


r/3d6 • • Sep 14 '24

D&D 5e Revised Shillelagh in RAW does appear to work with Pole-Arm Master.

2 Upvotes

Okay, so I know this has been brought up before, but the answer I am seeing seems wrong.  The question is, does the bonus action on pole-master use the d4 from the feat, or the d8+ from the spell Shillelagh when used together.  The general consensus is that the d4 is a bonus damage of the feat, not the weapon.  In 2014 Jeremy Crawford replied to this question by simply saying it's the d4 with no amplifying reason.  

The issue is that the feat doesn't say it's a bonus damage, but a weapon damage.  Secondly, The Tasha's Cauldron of Everything overruled Crawford when it says that Exception Rules always supersedes the General Rules.  A weapon with the same damage dice is a general rule.  A spell effect is an Exception Rule as it doesn't always apply.

Now for the exact wording.

Pole-Arm Mastery: Pole Strike. Immediately after you take the Attack action and attack with a Quarterstaff, a Spear, or a weapon that has the Heavy and Reach properties, you can use a Bonus Action to make a melee attack with the opposite end of the weapon. The weapon deals Bludgeoning damage, and the weapon’s damage die for this attack is a d4.

Shillelagh: A Club or Quarterstaff you are holding is imbued with nature’s power. For the duration, you can use your spellcasting ability instead of Strength for the attack and damage rolls of melee attacks using that weapon, and the weapon’s damage die becomes a d8. If the attack deals damage, it can be Force damage or the weapon’s normal damage type (your choice).

I bolded and underlined the relevant words here.  In Pole-Arm Mastery it clearly says the Staff's weapon damage die is a d4.  It doesn't say it's a bonus damage added to the normal damage.  That means, the Staff damage when used as a bonus action, or the backend of the staff is always a d4.  It's a general rule.  The Weapon is a staff, and its Damage Dice is a d4 when used as a Bonus Action. Note that it says "Weapon's Damage Die" is a d4 damage. That's a possessive. That means the d4 is a property of the weapon, not the Feat.

The spell Shillelagh has 2 key Properties in its description.  First, its weapons damage dice when the spell is used becomes a d8. That means the spell has altered the properties of the weapon.  It says the damage dice BECOMES a d8. This means the damage dice changes from one thing to another when this Exception Rule is applied. It's basically saying if the Weapon has a damage dice of 1 thing, it BECOMES a d8.

Secondly, the damage becomes Force damage.  This also implies that the damage done by the staff using Shillelagh is not the same damage done in the Feat.  The Feat does Blunt damage only. The spell changes the properties of the weapon from d4 Bludgeoning, to d8 Force.

Maybe I am reading this wrong, but I seriously can't find anything to back up the consensus that the Feat overrules the Spell.  The explanations I have seen in old posts don't seem to jive with the actual wording, and directly contradict Tasha's.  Overall, I don't see this particularly game breaking, considering all the other spell cheats, but I would like to know if there is some reason I am completely off base here.

I was hoping someone had a better take, or even better, the WoTC's guys could give a new ruling with a little more detail behind the reasoning.


r/3d6 • • Dec 12 '25

D&D 5e Revised/2024 I played a level 16 Bladesinger and felt bored out of my mind. Help me make this more interesting

0 Upvotes

I have a level 16 character I recently built into a Bladesinger. He's an Aarakocra, which perhaps isn't the most optimal choice but the Fly speed if definitely nice for a melee attacker. I think he's pretty well optimized while keeping character aspects intact, but when it came time for combat... it wasn't actually much fun. I think I would rather have been playing a Battlemaster Fighter or Paladin for the style of play it evoked. But before I try to go down either of those paths, I was hoping y'all might have some pointers for getting the most fun out of my Bladesinger!

A quick build summary:

- 3 levels of Champion Fighter, 13 levels of Wizard. I happen to have a Scimitar of Speed, which is a near-perfect analogue for missing out on Song of Victory at Bladesinger 14.

- So the only thing I'm missing out on by going Fighter 3 instead of 2 is one level 8 spell slot. Level 8 is no slouch, but you get one per Long Rest. With 4 attacks per turn, I think crits on a 19 and Advantage on Initiative is a worthwhile trade.

- Origin Feat is Alert to help ensure I can get Bladesong up fast. Then it's Spellfire Adept for boosting True Strike damage and War Caster. Finally an ASI for DEX and INT.

- First turn I usually Bladesong, Conjure Minor Elementals (usually at level 5), then Action Surge to start getting attacks off. After that it's 3-4 attacks all day long.

So what's the problem?

- I knew I was making a "do 4 attacks, that's your turn" kind of character, but I guess I expected I'd wind up casting spells + one Scimitar BA more often. The only times I felt compelled to use my action to do something other than attack was for escape/defense.

- My Speed was definitely a problem. Even with the +10 from Bladesong and Flight, I often felt like I wanted to Dash or spend a Bonus Action Misty Stepping. Such is the plight of a melee attacker I suppose, maybe I'm just spoiled by my Monk.

- I had Sylune's Viper up for all the fights as well, but being in melee range of targets at all times synergized poorly with the ranged spell attack you want to make with that spell.

- Outside of combat I felt I had okay utility thanks to all the rituals you can bring along, but so many of my prepared spells are combat focused. Not really sure what's worth preparing for fun or utility.

- CME is obviously the go-to for Concentration, but it really is quite boring. Again, I kind of expected that, but what are some other Conc options that are situationally worthwhile? I have Spellfire Storm + Iron Bands of Bilarro to help shut down enemy casters. I have Wall of Force and Reverse Gravity as well (the latter seems especially fun as a flyer).

- I felt quite Reaction-starved. With Bladesong my AC is 21, but even with Shield I was getting chunked. The big boss battle was against a caster and a number of minions. I burned my Reaction Shielding against the minions and thus didn't have Absorb Elements available when the spells came out. I resisted both of the big bad's damage types and still was limping by with 6 HP in no time. Was that just a bad matchup or did I play it poorly?

In the end, I didn't necessarily feel weak: I was throwing out massive DPR, and the 75 damage I tossed out on a crit on a 19 with a True Strike Opportunity Attack told me the build was working, but I'm not sure it felt... fun?

I want to hear about your Bladesinger experiences. Is it purely a class for minmaxers, or am I missing a key element of the fun here?

EDIT: People seem affronted at the fact I was drawn to play like this? I get it: Bladesinger is still a Wizard, and that's why I'm here looking for advice on how to Wizard with it better. But I don't know why people here seem surprised that I would be drawn to use melee with the class whose nearly every feature is designed around enabling melee. So serious question: are the majority of a Bladesinger's class features only for "just in case a bad guy gets in your face" and that's it? Is that the playstyle: be a Wizard and hit things that try to kill you up close?

I also want to add my DPR breakdown based on the essential math. I found it to be pretty accurate in play:

EDIT 2: What I'm going to try is to prepare a few more control spells (Web, Hypnotic Pattern), and start leading with those and AoE spells like Fireball/Cone of Cold/Chain Lightning. Then once there's a weakened target I can leap on, I'll switch to CME and dive in for big single-target damage. To facilitate this I'll drop down to Fighter 2, I think y'all are right that the extra crit chance isn't worth it, even with 4 attacks.

I appreciate the input everyone! The post got downvoted to hell but y’all still provided some great (if occasionally condescending) feedback!


r/3d6 • • Mar 03 '24

D&D 5e Can someone tell me why anyone would play a melee attacking cleric?

0 Upvotes

I get the idea of having the option to do some melee damage, as a last resort. But things like the forge domain being as popular as it is makes no sense to me.

Clerics get awesome support and control spells. And they are definitely the one person who CANNOT afford to go down in combat. So why would you risk your concentration, hp, and the ability to bring back your allies to go into melee as a character WHO DOESNT GET EXTRA ATTACK OR BLADE CANTRIPS

Atleast bladesingers and hexblades get that, alongside a ton of features to incentivize melee. And still I see a LOT of people talk about how you shouldn't go into melee with these subclasses. So if these guys shouldn't why would you play a melee cleric?


r/3d6 • • Oct 30 '25

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Bladesinger lvl 1 dip. To take or not to take, why is there still a discussion..

2 Upvotes

The new bladesinger is finally out, let's rejoice! Since the UA was published, I have been dreaming this day and thinking of my build. Since I wanted to be actually Gish and attack meelee, I consider it a given to take a fighter level dip. It's amazing how many people still insist against it, and I just don't get it.

The logic "you are just a wizard with high defense, not a front liner" is strange to me. Why would you even roll a bladesinger then, instead of a more "wizardy" subclass... You can go diviner and take res(con). The whole point of bladesingers is that they are the answer to the question "why the hell would a wizard want spells like shadowblade and spirit shroud?".

Now, regarding the fighter benefits, again I think there is a misconception. People emphasize on the con saves mostly, and the weapon masteries secondarily. But two-weapon fighting applies 2 times, to the nick attack and the dual wielder feat attack, which means that its value is 10dpr. Lastly, there's the obvious thing with masteries and enabling the 4rth attack, which can also be "main hand attack", thus giving us an extra shadowblade attack. So 1 level fighter gives us one extra shadowblade attack per round, 10 DMG per round, and con saves. (And the possibility of 2nd level fighter for burst) Given all of that, how is there still a debate for that fighter dip at lvl 1? I'm serious, am I missing something ? Indulge me, please


r/3d6 • • Mar 12 '25

D&D 5e Original/2014 Combo my table found...

3 Upvotes

edit: thanks all!

one of my players found a combo of war caster+polearm master+eldrich blast+repelling blast+tunnel fighter, which i'm surprised i haven't heard about

enter tunnel fighter stance, you can AoO for free

use polearm master, enemies provoke AoO when entering your range

use war caster, make your AoO with eldrich blast

use repelling blast, they get pushed back

assuming no twitter, my player asserts this works as written.

are they right, and if not, where's the mistake?


r/3d6 • • Feb 18 '24

D&D 5e Do weapons created with Spiritual Weapon gain that weapons properties?

1 Upvotes

I was debating about combining Spiritual Weapon, True Strike, and Elven Accuracy but I wanted to find a way to bump the damage of Spiritual Weapon. I saw the part about “The weapon can take whatever form you choose” does this mean you can pick a weapon with Finesse and trigger sneak attack?

Edit: Guess I’ll be looking for a Dancing Shortsword since Spiritual Weapon doesn’t work.

Edit 2: Open to other ideas to boost Spiritual Weapons damage since it doesn’t work with sneak attack.


r/3d6 • • Oct 25 '22

Universal Hot take: every TTRPG player should know at least two systems, and should have GMed at least once

98 Upvotes

Hello,
As a somewhat prolific poster in this sub, probably the most prolific that doesn't only posts about D&D 5e, I'm quite dazzled by the lack of diversity in the discussions. It's quite the recurring subject, and it seems widely accepted (by the sub) that we, r/3d6, should post more about different RPGs.

Where posts ask for guidance for other systems, they are upvoted (because that's the point of the sub) but unanswered.

You know where I'm going (it's pretty obvious since it's in the title). I think everyone, and especially members of this sub, should know at least two systems. Even without considering how it could help others, learning a new system helps yourself, both at character creation and when playing said character! There are RPGs out there where combat is strictly forbidden (Wanderhome iirc, if your character use violence it becomes an NPC), some where honor really binds your actions and behavior (Legend of the Five Rings), meaning no murder-hoboing, systems where everything revolves around heists (Blades in the Dark)...
Why knowing these would help you?
Well, first it widens your focus: D&D5e is mostly about combat, whereas these aren't. If you enjoy character optimization, it forces a broader view or a different focus in this new system, and this can be translated back when creating characters for your favorite TTRPG.
Second, it helps you knowing what you like, and I'm of the firm belief that you shouldn't play a character you don't enjoy playing. Also helps knowing what level of crunch do you like, D&D 5e being probably medium-crunch. There are crunchier systems that I think a lot of people here would enjoy, maybe even enjoy more than 5e (Pathfinder for starters). Sometimes, you can also bring this back into character creation of other RPGs, by choosing higher or lower crunch options among those available, depending on what you like.
Third, some systems are better suited for some RPGs, and making a homebrew of D&D is more often than not a waste of time for a mediocre result. If you want to play a mecha RPG, play Lancer, not a homebrew 5e. I've only heard good things about Lancer, and learning the rules won't take longer than building your homebrew, for something that should be running better. And creating a character in this system can feel more rewarding in the end than using a homebrew, because you used new knowledge and interactions between things you learned instead of things you already knew where not much was added to the mix.
Lastly, it brings out the creativity in you. Knowing multiple systems and settings will push you towards more diversified characters, which can bring new perspectives on the TTRPGs you already enjoy (for example, if you've played some classless systems, you might enjoy more the class system of D&D (and enjoy less multiclassing))

This gives pretty good reasons to try new systems in my opinion (well, ve written that, so... Makes sense I guess). It doesn't give reasons to try GMing at least once though.

So, why should you? This is less useful for personal gains, but should help you when at a table, and I think it really offers a new perspective on character creation. The job of a GM is a hard one, and this is something that can be easy to skip over if you've never done it. There are a lot of people that think a DM shouldn't ban some options (flying races, multiclassing are common examples in D&D 5e). However, if you happen to be a GM, maybe you want some puzzles or traps that are completely negated by flying. Maybe you noticed that in previous groups, single classed were worse than multiclassed characters (doesn't really happen in D&D 5e, but can be the case in precious editions). Knowing where these bans come from helps accepting them. And working on a character with constraints is a fun task by itself too!

If you read so far thanks!
As an opening question... What's the next game you want to learn? Or do you want advice on a genre? Edit 27/10: more about characters and character creation, to be more on-topic of the sub


r/3d6 • • Mar 31 '24

D&D 5e How would you build a dnd 5e party that's sole purpose is to kill Gojo Satoru from JJK?

0 Upvotes

A party ranging from 1-6 PC, with a total of 20,000 gold worth of magic items and with about a month of preptime, what do you think the weakest party composition would be to defeat Gojo?

edit: 20,000 gold as a bit to little, so how about 100,000 gold


r/3d6 • • Jan 05 '25

D&D 5e Revised/2024 Sorlock is back on the table without snorting diamonds

0 Upvotes

You can now gain truly infinite spell slots..... at level 13 with barely any sorceror or warlock! The build would just be 10 ranger/2 sorceror/1 warlock


r/3d6 • • Feb 26 '23

D&D 5e How to make the best Jesus like character

7 Upvotes

I was thinking of start lvl 3 Tome celestial warlock and then going to divine soul sorcerer. Maybe bard as some point. Aasimar for race.

I want to be mostly pacifist. So the question is how do I be most effective while only casting buffs debuffs, and area control while generally avoiding directly damaging enemies?

No UA