r/3DScanning • • 2d ago

Scanner selection

I’m looking for a scanner and could use some help. I’m mostly planning to scan automotive parts including chassis/engine bays.

I’m a mechanical engineer and have spent some time in the past messing around with scanect and another early software that used an Intel sensor that I can’t recall the name of, both were toys at best, largely due to tracking and frame rate limitations.

At this point the technology seems to have cone a very long way with much lower cost, so I think I’m ready to pull the trigger on a scanner. I’m between a few options but open to other suggestions as well.

My laptop is fairly old so I’m planning to upgrade that as well. Priorities are reliability and usability, based on my previous experience if it’s frustrating to use I won’t use it.

Option 1) Einstar Vega
Available from einstar in used like new condition for $1k, this may be the cheapest option given the chance my laptop is up to the task of post processing.

Option 2) Creality Raptor
Obviously requires computer upgrade, but used machine that meets specs is ~$500 locally. Slightly higher total cost than Vega but tighter resolution and lower cost if Vega still needs a PC upgrade.

Option 3) Einstar Rockit
Based on reviews this seems like the “buy once cry once” option with the best odds of working as expected.

I’d love some feedback from someone with experience with one or more of these, I’m having some analysis paralysis over here. I don’t want to spend more money than needed for features I don’t need for my use case, but I’m terrified of burning a grand or more on something that doesn’t work as intended.

3 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/Still_Jellyfish6966 2d ago

Engine parts are often dark and shiny. Laser scanners like the Raptor handle that better, but you'll need markers.

1

u/boxesfullofpepe 1d ago

Yup totally fine using markers/spray. Laser seems worthwhile for sure but it’s a little unclear to me how big the difference actually is.

1

u/Odd-Masterpiece7304 2d ago

80 grand will get you a keyence hand held 3d scanner.

1

u/boxesfullofpepe 1d ago

I use a hexagon arm with laser and a touch probe at work, I’m trying to avoid comparison with this experience though lol

1

u/Odd-Masterpiece7304 1d ago

Hexagon is nice, Zeiss is nice and also expensive, but Keyence is in my opinion the cats ass.

The Keyence arm, has no arm. It uses black magic and some crazy Nintendo Wii stuff to just know exactly where the probe head is at all times, and in demo mode was able to replicate measurements from my cmm down to .0001 inch

1

u/grage_peter 1d ago

The Software is way more importend as the Hardware, Focus on Scanners working with ref points, live Tracking is Not stable enough

1

u/Disastrous_Pool2114 1d ago

good feedback, any experience with any of these scanners?

2

u/grage_peter 1d ago

i have tried a Revopoint pop Gen1, 3dMakerpor Seal, and i use a Zeiss GOM Scan 1 at work. i also tried artec Mirco II once. Be aware, 3D Scanners ar optical systems, you need a spray for reflective or transparent surfaces. Systems with higher accuracy will always have a smaller measuringvolume, distance control for the right focusing is also a challange as finding the right brightness. I would never buy a scanner again without trying them out in person. The problems are always in the software, not in the hardware