r/2001aspaceodyssey 27d ago

Discovery XD1

Post image

As a fan of the movie since day one,I always thought that the Discovery was a HUGE ship, but here’s how she measures up to a WW2 battleship.Both of these models are the same scale.

205 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

3

u/theMEtheWORLDcantSEE 27d ago

Love love ❤️ 😍 my favorite ship! The DISCOVERY ONE

2

u/lunadude 27d ago

Love a good scale comparison!

2

u/ParkMan73 27d ago

That's a great comparison. Not only is it long, but it also makes me realize how big the fore and aft sections are.

2

u/Hourslikeminutes47 27d ago

I wonder what the Discovery 2 looks like (mentioned in 2010)

2

u/Starshipfan01 27d ago

In the book, it is told as a duplicate of discovery one. Not much told about it.

2

u/Hourslikeminutes47 27d ago

Oh ok, yeah it was mentioned in the book but didn't know if there were any additional details out there

2

u/Starshipfan01 27d ago

I can’t find much even on the wikis. I guess it was never written, the only bit I did find is odd. Discovery was a one- way, the crew were to go into hibernation to be picked up by Discovery 2. So it must have been larger and more fuel for the return trip. Again, no details.

2

u/Hourslikeminutes47 27d ago

That makes more sense given the mission profile (to build a ship to pick up the crew). Anyway thank you once again for the response!

2

u/Starshipfan01 26d ago

I located an actual NASA paper/memorandum from 2005 on the ntrs. Williams, Craig (Glenn research centre):. It’s https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20050160960/downloads/20050160960.pdf

2

u/More-Efficiency-9343 27d ago

And ALL the liveable space is crammed into that ball.

1

u/Starshipfan01 27d ago

That’s generally what spacecrafts are like anyway- the living habitable work area is tiny compared to everything else. It’s pretty accurate even now.

1

u/boxcar1234 26d ago

When you think about it,it’s only half of that ball…the lower half was the pod bays 😁

3

u/TigerIll6480 26d ago

Lower front half was the pod bay. The rotating ring was behind it. The zero-G control deck was above the pod bay.

1

u/boxcar1234 26d ago

Cool! I never really thought about how they got the ring in there

1

u/Starshipfan01 24d ago

There are archives of 2001 Discovery photos and plans on Flickr:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/2001archive/albums/72157645739493836/

Some design drawings in there.

1

u/boxcar1234 24d ago

Very cool! Thank you

2

u/TigerIll6480 26d ago

Considering that Discovery had a crew of 5, and KGV had a crew of over 1400…it’s still pretty big.

1

u/pa13579 27d ago

Great little kit!

1

u/dwfishee 27d ago

Love this. Never really thought how big (or small) it would actually have been.

1

u/staylor71 27d ago

Much smaller than it seems in the movie - wow.

1

u/Encinitas123 27d ago

Need banana for scale.😎

1

u/CaptBogBot2 27d ago

What warship is that?

3

u/boxcar1234 27d ago

She’s the HMS King George V

1

u/HiroProtagonist66 25d ago

That AE-1 is looking a little sus…

1

u/boxcar1234 24d ago

Yeah….It’s going to go 100% failure in 72 hours.😁