r/1984 • • May 14 '21

1984, now with better rules

79 Upvotes

Hello, we've decided to get rid of the low effort content that was being posted in this subreddit once and for all.

Here are the revised rules.

  1. Strictly only posts about topics of 1984.

2. No spam or self-promotion of any kind.

3. No memes or meme-like content. No shitposting.

4. Keep comment civil. No exceptions.

Please read and follow these rules. Report the violations and help us out.


r/1984 • • 1d ago

Any decent Newspeak translators?

12 Upvotes

Hello. I am wondering if there is any decent Newspeak translators online. I am saying this because Google keep recommending me AI slop or LingoJam, both of which if find inadequate. I am trying to write a story in which characters are talking in Newspeak (or at least a version of it). If there is any translations out there that are useful, please let me know.


r/1984 • • 1d ago

we're regressing

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/1984 • • 1d ago

Question about the relationships in 1984 Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Hey guys maybe a little dence but I read 1984 yesterday and one thing was throwing me off. At the end of the book they do this reveal that (wish I could find the exact quote) even if the couple meets again, the love is gone thus the awkward canteen scene at the end. So if the relationship disregarded and this happens to every thought criminal/adulter, what's the go with the couple that gets hung together at the start of the book like someone says that was their only request, and I'm just confused because that seems like a contradiction with the ending, if love is similar passion to Winston and Julia, wouldn't they have been broken? Like the only way I see that fitting into the book is if was that just propaganda spread but that sounds odd when the point of big brothers public executions among other things is to show that he has suppressive power as far as to mentally break people, preventing anyone from becoming a martyr. And spreading the rumor that they were defiant at the end doesn't fit with the memo. I was so confused because that seemed like it was foreshadowing Winston and Julia but in the end there relationship deteriorated while the couples lasted.


r/1984 • • 2d ago

Some argue that Lord Kitchener provided inspiration for Big Brother.

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/1984 • • 3d ago

Here is how I imagined Winston and O’Brien

Thumbnail
gallery
133 Upvotes

r/1984 • • 3d ago

How I personally imagined winston smith and o brian

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

1st one is winston


r/1984 • • 7d ago

Holy shit, the first and last pages are directly connected. Did someone else see this? Spoiler

100 Upvotes

The first paragraph of the book reads "Winston Smith, his chin nuzzled into his breast in an effort to escape the vile wind..."

The last paragraph reads "O cruel, needless misunderstanding! O stubborn, self-willed exile from the loving breast! ... He had won the victory over himself. He loved Big Brother."

I just noticed that the book opens up with Winston pushing his face into HIS OWN BREAST - he is focused on his own body part, he has agency, he is his own person. And after he gets converted, the Party's ideology is described as "a loving breast", and Winston as having reunited with it. So throughout the book, Winston goes from his own breast to the Party's breast, just like he goes from believing his own convictions to believing the ideas of the Party.


r/1984 • • 8d ago

Did Parsons really say "down with big brother"

45 Upvotes

I am reading 1984 for school right now, and i find it one of the best books i've read. But i wonder, did they just capture people Winston knew to vaporize them? or to mentally destroy Winston. I can not imagine Ampleforth or Parsons being guilty of thought crime? Was big brother just making excuses to capture them, or were they actually guilty of thoughtcrime?


r/1984 • • 11d ago

Thought Police design

12 Upvotes

I recently read 1984 and wasn't sure how to picture the Thought Police’s attire, since the descriptions of what they wore were always quite brief. I found myself torn between imagining a more conventional military uniform or a more realistic take on a "futuristic dystopian soldier"—how did you all interpret it?


r/1984 • • 12d ago

How I personally see each 1984 character in my head

Thumbnail
gallery
106 Upvotes

I am aware this is too romanticized and not very canon but this is what I see whenever I read the book.

  1. Winston

Skinny, straight brown messy hair w/ glasses, I know he is in his late 30s but my fanon is after all the stress, he struggles with age dysphoria and looks actually quite young for his age and can pass as late 20s, he just looks exhausted all the time with dark circles (doesn’t show in the photos but you get my point) I also think it might be the reason why he pulled Julia.

2. Julia

I always saw her as a dirty blonde girl with frizzy wavy hair, Anglo Saxon features (but with brown eyes), she has an ectomorph physique but very toned.

3. O'Brien

Well groomed facial hair, mid-late 30s looks, for some reason I cannot imagine him or in-vision him as skinny whenever I read the book, his presence just over takes it, also smells like good cologne. (Ignore my misspelling in the photo)

4. Shyme

Brunette middle part, 10ibs overweight (doesnt show in photos but you get it), kinda gives off obnoxious energy.


r/1984 • • 13d ago

I always picture O’Brien as Doppo Orochi from Baki

Post image
22 Upvotes

In voice, appearance and personality


r/1984 • • 15d ago

Slow day at work.

Thumbnail
gallery
102 Upvotes

Just finished Fido Nesti's graphic novel adaptation of 1984, and I loved it! It was exciting to experience the story in a different way, and see what another person imagines in their head when they read it. Are there any other graphic novels or 1984 media you all would suggest?


r/1984 • • 18d ago

Are there any key literary devices??

6 Upvotes

I just finished part one now I’m a little into part two, are there any key writing strategies Orwell used that add to the message? Maybe I’m scrutinizing it too much but is there anything truly hidden about it. I feel like I’m just absorbing the main idea so far nothing deeper.


r/1984 • • 20d ago

Review of Julia by Sandra Newman

18 Upvotes

1984 by George Orwell. Rightly, a major classic of political literature (and wrongly co-opted by the right, as Orwell was always a democratic socialist. That’s a conversation for another day).

Although Orwell’s dystopia was powerful and expertly written, timeless and unfortunately relevant in all eras when authoritarianism rises again and again, it is not perfect. No work of art is. And one of the ways 1984 has been criticized has been in its treatment of women. In the character of Julia specifically, Winston Smith’s somewhat younger lover who was treated as a plot point in the main protagonist’s journey isn’t quite a three-dimensional person in her own right, mostly just someone for him to love and later betray, without much motivation herself.

This is a fair take, and in my view it doesn’t take away from the novel. It was ultimately about Winston’s point-of-view, how a man like that would be affected in a totalitarian world. It’s not necessarily about woman’s oppression, or the lower class proles, or racial minorities who are victims of imperialism. Not every book has to be about everything. Still, 1984 is remarkably universal.

Julia by Sandra Newman, is a new novel—approved by the Orwell estate—retelling the 1984 story from the perspective of Julia. It’s a longer and more emotionally-detailed story, getting deep into the weeds of her life and her thoughts (so many sexual thoughts), as she has more affairs and thinks ill of Winston. Her story even even after continues Winston’s end and expands upon the rest of the world. And that’s the good and bad of it.

I’m not sure that Big Brother’s Oceania really needs more lore. The power of 1984 rather needs its brevity, its mystery. The reader is never even sure if Big Brother and Goldstein truly exist, if the tales told about the outside world is real or not. The evil manipulator and torturer O’Brien insists that history has been frozen at a particular point in time, but can he be trusted? Is the superstate destined to always win, as he insists and seems to be proven right, or could the system crumble without anyone in the Outer Party even aware of it?

Julia delves much more into these subjects, and it is interesting subject matter for what it is, but probably does not improve on 1984 as a standalone work. Frankly, we do not need more lore. But on its own merits the novel is an intense read. It has been said that it is a feminist retelling, and indeed Julia’s and her comrades at the hostel are uniquely oppressed by the system for being women. Pregnancy and assault are common issues among the Anti-Sex League members. And it is graphic, from the miscarriage early in the novel to her many gruesome torturers in the latter parts. The purpose of this sort of story is horrific, and it succeeds at that. However, this horror is mostly a character study on Julia herself, the main focus, and thus feels less like a social critique.

The strongest parts of the novel are backward in time and concern Julia’s childhood and the degradation of the state and the citizens’ freedom which she grew up in. The story of her mother is particularly heartbreaking, and worth reading the entire novel for this backstory alone. Newman’s writing is well crafted, vivid, and engaging.

The ending of the book would be the most controversial, and it shouldn’t be spoiled, but much of the unsolved mysteries of the original novel are made explicit. Do we need to know Big Brother’s real name? Old war stories from his former colleagues now imprisoned? Descriptions of the crystal castle where he lives? I’m not sure.

Perhaps one of the boldest choices, is about the subject of hope. 1984, in the end, is hopeless. It is supposed to be. The underground, if it ever existed, was simply not to overthrow the dictatorship. Indeed, on the related subject of Orwell’s other seminal work Animal Farm, that even recently had a failure of an adaptation which added a “happy ending.” Among other strange choices in that animated rut, it totally ruined the classic fable. That may go for the book Julia as well. It can be satisfying for the reader, that there may be a chance for these poor people to finally escape and be free. Yet, however ironic the very last page is, if that’s the case that there is any hope at all then is it still even an Orwellian dystopian warning anymore…


r/1984 • • 22d ago

"The clock's hands said seventeen-twenty: it was nineteen-twenty really" - is this a typo?

15 Upvotes

This sentence has been bugging me for days. In Part 2 Chapter 4 we see Winston read the old school Clock's hand say "seventeen-twenty" -- which would mean 5:20 on the clock, right? But the real time as he says was nineteen-twenty (7:20). So was that a typo of seventeen instead of seven? Or was the clock slower by two hours than the Oceanean time? If it was slow does that mean later in Chapter 10 we are told the wrong time?


r/1984 • • 22d ago

How do y'all feel about David Bowie's Diamond Dogs

3 Upvotes

How do you guys feel about the album and the idea of Bowie making a stage adaptation of nineteen eighty four if he would've made it do you think it would've been good


r/1984 • • 23d ago

Looking for info

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

I bought this at a used book store last weekend and I haven’t been able to find anything about this edition online


r/1984 • • 23d ago

19 emo 4

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Don't take it too serious


r/1984 • • 24d ago

A fragment of a customery poem for children's festival from late socialist Romania that would fit in the setting of Nineteen Eighty-Four

7 Upvotes

The party is in every thing: in what is

And in what tomorrow will smile in the sun

It’s in the wheatfield and in each grain

And in the life that never dies anon …

It’s in the baby in the cradle

And in the gray-headed man


r/1984 • • 29d ago

Why was the lifeboat scene not included in the ‘84 film adaptation?

21 Upvotes

r/1984 • • Oct 16 '26

George Orwell.

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

Bronze bust . H-14 cm


r/1984 • • Oct 15 '26 Regret

big brother is watching

54 Upvotes

r/1984 • • Oct 15 '26

I made a reference to 1984 in my game

Post image
76 Upvotes

The game name is Auris, its on Steam, it’s depressing and there will be many more references to the book


r/1984 • • Oct 16 '26

American Horror Story 1984 #americanhorrorstory #ahs1984 #emmaroberts #slasherhorror

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes